Game Holy Shōnen Trinity 5 (mafia wins!)

[Flower]

Are you being intentionally daft? Phase started. I got my results. I saw two users according to my actions lying aka Nat and vivo. Latter is a host error so leave that aside. And you wonder why I didn't jump on hero immediately after that?

Yes. Because Natalija revealed herself. And it's clear she didn't kill Sin. So why did you not instantly go for Hero?

 

[Melodie]

Yes. Because Natalija revealed herself. And it's clear she didn't kill Sin. So why did you not instantly go for Hero?

?????? Revealed herself how? Prior phases? If so from my perspective it still was a lie that she did nothing and therefore suspicious at the time

 

[Flower]

?????? Revealed herself how? Prior phases? If so from my perspective it still was a lie that she did nothing and therefore suspicious at the time

Do you even read anything at all? Or just come out when it's time to defend yourself?

 

[Flower]

@Melodie at least read host Write ups.

Natalija (Nefertari Vivi) has revealed her identity as the princess of Alabasta Kingdom.​

 

[Flower]

@Natalija and you're seriously trusting Melodie given all that?

 

[Melontonin]

Thanks Lemon!

We still don’t know what he used though, and Sin didn’t give any signs either (I think?)

Well he sure was confident that Sin killed Cooler, that could multiple possible roles but we shall wait for Viveo

 

[Hayumi]

I watched usopp. I opted to not send him a message

Did anyone visit him?

 

[Natalija]

@Natalija and you're seriously trusting Melodie given all that?

I'm trusting she did what she said she did because she caught me red handed. I do want to hear what @Juan did though

With Hero's flip we'll know what to do next, don't be alarmed

 

[Natalija]

Well he sure was confident that Sin killed Cooler, that could multiple possible roles but we shall wait for Viveo

Yeah, but Diez made it sound like Sin would know he used something on him. Let's see

 

[Flower]

I'm trusting she did what she said she did because she caught me red handed. I do want to hear what @Juan did though

With Hero's flip we'll know what to do next, don't be alarmed

Yeah, Hero is the last person I want to lynch given my role.

So I won't vote for him.

 

[Natalija]

Yeah, Hero is the last person I want to lynch given my role.

So I won't vote for him.

Do as you please.

 

[Flower]

@Hero what's the name of your passive?

 

[Juan]

I do want to hear what @Juan did though

i'm willing to claim if needed, but I think holding what kind of investigate ability I have hidden is a better idea, so as to confuse scum on what i'm carrying

 

[Natalija]

i'm willing to claim if needed, but I think holding what kind of investigate ability I have hidden is a better idea, so as to confuse scum on what i'm carrying

It's fine if you wanna keep it secret tbh, Hero's flip would also inform about you.

 

[Juan]

It's fine if you wanna keep it secret tbh, Hero's flip would also inform about you.

alrighty

 

[Flower]

Melodie, why so quiet again now?

 

[Hayumi]

Ussop went to sleep and now the thread died lmfao

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Why give scum such a role and why let me know who Hero is and Hero know who I am when he's scum? It doesn't add up at all.

this is racking my brain here as well. I have seen of scum roles getting this ability and town as well. Knowing the character and not the alignment.

What would be the purpose of this ability if you are both different alignment? I doubt for flavor.

But I don't exactly like his response as to why he blocked sin compare to usopp or xebec who he heavily sussed as a response to why he was seen shown visiting Sin.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

I am also thinking about Melodie's claim. She could be a scum watcher or someone in her team could be and she provided that information so she wouldn't get lynched but her posts with Nat didn't indicate that for me.

I don't think mafia would question or push for an innocent child but

 

[Flower]

this is racking my brain here as well. I have seen of scum roles getting this ability and town as well. Knowing the character and not the alignment.

What would be the purpose of this ability if you are both different alignment? I doubt for flavor.

But I don't exactly like his response as to why he blocked sin compare to usopp or xebec who he heavily sussed as a response to why he was seen shown visiting Sin.

It would make sense to me if I knew his character and had an alignment check, but what good does it do to know this when I can't even check his alignment?

The only reason I can think of is if we're both Town and the not knowing alignment thingy is just a nerf.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Did anyone else claim roleblocker?

 

[Flower]

Did anyone else claim roleblocker?

Cypher 1.0 was a 1 shot blocker, but nobody else claimed that iirc.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Cypher 1.0 was a 1 shot blocker, but nobody else claimed that iirc.

hmm nat was given a one shot watcher ability. Mel would be our watcher I'm assuming if she is telling the truth.

Vivo and Juan are the trackers?

 

[Flower]

hmm nat was given a one shot watcher ability. Mel would be our watcher I'm assuming if she is telling the truth.

Vivo and Juan are the trackers?

Apparently.

And apparently Vivo is a Tracker who did nothing at night.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

theres basically no resistance to this wagon too which worries me

 

[Natalija]

theres basically no resistance to this wagon too which worries me

Flowa is resisting all day long.

Even if it's a mislynch by some chance, it will be a useful one.

Right now I don't think two watchers could have made a mistake, unless if Melodie both watched and killed

 

[Flower]

theres basically no resistance to this wagon too which worries me

Either...

1) He's Town

Or

2) He's being bussed hard.

 

[Flower]

Flowa is resisting all day long.

Even if it's a mislynch by some chance, it will be a useful one.

Right now I don't think two watchers could have made a mistake, unless if Melodie both watched and killed

This is called game solving and not resisting. I legit said he could be scum. Just don't count on me to vote for him.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Flowa is resisting all day long.

Even if it's a mislynch by some chance, it will be a useful one.

Right now I don't think two watchers could have made a mistake, unless if Melodie both watched and killed

Flower being one yes but not anyone else I can see tbh. I will have to do a vote count later and see

 

[Natalija]

I still don't know how was I gifted an ability. If someone did it, please send more hopefully it's not a trap

 

[Flower]

Guess Hero's flip will also confirm me as Town as long as he has this passive and he wasn't given a fake role to claim.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

I still don't know how was I gifted an ability. If someone did it, please send more hopefully it's not a trap

i think the fact no one is saying they did it is more than likely not a trap and it's a town ability cause mafia would probably want to give reveal that they did it to get town credit

 

[Natalija]

i think the fact no one is saying they did it is more than likely not a trap and it's a town ability cause mafia would probably want to give reveal that they did it to get town credit

The fact that it was correct probably means that it isn't a trap. But still very strange, I was never given an ability before

 

[Flower]

In Get Good 2 I was given a role cop by the Godfather.

 

[Natalija]

I don't want gifts by scum, back off

 

[Flower]

I don't want gifts by scum, back off

Dw, the Godfather was Ish back then and he isn't in the game.

Was probably a Town ability.

 

[Ekkologix]

Again, how would I know?

It's not like Hayumi isn't permanently a hot topic. That much is clear.

This is the part where I lose some brain cells. I can’t give reasoning for why scum did what they did with the votes. Me and Cypher were both being sussed, that’s all I know. I’d really like to hear others comment on the whole voting thing and how it relates to melodie

i'll give u a reason thats very clear stop trying to deny it
hayumi is simply part of their scum team and they cant afford to lose him lol

surprise, i know

 

[Natalija]

Also maybe important to note: I got the ability before I revealed myself as Vivi.

 

[Flower]

Also maybe important to note: I got the ability before I revealed myself as Vivi.

D2, though?

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

1. Alibaba Saluja
2. Shrike > Hayumi
3. Go D. Usopp > Kvothe > Hayumi
4. Melodie > Hero
5. Dragon D Xebec > Melodie > Hero
6. Natalija > Hero
7. Vivo Diez > Alibaba > Hero
8. Cypher 2.0 > Melodie
9. nfcnorth
10. Hayumi > Hero
11. Kvothe Kingkiller > Hero
12. Melontonin > Hayumi > Melodie > Hero
13. Juan > Hero
14. John Wayne
15. Hero > Hero

Self votes:
Alibaba, nfcnorth, john wayne

Hero	9​
Hayumi	2​
Melodie	1​

 

[Natalija]

D2, though?

Yeah.

 

[Ekkologix]

You didn't lie at all.

All you said previously is you saw Hero and Mel visit Sin.


It's even possible to make up a Watcher role given what you put out there, just add you to the visitors and anyone can fake Watcher.


Fact is if she saw you two visit and you're confirmed, I would insta assume Hero is the killer and go for him if I was Mel and was Town. Mel didn't. Stop trusting her this much.

i belive i was the first one to say an interaction happened between mel and sin, but i thought sin failed a kill on her

juan said hero targeted sin i think

u can kinda make out a watcher result off that tbh

 

[Ekkologix]

1. Alibaba Saluja
2. Shrike > Hayumi
3. Go D. Usopp > Kvothe > Hayumi
4. Melodie > Hero
5. Dragon D Xebec > Melodie > Hero
6. Natalija > Hero
7. Vivo Diez > Alibaba > Hero
8. Cypher 2.0 > Melodie
9. nfcnorth
10. Hayumi > Hero
11. Kvothe Kingkiller > Hero
12. Melontonin > Hayumi > Melodie > Hero
13. Juan > Hero
14. John Wayne
15. Hero > Hero

Self votes:
Alibaba, nfcnorth, john wayne

Hero	9​
Hayumi	2​
Melodie	1​

geezus how the fk does he have 9 votes lol

i think we r getting played, thats alot of votes tbh

hes not even defending himself tho

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

i belive i was the first one to say an interaction happened between mel and sin, but i thought sin failed a kill on her

juan said hero targeted sin i think

u can kinda make out a watcher result off that tbh

she knew nat was on sin too

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

geezus how the fk does he have 9 votes lol

i think we r getting played, thats alot of votes tbh

hes not even defending himself tho

yah that's what worries me tbh

 

[Natalija]

i belive i was the first one to say an interaction happened between mel and sin, but i thought sin failed a kill on her

juan said hero targeted sin i think

u can kinda make out a watcher result off that tbh

You can't do it to such detail to know there was even a Diez mistake.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

You can't do it to such detail to know there was even a Diez mistake.

i need to know what his results were n1 and n2. if he tracked sin n1, why would he attempt to do it n2 and then back out from it.

 

[Flower]

she knew nat was on sin too

Since Nat claimed she was on Sin, this can still be fake.

 

[Natalija]

i need to know what his results were n1 and n2. if he tracked sin n1, why would he attempt to do it n2 and then back out from it.

I don't think he tracked him, he never said that. That's a Flowa original made up story.

Dies just said he used something on him

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

I don't think he tracked him, he never said that. That's a Flowa original made up story.

Dies just said he used something on him

Oh

 

[Flower]

I don't think he tracked him, he never said that. That's a Flowa original made up story.

Dies just said he used something on him

Which was obviously a tracker.

Please just read posts...

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Another worry I just thought of as to why there are many votes, hero is unlynchable

 

[Natalija]

Because you were the most deadset on getting him out of the game and I used an ability on you that I think you somehow ignored

Which was obviously a tracker.

Please just read posts...

Read above. That's the only thing we have before he finally speaks

 

[Flower]

Read above. That's the only thing we have before he finally speaks

Not the only thing .

-@SinRaven was deadset on lynching Cooler on possibly the most minor thing I've ever seen in a mafia game. I don't think him ending up dead after he didn't get lynched is a coincidence.

-@Nessos is being very blunt and specific for this claim to not be true imo. I wonder that encouraged him to reveal tho?

-I like that @Alibaba Saluja is finally posting more relevant shit.

-@Shrike is being unusually on the down low, usually he's in here leading investigations.

-I can't keep track of all of @Go D. Usopp 's theories. It seems orchestrated to me.

-@Hayumi's actions and stances have been a bit weird lately, I need to read up on her posts.

 

[Natalija]

Not the only thing .

Yeah, he obviously thought Sin killed Cooler. But he should clear it up either way. We have hours of time to talk

 

[Vivo Diez]

Which was obviously a tracker.

Please just read posts...

Huh ?

 

[Flower]

Huh ?

Huh .

 

[Ekkologix]

Another worry I just thought of as to why there are many votes, hero is unlynchable

w8 did he say he is unlynchable?

will they lynch fails or go to next in line lol. or maybe goes to cypher

being unlychable seems scum ability lol

 

[Vivo Diez]

I'm on the fence whether I should reveal more than I have. It's not a hard investigative case with what I've already said and if I straight up claim I'll be reduced to Xebec levels of uselessness

 

[Juan]

Another worry I just thought of as to why there are many votes, hero is unlynchable

i don't think nitty is retarded

 

[Flower]

I feel like the game is headed the wrong direction .

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

w8 did he say he is unlynchable?

will they lynch fails or go to next in line lol. or maybe goes to cypher

being unlychable seems scum ability lol

he didnt. Just a theory why there would be so many votes on him

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

i don't think nitty is retarded

were you not there when sin had a role where he can't be lynched or killed and the only way to get rid of him was to eliminate his other teammates

 

[Natalija]

I'm on the fence whether I should reveal more than I have. It's not a hard investigative case with what I've already said and if I straight up claim I'll be reduced to Xebec levels of uselessness

I'll be frank, I'm not entirely sure.

But Sin was immune to role blocks, so maybe it wasn't that

 

[Juan]

were you not there when sin had a role where he can't be lynched or killed and the only way to get rid of him was to eliminate his other teammates

no

what the fuck

maybe nitty IS retarded

 

[Natalija]

no

what the fuck

maybe nitty IS retarded

Yeah, such roles exist. It's pretty cool when you roll scum with that

 

[Ekkologix]

well then start by lynching his teammates hayumi cypher shrike NFC maybe

 

[Flower]

I once included two unlynchable and unkillable scums in the same scum team when I hosted a game.

 

[Natalija]

I once included two unlynchable and unkillable scums in the same scum team when I hosted a game.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

well then start by lynching his teammates hayumi cypher shrike NFC maybe

down for nfc as a second wagon tbh

 

[Flower]

well then start by lynching his teammates hayumi cypher shrike NFC maybe

Not this s*** again.

 

[Ekkologix]

Not this s*** again.

u dug ur own grave again

 

[Flower]

Scum Charles .

 

[Natalija]

Scum Charles .

I gave your scum role some justice

 

[Flower]

I gave your scum role some justice

You were Cultafia Godfather.


I was never Cultafia.


I wanna be that one day.

 

[Ekkologix]

k real talk i think we shud change off the hero wagon man lol

look how quiet it got with him leading there and ningens happy about it

 

[Flower]

k real talk i think we shud change off the hero wagon man lol

look how quiet it got with him leading there and ningens happy about it

Let's just go for Scumlodie.

 

[Vivo Diez]

down for nfc as a second wagon tbh

What's the case against nfc?

 

[Ekkologix]

Let's just go for Scumlodie.

if u will hard cfd im down lol
cant get u guys to vote hayumi anyway

[vote lynch melodie]

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

What's the case against nfc?

meta read for me