I was first to point out Infinity lying about not playing mafia before but that is only part of the reason I suspect him, Avalon is a really good player and he won't make any scum slips
You being unkillable and confirmed town is a valuable asset
He knew it was me, we're playing a game within the game
Unless Odd is their scummate, I just don't see why they'd be sticking to LG so much if they're scum Okosan.
Infinity was in here early trying to get the ball rolling, trying to poke at people to get any kind of reaction to read, and their interaction with Kvothe felt like TvT.
All this talk of Infinity/Optimistic being a strong scum read, and no vote. You extending that promise to not vote them for the rest of the game Odd?
They voted him for more than self-preservation.
The sequence of posts of Melodie being unrepentant and explaining why they aren't crying over LG is more effort than I think scum!Melodie would put in to defend themselves. Putting them at low priority for today.
They said your vote was self-preservation and that they didn't expect their LG vote to gain traction enough to be the lynch. I think this is just an honest misunderstanding though.
When did I ever say that?
How was I in any way "careless about who got lynched"? I voted for the person I most suspected, which was also a viable wagon. You're making it seem like I went and vanity voted for a non-competitive wagon, and so didn't care who of of the existing options got got.
8v2 is more likely as that's within normal ratio guidelines, 7v3 only allows a single mislynch before you're in LYLO. Shizune games also skew towards fewer mafia.
This way doubting a blocker makes Sense.
How about you vote for someone and explain why you are voting for them
It's highly suspect
Pretty sure Shizune won't count that and you're still voting for me
This post made me see Melodie in better light now. Definitely removing the suspicion I have.Sin, I suspect WPK plenty. I also there is one mafia out of the birds.
No because I visited the thread unhealthy amount of times, saying I did not come back is dishonest because there are also posts to prove so. yea I did not come back the last couple hours of the day phase, and I never will in any phase due to timezone. Also I'm not 'blaming' or throwing 'shade' at you for the lynch on Lord Genome, pretty forced narrative considering I said very clearly that I do not mind the lynch on him whatsoever considering his attitude towards the game as evidently.
Some of you all throw out the most necessary claims and stuff in the thread for whatever unholy reason
Ugh, this feels like bussing tbh. All the reasoning feels like he's trying to justify the vote and not look like sheeping. Bit the greatest look. I don't wanna press it right now tho, but it's something I wanted to point out.
Coo! (Nice. Good waste of a vote
)You seem very snippish this game.Coo! (Nice. Good waste of a vote
I really don't like this post of Drago it is Just made to throw shade.
Also this one of Drago is a bit too much acting like a good buddy and gives me
Also this is throwing shade on me based on the Genome lynch. And now Melodie is denying it after I called her out for it.
Can you Vote me once and Change Back to whoever you want? Wanna try something.
Cooooo! (Nice)
[Change vote lynch Nessos]
Read the full post, jealous little Dove.
If I was out to make others doubt Odd's claim I would have made an argument in that direction. You asked me a question, I gave the logical answer, now supposedly because in your head 8v2 would make you doubt Odd's claim I'm the one pushing that idea?Read the full post, jealous little Dove.
You really seems to have problems when a big noisy bird is in front of you
Btw I also have to admit I mixed up Kouga and Kvothe. Just noticed Kvothe made the more detailed 8 vs 2 post and Kouga Most likely only used it to
If you really think it is 8v2 it doesn't mak much sense to suspect Odd. And in 7v3 version roleblocker makes sense.
Run through your mechanical logic here. A roleblocker of either alignment can exist in either of those formats, so even if Odd is telling his role truthfully it doesn't mean he's town.
In a 7v3 a scum roleblocker would be too overpowered. Scum roleblocker makes only sense in 8v2.
Scum roleblocker is hardly overpowered in that format, still have 6/7 people able to do actions. Most games of this size don't have all of town having abilities which is likely the case here, the roleblocker isn't in a position to just cuck the 1-2 PRs and if it could, then it did a good job routing them out. Night is scum's territory, townies getting actions blocked isn't as impactful as mafia getting actions blocked.
Yes, it was a one shot roleblockOdd was it a one shot roleblock?
Rogue
alignment: guilty
wincon: eliminate everyone outside your mafia
“You're gonna find a number of outfits that covet our skills. Adventurers, SI:7... heck, even the disorganized rabble wouldn't mind a spy or two inside Stormwind. But you remember this: You're your own man. Don't let nobody bully you into doing something you don't wanna do! Besides, we hold all the cards... at least, we do before the game's done.”
[Active - Stealth] - The Rogue can stalk another player during the night to learn what their ability is. If the Rogue's target uses their ability on another player while being stalked, the Rogue will also learn who they target.
[One Shot Active - Pickpocket] - The Rogue can permanently steal an ability from a player that she has previously stalked. If the Rogue dies, her stolen ability will be returned to its rightful owner.
[One Shot Active - Vanish] - The Rogue can use shadow magic to become invisible, enabling her to fool watchers and trackers for that night.
Hunter
alignment: innocent
wincon: eliminate all threats to the town
“The way of the hunter is one of mastery over the beasts of the world, an unparalleled precision in marksmanship, and the knowledge of how to survive in situations where others would perish.”
[Passive - Tame Beast] - The Hunter's faithful animal companion watches her back, telling her the names of any players who target her with an ability.
How you think about Okosans last Minute Vote? Especially after he critisized me for voting Kouga?
He implied bussing on Sins vote like it is confirmed Kouga is scum.
Coooo! (Lmao)
COOO? (Really why? That seems pretty bad tbh. If there are only 2 mafia then they were confirmed town. And with 3 mafia they're still pretty likely town)
Another round Jealous Little Dove vs Big Noisy Albatros?
Coooo! (Lmao)
I noticed it, not reading much into it at the moment
Good point, didn't think of that. What I am thinking of is that you have too much information, like you know exactly how the janitoring of Kvothe and killing of Kvothe was performed
Cooo! (It's called basic analysis? Like, the second WPK dies as scum, assuming you're not lying about your action / Optimistic can be blocked, Optimistic is confirmed town in a mafia team of 2)
In a team of 3 like I have been preparing for, my roleblock doesn't confirm him at all. Always think of the worst case scenario
COOO! (It semi confirms them. Makes it so Optimistic couldn't have A) Carried the kill. Or B) Done the janitor)
If they killed someone else they could have had a free mislynch, it's not the optimal move. They must have gotten scared of his big nasty ability combined with the fact that I promised not to roleblock him
Did you do the thing to Kvothe?
Coo! (Nah because Optimistic is a pretty easy save target last night. So in Okosan's mind it's them knowing it confirms them. So like 85/15 on a team of 2/3 is what Okosan is leaning)
My paranoid brain says you did that because you knew that Kvothe would have no information and you can get town read for bringing back a janitored kill
Cooo! (Well here's why Okosan did it. 1) Obviously Okosan wasn't going to use it on LG who barely posted. 2) Okosan didn't want to wait too long in case he just died without it getting used. 3) Since the role was janitored Okosan figured if scum ever tried to come up with a fake claim that matched Kvothe's role Kvothe could just cc)
About LG, I mean if someone else had the role and didn't get lynched D1. The ability could have potentially produced a lot of informationCooo! (Well here's why Okosan did it. 1) Obviously Okosan wasn't going to use it on LG who barely posted. 2) Okosan didn't want to wait too long in case he just died without it getting used. 3) Since the role was janitored Okosan figured if scum ever tried to come up with a fake claim that matched Kvothe's role Kvothe could just cc)
COOOO! (Plus it helps that Kvothe was actually talking beforehand too
Coooo! (Odd you're supposed to scum read Okosan that way we can bait mafia into cc'ing)
Sorry about that, I got a different plan in mind anyway
