Game The Puddletown Mafia (Town victory)

[Psyche]

Melodie is not even defending herself.

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

I wonder when the last time a sweep happened.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Melodie is not even defending herself.

tilt OP

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

sorta feel really bad for her lol

“im gonna tryhard this game datteboyo!”

“oh i rolled mafia ”

“ok i can make this work”

“wait Darth what are u doing ”

“ok well he’s getting lynched whatever”

“WHAT”

“RUFFRUFF???”

 

[Nevan]

Melodie already has majority right?

Then I'll keep my vote in White in case some weird shit happens.

 

[Nevan]

If White is town I'm pretty suspect of WPK.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

gonna grab a vote count now

hol' up

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

W: Psychic -> Melodie
Melodie: DDL
Plat: Psychic -> Mr. Waffles -> Melodie
DDL: WPK -> Dr. White -> Melodie
SinRaven: DDL -> Melodie
Didi: DDL -> Dr. White -> Melodie
Psychic: Didi
Nevan: Dr. White
Mr. Waffles: DDL
Reznor: Dr. White -> Melodie
WPK: DR. White
Dr. White: WPK -> Melodie

Melodie: 7
Dr. White: 2
DDL: 2
Didi: 1

Shiny hasn't voted and only posted twice. Melodie only posted twice.

 

[Nevan]

Well seeing if White is lying would be super simple if melodie is scum and not the godfather, just an invest or a roleblock would reveal that.

 

[Platinum]

This is a very odd lack of activity from flufflord shiny.

 

[Nevan]

Who do you think is the last scum if White is town and Melodie scum Wad?

 

[Nevan]

He was trying to pass off as confirmed town earlier.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Well seeing if White is lying would be super simple if melodie is scum and not the godfather, just an invest or a roleblock would reveal that.

Well the investigation wouldn't reveal that if he's honest about his allusions to being Miller.

Who do you think is the last scum if White is town and Melodie scum Wad?

Shiny or Didi. But if Melodie is Godfather then it could be WPK, and she just straight up overruled his faction kill meta.

 

[Nevan]

Well the investigation wouldn't reveal that if he's honest about his allusions to being Miller.

Depends on if he's godfather or not.

 

[Nevan]

@Shiny Come here and share your thoughts.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Ah, so accounting for the possibility that he was Godfather inviting an investigation and now decided to use that hint open-endedly to account for a Miller claim?

Makes sense.

So in that case, if Melodie flips non-GF, we have the roleblocker roleblock another target, and cop will investigate Dr. White to see if he really comes up as guilty?

 

[Nevan]

We could do it that way yes, the only problem would be if the cop dies by chance.

 

[Nevan]

Basically.

>Melodie flips godfather
Roleblock White and investigate someone else.

>Melodie flips non-godfather scum.

You could either send a simple invest or roleblock White's way or both together in case one of them dies.

>Melodie flips town

Unlikely but we should probably discuss what to do in this case.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

probably chastise her for being bad as hell

 

[Platinum]

She played exactly the same way in my game as the vigilante, so its possible.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

ya but she promised she would try this game

i can only forgive her for not trying if she's just tilted cuz her team got rekt

 

[Nevan]

Well let's see.

@Melodie you here?

 

[Melodie]

@Melodie is just lurking atm.

Fake news I just woke up

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

 

[Melodie]

Wtf am I supposed to defend myself from. The fact that I was tunneling on plat day one but suspecting everyone that participated in that innocent child shit show?

I'm an innocent townie

 

[Melodie]

Also calling my vote on Platinum throwaway is silly, I just voted for what I suspected at the time, hypothetically speaking if I was mafia I'd bus Darth, and you know it waf idc if this is "muh wifom" I don't want to be mislynched yet again

 

[Nevan]

Also calling my vote on Platinum throwaway is silly, I just voted for what I suspected at the time, hypothetically speaking if I was mafia I'd bus Darth, and you know it waf idc if this is "muh wifom" I don't want to be mislynched yet again

It's ok you can tell us your scummate.

 

[Melodie]

It's ok you can tell us your scummate.

I have no mates

:Sadpanda

 

[Melodie]

The fuck. Boosted emotes usage

 

[Melodie]

And I'm the inactifag why r u hiding

 

[Melodie]

Same

 

[Psyche]

I'm good with a Plat lynch. someone lie detect Didi's post.

[Change vote lynch Plat]

switch it guys.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Also calling my vote on Platinum throwaway is silly, I just voted for what I suspected at the time, hypothetically speaking if I was mafia I'd bus Darth, and you know it waf idc if this is "muh wifom" I don't want to be mislynched yet again

if ur getting mislynched its almost entirely ur fault tbh

 

[Psyche]

Plat, Didi, and DDL....two of these are mafia.

 

[Shiny]

im seriously wondering why so many people suspect me..is it this easy because i don't know how to protect properly? like... wad's reason is because i posted a bit more than previous games

no votes on the first phase? i didn't vote in previous games and i flipped town so gtfo with that argument

This is a very odd lack of activity from flufflord shiny.

agreed, i was going to ask nitty for a pass this phase but since we have almost 2 hours left this isn't necessary so here i am, sin is the flufflord...i think ruffruff scumhunted more

the last mafia is someone that has low moral due the teammated getting killed so early, melodie or WpK seems interesting right now

 

[Melodie]

^^^^^^^^^

IM GETTING LYNCHED OVER THAT

 

[Melodie]

if ur getting mislynched its almost entirely ur fault tbh

Sure, I didn't participate much this phase if at all, but the reasoning outside of that really isn't firm at all. If a person votes for what they deem suspicious/following their lead early on it's a throwaway, and if they're voting for the top contenders for the lynch it's sheeping? Sounds like just a forced narrative to view someone as mafia.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

still your fault

 

[Platinum]

no votes on the first phase? i didn't vote in previous games and i flipped town so gtfo with that argument

That's....

That's not the greatest of arguments.

 

[Shiny]

^^^^^^^^^

IM GETTING LYNCHED OVER THAT

Because im proner

 

[Platinum]

> Rating that post a ningen

A little agressive aren't you now Shiny?

 

[Melodie]

Because im proner

Not particularly directed at you (I mean, you weren't even in my top 3 scum options.), but that particular post; it's ludicrously scummy.

T H R O W A W A Y V O T E

[Vote Lynch Shiny]

 

[Shiny]

why it was scummy?

 

[Melodie]

why it was scummy?

Hello, I hope this helps you in giving you a reason to vote for yourself.

1) dismissing legitimate reasons/undermining them into one sole reason to discredit reasons as to why you're suspected at any point in time.
2) Extremely weak reasoning as to why you're mafia or town right afterwards that can't be taken seriously, but somehow stated as such.
3) Giving out a random reason due to inactivity and participating just because, while calling out Sin on something you pretty much have been doing.
4) Stating the numbers of mafia. I can't believe that mafia has only 3 people or even 4 considering how the set-up seems so far. It gives off the impression that you're feigning ignorance of how many mafias there are. It's just not realistic to assume there are three mafia players considering what we know.

 

[Reznor]

Fake news I just woke up

I saw you just prior to making that post.
Is your defense to call me a liar?

 

[Melodie]

I saw you just prior to making that post.
Is your defense to call me a liar?

I'm just pretty sure I was on bed/sleeping at that time.

 

[Nevan]

@Melodie What are your thoughts of Dr. White, WPK and Didi?

 

[Shiny]

im clearly in the dumb town player :

 

[Melodie]

@Melodie What are your thoughts of Dr. White, WPK and Didi?

I suspect Didi and Dr. White heavily, did so since day one. I haven't looked much into his arguments this day/people supposedly saying he claimed, but I'm pretty sure claiming is an instant mod-kill, so if that's the case, then he'd be lying. But again, I haven't looked into it. Since their interactions with the innocent child, till the fact that they're being extremely sensitive/reacting extremely to any suspicion or anyone calling them out on a particular thing.

No thoughts on WPK much, honestly.

 

[Melodie]

im clearly in the dumb town player :

Nice card

 

[Melodie]

Vote count

Nevan - Darth > Ruffruff
Reznor - DDL > Ruffruff
WPK - Didi > Ruffruff
W - Ruffruff
Didi - Ruffruff
A - Ruffruff > Didi > Shiny
DDL - Ruffruff
Platinum - Ruffruff
SinRaven - W > Ruffruff
Dr. White - Ruffruff
Shiny - Ruffruff
Melodie - Ruffruff
Psychic - Didi
Mr. Waffles - Ruffruff

Ruffruff - 12
Shiny - 1
Didi - 1

Self votes

Ruffruff

Ruffruff (James Rowe) has been lynched.



Night 2 begins. No more posts, no exceptions.​

also if Melodie does flip scum roleblocker should prolly RB dr. White to be safe

HELLO?

 

[Nevan]

Melodie if you're town you're a terrible player.

 

[Melodie]

Good to know

 

[Nevan]

Any opinions plat?

Reznor?

 

[Melodie]

Not sure if that's a compliment, considering it's coming from you

 

[Platinum]

Any opinions plat?

Reznor?

Shiny is making me more sus of them. Outside of that, not much has changed I feel.

 

[Melodie]

Any half decent player (which is a reach, to most), would be suspicious of shiny right now

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

sure why not

[Change Vote Lynch Shiny]

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

cuz u know

Darth...ruffruff...shiny

Team of dreams man

 

[Reznor]

Any opinions plat?

Reznor?

I don't have a strong opinion on him atm. I'll iso him later if I'm alive tomorrow.

 

[Melodie]

There is hope

 

[Reznor]

cuz u know

Darth...ruffruff...shiny

Team of dreams man

OR respect Nitty's commitment to RNG

 

[Melodie]

Or not

 

[Reznor]

There's like, no chance that you were online even a hour before I said you were on Melodie? I can't let you live if you're only explanation is that I'm lying.

 

[Melodie]

Maybe I was browsing on phone? I do that a lot memory of a goldfish

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

OR respect Nitty's commitment to RNG

i need to like

make a conspiracy wall of all the different interactions this game and shit

 

[Melodie]

It's literally around the time I decided to sleep. Not mid sleep

 

[Melodie]

Driving, I don't want to die in two places laters

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

/meirl/

 

[Nevan]

A bunch of people were on me last phase, what happened? It seems im proven town now

im seriously wondering why so many people suspect me..is it this easy because i don't know how to protect properly? like... wad's reason is because i posted a bit more than previous games

no votes on the first phase? i didn't vote in previous games and i flipped town so gtfo with that argument



agreed, i was going to ask nitty for a pass this phase but since we have almost 2 hours left this isn't necessary so here i am, sin is the flufflord...i think ruffruff scumhunted more

the last mafia is someone that has low moral due the teammated getting killed so early, melodie or WpK seems interesting right now

Because im proner

why it was scummy?

im clearly in the dumb town player :

These are all of Shiny's posts during this phase.

 

[Nevan]

wpk: town, he would be much more active if his scum team were getting destroyed like this, his current playstyle seems quite townish

Sin: hard to read, he acts quite useless and may appear to you as town but like I said before, he loves to fluffy post when godfather, I would use the lie detector on him

Nevan is a 50/50 to me, his questions on ruffruff appeared strange at first and an attempt to appear as town and now if ruffruff flips scum he may think "more people will think i'm town because a pressured a scum" .. seems a good strategy to fly out of the radar to me and avoid the lie detector

DDL is a very good player, his mafia plays are quite good and i feel he is pulling the same thing since the start of the game, or he could just be an useful town

These were his reads during day 2.

 

[Reznor]

Maybe I was browsing on phone? I do that a lot memory of a goldfish

It's literally around the time I decided to sleep. Not mid sleep

Then why'd you start out with "Fake News" as your reply?

I'll see if there's another good lynch maybe.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

1. Dr. White
2. WPK
3. Shiny
4. Mr. Waffles
5. SinRaven
6. Nevan
7. Reznor (Alastair Remington)
8. Platinum
9. Didi
10. Psychic
11. Melodie
12. WAD
13. DDL

probably 2 anti-town left...hopefully...max

so...11v2 or 11v1v1

time to organize this:

WAD
Reznor

Psychic
SinRaven
Nevan

Didi
Platinum
DDL

WPK
Mr. Waffles

Dr. White

Shiny
Melodie

 

[Reznor]

I don't like that Dr. White stopped talking once we moved off of him.

 

[Nevan]

@Shiny I asked your twice about your reads on White and Didi and you didn't give them.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

basically the people who are bolded blue, are for the time being, untouchable

heres the thing actually

we want to lynch someone most likely to be godfather for the cop's sake

mafia got to choose their own godfather

darth...ruffruff...who the hell would be their other teammate if SHINY was the chosen godfather? like cmon dude

so

[Change Vote Lynch Melodie]

honestly the only other alternative is dr. white and maybe its not the worst lynch cuz >miller but i actually see it far more plausible that he's who he says he is and hinted it in a dumb way and vote tracking does help him, objectively re: darth

meanwhile......again...u only have urself to blame if u get mislynched for this and ur most likely to be godfather and most likely to try and goon me n1 i think

 

[Nevan]

I'm not sure Dr. White actitude about RuffRuff in day 2 is consistent with his miller claim.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

if u guys wanna lynch shiny thats fine ill help but i think melodie dug her own grave

showing up in the last 2 hours of not just today but day 2 as well?

bluh

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

I'm not sure Dr. White actitude about RuffRuff in day 2 is consistent with his miller claim.

oh shit

let me read that quick
if so we need to switch on him like right away

 

[Reznor]

Was Dr. White really on the right side vote-wise? I seem to recall some resistance.