Game RPG Mafia (mafia+indies win!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
You wanna know why I went for Legend instead of the big two (Sin or Kira)?
Because Legend was the most universally agreed upon scum. I think there is not a single person who can view him as anything but scum.
We are on the last dash of the game, we need to lynch scum.
And since we have no solid proof of anything because nobody got a single guilty verdict, no watcher saw anyone get killed and no tracker saw anyone do anything, we have to go with hunches.

If my read on Sin is a 90% scum, then my read on Legend is 99% scum.
I went for the bigger odds, in the unlikely event that Sin is actually town.

But you let's just play ball, then.

[Vote lynch SinRaven]

If he is mafia, his whole faction just revealed to try and save him. We can pull something off.
If he is town, we lost.
Go big or go home :zaru

Kira Yagami said:
List so far:
Kira
Didi
Okosan
Novaseline
Iwandesu
Legend
Santi
Degaforce
Jayjay
Smileyman

This group :skully



@Degaforce why didnt you use your sword?
Click to expand...
It's passive, it has trigger conditions.
 
Degaforce said:
You wanna know why I went for Legend instead of the big two (Sin or Kira)?
Because Legend was the most universally agreed upon scum. I think there is not a single person who can view him as anything but scum.
We are on the last dash of the game, we need to lynch scum.
And since we have no solid proof of anything because nobody got a single guilty verdict, no watcher saw anyone get killed and no tracker saw anyone do anything, we have to go with hunches.

If my read on Sin is a 90% scum, then my read on Legend is 99% scum.
I went for the bigger odds, in the unlikely event that Sin is actually town.

But you let's just play ball, then.

[Vote lynch SinRaven]

If he is mafia, his whole faction just revealed to try and save him. We can pull something off.
If he is town, we lost.
Go big or go home :zaru


It's passive, it has trigger conditions.
Click to expand...

Can you tell us who you cleared ? Because right now the King says he'll lynch according to majority. But it doesn't make sense with so low Town members. Scums might be the ones voting for the target with most votes.

If you vote Legend and the people you cleared vote with you, the King might listen.
 
Didi said:
I agree we need to lynch scum cuz shit is dire, but we also need to go big or go home because shit is SO dire
cuz
look at the numbers
zero grey lynched

I don't think Sin is grey
Kira is definitely grey


but w/e
you do you, Dega
at least it's a better choice than low hanging fruit Legend
Click to expand...
What has Kira done that Sin hasn't?
It wasn't easy picking between the two for me.
I settled for Sin because of this sudden change in tides once the vote count showed him biting the dust.
 
Degaforce said:
What has Kira done that Sin hasn't?
It wasn't easy picking between the two for me.
I settled for Sin because of this sudden change in tides once the vote count showed him biting the dust.
Click to expand...


hmmmmmmmmmm

I can understand that
it was weird
then again
Sin is known to be weird when he thinks he's getting lynched


tho usually with more rage

I dunno

I'm tunneling on Kira and I'm sticking to it

gonna embarass myself if I'm wrong :catippy
 
novaselinenever said:
didn't you investigate some people ? or am i mistaken you for another person ?

I also saw you say that you trust 1 person. If you and that person are confirmed Townies, the king should listen to you two and not lynch with majority. We might not have majority or barely have it.
Click to expand...
No, I don't have any powers except a cool looking sword.
This is what I get for not going on quests early :oldshrug

But yeah, maybe instead of going full scum reads we can agree on town reads, barring the obvious.
The people I see as town:
Mohit - Way too dumb to be mafia. No offense.
Okosan/Santi - One of them is 100% town, if not both of them.
Smileyman - Same as Mohit, but more lost that dumb. Kinda reminds me of myself on my first years of mafia.

Now it's your turn. Who can you trust?
 
Didi said:
hmmmmmmmmmm

I can understand that
it was weird
then again
Sin is known to be weird when he thinks he's getting lynched


tho usually with more rage

I dunno

I'm tunneling on Kira and I'm sticking to it

gonna embarass myself if I'm wrong :catippy
Click to expand...
That whole green text thing was Sin Rage, roleplay version. It was glorious.
Didi said:
btw I was wrong about you being the peasant that killed RemChu, right?

cuz I thought you were confirmed town but apparently that wasn't you and your sword
Click to expand...
Nah, wasn't me. I only got the sword last night and it's a passive skill.
 
Degaforce said:
No, I don't have any powers except a cool looking sword.
This is what I get for not going on quests early :oldshrug

But yeah, maybe instead of going full scum reads we can agree on town reads, barring the obvious.
The people I see as town:
Mohit - Way too dumb to be mafia. No offense.
Okosan/Santi - One of them is 100% town, if not both of them.
Smileyman - Same as Mohit, but more lost that dumb. Kinda reminds me of myself on my first years of mafia.

Now it's your turn. Who can you trust?
Click to expand...

I trust no one. I'm even more lost. I thought you had an investigative ability with your " There is 1 person I trust ".

Iwandesu I'm positive isn't scum. The king obviously. Didi was a Town read but I'm questioning it with his constant tunneling and fluffing.

I see you too as Town but it's weird that 2 of my strongest anti-town reads are people you see as Town. For me Mohit and Smileyman can't be Town.

Mohit was just all over the place with his anti-king movement that he continued even when Town is loosing majority. Also his aggresive defense when questioned D3. He also dipped every time the heat was on him.

Smileyman has been just as inactive as me, but it's his scum play from the experience I have with him. And then he was everywhere today when he was mentioned as a Top lynch target.
 
novaselinenever said:
I trust no one. I'm even more lost. I thought you had an investigative ability with your " There is 1 person I trust ".

Iwandesu I'm positive isn't scum. The king obviously. Didi was a Town read but I'm questioning it with his constant tunneling and fluffing.
Click to expand...
Did..did you miss the part when he confessed to being a bloodthirsty werewolf? :zaru

Ah! I get it. You are his partner. Gotcha. Makes sense, actually.
 
novaselinenever said:
I trust no one. I'm even more lost. I thought you had an investigative ability with your " There is 1 person I trust ".

Iwandesu I'm positive isn't scum. The king obviously. Didi was a Town read but I'm questioning it with his constant tunneling and fluffing.

I see you too as Town but it's weird that 2 of my strongest anti-town reads are people you see as Town. For me Mohit and Smileyman can't be Town.

Mohit was just all over the place with his anti-king movement that he continued even when Town is loosing majority. Also his aggresive defense when questioned D3. He also dipped every time the heat was on him.

Smileyman has been just as inactive as me, but it's his scum play from the experience I have with him. And then he was everywhere today when he was mentioned as a Top lynch target.
Click to expand...
I'll address the rest of the post, I just was so shocked to see you have iwan as town that I had to comment on that.

The biggest problem in mafia is separating the scum from the idiots.
Mohit comes out as genuinely ignorant. He doesn't seem to be faking it.

Same with Smiley, but apparently you know him more than I do. Point for you.
 
Degaforce said:
I'll address the rest of the post, I just was so shocked to see you have iwan as town that I had to comment on that.

The biggest problem in mafia is separating the scum from the idiots.
Mohit comes out as genuinely ignorant. He doesn't seem to be faking it.

Same with Smiley, but apparently you know him more than I do. Point for you.
Click to expand...

All right, leaving out Mohit and Smiley. Who is the best target between Legend and Sin ? You had Legend as 99% scum
 
novaselinenever said:
All right, leaving out Mohit and Smiley. Who is the best target between Legend and Sin ? You had Legend as 99% scum
Click to expand...
As I said, there isn't a single person who could see Legend as anything but scum.
The problem with lynching him is that it gives no info. It just stalls for time. You can't link any scummates to Legend.

That's why one of Sin or Kira have to go. Their deaths will trigger a domino effect and clear the game up.
Or we miss and lose the game.
Go big or go home :zaru
 
Legend said:
Im on break from work.

1) why is this phase not over yet

2) im not scum

3) im starting to get the bastard mechanic of this game. There may not be a mafia at all. There are anti town (indies) but not an actual mafia. Normally by now we would hit mafia by dumb luck.
Click to expand...

Thought you weren't in the game anymore... Eh you're scum you popping out the blue after being called scum by another poster isn't good for you either
 
Degaforce said:
As I said, there isn't a single person who could see Legend as anything but scum.
The problem with lynching him is that it gives no info. It just stalls for time. You can't link any scummates to Legend.

That's why one of Sin or Kira have to go. Their deaths will trigger a domino effect and clear the game up.
Or we miss and lose the game.
Go big or go home :zaru
Click to expand...

All right but choose one of them lol. I'm voting with you. I've been mostly going after Mohit and Smiley because the other are neutral I don't know them. I've been also sheeping Didi but I'm not sure about him anymore.
 
Legend said:
Im on break from work.

1) why is this phase not over yet

2) im not scum

3) im starting to get the bastard mechanic of this game. There may not be a mafia at all. There are anti town (indies) but not an actual mafia. Normally by now we would hit mafia by dumb luck.
Click to expand...
Number 3 is a scary possibility that I have considered since Law was town.
Legend said:
So you have me as 99% scum. But with no proof. How does that make sense?
Click to expand...
The evidence is that nobody can see you as town.
You went on quests every day for 6 days straight but you haven't contributed anything to the game.
I remember playing with you one Favorites where you were Kyuubei and I was Selena. We were masons. You were the best teammate I had. You were Helpful, you gave insight, you conversed about the game, etc.
I see none of that here, and that makes me sad. You are not the same Legend as back then :tomacry
 
Legend said:
1) who the hell are you?
2) you thought wrong.
3) doesnt matter i just got online. Dega has been calling me scum for 2 days in a row at least. Me popping in and calling BS on it is the opposite.
Click to expand...

Whatever I don't care for the meaningless talk. It doesn't matter who I am I'm in the game and we run into each other in the comic section

Just know you Popping up after being inactive and then popping up specifically after being called scum doesn't help.
 
Degaforce said:
Number 3 is a scary possibility that I have considered since Law was town.

The evidence is that nobody can see you as town.
You went on quests every day for 6 days straight but you haven't contributed anything to the game.
I remember playing with you one Favorites where you were Kyuubei and I was Selena. We were masons. You were the best teammate I had. You were Helpful, you gave insight, you conversed about the game, etc.
I see none of that here, and that makes me sad. You are not the same Legend as back then :tomacry
Click to expand...
From reading back and looking at the number of players in the game. That's becoming a strong possibility. Especially with Nitty stating not to trust the writeups and this is a bastard game.

Ive become jaded at times. I do have a preference for playing anti-town. But im Town.

I wasnt chosen for the first quest.

I have a ability that only works 1/3 of the time.
KC said:
Whatever I don't care for the meaningless talk. It doesn't matter who I am I'm in the game and we run into each other in the comic section

Just know you Popping up after being inactive and then popping up specifically after being called scum doesn't help.
Click to expand...
I have a decent postcount. I just post in spurts.

Ill be back in 2 hours. Back to work.
 
To begin with, here are Mr. Waffles (Peasant) and Babby's (Royal Guard) roles:

dk7jVci.png


Peasant
Follower of Melandru

wincon: eliminate all threats to the kingdom

[Passive - Animal Familiar] - You have 2 lives.

[Active - Man's Best Friend] - Your pet can protect or roleblock another player each night.

[Active - The Cloak of Shadows] - You become invisible by night, causing actions targeting you to fail. You cannot use the cloak 2 nights in a row.

1YfUAlv.png


Royal Guard
Follower of Lyssa

wincon: eliminate all threats to the kingdom​
 
A Peasant killed Santi (Peasant)!

dk7jVci.png


Peasant
Follower of Balthazar

wincon: eliminate all threats to the kingdom

[Active - Intermediate Warrior] - Each night you can attempt to kill someone else, with a 2 in 3 chance at success.

The Sisterhood of Grenth superkilled Legend (Peasant), Jayjay (Werewolf) and Platinum (The King)!

dk7jVci.png


Peasant
Follower of Balthazar

wincon: eliminate all threats to the kingdom

[Active - Intermediate Warrior] - Each night you can attempt to kill someone else, with a 2 in 3 chance at success.

HiiiS4b.png


Werewolf
Follower of Lyssa

wincon: outnumber the kingdom

[Active - Tracker] - Each night you can follow someone to learn who they target.

[Active - Cop] - You can investigate someone to learn their alignment each night.​

cW8dLv8.png


The King
wincon: remain the king until the end of the game

[Passive - The Crown] - You scan innocent to investigations and appear innocent in writeups. Kills targeting you are redirected to your guards.

[Active - Divine Authority] - You alone decide who is lynched every day.​

With Iwandesu (Werewolf), Mohit (Peasant) and SinRaven (Peasant) all dying for speaking the other gods' names in Grenth's presence, The Sisterhood of Grenth (Didi, Okosan and Novaselinenever) has won the game.

Platinum (The King) won by remaining in power until the final writeup, and consequently his Court (Nighty The Mighty, Underworld Broker and Revan Reborn) won as well.

Thanks for playing!​
 
Kira Yagami said:
Was wrong about Raven but Glad i got didi and okosan right :blobowo
Click to expand...
Santi said:
Eh, started to figure out Didi after he started pushing on Kira so hard but was too distracted by ScumRaven.
Click to expand...


Yeah I was going a bit more all-out / aggressively going for the win, since we were close to winning and still had a shitton of protection that we didn't have to use so I could take the heat
 
Good game :handshake

3 scum in such a large game was unexpected.

Hahahaha

Shizune said:
Stay tuned for when I get home tonight, there were a ton of hostile indies that were supposed to be activated and not a single one occurred for various reasons. To begin with, there were large events planned around the king being overthrown. I didn't anticipate him actually achieving his first wincon.
Click to expand...

The kingdom were literally sheep and just went with the status quo.

@SinRaven
ah I regret fighting with you,

I should have tried to recruit you, well played btw. Nitty sorta hinted to me that I would incriminate myself fighting you more. lol.


I thought I could win by recruiting the King, and spent days figuring it out, the night I tried to do it it failed and I was killed. Oh well.
 
Only 3 maf,wasnt expecting that

Didi said:
E Z G A E M :catspaz

didn't even have to use our One-shot of killing everyone but Nova on a 5-man quest :kibashades
Click to expand...
Didi said:
Sorry that you couldn't convince people to turn on me, you tried your best. Should've shot for the big man instead of shooting for Sin :ufdup
Click to expand...

I KNEW I WASNT TRIPPING ABOUT YOU :blobmod
That last minute vote changes on me you led while i was logged off :blobcry
 
Shizune said:
Platinum (The King) won by remaining in power until the final writeup, and consequently his Court (Nighty The Mighty, Underworld Broker and Revan Reborn) won as well.
Click to expand...

Yay, we won!! :blobaww

Didi said:
Btw thanks for calling your actions out in your QT @Underworld Broker , helped us to plan around them :kibashades
Click to expand...

Didn't know where to send in my actions tbh :blobcry
 
RemChu said:
Good game :handshake

3 scum in such a large game was unexpected.

Hahahaha
Click to expand...


yeah, though to be fair we had very strong abilities to compensate

But that was definitely tricky, especially because the longer the game drags on it's almost impossible to not become suspected :catsweat

especially if you're vocal like me yet no mafia is getting lynched somehow, that should set off some alarmbells for everyone

Near the end we were all starting to become high on suspect list
good thing it was easy to call out many semi-blenders like Santi and Legend and total blenders like Darth on being scummy as well


and thank god for everyone's insistence on Sin :skully
 
Underworld Broker said:
Yay, we won!! :blobaww



Didn't know where to send in my actions tbh :blobcry
Click to expand...


we called ours out in our QT as well tbh, but ours wasn't being watched :catshrug

I was actually getting paranoid that Nighty would connect the dots in me catching on to Nighty's courthood so easily if we also shot the one of you two that actually had powers, that's why we shot Nighty that night as well (that and Nighty was a known quantity and we wanted to have as many possible scum around for town to paranoia over)
 
Didi said:
Also you got kinda lucky King's Court, 1 royal guard dies earlier -> Plat dies a phase earlier and you guys don't win :catsweat
Click to expand...

To be fair Rion was supposed to be the fourth royal guard, but he quit right before the game started so. :zaru

Also Didi, you're probably wondering why you had an ability to infiltrate multiple quicktopics if you only discovered the one. Well, part of the event surrounding the king being overthrown was 3 players of nobility descent starting their own mason groups called noble houses. I planned for you to infiltrate an additional 3 quicktopics.
 
Didi said:
we called ours out in our QT as well tbh, but ours wasn't being watched :catshrug

I was actually getting paranoid that Nighty would connect the dots in me catching on to Nighty's courthood so easily if we also shot the one of you two that actually had powers, that's why we shot Nighty that night as well (that and Nighty was a known quantity and we wanted to have as many possible scum around for town to paranoia over)
Click to expand...

I would've sided with you as long as the king did stay in power tbh. had suspicion on our king actually not being part of town, 'cause he wouldn't need us as independet help if he was blue.
 
Shizune said:
To be fair Rion was supposed to be the fourth royal guard, but he quit right before the game started so. :zaru

Also Didi, you're probably wondering why you had an ability to infiltrate multiple quicktopics if you only discovered the one. Well, part of the event surrounding the king being overthrown was 3 players of nobility descent starting their own mason groups called noble houses. I planned for you to infiltrate an additional 3 quicktopics.
Click to expand...


yeah I was wondering that! Good to know, sweet content I missed out on oh well.

Makes sense too, me infiltrating the Wolves would've been too OP but that sounds like a good way of kinda keeping track of what people are thinking and discussing in private
 
Here's something for you guys to do while you wait for me to give the full details behind this game:

I'm not going to decide the MVPs this game, I'll leave that up to you all. If I'm understanding the points system correctly, I believe I can award 3 MVPs this game (@Tiger will need to confirm this).

1 MVP must be town.
1 MVP must be mafia.
1 MVP must be indie (the king, his court and all the werewolves count).

This is your decision to make.​
 
Finally, I want to sincerely apologize for phase timings being all over the place throughout this game. I tried to do phase changes in the morning to better accommodate you all, but I learned that's just not doable for me. In the future I'll be returning to changing phases at midnight my time.

These last two phases were particularly inconsistent, because frankly this game lasted for two weeks and it's inevitable that over the course of two weeks my schedule won't be perfect the entire time.

I'm sorry if this worsened the experience for anyone.
 
Figured out Didi at the end of the last phase. He seemed like he didn't care who got lynched at that point, while it was exactly the phase where you should care. I had him in cahoots with Mohit though,since he didn't seem to want to lynch him. Nova and Okosan skated by easily despite being prime suspects for many phases in a row.

I kinda gave up after having to deal with so many shenanigans for so long. It was tiring to defend myself against so many weird suspicions that I really didn't have any hand in.


Didi was at the top of his game though. Very well played.
 
Shizune said:
Here's something for you guys to do while you wait for me to give the full details behind this game:

I'm not going to decide the MVPs this game, I'll leave that up to you all. If I'm understanding the points system correctly, I believe I can award 3 MVPs this game (@Tiger will need to confirm this).

1 MVP must be town.
1 MVP must be mafia.
1 MVP must be indie (the king, his court and all the werewolves count).

This is your decision to make.​
Click to expand...


I think you can only name one Player of the game for like 2 points or maybe 2 players for both 1 point but I'm not entirely sure
the thread is quite ambiguously written

@W @Tiger
 
Didi said:
yeah I was wondering that! Good to know, sweet content I missed out on oh well.

Makes sense too, me infiltrating the Wolves would've been too OP but that sounds like a good way of kinda keeping track of what people are thinking and discussing in private
Click to expand...

could you imagine how much info you would've gotten if our court would've been active, lmao i'm sually talking a lot if my partners are active, lol
 
>When you semi-randomly kill Reznor and Dr White for being prominent townies and people start seeing a pattern that's not there and you start exploiting that pattern for maximum fake info and paranoia in the thread

easily my favourite thing about this game
1445716497561.png


Underworld Broker said:
could you imagine how much info you would've gotten if our court would've been active, lmao i'm sually talking a lot if my partners are active, lol
Click to expand...


yeah you guys were kinda quiet
well
Revan got gooned d1
and Nighty was like off for long periods then there for a short while then off again

it was mostly you there yeah lmao
 
Didi said:
>When you semi-randomly kill Reznor and Dr White for being prominent townies and people start seeing a pattern that's not there and you start exploiting that pattern for maximum fake info and paranoia in the thread

easily my favourite thing about this game
1445716497561.png





yeah you guys were kinda quiet
well
Revan got gooned d1
and Nighty was like off for long periods then there for a short while then off again

it was mostly you there yeah lmao
Click to expand...
I did scum read you early to which you responded "I'll revive you again" i didn't think you would be inactive so early as scum, and then others began popping up on my radar like rem, tiger, and santi.

I love how everyone ignored me about novaseline the whole game :dead
 
Shizune said:
Here's something for you guys to do while you wait for me to give the full details behind this game:

I'm not going to decide the MVPs this game, I'll leave that up to you all. If I'm understanding the points system correctly, I believe I can award 3 MVPs this game (@Tiger will need to confirm this).

1 MVP must be town.
1 MVP must be mafia.
1 MVP must be indie (the king, his court and all the werewolves count).

This is your decision to make.​
Click to expand...
Mafia MVP is obviously @Didi. @Okosan and @novaselinenever played well, but were both almost unanimously suspected. Didi was considered town by most for a long time and was only suspected for being too perfect for a townie until the end.

Indie MVP is @Platinum. Leaving his decisions, besides the first one, to who got the most votes is what left him in power for so long. Many people opposed him, but due to his choices many also stood by his side. And he did very well to not stand out as the King. @RemChu did well, but I figure only survived as long as he did thanks to the people by his side. He focused on me as a bit too much which gained too much attention. He should rather had his werewolves go for me. It was a great bait to let me role block him though. Had I not been roleblocked myself and had he not died, I would've joined him and I think at that point we would've had a great chance to win.

Town MVP is @Dr. White. That much should be obvious. The leader of pretty much every discussion. He wasn't revived for nothing. Great plans he made on the quests as well and used it all to its fullest.
@Mr. Waffles comes second for me. He contributed well for his doing and wasn't afraid to speak up by sharing information to defend or pressure certain people. I think with a little bit more effort he could've helped solve the game.
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
Back
Top