Game RPG Mafia (mafia+indies win!)

[SinRaven]

[Vote Lynch @Okosan]

While many are perhaps acting more suspicious, this bird is skimming the sidelines of all discussion, but adding little.

I'd like to hear her opinion on a few matters. What is your opinion on the King currently? What do you think about the nightly victims, specifically the ones last night? Who do you trust and more importantly, who don't you trust?

 

[SinRaven]

If any of you still suspect me: I welcome any new arguments with open arms and will defend myself against them properly.

Repeating the old points will have me ignore them, though.

 

[SinRaven]

I would like for @Degaforce, @Underworld Broker, @Mr. Waffles and @Dr. White to join me on the quest to the hermit's hut. I don't yet trust you all, but to me this is the safest combination of people.

Others are welcome to join as well, but I'd like to hear why I should trust you and take you.

 

[Iwandesu]

The fact katsuargi got normally killed means we indeed broke the game code.
Who were yesterday quest leaders?
Also im leading the swamp.
SWAMP-5 Man group.
Start group

 

[Cooler]

@Cooler is lurking right now.

Nope. Had the tab open and was away from keyboard. I wanted to start a quest so I wouldn't be lurking intentionally.

 

[Iwandesu]

The Swamp - 5 man dungeon
[Start Group]

Quests are so beneficial

Oh well
join group

 

[Cooler]

The Jungle in the Sky - 5 man dungeon

Start Group


Does this still count?

 

[Jeroen]

I would like for @Degaforce, @Underworld Broker, @Mr. Waffles and @Dr. White to join me on the quest to the hermit's hut. I don't yet trust you all, but to me this is the safest combination of people.

Others are welcome to join as well, but I'd like to hear why I should trust you and take you.

I'm okay with joining, but I'll do so if I survive the wrap up of last night's quest.

Also im leading the swamp.
SWAMP-5 Man group.
Start group

You're competing with Priscilla on this.

 

[Didi]

>Kira has lead multiple quests yet mafia chose to normalkill Katsuargi of all people last night

???
[Vote Lynch Kira]

The fact katsuargi got normally killed means we indeed broke the game code.
Who were yesterday quest leaders?
Also im leading the swamp.
SWAMP-5 Man group.
Start group

[Join Group]

 

[Iwandesu]

I wanted the swamp since yesterday.
But i dont mind normally joining the quest.
Anyway how benefiticial would be saving the child?
@Mr. Waffles @RemChu @Priscilla
If one of you had to die which one should?

 

[Underworld Broker]

The Hermit - 5 man dungeon

[Start Group]

[Join Group]

 

[Didi]

The fact katsuargi got normally killed means we indeed broke the game code.
Who were yesterday quest leaders?
Also im leading the swamp.
SWAMP-5 Man group.
Start group

Kira and I thought Sin but apparently Priscilla for reasons as of yet undiscovered

 

[Iwandesu]

>Kira has lead multiple quests yet mafia chose to normalkill Katsuargi of all people last night

???
[Vote Lynch Kira]





[Join Group]

Just join priscilla
And yeah Either mafia is going for framing or they lacked options.

 

[Didi]

I wanted the swamp since yesterday.
But i dont mind normally joining the quest.
Anyway how benefiticial would be saving the child?
@Mr. Waffles @RemChu @Priscilla
If one of you had to die which one should?

RemChu
because either him or Sin are scum
so him dying would 100% get us scum

 

[Didi]

Just join priscilla
And yeah Either mafia is going for framing or they lacked options.

I'd much rather join you tbh
trust you more than Priscilla


but fine

The Swamp - 5 man dungeon
[Start Group]

Quests are so beneficial

[Join Group]

 

[Jeroen]

Anyway how benefiticial would be saving the child?

No idea.
I'm assuming gratitude from the father or something.

@Mr. Waffles @RemChu @Priscilla
If one of you had to die which one should?

No idea on this either.

 

[Katou]

I wanted the swamp since yesterday.
But i dont mind normally joining the quest.
Anyway how benefiticial would be saving the child?
@Mr. Waffles @RemChu @Priscilla
If one of you had to die which one should?

Doesn't say what benefit ..
just that 1 of the 3 of us should be sacrificed in order to heal the child ..
i already volunteered tbh ..
Rem and Waffles are better alive anyway..

 

[Iwandesu]

RemChu
because either him or Sin are scum
so him dying would 100% get us scum

Yeah i thought the same.
Imo king should definitely look for remchu if he refuses a sacrifice

 

[Iwandesu]

Doesn't say what benefit ..
just that 1 of the 3 of us should be sacrificed in order to heal the child ..
i already volunteered tbh ..
Rem and Waffles are better alive anyway..

I mean if remchu is a Town power role then sure.
if scum...

 

[Iwandesu]

Also gratitude from the rather sounds boring lol

 

[Katou]

Well..there's that bastard role to think about... sacrifice is probably a bluff... but u never know

 

[Katou]

Rule*

 

[Degaforce]

I would like for @Degaforce, @Underworld Broker, @Mr. Waffles and @Dr. White to join me on the quest to the hermit's hut. I don't yet trust you all, but to me this is the safest combination of people.

Others are welcome to join as well, but I'd like to hear why I should trust you and take you.

I'd like to get the result of our quest first, to decide.
Also, I believe the swamp would fit my character better.

 

[Iwandesu]

I wonder why anyone would kill katsu, tho.
he was confirmed town sure.
But he was a poor tracker.
Imo mafia should be among the suspected people (duh)
Did katsu state who he was gonna track ?

 

[Iwandesu]

I'm fully dedicated to clearing quests successfully and have done so ever phase so far. .

Also, Dega didn't target anyone last night.

Hey dega do you have anything to tell us

 

[Smileyman]

The fact katsuargi got normally killed means we indeed broke the game code.
Who were yesterday quest leaders?
Also im leading the swamp.
SWAMP-5 Man group.
Start group

[Join group]

 

[Jeroen]

[Join group]

Anything else to add, or just gonna skip again ?

 

[Ishmael]

[Vote Lynch @Okosan]

While many are perhaps acting more suspicious, this bird is skimming the sidelines of all discussion, but adding little.

I'd like to hear her opinion on a few matters. What is your opinion on the King currently? What do you think about the nightly victims, specifically the ones last night? Who do you trust and more importantly, who don't you trust?

Showing cannibalism now aren't we?

 

[Kira Yagami]

Whose group did Katsu join yesterday?

>Kira has lead multiple quests yet mafia chose to normalkill Katsuargi of all people last night

???
[Vote Lynch Kira]





[Join Group]

Out of all the suspected people you jump to lynch me and for such a bad reason,Scummy

 

[Iwandesu]

You Also seemed awfully interested on confirming Katsu status yesterday

 

[Ishmael]

Whose group did Katsu join yesterday?




Out of all the suspected people you jump to lynch me and for such a bad reason,Scummy

Actually not a bad reason your basically someone who's led multiple quest but hasn't been attacked (to my knowledge) or killed. Unlike the other unfortunate soul's.

 

[Ishmael]

@Darth you going to help out or what buddy?

 

[Iwandesu]

Anyone who didnt get killed yesterday despite being quest leader is suspicious.
@SinRaven
@Kira Yagami
Why would mafia faction kill @Katsuargi instead of super killing your asses?

 

[Jeroen]

Anyone who didnt get killed yesterday despite being quest leader is suspicious.
@SinRaven
@Kira Yagami
Why would mafia faction kill @Katsuargi instead of super killing your asses?

Sin wasn't a quest leader.

 

[Iwandesu]

Legit question.
If you are unable to answer you may lie as valid targets to that trash king if he manages to live another day.

Sin wasn't a quest leader.

I thought he was
Who was the other quest leader ?

 

[Jeroen]

Legit question.
If you are unable to answer you may lie as valid targets to that trash king if he manages to live another day.

I thought he was
Who was the other quest leader ?

Priscilla was the quest leader for some reason.

 

[Iwandesu]

btw i would like to reiterate how i think the king should have been dethroned long ago.
I still cant believe he killed law instead of finishing the rem x sin dilenma .

 

[Iwandesu]

Ok ok.
So @Priscilla
Come forth and tell me why your ass is less worthy than katsu's ?

 

[Degaforce]

Hey dega do you have anything to tell us

I will once I get the results of the quest.

Whose group did Katsu join yesterday?




Out of all the suspected people you jump to lynch me and for such a bad reason,Scummy

Katsu joined Law's group. So no quest there.

And his reason for suspecting you is completely valid. Why are you turning it around?

 

[Kira Yagami]

Actually not a bad reason your basically someone who's led multiple quest but hasn't been attacked (to my knowledge) or killed. Unlike the other unfortunate soul's.

It is imo
We cant just say every quest leader who doesnt get offed is scum

Anyone who didnt get killed yesterday despite being quest leader is suspicious.
@SinRaven
@Kira Yagami
Why would mafia faction kill @Katsuargi instead of super killing your asses?

Honestly i dont know
Guess they thought Katsu with his tracking ability was more important to get rid of than I
OR im being framed.

 

[Didi]

Sin wasn't a quest leader.

But did mafia know that?

Or are you saying you knew because you were on the actual quest and thus mafia knew?

Whose group did Katsu join yesterday?




Out of all the suspected people you jump to lynch me and for such a bad reason,Scummy

how is it a bad reason? It's objectively scummy to be not targeted multiple times while being a questleader, even moreso considering they normalkilled a pretty random seeming guy (well, I suppose he did confess to having a tracking ability) last night instead instead of superkilling a quest leader?

Just dismissing me and going the very textbook definition of OMGUS only makes you look worse

Are you seeing this @King ?

 

[Didi]

It is imo
We cant just say every quest leader who doesnt get offed is scum

No one did, don't try and twist the argument. However going on multiple and escaping the dance everytime? More so.
It's been what, 2 or 3 times now for you?


But your instinctive OMGUS reply has already told me enough, Kira Yascumi

 

[SinRaven]

But did mafia know that?

Or are you saying you knew because you were on the actual quest and thus mafia knew?

You are operating on the basis that one of Rem and I is a traitor. I didn't lead the quest like I wanted to and Rem joined the quest according to Waffles word. They would know I wasn't the quest leader in both situations. The only way they wouldn't know is if both Rem and I, and also Waffles and Priscilla, we're innocent.

 

[Jeroen]

But did mafia know that?

Or are you saying you knew because you were on the actual quest and thus mafia knew?

Fair point I suppose.

 

[Didi]

You are operating on the basis that one of Rem and I is a traitor. I didn't lead the quest like I wanted to and Rem joined the quest according to Waffles word. They would know I wasn't the quest leader in both situations. The only way they wouldn't know is if both Rem and I, and also Waffles and Priscilla, we're innocent.

That's... a really good point!

 

[SinRaven]

I second the notion in which RemChu would sacrifice himself, obviously. I'm not afraid to see what he would turn out to be.

The only con I could see is that an evil man sacrificing himself could have evil results, but that's just theorycrafting.

 

[SinRaven]

I like the pressure put on Kira, makes me have more faith in Didi as well.

Okosan was around a few minutes ago, but flew off as soon as I called her out. I say she too makes a valid target for today.

 

[Jeroen]

Guessing Smileyman skipped again.

 

[Legend]

The Jungle in the Sky - 5 man dungeon

Start Quest

[JOIN GROUP]

 

[Kira Yagami]

how is it a bad reason? It's objectively scummy to be not targeted multiple times while being a questleader, even moreso considering they normalkilled a pretty random seeming guy (well, I suppose he did confess to having a tracking ability) last night instead instead of superkilling a quest leader?

Just dismissing me and going the very textbook definition of OMGUS only makes you look worse

Are you seeing this @King ?

Again,Not a good enough reason to lynch me
This normalkill move could simply be mafia framing us and trying to make us point fingers at the quest leaders
In fact you could be that mafia seeing how hard you'rs pushing this

No one did, don't try and twist the argument.

Mate,You vote lynched me which means you think im scum

However going on multiple and escaping the dance everytime? More so.
It's been what, 2 or 3 times now for you?

2

 

[Legend]

[Vote Lynch Underworld Broker]

In the quest pm you mentioned something to Nitty about checking something in the other qt. What was that about?

 

[novaselinenever]

Guessing Smileyman skipped again.

I know the guy. This is scum play. He doesn't try to blend in nor participate in case of a slip up.

He's much more active and question everything as Town.

 

[Jeroen]

I know the guy. This is scum play. He doesn't try to blend in nor participate in case of a slip up.

He's much more active and question everything as Town.

Good to know.

 

[novaselinenever]

The Jungle in the Sky - 5 man dungeon

Start Group

[Join group]

 

[novaselinenever]

Good to know.

Mohit is also another one I've played with before.

I voted for him last day phase because of his aggressiveness defending himself. It's something he often does as scum.

 

[Didi]

Again,Not a good enough reason to lynch me
This normalkill move could simply be mafia framing us and trying to make us point fingers at the quest leaders
In fact you could be that mafia seeing how hard you'rs pushing this


Mate,You vote lynched me which means you think im scum

2

yeah I do, don't pretend people weren't saying you were scummy already before this happened though bro
you're acting like this is the only point against you

I like the pressure put on Kira, makes me have more faith in Didi as well.

Okosan was around a few minutes ago, but flew off as soon as I called her out. I say she too makes a valid target for today.

Yeah the birdy has been a bit off, I agree. Very sporadic activity, not much of worth said

 

[novaselinenever]

How is the King still in power ?

 

[Didi]

Nice that you're finally choosing to contribute nova

got some more stuff?
what do you think about the Sin/Remchu debacle and in general the Sin/WPK/dega conspiracy?

Or any townreads / other general scumreads besides your ones based on meta?

 

[novaselinenever]

Nice that you're finally choosing to contribute nova

got some more stuff?
what do you think about the Sin/Remchu debacle and in general the Sin/WPK/dega conspiracy?

Or any townreads / other general scumreads besides your ones based on meta?

Not really. Had trouble keeping up with the game the last day phases and all these players seem pretty neutral to me.

The only thing that caught my eye is the theory about Mafia killing quests leaders every night phase except the last one.

Last night phase Mafia didn't superkill, it was just a regular kill. Maybe they can only superkill when they're part of quest or just the leaders.

 

[Shiny]

no one accepts me on quests

 

[Jeroen]

no one accepts me on quests

That's because the one time you did go, you got yourself captured and we had to save your sorry ass.

 

[Didi]

Not really. Had trouble keeping up with the game the last day phases and all these players seem pretty neutral to me.

The only thing that caught my eye is the theory about Mafia killing quests leaders every night phase except the last one.

Last night phase Mafia didn't superkill, it was just a regular kill. Maybe they can only superkill when they're part of quest or just the leaders.

wow, good of you to catch the thing everybody has been discussing to death, real observant of ya

 

[Kira Yagami]

yeah I do, don't pretend people weren't saying you were scummy already before this happened though bro

only ScumRaven suspected me yesterday and for no good reason iirc

you're acting like this is the only point against you

This is the only point against me
Unless you can bring another forth

 

[Didi]

yeah, your weird stonewalling on Tiger's poison sacrifice caused us to have a fairly useless lynch yesterday (instead of a more informative one in like Sin or WPK etc. Or just an obvious one in Nevan, who by the way, is still definitely hella scum @King )

 

[SinRaven]

only ScumRaven suspected me yesterday and for no good reason iirc

Tiger suspected you as well for how you tried to switch his plans up for the poisoning.

 

[Didi]

Also I'm positive that more people than just Sin (hell, even more than just Sin and Law) called you out yesterday

Having to resort to baldfaced lies only makes you look more confirmed, mr Scum Scum Scummy Scum

 

[Hidden]

[Vote Lynch @Okosan]


While many are perhaps acting more suspicious, this bird is skimming the sidelines of all discussion, but adding little.


I'd like to hear her opinion on a few matters. What is your opinion on the King currently? What do you think about the nightly victims, specifically the ones last night? Who do you trust and more importantly, who don't you trust?

Cooo! COOO! (Sure sure. Currently, Okosan believes that we should keep the King in power. Sure it would be nice to have actual, direct control over the lynch. But at this point if we allow this to happen Mafia (and apparently werewolves ffs) are probably going to have a pretty good chunk of the control as well. About the victims, first off, just fantastic. We still have werewolves alive. Actually kill him (but like really please don't, though, thanks). The kill on Kat at seems to point towards the fact that maybe there wasn't mafia on a quest? We don't know if they have to kill the leader or not so it's hard to tell.)

COOOO! (Okosan is suspicious of people like Kira (For leading so many quests and the thing with poisoning law yesterday), Shiny, RemChu, and the people that come in just to join a quest and leave. So since there wasn't a superkill today that makes Okosan feel like Sin isn't Mafia due to the fact that he was trying to lead a quest earlier, and this recent thing where RemChu hasn't volunteered yet also seems sus. So he'd say hi biggest suspects for today are RemChu and Kira, in that order.)

Coo! (Okosan feels like he can trust people like Dr. White (Obviously), JayJay (Maybe a little too sus of Broker and Nighty, but still), Didi, and KC? The thing is just that there is so many more people to distrust right now as opposed to trust.)

 

[Platinum]

The Katsu kill is very interesting.

If anything, I think it is apparent that the mafia is headed by someone with not a lot of experience. The fact that certain people have been left to linger signals to me a lack of player familiarity.

 

[Underworld Broker]

[Vote Lynch Underworld Broker]

In the quest pm you mentioned something to Nitty about checking something in the other qt. What was that about?

Oh my god i totally scum slipped

Nah, if you would've followed previous DP you'd know what i am

btw. thanks for reminding me, gotta check

 

[Underworld Broker]

I still got no answer in QT

 

[Kira Yagami]

yeah, your weird stonewalling on Tiger's poison sacrifice caused us to have a fairly useless lynch yesterday (instead of a more informative one in like Sin or WPK etc. Or just an obvious one in Nevan, who by the way, is still definitely hella scum @King )

Please
1.the person who got poisoned was not entirely up to me,it was a group vote
2. Everyone thought Tiger was sus so dont act like anyone wouldve agreed to have him alive for another 2 cycles mate

Tiger suspected you as well for how you tried to switch his plans up for the poisoning.

Oh yeah he did too,he slipped my mind
Though Tbf he did suspect Stelios,AlwaysMind and MSAL too and he was wrong
I am in the same boat as them

Also I'm positive that more people than just Sin (hell, even more than just Sin and Law) called you out yesterday

Having to resort to baldfaced lies only makes you look more confirmed, mr Scum Scum Scummy Scum

No,i really dont recall anyone other than them two,quote these people please

 

[Underworld Broker]

oh yeah, my mafia buddies just said they tracked jayjay and he's probably a werewolf

@Legend

 

[Jeroen]

Everyone thought Tiger was sus so dont act like anyone wouldve agreed to have him alive for another 2 cycles mate

But you, and Stelios, were already against before the 2 cycle thing was known.

 

[Underworld Broker]

sorry, i shouldn't troll someone who wasn't following the game so far

 

[Degaforce]

sorry, i shouldn't troll someone who wasn't following the game so far

Do you know what happens to you guys if the King is removed from power?
Do you leave and lose the game permanently?
Do you turn into mafia?
Do you turn into town?

This seems the only valid reason right now to keep the King in power.

 

[Underworld Broker]

Do you know what happens to you guys if the King is removed from power?

Nope dunno. Have to keep him in power.

Do you leave and lose the game permanently?

Probably.

Do you turn into mafia?

Doubt so, wouldn't be balanced imo.

Do you turn into town?

Could be an option, what usually happens to a royal court if the king has no power?

Though i already said it once, i wouldn't recommend voting the king down. Not sure if mafia could get an upgrade or some other thing triggers (maybe some other role in the game that has to get rid off the king?). I mean otherwise we wouldn't be in the game with the win con we currently have. Also bastard mechanics, haven't seen what's that bastard yet.

Maybe we already got mafia and they flipped blue, idk.

 

[Iwandesu]

Anyway
Smileyman
Nevan
Im positive nevan is scum.
Smileyman is most definitely scum.
There must be one scum that is not inactive.
@SinRaven argues neither him nor remchu are likely to be scum but a remchu death is information because ?
I mean If you are so sure neither of you are scum then remchu death would be useless no ?
I myself am sure one of you should be scum unless mafia can really Just spam super kills as Far as There is a Quest leader.
Imo your attempt to discredit remchu Lynch is a way to avoid getting called máfia when remchu flips town.

 

[Underworld Broker]

Btw. just some random thought but i guess Mohit got converted, he isn't pushing anymore for the king to get overthrown

 

[Didi]

I mean
usually a peasant revolt ends with the nobles losing their heads

that's what I'd assume

 

[SinRaven]

Anyway
Smileyman
Nevan
Im positive nevan is scum.
Smileyman is most definitely scum.
There must be one scum that is not inactive.
@SinRaven argues neither him nor remchu are likely to be scum but a remchu death is information because ?
I mean If you are so sure neither of you are scum then remchu death would be useless no ?
I myself am sure one of you should be scum unless mafia can really Just spam super kills as Far as There is a Quest leader.
Imo your attempt to discredit remchu Lynch is a way to avoid getting called máfia when remchu flips town.

Are you confusing me with someone else?

I do think RemChu is suspicious, especially after the more recent events. I wouldn't mind seeing him dead, which is one reason why I agreed with the notion to have RemChu sacrificing himself in his current quest with Waffles and Priscilla.