Game HST Mafia 3 (mafia wins!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
White Wolf said:
Why is crocodile town?
Why trust the mod?
Why rolecrushed when there was a writeup for it the day they rolecrushed me?

Questions
Click to expand...

The crocodile is town because nevan says he fools the crocodile into a honking he is town. It doesn’t make sense that a scum fools another scum since they would both be on the same QT and independent chat.
 
Given Shiny’s voting performance I can’t believe that he is scum. I m still tinfoiling though because his partner the one he vouched for turned out scum. However he could have lynched me yesterday but didn’t :hm

I don’t think alwaysmind is one of the remaining scum. He was swayed to easy last round when I believed that mr 0 was scum. I don’t see him being mafia that survived with such aloofness until now. Someone else left him alive. However his behavior is one of the scumiest around.

I believe nighty is town alright. She was targeted for a kill early game and her roleclaim made sense as well and justified her being still alive.


If white wolf could kill me, after my yesterday push on him he would have. I m 100% confident he is telling the truth about being rolecrashed.

Sinraven has to be scum. He would leave alwaysmind alive. Not sure about the rest of us unless he was confident we are harmless. And that we are. I already claimed I was harmless long time ago , nighty said she can only come back alive , alwaysmind, WW and shiny all three claimed rolecrashed :hm

This fits but one of them has to be lying

[vote lynch Sinraven]



@Nighty the Mighty, @White Wolf , @Shiny give me your reads
 
I don't trust shiny and it seems too convenient.
Nighty seems ok
When did AM claim rolecrush?

Raven's been trying hard but that's kinda sus in itself and he did call out town tell on you which could've been a red herring to make himself look more proactive and townie.


I suppose in terms of scum still feel Shiny>Raven>Stelios>AM>Nighty>Myself
 
Stelios said:
Something with the numbers don’t add up. I just had a thought , maybe a stupid thought, but a thought never the less. I wonder if there’s a role that when killed shows like town even thought mafia. Wad’s role would fit that narrative but it’s not like I m willing to believe this is the case or waste any more thinking of it. Why three sinraven ?
Click to expand...

Would Nitty remove death millers from OP (cos he copied directly from WoW game) if there actually was a death miller tho (or reverse death miller w/e)...? I mean, I guess. He did say the host will lie. It'd be one way of explaining why mafia's been so seemingly untouchable. It's possible I guess, but who knows really.


If Shinji (SK) was mafia, it'd be realistic, cos isn't his zanpakuto the ability to reverse/flip shit? (been a while since I bleach'd tbh) (tho if yea, then it'd make sense as an ability flip affiliation on whoever used) but he was nothing more than a survivor which makes sense with the mid-game joining.

Not sure who else has a similar power in that sense, or just one role with the ability to die as town but eh. Tinfoiling
 
Stelios said:
Something with the numbers don’t add up. I just had a thought , maybe a stupid thought, but a thought never the less. I wonder if there’s a role that when killed shows like town even thought mafia. Wad’s role would fit that narrative but it’s not like I m willing to believe this is the case or waste any more thinking of it. Why three sinraven ?
Click to expand...
Because a fee days ago we calculated how many townies are left and how many anti town (or non townies) from that

I believe we had 5 non townies so with three dead (Nevan, SK and Waffles) that makes two left.

So I miscalculated :hm
 
What bothers me Sin is that we are both alive late game. You have killed me as mafia early in previous games so I m starting to have doubts about you as well now. I strongly believe WW would kill me. Nighty already voted to lynch me so I don’t tinfoil her as being scum. I think shiny and alwaysmind are the most coy here after all :hm

Shiny’s last minute voting gimmicks and alwaysmind being seemingly useless and unreadable as usual
 
Stelios said:
@White Wolf @Nighty the Mighty thoughts on shiny and alwaysmind?
Click to expand...
White Wolf said:
I don't trust shiny and it seems too convenient.
Click to expand...

White Wolf said:
When did AM claim rolecrush?
Click to expand...

White Wolf said:
I suppose in terms of scum still feel Shiny>Raven>Stelios>AM>Nighty>Myself
Click to expand...


What I see is: Shiny claimed RC when no writeup happened while when I was RC'd there was one and it looked like a one shot that hit all previously marked players (I'm assuming others were already dead)
Shiny is Crocodile... why that would put him as town, I've no idea.
The host is lying, cos Bastard mechanics.
I mean Robin being mafia w/ Luffy in game seems bogus on its own.
And they could've offed WAD early on by counterclaiming his 'no SHs in game' claim.

Though let's take it at face value WAD was town, not fake-died-as-town-tinfoil. Why would Robin (start of series scum) be partnered with Crocodile (marineford-less scum-than-alabasta-arc) town Crocodile?

I mean Robin tricked Crocodile... canonically, but flipping the script and making him town seems retarded af.


That and why kill RemChu of all people? That's either master-ploy, or rookie mistake since he wasn't confirmed by any means or known whatsoever.

The RemChu kill unless really brilliant ploy by you (Stel) or you (Raven) or I guess you (Nighty ... but much less so cos she's a dum nerd :pandaslam: ) screams more rookie bs from AM/Shiny who can slip up more times than not.
 
SinRaven said:
Stelios you havent answered this

Because I think one of them is lying
Click to expand...

I believe that White Wolf poisoned WPK. Whether he is rolecrashed or it was one shot that Is up for debate.

We have nothing about Nighty confirming her role. She came back to life and she said she had one shot return to life iirc. The mist happened at her and platinum’s death as well. She said she is Nemu and claimed town. I guess the more one likely to lie is Nighty.

But now I return back to you again. I sused White Wolf’s poison write up and you and Nevan supported that it’s because of the game.
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
Back
Top