Game The Puddletown Mafia (Town victory)

[Psyche]

I was just in a shit mood cuz I'm busy as fuck with all sorts of things and my GPU decided to die and ugh
plus I usually get annoyed when a lot of people name me scummy for no reason, I want to catch scum not have to defend myself constantly especially when from my PoV I've done nothing wrong but I got unlucky and looked bad because I started an Ava wagon and didn't get back for the end of the phase. Even more frustrating because I also motorheaded the Darth wagon but people refuse to acknowledge that
oh well

plus I'm having a stomach ache

oh well




I already did this like a million times now zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

I am town

Tl;dr

Are you town?

 

[Platinum]

Tl;dr

Are you town?

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

She wants a single post containing nothing more than "I am town" because in the last game she hosted the LD would fail if the post contained anything more than that.

 

[Nevan]

@Dr. White Only came to defend yourself and then leave?

Come on bro, I know you can do better than that.

 

[Dr. White]

@Dr. White

I think you hinted Miller?

Do you have an active ability?

I do not have an active ability

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

 

[Didi]

Tl;dr

Are you town?

I am town

 

[Didi]

In b4 Reznor

 

[Dr. White]

Letting WPK coast

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

So, basically Dr. White is indirectly claiming Miller.

I mean, could very easily be a scum ploy hoping there’s no Miller, and it’s not a risky lynch since at worst...we lose the Miller...

But I definitely feel a Melodie lynch is the better choice.

 

[Reznor]

I am town

In b4 Reznor

 

[Nevan]

If we lynch scum, then it should be fairly easy to prove he's lying, but if we don't things get murkier.

I don't really buy his story, but I could see an alternative lynch.

 

[Nevan]

@Dr. White Scumhunt, find a better target and you might survive this phase.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

My biggest concern with Dr. White is he’s completely avoiding discussing Melodie, who is currently my #1 suspect.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Also this post;

Finna fall out in a minute, but I believe this vote is very telling. Should be one mafia off the vote and the rest on the vote bussing Darth. I like Didi for mafia so far. Ruff was also outed as lying, so I'll hear him out but that's pretty damning evidence. Likewise I like Nevan as town for now, and I was scum reading WAD last phase for a bit so I'd very much like to see what his contributions will be this phase.

also for note Ava's behavior (while always very facetious and trolly) seems like he may have been freaking out over how to deal with his teammate getting voted on D1. To bus or not to bus, and the no lynch may have been a sign of him thinking it was possible Darth would pull through, before ultimately voting him again.

The bolded could very well apply to him(bussing Darth) and Melodie (voted Platinum).

Didn’t vote Ruffruff immediately despite acknowledging that he was pretty much for sure scum. Wrong about Ava...

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Melodie has also straight up ignored Dr. White as well, even when it was the trio of Plat, Didi, and him who discussed possible conversion/bastard mechanics with the innocent child...she only named and suspected the previous two.

Dun dun dun...

 

[Reznor]

So granted that Dr. White couldn't claim Miller off the bat, my understanding is that the second best option/other school of thought is that you play so unscummily that noone ever has a reason to investigate you.

I don't think that Dr. White has been making much of an effort to do the second

 

[Dr. White]

Guess we'll just have to see what I flip Don't be mad when mafia gets a potential 3 of tonight with that extra kill though. Also what were you guys talking about with WAD being implicitly confirmeD?

 

[Reznor]

Didn’t vote Ruffruff immediately despite acknowledging that he was pretty much for sure scum. Wrong about Ava...

This basically.

Like, I felt like I had the freedom to move about before coming back to Ruffruff, pressing a few more people. I'm confirmed af.

Other people not voting Ruffruff has some benefit, but they still risk some scumread from it. I would probably do it as the doctor, since light scum read makes me more likely to not get killed at night and I get the benefit of pressuring more people.

By contrast, Dr. White doesn't have such freedom, he has literally the least since him getting scumread might waste us both an investigate and a lynch.

 

[Reznor]

Guess we'll just have to see what I flip Don't be mad when mafia gets a potential 3 of tonight with that extra kill though. Also what were you guys talking about with WAD being implicitly confirmeD?

Ava agreed with a post implying that he defended WAD.
Immediately upon learning that, Nitty decided that mafia needed compensation for that.

Basically, the extra lynch is a price we pay for getting to know that WAD was protected.

 

[Reznor]

That post is a lot worse. Dr. White is giving up and just fearmongering up and just casting some general doubt.

 

[Reznor]

Except I immediately worked around not claiming.

Can you demonstrate this with quotes please?

 

[Dr. White]

Can you demonstrate this with quotes please?

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

I don’t wanna lynch you even Dr. Dubya~

 

[Didi]

[Vote Lynch Dr White]

Starting to like this better than the DDL lynch

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Well at least not today.
Granted you’re still a top 3 candidate for sure.

 

[Reznor]

What is this.

You gonna OMGUS me or are you implying that you did already?

 

[Reznor]

Complaining about being suspected is the new meta.

 

[Reznor]

Complaining about being suspected is the new meta.

 

[Dr. White]

What is this.

You gonna OMGUS me or are you implying that you did already?

What is this.

You gonna OMGUS me or are you implying that you did already?

We were literally just talking about my opening post, and I claimed I immediately worked around it while explaining why it would be stupid from a mafia viewpoint

 

[Reznor]

Investigate me night 1.

Also was rez in the sign ups?

This is the opposite of a miller hint tho

 

[Dr. White]

This is the opposite of a miller hint tho

Yes because mafia is going to tell the investigator to invest them N1, with no pressure on them because that gambit is worth it out of the gate.

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

[Vote Lynch Dr.White]

Was my first choice of lynch in this game and he hasn't done anything since to make me doubt my suspicion. Ruff's flip puts him in an even worse light for how he was buddying him.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

This is the opposite of a miller hint tho

Have an agree.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

That said I really wish we were lynching Melodie instead.

Maybe she will get herself modkilled.

 

[Reznor]

I don't know what the intended play is for that so I can't really answer "Why as mafia would I...." but it also doesn't seem a good idea if you actually are miller.

WIFOM arguments asking me to explain what you'd be thinking as mafia doing this are the only arguments you're making.
Accept the goddamn burden of proof here.

Why would you do that?

 

[Dr. White]

Posts like this never sit well with me. "Oh you guys are dumb, i'm becoming apathetic" is a terrible way of trying to get votes off you if you are actually town.

Except that's not what I am saying. I'm saying the reasons used to suspect me and vote are bs in comparison to multiple other posters. Where is Nevan dogging DD, and WPK to scumhunt/post? Why are other relative inactives (Which I've only been inactive this one phase) being pressured? Why isn't Didi's opportunistic vote/blow up being analyzed?

 

[Reznor]

Like, if you are mafia and you resist a call to ask if you're town, that gets people on your trail.
Saying "I'm town" immediately discourages them from LDing you.

It could have easily been that you thought the cop wouldn't bother with you inviting it.

 

[Reznor]

Except that's not what I am saying. I'm saying the reasons used to suspect me and vote are bs in comparison to multiple other posters. Where is Nevan dogging DD, and WPK to scumhunt/post? Why are other relative inactives (Which I've only been inactive this one phase) being pressured? Why isn't Didi's opportunistic vote/blow up being analyzed?

We've talked about those people quite a bit.

 

[Reznor]

@Melodie is just lurking atm.

 

[Nevan]

[Vote Lynch Dr.White]

Was my first choice of lynch in this game and he hasn't done anything since to make me doubt my suspicion. Ruff's flip puts him in an even worse light for how he was buddying him.

WPK is here, @Dr. White you suspected him didn't you?

 

[Dr. White]

I don't know what the intended play is for that so I can't really answer "Why as mafia would I...." but it also doesn't seem a good idea if you actually are miller.

WIFOM arguments asking me to explain what you'd be thinking as mafia doing this are the only arguments you're making.
Accept the goddamn burden of proof here.

Why would you do that?

So I have a response to this but I'm not sure If I'm allowed to expressly post as if I'm the miller now lest I get modkilled (I may even be dead already depending on how Shizune views it), so I'm really confused with how to go on from here talking about this.

 

[Dr. White]

WPK is here, @Dr. White you suspected him didn't you?

Yes and I've made my points on him already which clearly isn't enough for people to charge on him. All I will say is take note of the people who are coming in for them vulture votes on me.

 

[Nevan]

@WolfPrinceKouga Who do you think is the last mafia?

What do you think of Melodie and Didi?

 

[Reznor]

So I have a response to this but I'm not sure If I'm allowed to expressly post as if I'm the miller now lest I get modkilled (I may even be dead already depending on how Shizune views it), so I'm really confused with how to go on from here talking about this.

I suppose it's a bit unfair to ask you to explain about it.

 

[Nevan]

Yes and I've made my points on him already which clearly isn't enough for people to charge on him. All I will say is take note of the people who are coming in for them vulture votes on me.

No you didn't, the only thing you said is that we let him coast.

You wanted a chance to defend yourself, interact with people, question WPK and pressure him, give your thoughts on Melodie, do actual scumhunting.

 

[Dr. White]

No you didn't, the only thing you said is that we let him coast.

You wanted a chance to defend yourself, interact with people, question WPK and pressure him, give your thoughts on Melodie, do actual scumhunting.

I gave my reasons for him day 1, and then talked about him coasting, which is all he had done so far. Fuck else do you want me to say about him?

I gave you Didi, and DDL who are my scumreads, fuck else do you want me to say about them?

Melodie could be scum given she's towing the line between appearing to be active, and bledning/inactifagging but It's hard to read her given her care for games has damatically dropped regardless of alignment.

Stop sitting here acting like I've coasted this whole game and have done nothing to scumhunt. my opinions are the same, I can't pull scumhunting evidence out of thin air.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

So I have a response to this but I'm not sure If I'm allowed to expressly post as if I'm the miller now lest I get modkilled (I may even be dead already depending on how Shizune views it), so I'm really confused with how to go on from here talking about this.

if someone was hypothetically the killer

what would have been the best way to play this game iyo

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

miller*

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

also do you inherently disagree with my post stating that I don’t think WPK would have gone after me n1

and did u acknowledge that I was likely the intended target or the faction kill n1

 

[Nevan]

I gave my reasons for him day 1, and then talked about him coasting, which is all he had done so far. Fuck else do you want me to say about him?

I gave you Didi, and DDL who are my scumreads, fuck else do you want me to say about them?

Melodie could be scum given she's towing the line between appearing to be active, and bledning/inactifagging but It's hard to read her given her care for games has damatically dropped regardless of alignment.

Stop sitting here acting like I've coasted this whole game and have done nothing to scumhunt. my opinions are the same, I can't pull scumhunting evidence out of thin air.

S C U M H U N T.

If you find DDL and Didi suspect, go question them, put pressure so that they slip.

Stating your thoughts does nothing if you don't do anything to follow it up.

 

[Nevan]

@Melodie Come the fuck here invisifag.

 

[Dr. White]

if someone was hypothetically the killer

what would have been the best way to play this game iyo

Make it known that something was up with their invest status as essentially the same thing as saying I'm miller without going into detail.

 

[Dr. White]

also do you inherently disagree with my post stating that I don’t think WPK would have gone after me n1

and did u acknowledge that I was likely the intended target or the faction kill n1

Yeah once rez pointed it out to me. No clue about wpk targetting you though as he may not be gf, and there are multiple factors going into that such as how accurate you were in reads, perceived pw status, etc.

 

[Dr. White]

[Vote lynch WPK]

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

 

[Dr. White]

Gonna die anywho so goving ya'll this heads up. Since you apparently won't go after didi or ddl

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Lynch. Melodie.

 

[Dr. White]

Lynch. Melodie.

[Change vote lynch Melodie]

 

[Reznor]

Yeah okay

[Change vote lynch Melodie]

 

[Platinum]

The ironic humor of Dr White accidentally modkilling himself to prove his innocence, when he forced the same thing to happen to WW in my game is pretty amusing, if Shizune does judge him guilty for it.

[vote lynch Melodie]

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

@Nevan

What relevance does your enjoyment of my play matter? This only serves to try to discredit someone who has yet to post and is a top town player, even if you don't like your view of my town play.

This plus your part in the Reznor/town council speculation and focus on "inactives" puts you right below Dr.White on my scum list.

@Melodie : Why the focus on Plat with no mention of Didi and Dr.Whites part in that speculation? They come off worse in my view, in part because scum prefer to follow in such situations, though more so that Plat as a host is going to have more natural tinfoil, especially given the nature of his own game and experience with Nitty's prior games.

Given Darth's flip, Didi's talk of him being a great townie in a different game once pressured to participate, in response to WAD's suggestion of a policy lynch on Darth, looks to be an attempt to save his scummate.

[Vote Lynch Didi]

I don't like that Melodie tunnel visioned on Plat for that Reznor speculation, completely ignoring Didi and Dr.White. Melodie seemed caught off guard by how thoroughly Plat turned the tables, so tried to awkwardly force the conversation back to him being the aggressor. I'm always wary of people asking for my reads in a friendly manner, as scum want to know where everyone stands to better manipulate the game. LG did this to me in Plat's game.

Came out of it leaning slightly towards Melodie being scum.

I would say Melodie is the likelier of the two between Didi and Melodie to be the other mafia if Dr.White is mafia.

 

[Dr. White]

The ironic humor of Dr White accidentally modkilling himself to prove his innocence, when he forced the same thing to happen to WW in my game is pretty amusing, if Shizune does judge him guilty for it.

[vote lynch Melodie]

Mine was more thought out

 

[Psyche]

I was gonna say I believe dr. White, but nvm since you all wanna flip to melodie. Imo it’s prolly DDL and Didi.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

I was gonna say I believe dr. White, but nvm since you all wanna flip to melodie. Imo it’s prolly DDL and Didi.

this reinforces my read even more tbh

 

[Didi]

in b4 it's Psychic and Sinraven

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Why are we not lynching White anymore?

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

cuz Melodie has gone full ruffruff

let’s go for the 3peat

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Oh I see he claimed

k

[vote lynch MeloDIE]

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

in b4 it's Psychic and Sinraven

I fell for this tinfoil once.

never again.

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I mean how cool would it be if two scum players claimed mason and won the game with it

But I guess no one has the balls

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

cuz it’s an obscenely bad play l0l

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

cuz it’s an obscenely bad play l0l

What is stopping them from winning tho

 

[Psyche]

What is stopping them from winning tho

LOL DDL, the scum is leaking out of you.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

What is stopping them from winning tho

do I rly have to explain dis

 

[Didi]

what's the votecount btw

 

[Platinum]

What is stopping them from winning tho

Me, for one

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

THREEPEAT LEGGOOOO

 

[Didi]

whatever I wanna sleep anyway

[Vote Lynch Melodie]


I think she's just being Melodie and Dr White is legit being scummy af but whatever
I'll T R U ST
I N
W A D

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

also if Melodie does flip scum roleblocker should prolly RB dr. White to be safe