Game Holy Shōnen Trinity 5 (mafia wins!)

[Ekkologix]

Ok I'll share my wisdom with you

Vivo and Shrike are scum.

If Melodie or one of those doesn't flip scum then Usopp is definitely scum.

You're welcome

u mean usopp the role that u have right?

I would bet in usopp since he seems chaotic like in ToG

thats my secret capt'n... i am always chaotic

same question to you @Melodie cause I have short term memory

melodie watched me n1 but never sent a message i think

cuz she asked sin about me day 2 iirc

 

[Ekkologix]

what are you committed to

u arent powerwolfing us here right terry chan?

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

This whole thing is either a big clusterfuck or very simple and people are just confusing us.

Given how weak and nerfed Town roles are, I'm inclined to believe the latter is the case.

I would say Melodie, Shrike, Vivo and North are just the scum team, got caught and now they're spreading doubts.

call me paranoid but that just seems way too easy and considering how WoT went, I consider that a little too optimistic

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

u arent powerwolfing us here right terry chan?

I'm trying to make me a target shh

 

[Juan]

@Juan what is your character?

 

[Flower]

call me paranoid but that just seems way too easy and considering how WoT went, I consider that a little too optimistic

WoT had basically a semi open setup with Town knowing what their fellow Townies could do. Scum had to be a bit hax to balance this out. I don't see Mafia being overly powerful here.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

ooooh wow thats some bullshit then

 

[nfcnorth]

hmm well I know you like to hold your vote.

speaking of which, who would you consider for today's lynch as well as second wagon?

Tbh I have a couple people in mind. But tbh I think I might be doing so because of their stances on me so I kind of want to remove that and reassess because I think there is some bias in my thoughts right now.

 

[Juan]

also, wtf are you all on about

so i'm a tracker that can't be seen, but I ALSO roleblock people that target me?

that would make me unable to be caught mechanically lol, tf

 

[青月光]

Point 1 doesn't actually make sense. It's actually because of active town being active and people feeling good about that fact it less likely they get targeted. Why target someone you feel good about with a real?

As for point two it comes down to the fact you kind of have to pick someone. Which largely depends on who you ask and what there reads are. Calling it random is inaccurate as there is some logic to it. Even if it is as simple as they have played more games with me than other people they are looking at.

Me like the way you reason. You picked my interest about debating you. Let's go



1) That psychological reason may or may not be valid. People might take more pleasure in winning the game/the thought of it, than the entertainment they take from the "means"/during the game. As people play to win, this scenario I described is more likely than that one.

2) hmmm familiarity does indeed makes people more likely to think about us. I approve of this point if:

2.1) the scum team has played with you a lot more before (so it depends on how much you have played and who the scum team is). With the information available this is largely impossible to prove.

2.2) my point 1 gets completely discredited.

 

[Ekkologix]

melodie is scum getting bussed

one of shrike/juan has to be scum

one or both of vivo/alibaba has to be scum.

hayumi is also scum. idk what to make of nfc

game should be solverinoed

xebec is just slipping the radar but could be town with that useless ability after he claimed it

in the event kvothe is wolfing us then cypher is probably scum too but thats such a low chance lol

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

my submitted character shouldn't be in this game since I dropped out initially

 

[Flower]

Yeah, Neji should be Town.

And Shrike the Inventor/Hider hybrid ain't even Usopp? Lmfao.

 

[Juan]

ooooh wow thats some bullshit then

hm?

 

[Ekkologix]

now if u guys will gladly claim ur sht night 1 and 2 so we can piece it all together

 

[Juan]

my submitted character shouldn't be in this game since I dropped out initially

neji was your submission?

 

[Flower]

It's in the submission list, so it's in the game.

 

[Vivo Diez]

what are you committed to

Currently I'm on a first date with Melodie, Juan and NFC lynches.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

It's in the submission list, so it's in the game.

cant be

i dropped out. that would require nitty to drop another person submission from the game

 

[Flower]

@Kvothe Kingkiller Melodie basically replaced you since she has no submission.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

i dropped out PRIOR to the game too

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

@Kvothe Kingkiller Melodie basically replaced you since she has no submission.

Oh ok thats fine then

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

neji could be a scum character. He could be a tracker and roleblock people who checks him tbh

 

[Flower]

neji could be a scum character. He could be a tracker and roleblock people who checks him tbh

While also not appearing in Watcher results?

Do you want Juan to be scum?

 

[Juan]

man nvm i want this supposed scum role kvothe came up with, nitty did me dirty

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

While also not appearing in Watcher results?

Do you want Juan to be scum?

its not out of the ordinary considering mafia roles are quite strong in nitty's games.

I take everything with a grain of salt.

 

[Flower]

man nvm i want this supposed scum role kvothe came up with, nitty did me dirty

I want to be an unkillable Townie again.

 

[Shrike]

Send me something.

I'll send you a policy lynch in the next game for the horrendous play this game

 

[Flower]

its not out of the ordinary considering mafia roles are quite strong in nitty's games.

I take everything with a grain of salt.

Yes, but this role is just BS. You can't catch him.

 

[Hayumi]

man nvm i want this supposed scum role kvothe came up with, nitty did me dirty

Aww, so nitty gave you a shitty scum role instead?

 

[Flower]

I'll send you a policy lynch in the next game for the horrendous play this game

I'm already a policy lynch, so go ahead.

I just haven't been Town in ages.

 

[Juan]

if i was scum that was immune to watchers, i would have no reason to come out with "shrike is scum" lol

and before any of you say I was trying to distract from melodie, notice the moment i claimed i was ok with lynching melodie first

 

[Juan]

Aww, so nitty gave you a shitty scum role instead?

i dont talk to vanilla characters

@ me when your balls arent crushed

 

[Flower]

i dont talk to vanilla characters

@ me when your balls arent crushed

You talk to your sensei like that ?

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Yes, but this role is just BS. You can't catch him.

which is why I'm going to be mad if this is true cause what would be the point of watchers in this game

 

[Juan]

You talk to your sensei like that ?

my only sensei is my clan

 

[Flower]

Gai and Neji being different factions would be weird ngl.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Gai and Neji being different factions would be weird ngl.

We don't exactly know what the mafia team would be tbh

i am guessing usopp is a scum role though

 

[Juan]

@Pool Party Nitty can u update threadmarks pls

 

[Flower]

We don't exactly know what the mafia team would be tbh

i am guessing usopp is a scum role though

Scums are probably pirate charas from One Piece.


Poison: Crocodile or Capone Bege.

And I don't think Hayumi is scum because that would mean the Mafia has a double night kill and poison.

 

[Shrike]

Gai and Neji being different factions would be weird ngl.

But Madara and Shikamaru being on the same team wouldn't be weird?

I am literally at a point where flaming your logic is useless anymore and if you aren't scum it's insanity to read your spam posts.

 

[青月光]

Updating

Scum

Intuitive mind:

Shrike, Vivo

Rational mind:

NFC

One to go

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Scums are probably pirate charas from One Piece.


Poison: Crocodile or Capone Bege.

And I don't think Hayumi is scum because that would mean the Mafia has a double night kill and poison.

Does Bege poison? I thought he just makes stuff

 

[Flower]

But Madara and Shikamaru being on the same team wouldn't be weird?

I am literally at a point where flaming your logic is useless anymore and if you aren't scum it's insanity to read your spam posts.

How about you just read the flipped roles.

 

[Vivo Diez]

Does Bege poison? I thought he just makes stuff

His whole plan about assassinating Big Mom was to poison her

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

supposed claims so far

1. Alibaba Saluja - roleblock one shot, unknown ability
2. Shrike - inventor, deflector
3. Go D. Usopp - message, info gathering
4. Melodie - watcher, message
5. Dragon D Xebec - vengeful townie/bomb
6. Vivo Diez - roleblocker..?
7. Cypher 2.0 - ?
8. nfcnorth - info gathering ability
9. Hayumi - vig, might guy
10. Kvothe Kingkiller - no actives
11. Juan - tracker
12. John Wayne - masoner

 

[Flower]

Does Bege poison? I thought he just makes stuff

He had the plot to assassinate Linlin with poison rocket launchers made by Caesar Clown.

So yes, he does.

 

[Shrike]

supposed claims so far

I did NOT claim anything, let alone inventor. Didn't even know what an inventor was until Cypher started making it up.

 

[Flower]

supposed claims so far

I'm Rukia Kuchiki and my ability is a secret <3.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

I did NOT claim anything, let alone inventor. Didn't even know what an inventor was until Cypher started making it up.

inventor is a role that fits your description where you give out abilities

 

[Flower]

I did NOT claim anything, let alone inventor. Didn't even know what an inventor was until Cypher started making it up.

Handing out abilities is legit an Inventor.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

He had the plot to assassinate Linlin with poison rocket launchers made by Caesar Clown.

So yes, he does.

kind of a stretch cause its made by caesar. I see it more for croc than bege lol could be wrong though

 

[Shrike]

inventor is a role that fits your description where you give out abilities

I do not give out abilities. It was a one shot. So no, I didn't claim anything near it.

 

[Flower]

Redirecting abilities from yourself onto your target is also called a Hider.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

also nitty stopped reading one piece after the time skip so my guess he checked wiki page of bege and looked at abilities imo xd

 

[Flower]

So how in the world is an Inventor/Hider hybrid not Usopp?

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

So how in the world is an Inventor/Hider hybrid not Usopp?

can see that for bege tbh

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

I do not give out abilities. It was a one shot. So no, I didn't claim anything near it.

iii think youre missing the point. I chose something that was close to what youre describing when you gave an ability to nat

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

it was a one shot? I thought you can give another

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

it was a one shot? I thought you can give another

oh nvm just read your post again

 

[Hayumi]

i dont talk to vanilla characters

@ me when your balls arent crushed

Smh, well maybe if you hadn’t been so rough with me last night...

 

[Flower]

Passive - Miss Wednesday] - Vivi is masquerading as a member of the criminal syndicate Baroque Works. If Vivi's alignment is investigated, she will appear to be guilty. If Vivi's role is investigated, she will appear as Miss Wednesday.


I think this is interesting to note. This ability implies Crocodile is possibly the Godfather of the Mafia team. Or part of it because the guilty check also shows Nat as part of the Baroque Works.

 

[Ekkologix]

So how in the world is an Inventor/Hider hybrid not Usopp?

nooooo

usopp has to be the one shooting us from far and destroying us with tripple roleocks stronger than mei

i think shrike might be ichibe

he draws out stuff and send it. i forgot that bleach character tbh but he had hax abilities

 

[Ekkologix]

on members mafia badalight has brokis scum role and he had to draw stuff lol

ichibe can be a scum artist and he draws out stuff

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Passive - Miss Wednesday] - Vivi is masquerading as a member of the criminal syndicate Baroque Works. If Vivi's alignment is investigated, she will appear to be guilty. If Vivi's role is investigated, she will appear as Miss Wednesday.


I think this is interesting to note. This ability implies Crocodile is possibly the Godfather of the Mafia team. Or part of it because the guilty check also shows Nat as part of the Baroque Works.

interesting to note yea. It might be OP chars that are scum. We haven't seen Teach or Linlin yet have we?

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

wait usopp in baroque works? lol

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

thatd be funny to see ngl

 

[Juan]

nooooo

usopp has to be the one shooting us from far and destroying us with tripple roleocks stronger than mei

i think shrike might be ichibe

he draws out stuff and send it. i forgot that bleach character tbh but he had hax abilities

that's not what ichibei does

he doesn't send out drawings

 

[Flower]

interesting to note yea. It might be OP chars that are scum. We haven't seen Teach or Linlin yet have we?

Nope.

Linlin, Teach, Bege and Crocodile all are part of the One Piece Underworld. Same as Doflamingo who already flipped scum and who made a living by manipulating the government and pirates alike.

 

[Vivo Diez]

interesting to note yea. It might be OP chars that are scum. We haven't seen Teach or Linlin yet have we?

Doflamingo was indie. Vivi was town. Kuzan was town. Spandam was town. Wut are you on about.

 

[Ekkologix]

wait usopp in baroque works? lol

well bege usopp blackbeard and crocodile look like a good scum team lol

 

[Shrike]

wait usopp in baroque works? lol

Don't look for logic in flavor, there is none. As I said, Mei Terumi, Madara and Shikamaru were all town. Doflamingo was an indie. Don't try to analyze this, it's the wrong route. Watch people's behavior, back to the basics.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Doflamingo was indie. Vivi was town. Kuzan was town. Spandam was town. Wut are you on about.

I'm not saying all of them. Just a theory

alternatively it could be the villain of each series

 

[Flower]

We have yet to see a pirate antagonist from One Piece flip Town.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Don't look for logic in flavor, there is none. As I said, Mei Terumi, Madara and Shikamaru were all town. Doflamingo was an indie. Don't try to analyze this, it's the wrong route. Watch people's behavior, back to the basics.

i just want some fun theorizing

 

[Vivo Diez]

I'm not saying all of them. Just a theory

alternatively it could be the villain of each series

But Madara and Spandam flipped town

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

But Madara and Spandam flipped town

breh theres still obito. Im not saying allll villains im saying specific villains

 

[Ekkologix]

well theorize all u want ningens

but usopp has to be a scum role

good sht nitty

 

[Flower]

But Madara and Spandam flipped town

PIRATE VILLAIN.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

yall ruining my fun