Game HST Mafia 3 (mafia wins!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
Nevan said:
What are your thoughts on other playera?
Click to expand...

I actually think sin looks hella scummy after that night kill and what's happened so far today :catdankv2:

and based on this phase LG also still looks scummy to me so I'm content to leave my vote on him for now

reluctantly going to read you and shiny as town, that's such a brazen play if you're scum that idk

however outing yourselves like that is quite questionable as well :hm

stelios is tunnelling so hard that I'll throw him in the town pile as well

town:
plat
you
shiny
stelios

scum:
sin
lg

pending further examination:
wad
alwaysmind

:hm
 
Nighty the Mighty said:
As far as this roman thing I'm thinking it's an obfuscation kill, there's so little to go off that town is cannibalising itself searching for a target today - this is a very effective scum day because town did fucking nothing aside from RemChu bringing up the PM he got last night which town hasn't decided to act on to confirm or deny.
Click to expand...

Except RemChu fucked up, he quoted the PM verbatim which is against the rules, as such we are not allowed to use that information in the game. That is unless, it is represented to us in another matter.

Waste of a day phase, this day phase is a bright a sunny day on Pluto.
 
W said:
I mean, I think you moreso have to approach the game from a meta angle.

Alright, me and Plat are probably good doctor protection targets. Why not kill WPK then? Or you? And so on.
Click to expand...

this is hella wifom though and one could argue you're not a good doctor protection target as well if they really wanted to

ultimately the question you're asking here is what was the point of killing roman that isn't better served by killing someone else you're just asking it back to front (what's the point of killing someone else that isn't better served by killing roman).

I have the benefit of sleeping through most of this phase so I'm looking back on it but to me I think the purpose of the kill wasn't to remove Roman as a player but to get stronger players (like you, wpk, whoever else you want to put in this power bracket) squabbling about things with no answers. There's not really a way to know what mafia was trying to do last night without being one of them. Hell maybe the action got redirected or something for all we know.

but if we're speculating about motives and not assuming anything about who is or isn't scum:

>WPK has not been particularly active or instrumental thus far
>I'm good mislynch bait at this point
>you're good mislynch bait at this point
>sin is good mislynch bait
>plat was 90% the doc target so no point even attempting it from their perspective

etc.

I'm sure you can come up with something for every player in the game if you try hard enough and examine their play thus far.

That's not to say that we should ignore the night kill entirely but I feel like you guys got baited into talking about it hence why I read LG as scum - because he was prodding the "let's talk about why roman got lynched" discussion thread along whenever it died down

"oh, I'll iso roman's posts to see if he knew anything!"
"oh, his iso was useless, nothing to see here..."
"oh, I know some people who may have spited roman!
"oh, none of them would really spite kill him, I just checked a previous game..."

but then again maybe he's just trying to scumhunt/be useful town so who even knows

that's precisely the problem with this kind of kill
 
one could argue you're not a good doctor protection target as well if they really wanted to
Click to expand...

gonna stop you right there and honestly not read the rest of the post because now you just seem like you’re being willfully obtuse

im >ALWAYS< a good protection N1, excuse my hubris but if im town mafia would generally like to get rid of me and considering i have never gotten mislynched EVER that indicates all of my demises as town have been a result of being killed

but on top of that, it can’t be denied that my reveal yesterday puts me to be more likely Town than not, by quite a margin

you have to be seriously tinfoiling (and that’s fine) to think im scum, but to wholesale discount me as a possible doctor target on those 2 points seems disingenuous

so this ain’t a good look for you
 
W said:
gonna stop you right there and honestly not read the rest of the post because now you just seem like you’re being willfully obtuse

im >ALWAYS< a good protection N1, excuse my hubris but if im town mafia would generally like to get rid of me and considering i have never gotten mislynched EVER that indicates all of my demises as town have been a result of being killed

but on top of that, it can’t be denied that my reveal yesterday puts me to be more likely Town than not, by quite a margin

you have to be seriously tinfoiling (and that’s fine) to think im scum, but to wholesale discount me as a possible doctor target on those 2 points seems disingenuous

so this ain’t a good look for you
Click to expand...

but we're in the business of tinfoiling because we're speculating about the motive of the mafia killing roman?

you can't say "why didn't the mafia target me last night?" then get defensive when one of the possible answers is "because you are the mafia and didn't target yourself"

question: why not kill wad

answers:
good doc target, kill would be wifom with maf vs doc
wanted to do something else with the kill
wad is scum and didn't kill himself

where did I wholesale discount you as a doc target anyway?

what I said:

Nighty the Mighty said:
this is hella wifom though and one could argue you're not a good doctor protection target as well if they really wanted to
Click to expand...

what u read:

Nighty the Mighty said:
you're not a good doctor protection target
Click to expand...

this is hella reaching on ur part
 
Looks like I'm in the lead, gj retards. WPK should die in a fire alongside the trash white for blithering idiocy and mediocrity under the guise of 150 IQ off a preschoolers funko juicy popsicle stick. Do you expect someone to counter your stupidity in the middle of the night cause your senility prevents you from communicating like a normal human? Would rather play with 20 Eternal Itachi's than a buffoon such as yourself.

You're scum, or worse than scum.
 
Nighty the Mighty said:
was remchu allowed to quote the pm he received like that?
Click to expand...

Nighty the Mighty said:
I mean I'm pretty sure he clearly is because you haven't done anything about it thus far but alwaysmind is trying to use it to weasel out the pm :hm
Click to expand...

He was allowed to talk about it, but he was not allowed to quote his PM like that. Like how you guys missed that 20 hours ago. I thought this was top tier mafia, not noobpalooza.

ARGGGG!!!!!
 
Day 2 - nfcnorth (Hancock) is lynched
  • Index
    • Vote count

    1. WPK - White Wolf
    2. iwandesu
    4. Mr. Waffles - Nighty
    5. nfcnorth
    6. Nevan
    7. Shiny - nfcnorth
    8. Remchu - Mr. Waffles
    9. Platinum - Alwaysmind
    10. Lord Genome - Alwaysmind
    11. Nighty The Mighty - Lord Genome
    12. Alwaysmind - WAD > nfcnorth > SupremeKage > White Wolf
    13. White Wolf - Nevan > Alwaysmind > Shiny
    14. Stelios - White Wolf
    16. WAD - WPK > Shiny
    17. SinRaven - nfcnorth > Alwaysmind > Shiny
    18. SupremeKage - nfcnorth

    Shiny - 3
    White Wolf - 3
    nfcnorth - 2
    Alwaysmind - 2
    Nighty - 1
    Lord Genome - 1
    Mr. Waffles - 1

    Self votes

    nfcnorth
    Nevan

    nfcnorth (Boa Hancock) has been lynched!

    Shizune said:
    ​

    Boa Hancock ボア･ハンコック
    The Snake Princess
    wincon: eliminate all threats to the town

    "Whether I kick a kitten, tear off your ears... even slaughter innocent people... the world will never cease to forgive my actions! Why, you ask? That's right, it is because I am... beautiful!"

    [Passive - The Most Beautiful Woman in the World] - All interactions involving Hancock are included in the writeup, and the moderator will always compliment her.

    [Active - Mero Mero no Mi] - Hancock uses her powers of petrification to defy authority. She will roleblock anyone who uses an investigative ability on her. If another player insults Hancock in the thread, she can petrify them to vote silence them for that day.
    Click to expand...

    Night 2 start. No more posts, no exceptions.    ​
     
    White Wolf said:
    What do you want to know :drake
    Click to expand...

    For someone who calls other people stupid you are either purposely dumb or just dumb. I want to know if your meltdown was fake and if it was not if the other two that we’re voting for you if they are scum. I currently don’t want your opinion by the way I will seek this myself.

    Because now from your reaction I get scum vibes more than ever only a scum wouldn’t sought to pursuit its persecutors.


    [vote lynch White Wolf]
     
    Stelios said:
    For someone who calls other people stupid you are either purposely dumb or just dumb. I want to know if your meltdown was fake and if it was not if the other two that we’re voting for you if they are scum. I currently don’t want your opinion by the way I will seek this myself.

    Because now from your reaction I get scum vibes more than ever only a scum wouldn’t sought to pursuit its persecutors.


    [vote lynch White Wolf]
    Click to expand...
    It wasn't a meltdown, just the truth :drake
     
    Nighty the Mighty said:
    what fog lol

    which write up did I miss?
    Click to expand...

    :drake

    White Wolf said:
    o ya

    Zabuza?? He had some fog shit too, tho would he be the main antagonist/mafia in this? :dank iunno
    Thought BB cos he's at least, main relevance antagonist

    Least I'm assuming it's a mafia ability that hid the writeup like that lel
    Click to expand...

    Kages, swordsmen, other plebs.
    Pretty sure there was more in that village than just Zabuza. :maybe
     
    White Wolf said:
    That was janitor'd in a sense first night too tho cos we only got

    "HST Mafia" not "crispy anus roger" iirc
    Click to expand...

    True, but that was faction kill.
    The 2nd kill would have been character specific, non ?
    Hence show up in the write up.
    White Wolf said:
    Do you visit the NBD for all the Kisame vs. threads Waffle? :dead
    Click to expand...

    I don't think I've ever been in the NBD. :hm
     
    Shizune

    Users who are viewing this thread

    Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
    Back
    Top