Game RPG Mafia (mafia+indies win!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
"This game isn't being played in a way I'm comfortable with, so it must change, and anyone who disagrees is bad."

The game was designed to have a King.

Revan and Panda were bad at being town. They got executed. It really isn't two strikes yet-- so this broken record of "the King sucks" is getting old. Learn to play with the King.

Anyone who can't pressure players or scum-hunt in this environment should probably not sign up for games that have unique mechanics like this.

Getting in the way as town is no better than being scum. It has been that way since mafia/werewolf was invented, and that will never not be the case.
 
Didi said:
coming to such a drastic conclusion that 1 player could just yolo do it by himself
Click to expand...
The way it was fucking written :drake

Ian's post was literally "I got the power to overthrow the king whenever I want"

How in the heavens would you immediately equalize that to "oh, he means that thing which needs the compliance of at least 15+ people"

And it came right after Priscilla's claim of being able to usurp the king if he tries lynching them.
 
Tiger said:
Incredibly dumb thing to say in a King-led game. Literally...directing the King is the equivalent of trying to direct the town consensus. You being useless aside from complaining about the mistakes of others is what isn't a good look.
Click to expand...

Let me reiterate: everyone you’ve directed the king at has been based on knee-jerk reactions rather than any case of suspicion that you have on an individual. You’re not only directing the king, you’re doing so halphazardly in a way that would benefit scum.

Also, it’s easy to just call my criticisms useless complaints when you don’t have to actually address any of the arguments that I’ve made in regard to scum hunting being slowed down ain’t it?

[Vote lynch Tiger]
 
SinRaven said:
I've already shared our findings. We saw a vision of the Werebeasts.

Or were you perhaps refering to the blessing I got from my goddess? I will not share that information. It might help our enemies and it won't help us.

Unless perhaps you are one of the enemies of the Kingdom?
Click to expand...
No need to tell me your blessing
Just wanted to know if there are indeed such things.
 
Santi said:
Let me reiterate: everyone you’ve directed the king at has been based on knee-jerk reactions rather than any case of suspicion that you have on an individual. You’re not only directing the king, you’re doing so halphazardly in a way that would benefit scum.

Also, it’s easy to just call my criticisms useless complaints when you don’t have to actually address any of the arguments that I’ve made in regard to scum hunting being slowed down ain’t it?

[Vote lynch Tiger]
Click to expand...

Don't exaggerate when you're trying in vain to make a point, it hurts your attempt.

And again, people being bad at this game is not the King's fault.

Santi said:
Panda had a wagon that we can use later for information, Revan didn’t. Revan was definitely a strike.
Click to expand...

Revan was on several sus lists. You don't need a wagon to gather information. Try again.
 
iwandesu said:
We entered on a maze killed all undeads and found a powerful sword which was given to someone
Click to expand...
That's not what detailed means, man :geg
Or do you really not know who kept the sword?

BTW, Who was on the Dr. White group? Like, the final 3 that went on the Quest.

And a pop quiz:
- Law
- Underworld Broker
- Crugyr
- Shiny
There is one mafia here. If you guess the same as me you get a cookie.
Who wants to play? :distracted
 
Alwaysmind said:
Why do we bother voting when the liege will vote however he pleases?
Click to expand...


Could you BE anymore scummy?
image.gif
 
Tiger said:
Can anyone aside from the players themselves tell me right now why it would be BAD for us if:

Alwaysmind, Thorin, Mohit, jjcb, MSAL, or Priscilla

Was executed by the King today?

Keeping in mind that if we want him to go by popular demand, we need to give a few options-- not just one or two. And if you can't understand why that is, just sit down and watch for a while.
Click to expand...

When Alwaysmind plays he takes his role seriously to embrace the flavour and adds fun into the game Ribbit. You would be doing this game a great disservice by removing me from my post.
 
Degaforce said:
That's not what detailed means, man :geg
Or do you really not know who kept the sword?

BTW, Who was on the Dr. White group? Like, the final 3 that went on the Quest.

And a pop quiz:
- Law
- Underworld Broker
- Crugyr
- Shiny
There is one mafia here. If you guess the same as me you get a cookie.
Who wants to play? :distracted
Click to expand...
Why would i tell you who got the sword?
Also crugyr
 
Tiger said:
Can anyone aside from the players themselves tell me right now why it would be BAD for us if:

Alwaysmind, Thorin, Mohit, jjcb, MSAL, or Priscilla

Was executed by the King today?

Keeping in mind that if we want him to go by popular demand, we need to give a few options-- not just one or two. And if you can't understand why that is, just sit down and watch for a while.
Click to expand...
Dont mind alwaysmind or mohitz.
thorin and priscilla look useless to me.
Im actually liking how Msal and jjcb bother with their lifes
 
Didi said:
Also King, you're an idiot. Listen to me next time (if you'll have a next time). Alwaysmind is scum. :dead

[Vote Lynch Alwaysmind]
Click to expand...

Didi said:
Could you BE anymore scummy?
image.gif
Click to expand...

Coming from a guy that insulted the King above that’s pretty funny.

I’m mybline of work openly insulting the King is treason.

And there’s only one way traitors are punished and it’s a trip to the Tyburn tree/
 
iwandesu said:
Why would i tell you who got the sword?
Also crugyr
Click to expand...
You were in a 10 man group, right?
Can you be sure nobody on that group was scum?
If at least one of them was scum, they have the info on the sword wielder already.

But you are right, keep it secret.
It kind of gives soft protection. If he shows up dead, we can suspect people in that group more fervently.

If you had to pick one of the guys of the group who was the most suspicious, who would it be?
 
Santi said:
I also explicitly pointed out that although I didn’t necessarily sus Panda, I see zero reason for her to be alive and I’m satisfied with her being removed from the game early because she’ll only serve as a distraction later on.
Click to expand...

Tiger said:
Can anyone aside from the players themselves tell me right now why it would be BAD for us if:

Alwaysmind, Thorin, Mohit, jjcb, MSAL, or Priscilla

Was executed by the King today?

Keeping in mind that if we want him to go by popular demand, we need to give a few options-- not just one or two. And if you can't understand why that is, just sit down and watch for a while.
Click to expand...

Given the sentiment about Panda, you should be able to give a concise answer to this as well that may indeed help the King.

I can give a reason not to lynch Priscilla-- as thin as it is, she has claimed that if the King tries to execute her, she will usurp his throne. But that is literally the one and only reason I can come up with to not take her out of this game from his perspective.

Alwaysmind is hinting being part of a group that is loyal to the King, and not a peasant.

Jjcb is at least fighting, and his current pleas make his old words more dumb than a true slip.

Can you make a case to not lynch Thorin, Mohit, or MSAL? Because I wouldn't flinch at seeing any one of those three executed. If you were ok with Panda going for those reasons...surely there are no better?

And if you were operating under the assumption that more than 2 names should be put forth by popular demand, how would you approach it? Given that we don't get the final choice, are you more comfortable going with contributive members of the game on the off-chance they're mafia?

It's not exactly the same as a regular game, but that doesn't mean we just give up and stop pushing people.
 
Degaforce said:
You were in a 10 man group, right?
Can you be sure nobody on that group was scum?
If at least one of them was scum, they have the info on the sword wielder already.

But you are right, keep it secret.
It kind of gives soft protection. If he shows up dead, we can suspect people in that group more fervently.

If you had to pick one of the guys of the group who was the most suspicious, who would it be?
Click to expand...
No i cant
Worst case It tells me someone on that Qt is from mafia
 
Underworld Broker said:
Mohit's ass has to go if he's gonna complain even if the king does what the kingdom wants & Mohit has done zero to contribute finding scum, literally none of his posts seem like even trying to do anything other than overthrowing the king. as if Mohit is gonna do anything in the game ever after the king gets overthrown :zaru
Click to expand...
What have you don't to do to catch scum we only have lynch to Base off our reads what do you except, also you might have messed my post regarding few people here being retainers who according to me are indie and doesn't not have the town's benefit in their mind they seems to be doing everything possible just to make sure that King stays in power without even considering that what he actually doing is taking a shot in the blind
About why I didn't it's the same reason as iwan the day phase ended before I could decide on who to lynch.
@Underworld Broker you seem to have been after me from start of day 2 when this fiasco didn't even exclated as it has now, maybe you are one of the retainer and are trying everything to supresse the voice of us peasants :catthinks
Noted
 
Crugyr said:
why am I the scum one lol

I still need some people to join my battle please
Click to expand...
You can play too, you know? :maybe

In fact, you have advantage on that game! You know your own alignment, so you can narrow it down to only 3 players.
Unless, you know, you are the mafioso one and that's why you are not pointing fingers :maybe
Tiger said:
Those two can go on the list of potentials as well.

Is there anyone I've mentioned that you DON'T want to see the King execute?
Click to expand...
Eh, probably Alwaysmind.
I feel if he was mafia he would have backed down or at least toned down a little bit. Hes still going strong.
To be honest with you I always pick Alwaysmind as a Day 1 lynch because the guy is scummy regardless, so he works as a great bait to see who hops in the bandwagon for an easy lynch :shrug
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
Back
Top