Game Women In Fiction (mafia+indie win!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
Go D. Usopp said:
xadlin was doctor role but he died early

hero was immune to poisons and stuff but we never had to shoot him cuz he wasnt being an active threat

townies with these protective abilities cuda cucked us hard
Click to expand...

Hero was immune to your poison and your death miller ability, and Lord Melkor also became immune to those things after Hero trained him.
 
Go D. Usopp said:
this stuff was more calculated than u guys think

:witty

we r ridiculously outnumbered and down in vote power, i cant believe we pulled that off somehow

@Pool Party Nitty the roles r really well done wtf

every1 does something unique to them and together they become full force
Click to expand...
our actions were pretty on point, the only bad action we had was vote-stealing cooler. It helped that you were able to infiltrate the police force too.

It also helped that town was claiming their abilities.
 
WolfPrinceKiba said:
[Active - Identity Theft] - During the day, Mia can forge the documents necessary to impersonate another player, stealing their voting power.

I just love that I hit the nail on the head that FP had stolen Cooler's vote power :lmao
Click to expand...
At that time, we thought, if we had stolen the vote power, you would've been lynched lol but it actually didn't matter cause of your ability + hayumi's.
 
Go D. Usopp said:
even today we r hella down in vote power

had cooler/kat being dead by us or another townie, we will be struggling lol

probaably would need one more mislynch and night kill
Click to expand...
its why i never count anything out until I know of all the roles. I had a feeling the reason we didn't immediately win cause town had to have another vote power somewhere.

Reminder of the league game where mafia thought they had majority vote power and outed themselves by mislynching me.
 
Kvothe Kingkiller said:
its why i never count anything out until I know of all the roles. I had a feeling the reason we didn't immediately win cause town had to have another vote power somewhere.

Reminder of the league game where mafia thought they had majority vote power and outed themselves by mislynching me.
Click to expand...

Bold of you to bring that game up around Oddjutsu :homer
 
98688.gif


Great game everyone, amazing work Nitty! It must have been a nightmare to manage!

A big commend to my mafia teammates, I think we put up quite a spectacle.
 
DeVision said:
@Kvothe Kingkiller just here to say that you would've gone down if I was in.... I knew it. I effin knew it.

Liesopp was obvious as hell again too.. Damn.
Click to expand...
shoulda joined in :caticon

I don't get the anger on Usopp. He played well, people say he was outed scum at this point but even when he was on the goddess fake write up and the dead townies come back (the chat was also locked for us so me, JW, Usopp, and Parka couldn't coordinate), everyone still wanted to go lynch WPK. I tried to prod people about it and I even quoted Cooler thinking that was surprising he thought Usopp was town but no one was biting it so /shrug

I feel like ppl should lay off him. Parka, I, and JW also won the game but it seems a lot of anger is directed at Usopp and I suppose town for losing.

I also didn't do anything that was particularly scummy other than me getting caught off of a random interaction that siggy saw. My reaction to it was poor and so was my claim (chat was locked so I didn't have ideas of what to claim. Was also sick from the second vaccine shot.) but literally only happened off of a passive ability and not with someone that targeted me.

Siggy could've seen the random interaction where I forced Dunya to kill Juan. Stuff like that.
 
Kvothe Kingkiller said:
shoulda joined in :caticon

I don't get the anger on Usopp. He played well, people say he was outed scum at this point but even when he was on the goddess fake write up and the dead townies come back (the chat was also locked for us so me, JW, Usopp, and Parka couldn't coordinate), everyone still wanted to go lynch WPK. I tried to prod people about it and I even quoted Cooler thinking that was surprising he thought Usopp was town but no one was biting it so /shrug

I feel like ppl should lay off him. Parka, I, and JW also won the game but it seems a lot of anger is directed at Usopp and I suppose town for losing.

I also didn't do anything that was particularly scummy other than me getting caught off of a random interaction that siggy saw. My reaction to it was poor and so was my claim (chat was locked so I didn't have ideas of what to claim. Was also sick from the second vaccine shot.) but literally only happened off of a passive ability and not with someone that targeted me.

Siggy could've seen the random interaction where I forced Dunya to kill Juan. Stuff like that.
Click to expand...
i dont think they r angry kvothe, just a bit annoyed cuz of my play style

u dont see someone with top post count turn out scum very often here (700+ posts lol)

i just fill the thread with shitshow and am a scum af under their noses and still get away with it somehow

its pretty tilting i can imagine :mjlol
 
Go D. Usopp said:
i dont think they r angry kvothe, just a bit annoyed cuz of my play style

u dont see someone with top post count turn out scum very often here (700+ posts lol)

i just fill the thread with shitshow and am a scum af under their noses and still get away with it somehow

its pretty tilting i can imagine :mjlol
Click to expand...
i suppose :zaru im not the type to hide as scum. I subbed in and I was still top 10 ish posts
 
Kvothe Kingkiller said:
shoulda joined in :caticon

I don't get the anger on Usopp. He played well, people say he was outed scum at this point but even when he was on the goddess fake write up and the dead townies come back (the chat was also locked for us so me, JW, Usopp, and Parka couldn't coordinate), everyone still wanted to go lynch WPK. I tried to prod people about it and I even quoted Cooler thinking that was surprising he thought Usopp was town but no one was biting it so /shrug

I feel like ppl should lay off him. Parka, I, and JW also won the game but it seems a lot of anger is directed at Usopp and I suppose town for losing.

I also didn't do anything that was particularly scummy other than me getting caught off of a random interaction that siggy saw. My reaction to it was poor and so was my claim (chat was locked so I didn't have ideas of what to claim. Was also sick from the second vaccine shot.) but literally only happened off of a passive ability and not with someone that targeted me.

Siggy could've seen the random interaction where I forced Dunya to kill Juan. Stuff like that.
Click to expand...
Didn't matter what I said, town trusted Usopp over the claimed watcher with confirms behind him so I gave up then. Also Usopp pushing the "why isn't Sigi dead" angle really was oversold but no one commented on that.

This was just shit town play, yes myself included. Also I legit didn't notice you, but then again scum you is normal to me lmao.
 
Pool Party Nitty said:
The three biggest things I didn't understand this game were: 1. how Usopp got away with being caught redirecting abilities from himself to John Wayne, 2. how Parka got away with his really bad ability claims, and 3. how WPK was still a suspect after he got John Wayne lynched.
Click to expand...

1. I got a bit lost in this myself; I had Usopp as hostile indie most of the game, he does this "too scummy to be scum" thing pretty well. His beginning of game claim was a very bold move for scum

2. I trusted her innocent invest too much and her thread play seemed genuine to me. I never played with scum Parka before.

3. I thought the same but was heavily sussed the day JW was lynched and did not manage to put a counterwagon sucessfully. Plus this Usopp's fake execute thing also caused a lot of confusion.


Sigismund said:
Didn't matter what I said, town trusted Usopp over the claimed watcher with confirms behind him so I gave up then. Also Usopp pushing the "why isn't Sigi dead" angle really was oversold but no one commented on that.

This was just shit town play, yes myself included. Also I legit didn't notice you, but then again scum you is normal to me lmao.
Click to expand...

You should have put more effort I think, you only stated mechanical results without going deeper. But it was pretty obvious to me at the end of the game either you or Kvothe is scum despite both having innocent results due to conflicting claims. But it was too late then.
 
Last edited:
I like the unexpected roles alignments. This goes perfectly against retarded, miles away from mafia game claiming and all that. The game got served more than actually won by massive efforts, but I do not feel like getting into it. Abilities usage is abilities usage. Everyone is smart afterward and claims they would have known better whom to vig. It was not the reason for all this at all. There were unplanned things that also contributed to the game development like Sin's replacement, slipped "incoming action" on a failed kill. Stuff happens.

@WolfPrinceKiba thanks for playing wolf girl! I love that someone with such username got that character :lmao
The choice of the abilities and alignment was up to Nitty. I think that the way she was it kind of brought your high tier game out as in being forced to use it, but I get the lack of encouragement with the factors unrelated to the role.

I would like to also appreciate Cersei role again. All the books and fancy words compiled in three abilities. It will be one of my favorite roles I have ever seen on this platform, really.
 
Pool Party Nitty said:
Generally, I should have had more protective power in this game as well as less killing power. This game had a quick turnaround time from signups to game start, so there's a few things I would have changed if I had spent more time with it. Thankfully, all the killing roles died early, so this didn't become a problem. However, your role was far from useless, and the town was arguably overpowered as is so I couldn't have made you stronger without also making another townie weaker. You could have stopped the mafia kill tonight, but you didn't choose Sigismund, and even if you had you were trapped in Westview after protecting Kvothe last night.
Click to expand...
I respectfully disagree, being able to predict who to defend in a game where scum had the ability to fool invests or town had self sabotaging clears like the 50% lie detect is kinda p hard already, but then even if you get it right, 2/4 scum roles can bypass that protect and another one can use their faction kill to incriminate someone else even if I imagine to protect from it. If they chose to just use the poisoner or superkiller I literally couldn't do anything but defend from town misvigs lmao(unless you reach the very unlikely conditions of being able to stop the super kill).
 
Last edited:
Vivo Diez said:
I respectfully disagree, being able to predict who to defend in a game where scum had the ability to fool invests or town half self sabotaging clears like the 50% lie detect is kinda p hard already, but then even if you get it right, 2/4 scum roles can bypass that protect and another one can use their faction kill to incriminate someone else even if I imagine to protect from it. If they chose to just use the poisoner or superkiller I literally couldn't do anything but defend from town misvigs lmao(unless you react the very unlikely conditions of being able to stop the super kill).
Click to expand...
I think doctor roles in role madness usually get the short end of the stick. The targets they'd normally be able to save/deter a kill on just get more powerful kills sent their way and die anyways. Partly that aspect, and partly the lack of bold play from doctors to actually predict the NK instead of defaulting to the obvious choice are why I created the Bookie Doctor for Get Good. It earns power-ups even if it's target dies to a higher tier kill or if they got tampered with but otherwise would have saved their target.
 
WolfPrinceKiba said:
I think doctor roles in role madness usually get the short end of the stick. The targets they'd normally be able to save/deter a kill on just get more powerful kills sent their way and die anyways. Partly that aspect, and partly the lack of bold play from doctors to actually predict the NK instead of defaulting to the obvious choice are why I created the Bookie Doctor for Get Good. It earns power-ups even if it's target dies to a higher tier kill or if they got tampered with but otherwise would have saved their target.
Click to expand...

Yes, i liked you Get Good setup.

And upon seeing your false guilty flip i was suprised how well you maintained your town facade even when your lynch was obvious. And then every townie left rated your lynch result "winner".;)
 
Vivo Diez said:
I respectfully disagree, being able to predict who to defend in a game where scum had the ability to fool invests or town had self sabotaging clears like the 50% lie detect is kinda p hard already, but then even if you get it right, 2/4 scum roles can bypass that protect and another one can use their faction kill to incriminate someone else even if I imagine to protect from it. If they chose to just use the poisoner or superkiller I literally couldn't do anything but defend from town misvigs lmao(unless you reach the very unlikely conditions of being able to stop the super kill).
Click to expand...

What’s there to disagree about? Your role wasn’t useless, however weak or hard it may have been to use. I agree the game should have been rebalanced in your favor, but you still had the potential to make a big, clutch play like WPK did as Marika.
 
Honestly I should have been more involved in this one. I trusted Kue and Cypher's poe too much on the final day. I thought Kvothe might be scum (hence why I asked Cypher) but the invest result and the vouches actually led me to try and protect her the second to last night lol. I wanted to execute Usopp but the detail about his role felt genuine and I didn't want to risk offing a townie. I think the fact I wasn't on the police committee hurt as well because evidently there was a whole load of discussion there happening that I just missed.

Never really caught up after missing the first couple of days and the last day I didn't even meet the requirements to have any night abilities. Bit poor all round from me.

@Sigismund you deffo should have been more vocal though, you caught Usopp and Kvothe in a lie but didn't really bring much attention to it. You could have made them sweat. I was also stupid for ignoring it.
 
Cooler said:
Honestly I should have been more involved in this one. I trusted Kue and Cypher's poe too much on the final day. I thought Kvothe might be scum (hence why I asked Cypher) but the invest result and the vouches actually led me to try and protect her the second to last night lol. I wanted to execute Usopp but the detail about his role felt genuine and I didn't want to risk offing a townie. I think the fact I wasn't on the police committee hurt as well because evidently there was a whole load of discussion there happening that I just missed.

Never really caught up after missing the first couple of days and the last day I didn't even meet the requirements to have any night abilities. Bit poor all round from me.

@Sigismund you deffo should have been more vocal though, you caught Usopp and Kvothe in a lie but didn't really bring much attention to it. You could have made them sweat. I was also stupid for ignoring it.
Click to expand...
In my minimal defense, as I am a shit player (and even more shit town player so I didn't play well this game dont read this wrong) I did bring the Usopp being elsewhere point up a couple of different times, and it was discussed more widely than just by myself.

Like I said Kvothe I didn't scum read at all so I believed her redirected, thats completely on me, but I did try on Usopp, it was just drowned out, discussed, dismissed and ignored after that.
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
Back
Top