Game The Puddletown Mafia (Town victory)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
Platinum said:
Her aggressiveness in coming after me seemed genuine after reflecting on it a bit. Melodie can get by for a while without actually scum-hunting, so putting herself in a vulnerable position, that would look really bad on her if I was killed and people saw my town role, makes me think she is town.

Less confident mafia players will usually just circle the drain of the lynch wagon, or throw a vote on a buddy to get town cred. So her going out on a limb like that is a foolish move for scum to make.
Click to expand...

"For a while" may not be satisfactory, though. If she does nothing she will get policy lynched eventually.
 
like

-caught by LD
-he gave no indication he was a miller even when provided an opportunity to indirectly to allude to it
-ive never seen a miller give guilty results to investigations AND show as liars to LDs and so i dont think nitty would include that caveat as well
-he was generally evasive on d1 and fluffposted half his posts
-he didn't vote anyone

literally all the signs are pointing to him being scum
 
W said:
what’s ur read on Melodie and plat’s interaction last phase
Click to expand...
I don't like that Melodie tunnel visioned on Plat for that Reznor speculation, completely ignoring Didi and Dr.White. Melodie seemed caught off guard by how thoroughly Plat turned the tables, so tried to awkwardly force the conversation back to him being the aggressor. I'm always wary of people asking for my reads in a friendly manner, as scum want to know where everyone stands to better manipulate the game. LG did this to me in Plat's game.

Came out of it leaning slightly towards Melodie being scum.

Dragon D. Luffy said:
I swear if you weren't innocent child...

https://wiki.[Blocked Domain]/index.php?title=JEEP's_Tells_for_Finding_Mafia
Click to expand...
Triggered that you can't push a mislynch there?


W said:
Yet I can’t recall where you, as town, ardently defender another doomed townie who got lynched?

Anyways, objectively I can see your opposition to the Darth lynch. You don’t like lynching known lurkers/inactives on Day 1. Whatever, I heavily disagree with that philosophy but so be it. I even say I give you some credit because you helped start to push Darth back in the lead over Ava after he gave that one miserable post of his.

But why are you defending and tinfoiling for someone else who has been incriminated?

Is it like, your sworn duty to be the 10th man?
Click to expand...
The only 10th Man of this community was Draekke. May he work in peace, without the itch to constantly check the thread.

W said:
Also if you ask me who the mafia would target n1 is pointless here anyways

The answers were clearly between reznor (confirmed Town) and Nevan (most likely LD)

They chose one of the 2, surely. Doctor picked the right one.

Easy as that.
Click to expand...
Or they could have targeted someone else who had doctor protection or BP.

Platinum said:
There is another possibility actually, but I need to see how ruffruff flips to confirm my suspicions or not.
Click to expand...
Interested in what this might be and why you can't just say it now.

Dragon D. Luffy said:
"When in doubt, kill WPK"
Click to expand...
I rarely get doctor protection so it's always a good option. Mafia's that have kept me alive to try to mislynch me have gotten burned on multiple occasions.
 
Platinum said:
Lie detector usage is usually limited.

Also, this is a lot like the useless posts that are trying to seem constructive that Melodie was trying to accuse me of doing :catball
Click to expand...
I see, I was wondering if Lie Detector had any weakness or not.

Also I have no problem if Melodie accuses me like she did with you, since I have a 0% chance of being lynched today. :blobkinfe
 
Nevan said:
Of course you weren't blatant about it.

You said this when you could have said yes or asked about his alignment like I did.
Click to expand...

What...

1. Why would I say yes when it's false. People don't do the whole guilty/innocent claims here on Day 1.

2. I had no reason to ask about his alignment because I'm not a lie detector, didn't think there was a lie detector, and generally don't give people passes if they say "I'm town" when asked about their alignment.

I didn't tell him not to claim town whatsoever, like you're implying. I told him that I found the whole "Claim Guilty or Innocent" exercise to be futile and its only purpose in any game is for a self-aware miller to reveal themselves in a roundabout way.
 
A said:
So if I'm understanding this correctly, if someone asked atlantic storm "are you town"

He would reply "im mafia"

???

:dead
Click to expand...
Truth metas are dumb. They are crutches.
It sabatoges their scum play since they can handle suspicion. These people can't handle being pressured and need to be "confirmed town" to function.

W said:
In fact, I had quite the argument with Rotaretilbo in Viole’s bleach game because I chastised him on expecting people to play a psychology game like logical automatons.

People are illogical all the time in this game and you have to account for it as town.
Click to expand...
It's like if a suspect on a crime drama says "You have no proof!", the audience knows that they are guilty now, but the cops/lawyers are still stuck.
That's not how mafia works, but people do it anyway by criticizing how certain someone is or acting like suspicion is punitive.
 
Shizune said:
This is normally when the phase would end.

@Ava has replaced @A. Waltz because she has not met the normal posting minimum.

@WolfPrinceKouga is spared until the end of the day because he confirmed with me that he will be here.

This is the only phase I will replace people rather than modkilling them for breaking the posting rules.

Vote count

SinRaven - W
Didi - W > Darth
DDL - W
W - Darth
Platinum - Psychic
Psychic - Didi

W - 2
Darth - 2
Psychic - 1
Didi - 1​
Click to expand...
Here you go Wad.

:ufdup
 
A said:
Now shall we remove our votes from ruff ruff and kill someone else? :blobknife
Click to expand...

naw unless we can like perfectly coordinate vote shifting in the last 10 minutes I don’t want him showing up towards the end of the phase and being like “oh hey guys :catwalk”

and since nitty literally has phase times that are convenient for NOBODY except himself and the Asians (bunny) and Australians (Nighty) that aren’t actually playing this game I’ll be asleep at least an hour before votes lock :dead
 
W said:
naw unless we can like perfectly coordinate vote shifting in the last 10 minutes I don’t want him showing up towards the end of the phase and being like “oh hey guys :catwalk”

and since nitty literally has phase times that are convenient for NOBODY except himself and the Asians (bunny) and Australians (Nighty) that aren’t actually playing this game I’ll be asleep at least an hour before votes lock :dead
Click to expand...
how about i change my vote only then

so that Didi has 1 vote

so ruff ruff will have the majority still, but if he gets modkilled, then didi will have the majority

:dead
 
A said:
[Change Vote Lynch Didi]

:blobknife
Click to expand...
A said:
how about i change my vote only then

so that Didi has 1 vote

so ruff ruff will have the majority still, but if he gets modkilled, then didi will have the majority

:dead
Click to expand...
A said:
I think that makes sense in my head.

ruff ruff has like around 6 votes

didi has 1

if ruff gets modkilled, then didi becomes majority

so then didi, ruff ruff, melodie and shiny all die

:hestonpls
Click to expand...


:catrude
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 1, guests: 1)
Back
Top