Chaos
Filthy Casual
Oh the ability isn't called Polymorph but the point still stands.
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Ishmael
I'm not impressed.
@Kira Yagami you ever addressed or quoted a response to degas suspicion towards you bring lulu? If so I'd like to be directed to that post please.
Cooler
Well-Known Member
I didn't say you were scummy, I said I was on the fence.
You could have waited until you were 100%, as soon as you gave your result it was fairly obvious which way the lynch would go - there was clearly a significant chance of a mislynch when you gave that info. Now you're trying to shift the responsibility from your lie detect, what bollocks.
It would be crazy if I was the only one sussing you after UB flipped town...
Nothing is proven which is my point...all I said was I've gone from town reading Remchu to not trusting him until he delivers a 100% verdict on a scum target. He could be lying about his ability you know...34% is just high enough for there to be a reasonable chance of error, but I can't ignore the fact UB flipped town. Of course it's very possible that Rem just got unlucky, hence me being on the fence. But I was town reading him before so it was worth updating my read on him right...
Don't feel you've contributed much, did you claim indie?
Chaos with his demanding full role deets from Franky, back tracking immediately from his votes etc...
Ishmael
I'm not impressed.
Okosan also had a indie win con now, he claims to not know what triggered it to happen. And I'm sorry shizune but I don't have the will to keep up with MADS post and quote them everytime he post. I'll just take the consequences.
Kira Yagami
God
No i dont recall dega saying that
Ishmael
I'm not impressed.
Alright, this is what I have so far:
I found myself agreeing with most of Ish and Ratchet's posts. Town read on them.
Kira is a prime candidate for begin Lulu, don't sleep on his claims.
This may be the first time I've seen Town Okosan. I thought that didn't existUnless you are Lulu and you are playing us all
I had an initial scum read on Chaos but then he went ham on Cooler, pointing out all the things wrong with him that I agree on. Could go either way.
The biggest problem with UB's ability claim is this: She needs blood to use skills. She gets blood by being in the wagon on the person lynched. Why didn't she vote for Melodie? Seems pretty counter intuitive.
[Vote lynch UB]
One of degas post, one that actually has substance , the other I don't know.
Ishmael
I'm not impressed.
If we had to shoot anyone for info, who would you all prefer?
Magic
XIII
If you really believe lynch me, idc. Fucking liar.
Magic
XIII
believe that*
you won't though.
you won't though.
Kira Yagami
God
Cooler
Didi
*
It's a fair point
You'd assume Bard has the powers to heal people, to busdrive them or something similar and to turn them completely immune to actions
But transforming people isn't really in his moveset
You'd assume Bard has the powers to heal people, to busdrive them or something similar and to turn them completely immune to actions
But transforming people isn't really in his moveset
Ishmael
I'm not impressed.
And why him, reasoning with these answers would help get a look at where everyone head is.
Oddjutsu
A gift to goblinkind
When I said that I couldn't be killed what I really meant was that you can't shut me up
Cooler
Well-Known Member
This directed at me? How many times do I have to say on the fence...
Trying to make out that I don't have the balls to follow my reads when I've already said I'm not sure about you...
Considering my role gets nerfed for contributing to townie deaths and the vote stacking I'm not going to rush into voting right away fyi.
Magic
XIII
No shit I'm talking to you.
Didi
*
[Vote Lynch Lewd]
I don't fucking know - must admit I'm not too closely involved with this game cuz of the Alley game
I don't fucking know - must admit I'm not too closely involved with this game cuz of the Alley game
Cooler
Well-Known Member
Possibly - but I'm town. What are you reads if I flip town and what are you reads if I flip scum?
I guess because you've got no response to my points you didn't want to quote me?
Keeping throwing that hissy fit and sulking my man. It's a good look.
Franky
★Frankformer★
So I do agree with Cooler on Chaos not having an concrete stands and backing down often.
As well as he was weirdly willing to leave me alone when I dropped my role
Also surprised no one has jumped on the vote wagon yet and just started stacking like mad.
Anyway, before WPK comes in an calls me a spineless man.
[Vote Lynch Chaos]
As well as he was weirdly willing to leave me alone when I dropped my role
Also surprised no one has jumped on the vote wagon yet and just started stacking like mad.
Anyway, before WPK comes in an calls me a spineless man.
[Vote Lynch Chaos]
Chaos
Filthy Casual
I'm town though 
Also the more I think about it the more I really think MAD is Lulu
Why would he have revealed himself, making himself a target, when he could easily have passed as town
We have not seen Bard, yet Lulu has an ability in League that makes her polymorph people
It's a bold and elaborate set-up that was strictly unnecessary if he is who he says he is
inb4 look now Chaos is deflecting with indiehunting
Also the more I think about it the more I really think MAD is Lulu
Why would he have revealed himself, making himself a target, when he could easily have passed as town
We have not seen Bard, yet Lulu has an ability in League that makes her polymorph people
It's a bold and elaborate set-up that was strictly unnecessary if he is who he says he is
inb4 look now Chaos is deflecting with indiehunting
Chaos
Filthy Casual
Oh yea I accepted something that is probably a trap so if I die horribly tonight don't take offers over pm
Ishmael
I'm not impressed.
Lmao just know I know. Those who did it know who they are and I want you to know that I know. Stop with that petty shit.
Ishmael
I'm not impressed.
Was it kind of silly? I triggered a trap voting okosan.
Ishmael
I'm not impressed.
I'll give props to scum this game, you've blended good as hell.... not one of you are gone to my knowledge.
Didi
*
same lol
Ishmael
I'm not impressed.
We all getting hit with bs and no one finds it odd, what did the deal involve exactly? Don't have to share everything just stuff for us to tie things together
Chaos
Filthy Casual
It asked me to accept something which would give me the chance to get stronger.
I don't know anything more at this point.
Cooler
Well-Known Member
Pretty weird how we've got no leads from actions or in the thread.
Ishmael
I'm not impressed.
If you could kill anyone for info who would it be?
FLORIDA MAN
bastard
I'm town though
Also the more I think about it the more I really think MAD is Lulu
Why would he have revealed himself, making himself a target, when he could easily have passed as town
We have not seen Bard, yet Lulu has an ability in League that makes her polymorph people
It's a bold and elaborate set-up that was strictly unnecessary if he is who he says he is
inb4 look now Chaos is deflecting with indiehunting
alright, let’s assume I’m lulu (I’m not)
you haven’t reconciled how i was able to alter ratchet’s role on Night 1 to announce him as an innocent child in the writeup (when he’s not)
FLORIDA MAN
bastard
also i don’t get confirmation on my saves but i am fairly confident i saved nova last night
if u guys really get antsy and want to lynch me down the line...no problem, just give me one night and ill turn someone into a lightning rod to prove myself
if u guys really get antsy and want to lynch me down the line...no problem, just give me one night and ill turn someone into a lightning rod to prove myself
Cooler
Well-Known Member
No one really springs to mind. Franky and myself have both been lynch candidates so would give the most info probably, but I obviously wouldn't pick myself and I happen to believe Franky's D1 town claim.
Honestly if I was going to shoot someone it would be one of the lower activity peeps probably, Dega, WPK etc...
What are your thoughts on Mystic? I feel like he may be off his town meta a bit.
Ishmael
I'm not impressed.
I've suspected him as well, dosent seem likes he's truly actively trying to get scum, just game mechanics,fluff and etc..
Cooler
Well-Known Member
Yeah I'm down with lynching Mystic, or maybe Dega and WPK today.
Also Legend's posts appear quite scummy to me. Just fluff, asks MAD about his survivor win/con, makes a thing about being here at phase start and then says nothing else...guy is hella coasting.
Legend might be my pick thinking about it.
Also Legend's posts appear quite scummy to me. Just fluff, asks MAD about his survivor win/con, makes a thing about being here at phase start and then says nothing else...guy is hella coasting.
Legend might be my pick thinking about it.
Cooler
Well-Known Member
Yeah I'm down with lynching Mystic, or maybe Dega and WPK today.
Also Legend's posts appear quite scummy to me. Just fluff, asks MAD about his survivor win/con, makes a thing about being here at phase start and then says nothing else...guy is hella coasting.
Legend might be my pick thinking about it.
Also Legend's posts appear quite scummy to me. Just fluff, asks MAD about his survivor win/con, makes a thing about being here at phase start and then says nothing else...guy is hella coasting.
Legend might be my pick thinking about it.
Cooler
Well-Known Member
Apologies for the double post.
Cooler
Well-Known Member
There's a hidden message disguised as a subtle difference in the two posts, first one to find it wins the game.
Ratchet
The End and the Beginning
I felt like it was fairly obvious Remchu was advising that we possibly hold off on UB. I also don't see an issue with him coming forward - we don't exactly have an abundance of information on our hands here, and the 66% check is still pretty strong. This strikes me as a somewhat lazy attempt to discredit Remchu Cooler, if nothing else he has been careful in how he presents his information to us. And if I'm understanding his ability right, he won't be able to have a 100% check until Day 5. Which was why I said we should not lynch UB last phase, until he got his 100% check off.
Actually, the very first game I won as scum I was a scum lie detector. Though I'm guessing they're not really a thing on NF (lie detectors being scum, that is).
Ratchet
The End and the Beginning
It feels like you've suspected pretty much everyone at this point, Ishmael.
Yin
Yin Within Yin God, #Boosette / SC Meme-Let The Creativity Flow
~Mystic Serenade~
King of the Round
I already addressed that this sorta but this game has tilted me off the planet tbh 
If we're shooting in the dark here I'd go for one of the inactives. Actually waiting for Legend to answer my question but I'd lynch him tbh
If we're shooting in the dark here I'd go for one of the inactives. Actually waiting for Legend to answer my question but I'd lynch him tbh
Magic
XIII
Can we axe Chaos? 
Cooler
Well-Known Member
Maybe I missed those posts where he advised holding off. I wasn't around much at the weekend.
Any you could link that stand out? I do recall him saying this phase that he won't divulge info again until it's 100% which is a good look for him.
Like I said I was town reading him before, now with UB's flip I'm on the fence as there's definitely a chance he's been leading us up the garden path...I didn't say too much on it initially until Rem blew up in my face either BTW. I'm just being cautious of his lie detector claims until they're verified.
[Vote Lynch Legend]
Going to go with this for now.
I made ya an ava just in case you're interested:
Thanks!
Says it's too big?
Yin
Yin Within Yin God, #Boosette / SC Meme-Let The Creativity Flow
What size ya working on your avatars?
Magic
XIII
Magic
XIII
Learn to read.
Ishmael
I'm not impressed.
We'll we don't really got much to work off of, we aren't really working together, so I mean my trust in this game is low.
Magic
XIII
Like how hard is it to fucking PM him my dude.
REALLY .
REALLY .
~Mystic Serenade~
King of the Round
Also just so people don't use this against me later my vote is tentatively on Legend atm, I'll state otherwise if I change my mind.
But I'm not writing my actual vote until later cause vote stacking.
But I'm not writing my actual vote until later cause vote stacking.
Cooler
Well-Known Member
Learn to go fuck yourself.
Just because I've sussed you just a little bit for the way the UB played out you're throwing a bitch fit. Chill out you miserable cunt. It's not that big of a deal.
FLORIDA MAN
bastard
that aspect ratio is fucking horrendous
Hidden
A Human from the Present
Coooooo! (Okosan means, he did say that we wasn't really reading you as scum or anything. Just that it was strange is all. And like, regardless we do probably have bigger fish to fry besides you right now.)
Hidden
A Human from the Present
Cooo? (The big issue that Okosan as right now is while he honestly thinks there are scum hiding within the bottom posters, lynching them isn't really going to get us any info.)
Magic
XIII
No learn to fucking read, we wouldn't have a problem.
Fucking idiot.
Hidden
A Human from the Present
Cooo Coo! (Also actually if Remchu was advising that we hold off on voting for UB, why were they themselves voting for them?)
Magic
XIII
Hmmm, multiple people state I didn't push anyone, that I advised we wait. Yet you still hang on to your dumbfuck narrative.
Hidden
A Human from the Present
COO?? (Oh wait a minute were they? Remchu's name appears on the vote tally twice 
)
)Magic
XIII
Hidden
A Human from the Present
Hidden
A Human from the Present
COO COO! (Oh, well Okosan tried to distinguish it in the post, but whatever.)
Cooler
Well-Known Member
I can read fine, like right now - I'm reading your posts and they're saying, "I'm a pissy little prick"
Didi
*
[Vote Lynch Legend]
Also fine with this
Also fine with this
I quite like the thought that Mad could be Lulu
Shame with the UB lynch, I just wasn't around that day so I put my vote on the wagon at the time I was on.
Shame with the UB lynch, I just wasn't around that day so I put my vote on the wagon at the time I was on.
~Mystic Serenade~
King of the Round
Tbh I think Oddjutsu just interpreted his ability wrong and only his final vote is what was permanent and stacks 
So people who went fill got a role then a choice of champions right?
If so I think I know who Jinx is
If so I think I know who Jinx is
FLORIDA MAN
bastard
why is nobody answering my response to this theory
this seems like a convenient backdoor excuse to try and rally a lynch against me at a later date by those perpetuating it
Magic
XIII
They don't care they just want a mislynch like on Melodie and UB.
Calling it now.
Chaos, Lewd, etc. scum most likely.
WolfPrinceKiba
Dog of War
Immediately indie-hunting.
How does this make sense? He's a cultist who makes himself obvious due to anyone voting them getting a post restriction, a ridiculous one at that?
You talk about not shooting each other yet you want someone to shoot Franky who at the least has a genuine sounding claim?
Are you trying to justify the kill not being a good vig target because of the chance of LG having been investigated...and therefore it was performed by anti-town?
For me the big point was throwing shade towards Remchu's motivations with his lie detect info dump but using his info to justify his vote on UB, despite Remchu not voting there himself, pushing UB at all and even suggesting just waiting until he could use the 100% lie detect.
Nitty games have a history of not following tradition ratios, see RPG mafia : three mafia in like a 40 player game.
You could have not lynched UB and waited for the 100% like Remchu suggested, yet you threw shade at it only to jump aboard yourself. Things are only inevitable if people allow them to be.
[Vote Lynch Cooler]
Really the only reason I can see him as cultist revealing is so mafia/those with kills don't target him, which he did state as his reason for revealing as Bard. You're suggesting the polymorph ability would work to change someone's role to her choosing? I could see it, nor does it have to be anything more than a write-up tampering. I just think with that kind of moveset MAD could not reveal, coast the line of not being a target for town or mafia while converting people and choosing one of his converts to be proclaimed an innocent child in-thread to give them towncred.I'm town though
Also the more I think about it the more I really think MAD is Lulu
Why would he have revealed himself, making himself a target, when he could easily have passed as town
We have not seen Bard, yet Lulu has an ability in League that makes her polymorph people
It's a bold and elaborate set-up that was strictly unnecessary if he is who he says he is
inb4 look now Chaos is deflecting with indiehunting
Really the most concerning thing is that Bard hasn't showed up in a write-up and we had Zyra as an invisible hostile indie last LoL game.
Don't like this preemptive defense.
4. Degaforce - Illaoi, Gangplank > top
7. Mr. Waffles - Yorick, Kalista > top
18. Mysti - Quinn, Graves > bot
19. Oddjutsu (Zilean) - Lux, Kayle >support/mid most likely mid
so these are the people that filled, you can clearly see they have a role then champion select
This leaves 3 people bot
me
nova
Mysti
Nova got rid of Jinx, I'm not Jinx hence Mysti must be so
[vote lynch ~Mystic Serenade~]
With Jinx's flavour she surely has to be scum
7. Mr. Waffles - Yorick, Kalista > top
18. Mysti - Quinn, Graves > bot
19. Oddjutsu (Zilean) - Lux, Kayle >support/mid most likely mid
so these are the people that filled, you can clearly see they have a role then champion select
This leaves 3 people bot
me
nova
Mysti
Nova got rid of Jinx, I'm not Jinx hence Mysti must be so
[vote lynch ~Mystic Serenade~]
With Jinx's flavour she surely has to be scum
Didi
*
It's been quite well shown so far imo that flavour doesn't matter
You really are scum, aren't you?
Forgot to mention I assume Jinx is in the game for the spray paint img left in the write ups
WolfPrinceKiba
Dog of War
Scum surely like to have an indie to eat up attention yes. Okay...was anyone on you for having voted UB? You look bad there mostly if Cooler flips scum.
I would think if they chose fill then they would get a champion type that wasn't picked much, to give a good numbers balance.
After Melodie's lynch d1 this idea really should have been thrown out the window, even more so after UB's flip. Those that keep pushing this angle just look scummy at this point.
There are legit reasons to suspect Mystic but not this.
novaselinenever
Best Dad
Scum and you're getting lynched today.
I'm willing to bet on this
Didi
*
WolfPrinceKiba
Dog of War
Speaking of which @Kira Yagami what did you try to use on Mystic that failed? Depending on what it was more heat should go that way.
novaselinenever
Best Dad
Am I the only one seeing through Ishmael's bullshit or what? The dude is just spamming the thread to boost his posts counts. Just a bunch of bullshit, repeating what everyone is saying, narrating the flow of the game, some dumb hot takes once in a while. He suspected everyone so far, and there is no consistency whatsoever in his reads and thoughts. He just spit the first thoughts that come to his mind and see what sticks. Just iso his posts and this is clear as day. This is giving me mad GL vs KLK vibes.
Hidden
A Human from the Present
Cooooooo! (Also that list is wrong because Okosan also chose fill. He can't check the entire validity of the list right now though, sadly)