Game Holy Shōnen Trinity 5 (mafia wins!)

[Ekkologix]

I've seen this, it was in a 50 player game too

That guy won

jealous much cuz u lost ur vote count job??

 

[Natalija]

The sub arguments are bullshit anyway. Nat got subbed in as mafia last game and used the "unlikely to be subbed in as mafia" excuse.

It was different because my role just got added. This one already existed

 

[John Wayne]

jealous much cuz u lost ur vote count job??

always bby

 

[Flower]

Why do I need to reveal? I’m at work rn. Give me a rundown.

Confirmed Town Nat wants to lynch either you or Melodie today.

 

[Ekkologix]

So we have almost the same reads, then.

about 70% i guess
we never agree on something so maybe i shud invert my reads lol

 

[Vivo Diez]

It was different because my role just got added. This one already existed

Yeh, we don't know how the GM deems necessary to balance the game. So to claim that "oh its unlikely or likely x or y subbed in for mafia" when not having the full view of the game is kinda pointless.

 

[Hero]

I skimmed the thread. Y’all haven’t said shit that isn’t already known. I am town and you already know who I am.

I roleblocked attempted Sin last night. Since there were so many kills day 1, I wanted to confirm the Sin and Cooler theory. Besides, he was playing very lax and not really doing all the much within the second phase when there was so much to dig apart.

 

[Ekkologix]

i say we leave hero

put hayumi and melodie as the wagons

and keep eye on xebec. hes just slipping outta the radar

i really dont think hero and cypher r prio targets now

stop the nonsense derail for the 3rd time man

 

[Natalija]

I skimmed the thread. Y’all haven’t said shit that isn’t already known. I am town and you already know who I am.

I roleblocked attempted Sin last night. Since there were so many kills day 1, I wanted to confirm the Sin and Cooler theory. Besides, he was playing very lax and not really doing all the much within the second phase when there was so much to dig apart.

Is that so?

Because you and Melodie visited Sin last night, and now he's dead.

 

[Hero]

I’ll be off in 2.5 hours. I’ll be back

I think Melodie is the better option between him and Hayumi.

 

[Ekkologix]

I skimmed the thread. Y’all haven’t said shit that isn’t already known. I am town and you already know who I am.

I roleblocked attempted Sin last night. Since there were so many kills day 1, I wanted to confirm the Sin and Cooler theory. Besides, he was playing very lax and not really doing all the much within the second phase when there was so much to dig apart.

sin is immune to roleblocks lol thats a bit too convenient

 

[Flower]

Is that so?

Because you and Melodie visited Sin last night, and now he's dead.

Yes because Mel is the frigging scum killer.

 

[Hero]

Is that so?

Because you and Melodie visited Sin last night, and now he's dead.

I just told you I tried to roleblock sin. Get off my dick. If you think I’m scum, lynch me. This is the last time I’m speaking to you.

I have 1 passive which is the same as cypher’s & 1 active which I told you I used last night.

 

[Hero]

Is that so?

Because you and Melodie visited Sin last night, and now he's dead.

I just told you I tried to roleblock sin. Get off my dick. If you think I’m scum, lynch me. This is the last time I’m speaking to you.

I have 1 passive which is the same as cypher’s & 1 active which I told you I used.

 

[Ekkologix]

like sin cant miss a kill cuz of roleblocks

he has to have died by mafia or indie cuz their kills process first. not by vig (doubt we got another vig anyway tbh)

or sins's target was protected. no other possible outcome

 

[Hero]

sin is immune to roleblocks lol thats a bit too convenient

Then lynch me. I’m not arguing with no player dumber than me.

Not saying you’re dumb, but I’m not doing a Hayumi and losing my breath on this shit.

 

[Natalija]

I just told you I tried to roleblock sin. Get off my dick. If you think I’m scum, lynch me. This is the last time I’m speaking to you.

I have 1 passive which is the same as cypher’s & 1 active which I told you I used.

Don't be a sensitive princess, you asked for a rundown and I have you one. We're waiting on Melodie to speak about it too, and then we'll see.

 

[Natalija]

*gave you

 

[Ekkologix]

why is everyone and their mom targeting sin tho, why not hayumi

its just way too convienient for our claimed vig to just enjoy carefree life. none even protected him probably lol

 

[Hero]

Don't be a sensitive princess, you asked for a rundown and I have you one. We're waiting on Melodie to speak about it too, and then we'll see.

I don’t care. Do what you want. It’s very obvious which of the two of us are mafia based on thread presence.

 

[Flower]

Oh for crying out loud.

[Vote Lynch Melodie].

How much evidence do you need that this girl is scum?

 

[Vivo Diez]

Then lynch me. I’m not arguing with no player dumber than me.

Not saying you’re dumb, but I’m not doing a Hayumi and losing my breath on this shit.

Somebody edited their post huh. I thought that was against the rules?

 

[Melontonin]

Absolutely not, we're lynching Hero or Melodie today.

Why not Hayumi?

 

[Ekkologix]

Then lynch me. I’m not arguing with no player dumber than me.

Not saying you’re dumb, but I’m not doing a Hayumi and losing my breath on this shit.

dude im not lynching u i want hayumi or melodie as wagons wtf

if i want to br lynched be my guess

i think u r nonhostile independent with cypher since nessos was the guilty and hostile independent

 

[Ekkologix]

meaning no sk this game and hayumi/melodie is mafia lol

 

[Natalija]

Why not Hayumi?

I'm not against a Hayumi lynch, as always, but:

Because you and Melodie visited Sin last night, and now he's dead.

 

[Ekkologix]

dude im not lynching u i want hayumi or melodie as wagons wtf

if i want to br lynched be my guess

i think u r nonhostile independent with cypher since nessos was the guilty and hostile independent

if u want to be lynched be my guest*

fken phone

 

[Flower]

I'm still Town, though, but I'm actually fine with Usopp calling me non hostile Indie, too.

Better than his Cypher scum tinfoils.

 

[Melontonin]

How many people are actually buying this bomber claim?

I'll be honest, I'm leaving it alone for now. There are more suspicious people than Xebec rn: Hayumi, Hero, Melodie. I think arguing with him won't get us anywhere, just a ton of time wasting back and forth. We need a night action to confirm ideas of his alignment and until then I don't think he's a good lynch candidate.

There are tons more people that layed low from the crazy amount of attention he had yesterday.

 

[Natalija]

Oh for crying out loud.

[Vote Lynch Melodie].

How much evidence do you need that this girl is scum?

She said something very interesting, and if she can back it up, then she isn't

 

[Flower]

You do realize that with Mel/Hero being confirmed scum killer this means Hayumi is in the clear, actually, right?

Because scums only have one killing role.

 

[John Wayne]

Better than his Cypher scum tinfoils.

I mean your reactions are pretty funny in retrospect

 

[Flower]

She said something very interesting, and if she can back it up, then she isn't

She has to be because she lied about her voting power.

 

[Vivo Diez]

You do realize that with Mel/Hero being confirmed scum killer this means Hayumi is in the clear, actually, right?

Because scums only have one killing role.

Huh.

 

[John Wayne]

You do realize that with Mel/Hero being confirmed scum killer this means Hayumi is in the clear, actually, right?

Because scums only have one killing role.

why would they only have one killing role?

 

[Flower]

why would they only have one killing role?

Read the mechanics.

 

[Natalija]

Flowa I want to lynch you just based on the things you're saying today

 

[Flower]

Flowa I want to lynch you just based on the things you're saying today

Actually read the mechanics for once.

 

[Dragon D Xebec]

Melodie is probably GF. Very likely GF has two voting power. Melodie killed SinRaven while Hero roleblocked SinRaven because those two visited SinRaven yesterday.

 

[John Wayne]

Read the mechanics.

I did

"Faction kills are performed by a specific member of that mafia, and can be tracked or roleblocked by targeting that person. The mafia will decide among themselves who receives which role."

All this says is that a specific member performs the faction kill each night and that scum gets to decide who gets what role. It doesn't say a role performs it but a member.

 

[Natalija]

Actually read the mechanics for once.

They have a faction kill and can choose who kills, I see that.

 

[Flower]

Faction kills are carried out by a specific member of the Mafia.

This heavily implies there is only one killer.

That's why Nessos was there as an Anti-Town Indie and that's why Town has this many killers...to increase the amount of Town kills for balance reasons.

 

[Melontonin]

I'm inclined to believe Hero tbh.
[ vote lynch Melodie ]

 

[Flower]

I did

"Faction kills are performed by a specific member of that mafia, and can be tracked or roleblocked by targeting that person. The mafia will decide among themselves who receives which role."

All this says is that a specific member performs the faction kill each night and that scum gets to decide who gets what role. It doesn't say a role performs it but a member.

Still only one kill.

 

[Natalija]

Yes, it's possible that Hayumi is vig, which is why we should lynch Hero/Melodie.

 

[John Wayne]

Or it could mean that all roles could potentially perform the faction kill and add a bonus effect to it depending on the role. I've played in mafia teams that worked like that.

 

[Vivo Diez]

For someone who by her own self admittance doesn't read the rules, you were quick to jump to the rules because of your seemingly TMI slip.

If you weren't in my top 3 girls of this game, I would put you at the top of my sus list right about now @Cypher

 

[John Wayne]

If you weren't in my top 3 girls of this game, I would put you at the top of my sus list right about now @Cypher

but there's only like 3 girls in this game

 

[Natalija]

There's four girls in this game

 

[Flower]

For someone who by her own self admittance doesn't read the rules, you were quick to jump to the rules because of your seemingly TMI slip.

If you weren't in my top 3 girls of this game, I would put you at the top of my sus list right about now @Cypher

How generous of you.

 

[Flower]

There's four girls in this game

There are five now.

 

[Natalija]

There are five now.

No, you, me, Melon and Kvo.

 

[Flower]

No, you, me, Melon and Kvo.

And Melodie, too.

 

[John Wayne]

There are five now.

hmmm

You
Natalija
Kvothe
Melodie

who's the 5th?

 

[Natalija]

OH LOL ALSO MELODIE. She posts so little, I keep forgetting her

 

[Vivo Diez]

but there's only like 3 girls in this game

It's a gamble that there are even 2. The internet is a dangerous place

 

[Melontonin]

There's four girls in this game

 

[Vivo Diez]

hmmm

You
Natalija
Kvothe
Melodie

who's the 5th?

Oh right. Ye Kvothe is a definitely a girl. Can confirm

 

[Flower]

Why do I always accidentally Winner a post when I just wanna click Funny?

Ffs.

 

[Melontonin]

Wait, isn't Melodie a guy? I saw someone say "him"

 

[Natalija]

Busted? Did you wanna hide being a girl?

 

[Vivo Diez]

@John Wayne freaks me out with that masculine name juxtaposed with that loli avatar.

 

[Melontonin]

Busted? Did you wanna hide being a girl?

I liked people calling me lemon guy tbh

 

[John Wayne]

@John Wayne freaks me out with that masculine name juxtaposed with that loli avatar.

Just as planned

 

[nfcnorth]

Faction kills are carried out by a specific member of the Mafia.

This heavily implies there is only one killer.

That's why Nessos was there as an Anti-Town Indie and that's why Town has this many killers...to increase the amount of Town kills for balance reasons.

Think about why this would be bad though. It would be straight up unfun for the mafia to entierly depend on one person to do all there dirty work. You want to give all sides the ability to win and doing it the way you described is risky because it severely goes against this. Its far more likely they as a faction have one kill and get to pick who does it.

 

[nfcnorth]

As a host its best to give people as few reasons to hate you as possible Unless you are the type who likes pain

 

[Flower]

I liked people calling me lemon guy tbh

Just play with Iwan. He gets it wrong even when he actually knows you're a girl.

 

[Melontonin]

Did you anything last night @Alibaba Saluja and @Vivo Diez ?

 

[Flower]

But ya, I need to sleep now. GN!

 

[Natalija]

Just play with Iwan. He gets it wrong even when he actually knows you're a girl.

I’m thankful @Iwandesu always talks about me correctly

 

[Vivo Diez]

Did you anything last night @Alibaba Saluja and @Vivo Diez ?

Nope.

 

[Juan]

I skimmed the thread. Y’all haven’t said shit that isn’t already known. I am town and you already know who I am.

I roleblocked attempted Sin last night. Since there were so many kills day 1, I wanted to confirm the Sin and Cooler theory. Besides, he was playing very lax and not really doing all the much within the second phase when there was so much to dig apart.

> i tried to roleblock the unroleblockable character that turned up dead lol oopsie daisy dearie me

 

[Melodie]

Nataljia, vive dude and Hero targeted Sin in the night phase. I watched him and sent him a message.

so

1. Nat is lying? she targeted him
2. vive targeted sin
3. Hero targeted sin

 

[Melodie]

vive also is lying since he said he did nothing last night phase

 

[Natalija]

Nataljia, vive dude and Hero targeted Sin in the night phase. I watched him and sent him a message.

so

1. Nat is lying? she targeted him
2. vive targeted sin
3. Hero targeted sin

Okay. Melodie is telling the truth.

Lynch Hero.

 

[Melodie]

nevermind the vive thing, it was a host error (still sus tho..)

 

[Juan]

Nataljia, vive dude and Hero targeted Sin in the night phase. I watched him and sent him a message.

so

1. Nat is lying? she targeted him
2. vive targeted sin
3. Hero targeted sin

oh look

sounds like this lines up with something a certain someone else implied

wonder who that devilishly handsome someone could be

hmmmm

 

[Natalija]

nevermind the vive thing, it was a host error (still sus tho..)

Same thing happened to me. I also watched Sin.

 

[Natalija]

I'm inclined to believe Hero tbh.
[ vote lynch Melodie ]

Vote Hero, Lemon

 

[Juan]

two watchers?