Game The Puddletown Mafia (Town victory)

[Nevan]

> 48 hour phase
> we should discuss other potential suspects
> he says with like 3,5 hours left in the phase

What do you think the first 44,5 hours were for ?

I'm talking about suspects for the next phases

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Since I can't tag you.

You town, famalam?

I’m Town.

 

[Jeroen]

I'm talking about suspects for the next phases

I thought we already decided on that being you ?

 

[Nevan]

I thought we already decided on that being you ?

Ok then, then let's discuss it.

Why do you suspect me?

 

[Jeroen]

Ok then, then let's discuss it.

Why do you suspect me?

Who said anything about suspecting ?

 

[Nevan]

I'm talking about suspects for the next phases

I thought we already decided on that being you ?

Who said anything about suspecting ?

 

[Nevan]

I’m Town.

What is your opinion in ava's behaviour?

 

[Jeroen]

I'd do the whole joke over head thing, but that would probably go over your head too.

 

[A Optimistic]

i think waffles is kidding nevan

 

[A Optimistic]

oh nvm i got ninja'ed

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

What is your opinion in ava's behaviour?

He reads very strong town to me right now.

 

[Nevan]

He reads very strong town to me right now.

What do you think is the difference between his town and scum behaviour?

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

What do you think is the difference between his town and scum behaviour?

The thing with Ava is I don’t think he has a whole lot of experience in mafia games. I can only remember the one game where he was scum but he was lot more scared, less active, and jumpy like a rabbit. He also had very fragmented thought processes and posted stuff that didn’t sound organic.

Everything he’s been posting is giving me the impression that this is pure stream-of-consciousness and is not being edited or filtered in any way.

 

[A Optimistic]

hmm let me google what fragmented thought process means

Fragmented Thinking is the way many people, who are perceived to have Learning Disabilities, think.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

It’s not so much a dig on your intelligence, but the simple reality that scum have to sort of ‘act the fool’ and portray themselves as dumber than they are.

 

[A Optimistic]

It’s not so much a dig on your intelligence, but the simple reality that scum have to sort of ‘act the fool’ and portray themselves as dumber than they are.

I have to be honest, I think the 1 letter username is cool af.

You wouldn't be offended if I switched my name to A right?

 

[Nevan]

@Mr. Waffles Have any reads Mr. Pancakes?

 

[Jeroen]

@Mr. Waffles Have any reads Mr. Pancakes?

> Pancakes

Why so mean.

 

[Nevan]

> Pancakes

Why so mean.

You dissin pancakes bro?

 

[Nevan]

Anyway I was joking.

But I was serious about wanting your reads.

 

[Jeroen]

You dissin pancakes bro?

Anyway I was joking.

But I was serious about wanting your reads.

I know.

 

[Nevan]

I know.

Are you not going to give them.

 

[Jeroen]

Are you not going to give them.

You already asked twice and gotten nothing, so I'd say that's a safe bet to make.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

I have to be honest, I think the 1 letter username is cool af.

You wouldn't be offended if I switched my name to A right?

By all means.

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

@Melodie : Why the focus on Plat with no mention of Didi and Dr.Whites part in that speculation? They come off worse in my view, in part because scum prefer to follow in such situations, though more so that Plat as a host is going to have more natural tinfoil, especially given the nature of his own game and experience with Nitty's prior games.

 

[Dr. White]

All of this yet still not voting me. You catch the same disease as Franky and Hyperion?

Because I'm not you. I can call your move scummy, and yet still not drop a lone vote on you. I can keep you under tab, as I did not like Darth's defense at all, so he gets my vote for now. I was under the impression you would actually respond in depth, but guess not.

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

Because I'm not you. I can call your move scummy, and yet still not drop a lone vote on you. I can keep you under tab, as I did not like Darth's defense at all, so he gets my vote for now.

At least you're being consistent

I was under the impression you would actually respond in depth, but guess not.

That would be you assuming that an in-depth response would serve any purpose to me, which it only would if I felt I needed to dig deeper. Too many players get into pointless back and forths, as if scumtells are an objective measure that can be properly argued.

I'm sorry to dash your hopes of a riveting back and forth between us.

 

[A Optimistic]

30 more mins

thank god

please flip red darth

 

[Reznor]

Fuck, my subscription didn't alert me

 

[Reznor]

Well, nothing major I missed. Some good interactions to go off tomorrow if I'm alive by then.

I didn't pressure Reznor for it

 

[Nevan]

@Platinum Do you think you can recognize scum WPK/Didi?

 

[Shizune]

Votes lock in 10 minutes​

 

[Shizune]

Votes are locked.​

 

[A Optimistic]

 

[A Optimistic]

Flip red Darth!

 

[A Optimistic]

why is everyones name different except whitebeard and reznor

could the knight of smangs not ben affected? (see bottom of the thread)

 

[Shizune]

Vote count

SinRaven - W
Didi - W > Darth > A
DDL - W > A > Darth
W - Darth
Platinum - Psychic
Psychic - Didi
A - W > Darth > No Lynch > Darth
Mr. Waffles - Darth
WPK - Dr. White
Reznor - Ava > Darth
Darth - A
Dr. White - Darth
Melodie - Platinum
Nevan - Darth

Darth - 7
A - 2
W - 1
Psychic - 1
Platinum - 1
Dr. White - 1
Didi - 1

Darth (Bartholomew Clearwater) has been lynched!

Bartholomew Clearwater

[Active - Aristocrat] - Bartholomew is a local celebrity with a voting power of 2. Each day he can spread incriminating rumors about another player to vote silence them.

After years of lobbying the sheriff's office, a local investigator has convinced local law enforcement to try technology rather than faith for once. Charles Newbury used [The Polygraph Test] to lie detect the following message:

I didn't, I just didn't answer with a direct yes or no.

Yes.

RuffRuff appears to be lying.

Night 1 begins. No more posts, no exceptions.​

 

[A. Waltz]

what up bitches!!!! did i win yet

 

[Shizune]

The Puddletown Mafia attempted to kill [???], but it failed.

Day 2 begins. You may now post.
​

@Dr. White @WolfPrinceKouga @Shiny @Mr. Waffles @A @SinRaven @Nevan @Reznor @RuffRuff @Platinum @Didi @Psychic @Melodie @W @Dragon D. Luffy

 

[Dr. White]

Finna fall out in a minute, but I believe this vote is very telling. Should be one mafia off the vote and the rest on the vote bussing Darth. I like Didi for mafia so far. Ruff was also outed as lying, so I'll hear him out but that's pretty damning evidence. Likewise I like Nevan as town for now, and I was scum reading WAD last phase for a bit so I'd very much like to see what his contributions will be this phase.

also for note Ava's behavior (while always very facetious and trolly) seems like he may have been freaking out over how to deal with his teammate getting voted on D1. To bus or not to bus, and the no lynch may have been a sign of him thinking it was possible Darth would pull through, before ultimately voting him again.

 

[Reznor]

The Puddletown Mafia attempted to kill [???], but it failed.

Good work, doc.
Try harder, mafia.

 

[Reznor]

WPK and DDL seemed to be resisting it a good bit.
Ava suggested going after DDL if Darth flipped scum, so might as well do it, especially with the bits of suspicion already on him.

[Vote Lynch DDL]

 

[Dr. White]

WPK and DDL seemed to be resisting it a good bit.
Ava suggested going after DDL if Darth flipped scum, so might as well do it, especially with the bits of suspicion already on him.

[Vote Lynch DDL]

I knew there was someone missing from my list. I think DdL and Didi are good bets, but sid you forget about ruff?

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

Given Darth's flip, Didi's talk of him being a great townie in a different game once pressured to participate, in response to WAD's suggestion of a policy lynch on Darth, looks to be an attempt to save his scummate.

[Vote Lynch Didi]

 

[Reznor]

I knew there was someone missing from my list. I think DdL and Didi are good bets, but sid you forget about ruff?

Didn't forget about ruff. We'll see what he has to say.
I want to talk about a few other suspects before settling for the day though.

Ruff, DDL, Didi, WPK are my current priorities for pressuring.

You were too, but I liked your response about Didi and I think you were on the right side of this Darth business.

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

WPK and DDL seemed to be resisting it a good bit.
Ava suggested going after DDL if Darth flipped scum, so might as well do it, especially with the bits of suspicion already on him.

[Vote Lynch DDL]

I don't see how I resisted it. I questioned WAD's and Didi's early talks of policy lynching potential inactives. You would have to really stretch that to claim it as a resistance to Darth's lynch. My vote wasn't there as I had my own suspect I was pursuing.

 

[RuffRuff]

The way Nevan questioned me it was pretty obvious that he was gonna lie detect me, if I weren't town I'd have dodged the rest of the day and let it all slide.

Since role hinting/claiming is forbidden this game I suggest people refer to my D1 post regarding claiming innocent/guilty and draw a conclusion from it.

Only 3 people who haven't voted.

@Shiny
I see your lurking ass.

@RuffRuff
Will you be voting, or just make more excuses for why you're not voting ?

@Nevan
How about you, slick ?

You see it as excuses and I see it as valid points. It's my first game and I don't know who usually acts how etc. I don't want to put a vote without having a reason behind it Day1.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

[Vote Lynch Ruffruff]

it’s pretty cut n dry if you ask me

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

and pretty sure 1 of the above posters are scum because hello

the dude literally caught lying about being Town

it’s a slam dunk

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

and now he’s trying to soft claim miller despite that not being relevant to the question at all

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

and pretty sure 1 of the above posters are scum because hello

the dude literally caught lying about being Town

it’s a slam dunk

So we should just all vote Ruff Ruff and see if Nitty will end phase early in your opinion? There is more that can be accomplished.

 

[SinRaven]

Is WAD dead yet?

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Finna fall out in a minute, but I believe this vote is very telling. Should be one mafia off the vote and the rest on the vote bussing Darth. I like Didi for mafia so far. Ruff was also outed as lying, so I'll hear him out but that's pretty damning evidence. Likewise I like Nevan as town for now, and I was scum reading WAD last phase for a bit so I'd very much like to see what his contributions will be this phase.

also for note Ava's behavior (while always very facetious and trolly) seems like he may have been freaking out over how to deal with his teammate getting voted on D1. To bus or not to bus, and the no lynch may have been a sign of him thinking it was possible Darth would pull through, before ultimately voting him again.

Ava is like pretty much 100% town after that

don’t know how anyone can come to any other conclusion

WPK and DDL seemed to be resisting it a good bit.
Ava suggested going after DDL if Darth flipped scum, so might as well do it, especially with the bits of suspicion already on him.

[Vote Lynch DDL]

Didi more than WPK
yeah Didi voted for Darth early but as soon as Ava became a viable counterwagon he voted for him and never switched back to darth

Given Darth's flip, Didi's talk of him being a great townie in a different game once pressured to participate, in response to WAD's suggestion of a policy lynch on Darth, looks to be an attempt to save his scummate.

[Vote Lynch Didi]

what’s ur read on Melodie and plat’s interaction last phase

Didn't forget about ruff. We'll see what he has to say.
I want to talk about a few other suspects before settling for the day though.

Ruff, DDL, Didi, WPK are my current priorities for pressuring.

You were too, but I liked your response about Didi and I think you were on the right side of this Darth business.

dr. White had voted for Darth when it was already apparent that Darth has shot himself in the foot and knee with his low effort defense tbh

also

by posts...DDL is the most likely association by far

but the vote tracking...he actually put Darth back in the lead (or tied it cuz of darth’s double voting power) so hmmm

anyways

my current reads:

Reznor
Platinum
Ava
SinRaven
Nevan
Melodie
Psychic
Mr. Waffles
WPK
Dr. White
Dragon D. Luffy
Didi
Shiny
Ruffruff

 

[SinRaven]

Why are you reading me as town? Tryna buddie me you scum scum?

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

So we should just all vote Ruff Ruff and see if Nitty will end phase early in your opinion? There is more that can be accomplished.

Uh no we can talk but I’m very interested how everyone decided to collectively drag their feet there seems to me like scum’s gotta be in there

They have to be desperate right now. Already down a member. Failed kill last night.

There’s no hammering this game thus no termination of the day phase early, so we could literally all vote Ruffruff and talk about other suspects if we want.

And similarly I don’t see why we have to wait for what Ruffruff has to say BEFORE voting for him. Literally porque no los dos.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Why are you reading me as town? Tryna buddie me you scum scum?

already told u i read u as doing the exact same tunnel on me D1 dumb stuff u do as town like u did in nfcnorth’s game

 

[SinRaven]

already told u i read u as doing the exact same tunnel on me D1 dumb stuff u do as town like u did in nfcnorth’s game

Yeah you try to buddy me yum scum

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Yeah you try to buddy me yum scum

last person i want to be my buddy this game is u tbh

ur a nuisance

but i can divorce my views of you from my ability to read u

which is why im a much better player than you

 

[SinRaven]

last person i want to be my buddy this game is u tbh

ur a nuisance

but i can divorce my views of you from my ability to read u

which is why im a much better player than you

LOL

 

[SinRaven]

WAD's hilarious this game. Straight up comedy gold.

#staymad

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

what’s funny tho
surely it’s not me stating my superiority to you as a player because that’s just objective fact
is it because u r actually scum and ive misread you (which ruins my credibility in my claim to reliably read u? )

 

[SinRaven]

I wonder why he's so pressed at me. Did I hurt his poor pride somewhere again? Poor WAD..

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Reasons to lynch WAD exhibit a:



I rest my case.

[Vote lynch W]

Waffles why aren't you voting WAD?

I was the activity generator in his game, so we don't need him

I don't always vote Melodie day one anymore and W is a much more fun lynch regardless of his alignment.

Agreed 110%

Is WAD getting lynched yet?

@Psychic baby, lynch WAD for me

100% chance lynching you is fun

I have info that he's scum

I take it that all this resistance to the WAD lynch despite the amount of fun involved must mean that WAD is scum, got it

Wow 3 votes so much totally not able to turn that around

yes I'm definitely sure WAD is scum now

When W is dead

I'm saying he's getting mad to get people off him. Classic trick.

Ah boohoohoo

You guys are always up for meme lynches but now y'all scared big meanie wad will hurt you if you go for this one

Poor pups

WAD didn't even play in his game and that was a pretty interesting game

So invalid argument

Plus a day one wad lynch is quite possible the exact opposite of boring

Ah boohoo WAD is so afraid he's getting lynched he has to go for the low blows

Didn't you recently mention another game where you almost got lynched day one and tried to turn it by flaming

Well la die da

Oh no because I care about performance so much like you and I think it's the only thing that matters it means I'm so hurt by this

Oh no

Someone get me an adult

..

Lol

Oh yeah he's saying bullsshit

At least I'm not a destructive person, ruining most relationships I have with people over petty things, in both my off- and online life.

Im so lonely tho

And I like having fun so hey

Die

Nah I like it this way

I never liked those other idiots anyway

If WAD turns to be scum this game don't yall go crying about being outplayed

Remember: listen to Sin for the Win

IF YOU ALL LYNCH WAD I'LL SEND YOU ALL MY NUDES

No. Fuck you all for not lynching WAD!

Especially because he's scum!

DIE AHAHAHHAHAHA

As an FYI I'm redirecting the lynch to WAD

BAHAHAHAHAHAH

I'm also killing him tonight

UAHHAHAHAHAHA

Please make the WAD lynch happen

Don't let my memes be dreams

@Melodie @Psychic

@Darth @Platinum

@Dr. White @Shiny

... My friends... Please.... Don't let me suffer.... End him, you can do it!

Stay mad

NO WERE GONNA LYNCH WAD AND NOBODY ELSE

H A T E R S

Is WAD dead yet?

Why are you reading me as town? Tryna buddie me you scum scum?

Yeah you try to buddy me yum scum

LOL

WAD's hilarious this game. Straight up comedy gold.

#staymad

I wonder why he's so pressed at me. Did I hurt his poor pride somewhere again? Poor WAD..

>im the one pressed
>literally over 40 posts about me or concerning me alone

11th letter of the English alphabet.

 

[SinRaven]

>im the one pressed
>literally over 40 posts about me or concerning me alone

11th letter of the English alphabet.

But I'm not pressed. I just want you dead.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

But I'm not pressed. I just want you dead.

Have an optimistic.

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I did some work during the night phase. I believe this may be useful to find sense in last day's bandwagons:

Sin
Didi
DDL
Wad
Didi
Platinum
Psychic
Ava
Mr. Waffles
Ava
Ava
Didi
DDL
WPK
Ava
Reznor
Reznor
Darth
DDL
Dr. White
Melodie
Nevan

Red = Darth
Blue = Wad
Green = Ava
No color = Other
Gray = No Lynch

Final votes are in Bold. Votes that were changed later are not.

 

[Didi]

[Vote lynch RuffRuff]

Pretty cut and dry

As for the people talking about me; I was not only an early vote for Darth, I was an early motor for that wagon, I was announcing multiple times how everyone needed to vote him to force him to show up and how he was the best lynch by far in my opinion. I'd like to think I was a big factor in that wagon taking off the way it did

but then Ava showed up with a scummy as shit post (don't fucking deny that that wasn't a scum 101 post) so yeah I switched and I now look bad as fuck zzzzzzzzzz



I saw Ava spout some bullshit about how I should know his scum playstyle because of literally 1 game we have ever played together like a million months ago but obviously I don't remember details about some irrelevant gnat so fuck outta here with that shit mate

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Good work, doc.
Try harder, mafia.

I swear if you weren't innocent child...

https://wiki.[Blocked Domain]/index.php?title=JEEP's_Tells_for_Finding_Mafia

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

and now he’s trying to soft claim miller despite that not being relevant to the question at all

Pretty sure millers/godfathers fool LDs more often than not.

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

But I'm not seeing why Ruff's post was a miller hint?

Explain me I'm stupid when it comes to hints.

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

DDL
Dr. White
Melodie
Nevan

Ok so.

I bet there is scum among those folks.

(excluding me obviously, but I need to make a point here).

This is when Darth was leading the vote so scum would have a motivation to bus him.

Apparently Nevan is the LD which I'm also not getting but whatever. So I want to suspect White, who took his sweet time to vote, and Melodie, who engaged in contributive mode to create what seemed like a Platinum counter-wagon near the end of the phase.

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Also I don't like how WPK basically avoided talking about Darth during the last day. Add him to my scum list.

This is the only mention of Darth during the day phase, and it is actually only used to accuse Didi.

Your response to WAD saying to lynch inactives was "true that". You bringing up Darth performing well in some other game after being pressured doesn't really mean much to me, just your preemptive defense/an expectation that Darth needs to live up to.

Darth was leading the lynch with 3 votes at that point. WPK had a chance to say something and didn't.

I'm more suspicious of scum who avoids talking about their teammates than the ones who defend or suspect them.

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Basically, there is scum among WPK, Melodie, and White.

 

[A Optimistic]

Alright I finally got unbanned.

 

[A Optimistic]

[Vote lynch Ruffruff]

 

[A Optimistic]

The way Nevan questioned me it was pretty obvious that he was gonna lie detect me, if I weren't town I'd have dodged the rest of the day and let it all slide.

Since role hinting/claiming is forbidden this game I suggest people refer to my D1 post regarding claiming innocent/guilty and draw a conclusion from it.

You see it as excuses and I see it as valid points. It's my first game and I don't know who usually acts how etc. I don't want to put a vote without having a reason behind it Day1.

Miller will get a guilty result you're right...but the question you got caught lying about was which faction you're on, and miller is still a town role.

 

[A Optimistic]

WPK and DDL seemed to be resisting it a good bit.
Ava suggested going after DDL if Darth flipped scum, so might as well do it, especially with the bits of suspicion already on him.

[Vote Lynch DDL]

I literally did NOT say this.

 

[A Optimistic]

Underworld broker

 

[A Optimistic]

....white wolf

 

[A Optimistic]

Does anyone have a list of the people who didn't vote? I know Shiny was one of them.

You guys all had an issue with me voting no lynch for 5 seconds, but no comments about Shiny not voting at all?