Game HST Mafia 3 (mafia wins!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
SinRaven said:
I want to say SupremeKage isn't mafia. I think it's unlikely for Nitty to create an extra scum role halfway through Day One. If we assume his game was balanced from the get go (although it is a Nitty game), then making another scum role halfway through would probably shift the game in scum's favor.

Now Shiny.. Eh. His behavior is odd, especially compared to the last few games he played (doesn't seem to care as much), but Alwaysmind... Alwaysmind is all over the place. He's more 'Alwaysmind' than usual if you ask me..
Click to expand...

Oh all people, why so sure Kage is town? What are you hiding that is detrimental to town?

Nevan said:
:hm

Can you post your thoughts on Nfcnorth?

What do you think about the other people on the bandwagon?
Click to expand...

Seems that people were certain he was scum, I have failed to look into his posts. So I cannot say right now.
 
SinRaven said:
I want to say SupremeKage isn't mafia. I think it's unlikely for Nitty to create an extra scum role halfway through Day One. If we assume his game was balanced from the get go (although it is a Nitty game), then making another scum role halfway through would probably shift the game in scum's favor.
Click to expand...
If you think the game was balanced in the first place and Kage's addition didn't affect that then he would be a neutral indie, not town.
 
Alwaysmind said:
Oh all people, why so sure Kage is town? What are you hiding that is detrimental to town?



Seems that people were certain he was scum, I have failed to look into his posts. So I cannot say right now.
Click to expand...
So your saying you voted me with out looking at my posts?\
search
 
Nevan said:
Literally the post right above this, you answered this when asked why so sure he's town.
Click to expand...
Well true I guess, but I'm moreso saying that he probably isn't scum over that he probably is town. To me, he doesn't have to be town, in fact, I find a neutral indie just as likely. Hell, I could even see the possibility for him being an anti-town indie like a SK.

But mafia. Nah. Sounds like too much of a balance problem.
 
SinRaven said:
Aside from his scum 101 post this dayphase (and his general lack of contribution so far), I did note his less-serious playstyle in Day One as well. Now, I'm far from innocent concerning the Dr. White wagon, but I found NFC's involvement in it particularly noteworthy. Hiding behind the fact that his vote was 'worthless' and pushing for White, mostly because of his annoying behavior rather than thinking he was actually scummy.
Click to expand...
So you do think he's scummy.

SinRaven said:
I still think all these things make him scummy, but the fact that this bandwagon gained so much traction is making me paranoid. None of the players voting NFC are particularly trustworthy, but the fact that they all voted him without reasoning is also very weird.
Click to expand...
And yet you didn't start questioning them, you just unvoted Nfcnorth, in fact you were defending SupremeKage.

To me it very much looks like you either tried to bus Nfcnorth and unvoted when the wagon started to gain traction or you wanted to disassociate yourself from the lynch of a townie.

I lean more towards the second option, what about you?

SinRaven said:
I don't think all of them are scum, hell I don't even think more than one of them is. But fact of the matter is that it's very likely there is scum on this bandwagon and that makes me hesitant.
Click to expand...
I agree and you are pretty high on that list.
 
Nevan said:
So you do think he's scummy.
Click to expand...
Yes. But I find the people on his bandwagon more scummy. One does not exlude the other. I can suspect NFC and the people voting him at the same time.

[qupte]And yet you didn't start questioning them, you just unvoted Nfcnorth, in fact you were defending SupremeKage.

To me it very much looks like you either tried to bus Nfcnorth and unvoted when the wagon started to gain traction or you wanted to disassociate yourself from the lynch of a townie.[/quote]
I didn't defend SupremeKage. Lol. I was looking into the people on that wagon and said SupremeKage was the one unlikely to be mafia. There was no one to defend him against except myself.

That latter point is stupid tbh. I unvoted because three shady people jumped on without any reason, before I could state my own reasonings. That was weird. Yes I wanted to disassociate myself from those people.

I agree and you are pretty high on that list.
Click to expand...
High or on the top? Explain to me how I, the one who initiated the lynch but also questioned it, is more scummy than any of them, who never even gave a reason to vote NFC (while I did, albeit after I unvoted).

I like how you twist everything. You set it up so that it looks like I'm scum no matter how NFC flips.
 
SinRaven said:
Yeah I quite do have the feeling Nevan and Alwaysmind are sticking up for each other.

WAD, LG, thoughts?
Click to expand...

W said:
If I recall, Nevan has specifically asked AM to elucidate on his nfcnorth vote. So I don't believe so, no. Not to say this naturally excludes them from being in league together, but I don't see such an interaction.
Click to expand...

He did, but if you look at the posts it was very passive and there was serious follow up after alwaysminds answer, which seems really bad

It looked kinda fake but idk if alwaysmind as a person is throwing me off
 
nfcnorth said:
So @Alwaysmind what do you think of Nevan, Iwan and Stelios?
Click to expand...

Nevan i get town reads from.
Iwandesus hasn’t posted yet
Stelios might be telling the truth when he says he’s harmless I’d believe that given the content of his posts.

nfcnorth said:
Oh and sin
Click to expand...

As for Sin, his post below implies he knows Kage’s faction or atleast how many scums there are in this game
I think it's unlikely for Nitty to create an extra scum role halfway through Day One.
Click to expand...


Though I fear that We are running in circles my friends I cannot claim with confidence that any of my reads are accurate.
 
Optimistic Wolf said:
You got an ability related PM from host saying AM is guilty?
Click to expand...
No, it's unrelated to my role.

Just a random pm

title was like
"
Something's not quite right..."

in the midst of the night you find out Always is guilty, guilty in red.


I did not do anything towards him or whatever yet I got this pm. :oldshrug

I assumed some of you guys did too, been grieving so can't be asked to read previous pages.
 
oh nah, we've been poking at him cos he's weird as shit bricks this day phase (and in general, but more so today) first mention of that pm, when I said ability related I meant it was someone's ability, not yours specifically. It's kinda... common in nitty games.
That said not sure if town/scum, if memory servers me right in the past more often than not it was scum ability. so...

hm :hm
 
Optimistic Wolf said:
oh nah, we've been poking at him cos he's weird as shit bricks this day phase (and in general, but more so today) first mention of that pm, when I said ability related I meant it was someone's ability, not yours specifically. It's kinda... common in nitty games.
That said not sure if town/scum, if memory servers me right in the past more often than not it was scum ability. so...

hm :hm
Click to expand...
serves*

cos my typing isn't servering me right :catdefeat
 
RemChu said:
No, it's unrelated to my role.

Just a random pm

title was like
"
Something's not quite right..."

in the midst of the night you find out Always is guilty, guilty in red.


I did not do anything towards him or whatever yet I got this pm. :oldshrug

I assumed some of you guys did too, been grieving so can't be asked to read previous pages.
Click to expand...

Of course something is not right , Roman is dead.

Passing on as an ant being eaten by a bird, never to truly experience that life was to give him. But a shadow now in our mind, not able to discern his face in the crowd.

 
RemChu said:
No, it's unrelated to my role.

Just a random pm

title was like
"
Something's not quite right..."

in the midst of the night you find out Always is guilty, guilty in red.


I did not do anything towards him or whatever yet I got this pm. :oldshrug

I assumed some of you guys did too, been grieving so can't be asked to read previous pages.
Click to expand...

:thunk

[Vote Lynch alwaysmind]

My thought on this

If it's true we get scum, that mystery pm becomes trustworthy for anyone that gets it and it makes remchu looks better

If it's a bamboozled we would know that it's fake and not trustworthy for future reference and we lose alwaysmind :derpko
 
Lord Genome said:
Ok so after reading Romans posts I thought he was killed because he was going in on platinum and sin but then in his reads he says he's neutral

Actually he didn't have any real scum reads except wad

He did vote for supreme kage tho :thunk
Click to expand...

:hm

I think I should magnify Platinum's screenshot see if it's just photoshoped so we are done with his claim.
I like the clash between Sinraven and Nevan maybe this will lead somewhere.

W seems to be following the dogma "when a kill makes no sense , GF is WPK" . I think Shizune said that in a previous game
 
Alwaysmind said:
Still not asking the right questions which is why you will fail.
Click to expand...
Are you of importance to town?
Are you of detriment to town?
Are you capable of shedding coherent light on any situation at hand currently?
What can you provide to answer the right question?
What is the right question to you?
What is the answer to the right question?
Do. Fucking. Something. Give. Us. Something.
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
Back
Top