Game Holy Shōnen Trinity 5 (mafia wins!)

[John Wayne]

What's up with people getting here when I call them out?

Omfg, can you stop doing that?

I just happened to be browsing the forum right now

 

[Flower]

Not sure masoning counts as a visit in the first place?

Why would it not?

 

[Natalija]

Why would it not?

I'm assuming because it's active during the day

 

[Melontonin]

Might be wrong but something else about the day 1 lynch: maybe Hayumi is just lynch immune, assuming he's not a vig. So the lynch went to Cypher version 1, even with Melkor's vote manipulation. I just wish we just had an idea of his alignment that would help a lot.

Else that whole lynch is just too confusing imo.

 

[Flower]

I'm assuming because it's active during the day

You still go to a player's house and recruit them at night.


This reasoning doesn't even make sense.

 

[Flower]

@John Wayne any reason why you didn't appear in Watcher results?

 

[Flower]

@Melodie what do you make of this?

 

[John Wayne]

@John Wayne any reason why you didn't appear in Watcher results?

It's it's pretty embarrassing

You see I didn't actually send in the action correctly. I told Nitty to do it at first but then I changed my mind and told him not to do it.

Then I changed my mind again except... It looks like I forgot to write it down.

 

[Flower]

It's it's pretty embarrassing

You see I didn't actually send in the action correctly. I told Nitty to do it at first but then I changed my mind and told him not to do it.

Then I changed my mind again except... It looks like I forgot to write it down.

This contradicts your previous claim in which you clearly said you tried Masoning with Sin.

 

[John Wayne]

This contradicts your previous claim in which you clearly said you tried Masoning with Sin.

Yeah I thought I sent it rip

 

[Flower]

Yeah I thought I sent it rip

And I'm just supposed to believe that?

 

[John Wayne]

And I'm just supposed to believe that?

I'm sorry to disappoint you

 

[Flower]

I'm sorry to disappoint you

First Vivo, now you said you cancelled your actions.

Why decide against using your abilities in the first place ?

 

[nfcnorth]

Did anyone else claim roleblocker?

All I can say is that one exists

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

wat so 3 ppl didnt send in their actions?

 

[Flower]

wat so 3 ppl didnt send in their actions?

That's what they say .

 

[Vivo Diez]

It's it's pretty embarrassing

You see I didn't actually send in the action correctly. I told Nitty to do it at first but then I changed my mind and told him not to do it.

Then I changed my mind again except... It looks like I forgot to write it down.

Riiiiight. My action at least got confirmed by GM as an error. You just used my story to excuse yours . Nat's vouch for you is running really thin right about now.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

All I can say is that one exists

well hero is claiming roleblocker

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

is nat and jw still masons? Or was it for one night only

 

[Natalija]

is nat and jw still masons? Or was it for one night only

No, he can mason with someone else every day

 

[Flower]

is nat and jw still masons? Or was it for one night only

What if JW is a Neighbourizer and just showed Nat a fake role?

 

[Flower]

No, he can mason with someone else every day

Mason or Neighbour, though?

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

No, he can mason with someone else every day

that seems pretty strong for a town ability

 

[John Wayne]

Mason or Neighbour, though?

Mason, it's a three shot actually

 

[Flower]

No, he can mason with someone else every day

Mason, it's a three shot actually

So what is true now?

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Mason, it's a three shot actually

so you have 2 left?

 

[John Wayne]

so you have 2 left?

yup

 

[Natalija]

Jesus wept, he's telling the truth. I can see his whole role not posted by himself, but quoted by Nitty.

Barking up the wrong tree

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

yup

k i can believe it then but

 

[Flower]

Jesus wept, he's telling the truth. I can see his whole role not posted by himself, but quoted by Nitty.

Barking up the wrong tree

Yeah because there is just no way this can be a fake, right?

You are very trusting this game.

 

[nfcnorth]

Also just want to say that Nitty has kind of a history of lying mechanics. Aka things that seem neutral or not related to any faction can in fact be evil abilties. The moon goddess in Holy shonnen trinity mafia (I belive that it was that game) comes to mind. Presented in the name list of players write up but was a scum ability for an example disguisesd as a more neutral thing. Not sure if this a bastard game or not though

 

[Natalija]

Yeah because there is just no way this can be a fake, right?

You are very trusting this game.

No, I've never seen someone create a "fake" actual mason chat with me with "fake" role written by the host.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

im trusting jw and nat they wouldnt betray me right

 

[Flower]

No, I've never seen someone create a "fake" actual mason chat with me with "fake" role written by the host.

It's actually a great ability for scums. I have seen this before.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

@nfcnorth thoughts on hero and the current situation please?

 

[Flower]

im trusting jw and nat they wouldnt betray me right

And here I am not even trusting myself because I know what kind of crazy stuff I can pull as scum .

 

[Natalija]

It's actually a great ability for scums. I have seen this before.

Well then you can lynch Nitty for lying and the investigator can waste an investigation on JW for all I care

 

[Flower]

Well then you can lynch Nitty for lying and the investigator can waste an investigation on JW for all I care

Our Invest is kinda too busy being dead now.

 

[Natalija]

Our Invest is kinda too busy being dead now.

OH LOL REALLY?

 

[Flower]

OH LOL REALLY?

Cooler was this.

You never read.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

And here I am not even trusting myself because I know what kind of crazy stuff I can pull as scum .

with how simple my role is and how otherd are, i expect others to be not so elaborate as a fake scum role shown to our innocent child (who ppl are tinfoiling is fake as well). seems jarring to say the least

 

[Flower]

with how simple my role is and how otherd are, i expect others to be not so elaborate as a fake scum role shown to our innocent child (who ppl are tinfoiling is fake as well). seems jarring to say the least

Can we at least agree that all Townies absolutely have to use their actions from now on since we need the info? Townies not using their stuff is annoying af.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Can we at least agree that all Townies absolutely have to use their actions from now on since we need the info? Townies not using their stuff is annoying af.

youre not wrong though the only one i have doubts on would be vivo. Not sure why he backtracked on his action and if he selected a new target.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

I also think town has way too much killing power if hayumi and xebec are telling the truth.

also did @Alibaba Saluja or @Shrike ever claim anything or shared any info with us?

if someone is untrackable its one of them cruising by undetected and unquestioned each phase

heck even fken juan is actually doing smthing

this ^

can @Alibaba Saluja and @Shrike come out and play?

 

[Flower]

youre not wrong though the only one i have doubts on would be vivo. Not sure why he backtracked on his action and if he selected a new target.

Yeah, same can be said for JW.

Why decide against using abilities?

 

[Shrike]

I also think town has way too much killing power if hayumi and xebec are telling the truth.



this ^

can @Alibaba Saluja and @Shrike come out and play?

In a min, catching up.

 

[Flower]

And another one coming out like that.


What the actual f***?

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Yeah, same can be said for JW.

Why decide against using abilities?

his i can sort of understand if its a 3 shot tbh. Though I would prefer him to use it all now cause mafia knows his abilities

If it was every day, I would question it more

 

[Flower]

his i can sort of understand if its a 3 shot tbh. Though I would prefer him to use it all now cause mafia knows his abilities

If it was every day, I would question it more

Do you believe Usopp and Melodie with their messaging abilities are Town when there is a Mason recruiter?

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Do you believe Usopp and Melodie with their messaging abilities are Town when there is a Mason recruiter?

Out of the two, Melodie is the odd one for me.

Usopp's passive supposedly he gets a random interaction and then he can message people so that makes sense as a role.

Melodie can message people and be a watcher? Normally that's two abilities that don't get paired up for me. I am also thinking out of the characters in the role list who could that be

 

[nfcnorth]

No, I've never seen someone create a "fake" actual mason chat with me with "fake" role written by the host.

I have seen fake masons chats before but honestly its mainly been in favorites. If I remember right during Law/Tigers last favorites Remchu had a mason ability as mafia teammate of mine.

@nfcnorth thoughts on hero and the current situation please?

Tbh I don't like the hyper focus on all three on Hayumi, Hero and Melodie. Killers are certainly powerful but I always maintain that half the reason they exist is to make use of the actual powerful scum roles info. I do get that we don't have much else to go off atm but tbh I have been more intrested in people like Cypher 2.0, Juan and Melotain because I can't quiet figure them out atm. If I had to explain why it probably would be something on the lines of I think they might be getting to much of pass and I am seeing if that comes from having teammates or not.

I do think Nat's interaction with Melodie makes Melodie look the best out of the three though by a wide amount. Still sorting through if I by hero and Hayumi's stuff though. The extra lives thing is giving me pause for Hayumi.

 

[Flower]

Out of the two, Melodie is the odd one for me.

Usopp's passive supposedly he gets a random interaction and then he can message people so that makes sense as a role.

Melodie can message people and be a watcher? Normally that's two abilities that don't get paired up for me. I am also thinking out of the characters in the role list who could that be

I find it odd she can use two abilities.

When every other Town role only had one and Cypher 1.0 even had a passive limiting her to only one action at night.

 

[青月光]

I also think town has way too much killing power if hayumi and xebec are telling the truth.



this ^

can @Alibaba Saluja and @Shrike come out and play?

 

[Natalija]

I have seen fake masons chats before but honestly its mainly been in favorites. If I remember right during Law/Tigers last favorites Remchu had a mason ability as mafia teammate of mine.

That was probably super role madness madness chaos, no?

We have far simpler abilities here

 

[青月光]

What you need from me?

 

[nfcnorth]

[Illuminati] On Night 4, Spike, as Gandalf, may choose two other players to join a nightly 'Illuminati QT' where real names are forbidden. They won't know you chose them by name. If at any time, Spike no longer wants to be in the QT, he may have it dissolved.


Spoiler: Spike's fake role:

Gandalf​

[The Grey] Prior to Day 5, Gandalf has a Voting Power of 2.

[The White] After Day 5, Gandalf has a Voting Power of 5.

[Shadowfax] Each night, Gandalf may choose one player to put on his noble steed. That player will ride towards another target player until morning, to deliver a private message from Gandalf. While riding, the player is Role-blocked and immune to all actions.

[Conjurer of Cheap Tricks] The first two players that target Gandalf with a negative action are dazzled by his fireworks and magical display, failing their action.

[The Fellowship] One-Shot. On Night 4, two random players will join Gandalf in a neighbor's QT. Real names are forbidden. The three players may only talk at night.

This was in favorites mind you a game designed to spam power. But Fake mason with fake roles host provided in the mason chat can exist. Its just a question of is the host willing or has the desire to do so in this game.

That was probably super role madness madness chaos, no?

We have far simpler abilities here

True I do believe its far more likely to be true. But I have lost games hosted by nitty because people didn't question mechanics enough.

 

[Flower]

That was probably super role madness madness chaos, no?

We have far simpler abilities here

Yeah, but scums are equipped with fake claims as per the rules.

They likely have fake role sheets.

 

[nfcnorth]

This was in favorites mind you a game designed to spam power. But Fake mason with fake roles host provided in the mason chat can exist. Its just a question of is the host willing or has the desire to do so in this game.


True I do believe its far more likely to be true. But I have lost games hosted by nitty because people didn't question mechanics enough.

Also just for clarity I was godmother and spike (remchu) was a temmate of mine so this is mafia ability here.

 

[Flower]

If you think Hero is scum, then Hero definitely also has a fake role sheet with my passive and identity written down just in case I question him about it.

 

[Natalija]

Man I’m tired, just let it end

 

[nfcnorth]

True I do believe its far more likely to be true. But I have lost games hosted by nitty because people didn't question mechanics enough.

Actually I would like to ammend this instead of saying true I mean come from Hero. I think Hero has hosted enough he could probably fake a role if he wanted.

 

[Flower]

Actually I would like to ammend this instead of saying true I mean come from Hero. I think Hero has hosted enough he could probably fake a role if he wanted.

Why aren't you always discussing with us?

Get more active -_-...

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

What you need from me?

if you have any information and thoughts on hero and the situation

 

[Shrike]

Let's stop with susing Nat and JW (even though it irked the hell out of me that he is just like 'lul I am mason' and didn't really do much else). Just stop and focus on possible scum.

Don't let Cyprus control the narrative by constantly posting and thus making people respond and waste time. She was trying to throw the sus away from Hero all day but also distance herself by saying 'He's town, we're brother and sister, he must be town! Bbbbbuuuut also I don't know his alignment, but it was just logical that he is town, right?'. Common.

Nuke her along with Hero tbh. Hero 'threw the game', so fuck him and she is trying to get out of it now.

also did @Alibaba Saluja or @Shrike ever claim anything or shared any info with us?

if someone is untrackable its one of them cruising by undetected and unquestioned each phase

heck even fken juan is actually doing smthing

"Actually doing something" so giving good and non-ultra-shit reads isn't doing anything? K.

And another one coming out like that.


What the actual f***?

It's not 'another one coming out', I've been tagged twice by Usopp hours ago and now by Kvothe while I was reading. Just stop blabbering and get lynched.

[Change Vote Lynch Cypher]

 

[Flower]

Why is nobody saying anything about Mel having 2 abilities and all other Townies just one action ?

 

[Shrike]

Why is nobody saying anything about Mel having 2 abilities and all other Townies just one action ?

Because your own 1.0 role had 3 abolties. Having 2 isn't too strange.

 

[青月光]

if you have any information and thoughts on hero and the situation

I almost didn't read anything today, don't feel like playing this one today.

Specially since I'm playing another one where I have a broken OP indie Kurumi role



I did read like what? The last 2 or 3 pages?

Well I have a one-shot roleblock ability so that's it.

Do what you will with it

 

[Flower]

---

Because your own 1.0 role had 3 abolties. Having 2 isn't too strange.

That role had a passive limiting me to only one action at night.

This actually makes it even more weird Mel can use 2 actions.

 

[青月光]

Oh and I have 3 abilities too.

 

[Vivo Diez]

I almost didn't read anything today, don't feel like playing this one today.

Specially since I'm playing another one where I have a broken OP indie Kurumi role



I did read like what? The last 2 or 3 pages?

Well I have a one-shot roleblock ability so that's it.

Do what you will with it

So you're throwing the game

 

[Flower]

Oh and I have 3 abilities too.

All one-shots and only one action at night?

 

[青月光]

All one-shots and only one action at night?

One has a cooldown of one night and is unlimited.

The other is a one shot (roleblock) that also enables me to use the former ability again 2 nights in a row (we could say it resets the cooldown).

And lastly a passive.

 

[Vivo Diez]

All one-shots and only one action at night?

Are you trying to hand her over on a silver platter to mafia? What are you doing here...

One has a cooldown of one night and is unlimited.

The other is a one shot (roleblock) that also enables me to use the former ability again 2 nights in a row (we could say it resets the cooldown).

And lastly a passive.

O-oh.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Let's stop with susing Nat and JW (even though it irked the hell out of me that he is just like 'lul I am mason' and didn't really do much else). Just stop and focus on possible scum.

Don't let Cyprus control the narrative by constantly posting and thus making people respond and waste time. She was trying to throw the sus away from Hero all day but also distance herself by saying 'He's town, we're brother and sister, he must be town! Bbbbbuuuut also I don't know his alignment, but it was just logical that he is town, right?'. Common.

Nuke her along with Hero tbh. Hero 'threw the game', so fuck him and she is trying to get out of it now.


"Actually doing something" so giving good and non-ultra-shit reads isn't doing anything? K.


It's not 'another one coming out', I've been tagged twice by Usopp hours ago and now by Kvothe while I was reading. Just stop blabbering and get lynched.

[Change Vote Lynch Cypher]

bolded is kinda funny lol. I skimmed through the thread and only melodie called her that before it got memed

if hero flips town, does that make cypher look better or worse?

Do you think Melodie is town then

 

[青月光]

Are you trying to hand her over on a silver platter to mafia? What are you doing here...


O-oh.

I bet Mafia has better targets than me

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

I almost didn't read anything today, don't feel like playing this one today.

Specially since I'm playing another one where I have a broken OP indie Kurumi role



I did read like what? The last 2 or 3 pages?

Well I have a one-shot roleblock ability so that's it.

Do what you will with it

i didnt ask for your abilities

 

[青月光]

i didnt ask for your abilities

Sorry

But I didn't say what the other two abilities do

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

 

[Flower]

One has a cooldown of one night and is unlimited.

The other is a one shot (roleblock) that also enables me to use the former ability again 2 nights in a row (we could say it resets the cooldown).

And lastly a passive.

How is this Town here?

 

[Natalija]

Let's stop with susing Nat and JW (even though it irked the hell out of me that he is just like 'lul I am mason' and didn't really do much else). Just stop and focus on possible scum.

Don't let Cyprus control the narrative by constantly posting and thus making people respond and waste time. She was trying to throw the sus away from Hero all day but also distance herself by saying 'He's town, we're brother and sister, he must be town! Bbbbbuuuut also I don't know his alignment, but it was just logical that he is town, right?'. Common.

Nuke her along with Hero tbh. Hero 'threw the game', so fuck him and she is trying to get out of it now.


"Actually doing something" so giving good and non-ultra-shit reads isn't doing anything? K.


It's not 'another one coming out', I've been tagged twice by Usopp hours ago and now by Kvothe while I was reading. Just stop blabbering and get lynched.

[Change Vote Lynch Cypher]

y-e-s, even more so for saying it with a Doffy avi