Game The Puddletown Mafia (Town victory)

[Dragon D. Luffy]

(I'm actually to lazy to make a vote tally you get the point)

 

[A Optimistic]

didnt the girl with the L avatar only post twice?

she can get modkilled as well

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

didnt the girl with the L avatar only post twice?

she can get modkilled as well

nah she posted 4 times according to thread search

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

don’t ask me what the hell the actual content of those posts were cuz i couldn’t tell u

 

[A Optimistic]

nah she posted 4 times according to thread search

wow im so sad

i wont be satisfied with only 2 modkills

 

[A Optimistic]

FUCK SHINY IS HERE

 

[A Optimistic]

[change vote lynch shiny]

ruff ruff modkilled and shiny lynched

please shizune

 

[Didi]

So ava, you've just gone all in on 'everyone on WAD's scumlist + the people called my posts bad, are scum'-narrative, I see

 

[A Optimistic]

So ava, you've just gone all in on 'everyone on WAD's scumlist + the people called my posts bad, are scum'-narrative, I see

me and wad are allies and we shall always vote together

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

You know why they call me W?

Because it’s the only letter I know.

What are L’s? Never had em.

 

[A Optimistic]

also doctor please forget me

i got a cool role and i dont wanna die anytime soon

 

[A Optimistic]

please protect me *

 

[A Optimistic]

@Shizune

we need an explanation on how modkilling is gonna work this game

specifically, what happens to the person with the second most votes if the person with the most votes gets modkilled

 

[A Optimistic]

because the vote count should be

ruff ruff (around 4-7 not sure)

shiny - 1

 

[A Optimistic]

nevermind shiny just rated my vote he's not gonna get modkilled

[vote change lynch ruffruff]

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

 

[A Optimistic]

i know ur not mafia but i better not find out you're an indie

 

[Platinum]

Wait

I just read this post



these clowns decided that Darth, a known inactifag, should be the double voter?

Probably means that was the least powerful thing they had.

Now shall we remove our votes from ruff ruff and kill someone else?

You never rely on modkills when you need to get rid of scum.

how about i change my vote only then

so that Didi has 1 vote

so ruff ruff will have the majority still, but if he gets modkilled, then didi will have the majority

There are so many things wrong with this post that i'll just let you figure it out.

I mean

I would probably vote psychic of all the people not getting modkilled/lynched rn but that’s just me

well and plat i guess too lul

I'm here catchin up, and will be here for the rest of day phase probably, awakened from my slumber

This is why discussing modkills is stupid with hours left in the phase.

You know why they call me W?

Because it’s the only letter I know.

What are L’s? Never had em.

I regret that I have only one optimistic to give.

 

[Shiny]

like hell ill be modkilled

my current reads:

Reznor
Platinum
Ava
SinRaven
Nevan
Melodie
Psychic
Mr. Waffles
WPK
Dr. White
Dragon D. Luffy
Didi
Shiny
Ruffruff

mafia or town i play the same,i don't have a meta(like back in 2012-2013) so your reasoning is quite wrong, i'm town this game

@Shiny

Did you abstain from voting to try and save Darth?

he was going to get lynched either way lol

Of course I got no idea how Shiny plays so maybe he always does this?

always

Anyways I'd like to kill

1) ruffruff

2) didi

3) shiny

why? because i didn't vote? give me posts that i seems scummy because i didn't find them

Where’s Scumlord Shiny tho

Townlord

Shiny was last seen: Today at 6:05 PM

did he even post this dayphase?

Nope

The thing is if Ruffruff does flip scum I actually would be a lot more unsure of my shiny read for various reasons:

1. Because I would have to consider DDL more (and he’s made it to a neutral read for now)

2. Because both Ruffruff and shiny abstained from voting last phase: how likely is it that both scum neglected to vote?

I don't like to use previous games but.. i didn't vote in a lot of phases where i was town,nothing new here..like i said before darth was going to get lynched either way and i like to have Ava around, i wanted to see his serious side

[change vote lynch shiny]

ruff ruff modkilled and shiny lynched

please shizune

 

[A Optimistic]

Probably means that was the least powerful thing they had.



You never rely on modkills when you need to get rid of scum.



There are so many things wrong with this post that i'll just let you figure it out.










This is why discussing modkills is stupid with hours left in the phase.



I regret that I have only one optimistic to give.

Enjoy quoting me while you still can Plat. You might just lose that luxury.

 

[Shiny]

[vote lynch RuffRuff]

he could at least come here with a case but it seems he gave up, like wad said this is a "almost" classic mafia game and there are no shenanigans that makes a miller appear lying in a lie detector

at first i thought he could be a indie role but his lack of posts and the miller things are a confirmation

 

[Platinum]

Enjoy quoting me while you still can Plat. You might just lose that luxury.

So what are we going to call your ship with W, since you are so desparate for his love and approval?

I think A&W works pretty well.

You two can be known as the rootbeer float.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

shiny who are ur reads

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

So what are we going to call your ship with W, since you are so desparate for his love and approval?

I think A&W works pretty well.

You two can be known as the rootbeer float.

we are looking for a threelationship and trying to find a partner whose forum name starts with an H

 

[A Optimistic]

So what are we going to call your ship with W, since you are so desparate for his love and approval?

I think A&W works pretty well.

You two can be known as the rootbeer float.

I'm not Melodie, you can't provoke me no matter how hard you try.

 

[Platinum]

I'm not Melodie, you can't provoke me no matter how hard you try.

I would have to think you are competent, or a threat, to want to provoke you.

You aren't on Melodie's level .

 

[A Optimistic]

i will miss u after u die plat

 

[Nevan]

I'm here catchin up, and will be here for the rest of day phase probably, awakened from my slumber

That's weirdly on time for someone that didn't get tagged.

>Will be here the rest of the dayphase

Another lie.

 

[Shiny]

shiny who are ur reads

wpk: town, he would be much more active if his scum team were getting destroyed like this, his current playstyle seems quite townish

Sin: hard to read, he acts quite useless and may appear to you as town but like I said before, he loves to fluffy post when godfather, I would use the lie detector on him

Nevan is a 50/50 to me, his questions on ruffruff appeared strange at first and an attempt to appear as town and now if ruffruff flips scum he may think "more people will think i'm town because a pressured a scum" .. seems a good strategy to fly out of the radar to me and avoid the lie detector

DDL is a very good player, his mafia plays are quite good and i feel he is pulling the same thing since the start of the game, or he could just be an useful town

 

[Melodie]

That's weirdly on time for someone that didn't get tagged.

>Will be here the rest of the dayphase

Another lie.

I'm still here Typing a post.

 

[Nevan]

I'm still here Typing a post.

Cool, what are your reads?

 

[A Optimistic]

wpk: town, he would be much more active if his scum team were getting destroyed like this, his current playstyle seems quite townish

Sin: hard to read, he acts quite useless and may appear to you as town but like I said before, he loves to fluffy post when godfather, I would use the lie detector on him

Nevan is a 50/50 to me, his questions on ruffruff appeared strange at first and an attempt to appear as town and now if ruffruff flips scum he may think "more people will think i'm town because a pressured a scum" .. seems a good strategy to fly out of the radar to me and avoid the lie detector

DDL is a very good player, his mafia plays are quite good and i feel he is pulling the same thing since the start of the game, or he could just be an useful town

i thought nevan was the lie detector

 

[A Optimistic]

i mean nevan obviously isn't going to admit that cuz modkill

but he's the dude who keeps asking that are u town question

and who else besides the lie detector would ask that question in a vanilla game where u would assume a lie detector isn't in the game

 

[Shiny]

you have a point, totally missed that

 

[A Optimistic]

you have a point, totally missed that

the fact that u didnt know nevan is the lie detector actually goes with something i discovered earlier that i cant say without shizune ripping my asshole apart

aka u look even more mafia

which sucks cuz i like u a lot

 

[Nevan]

Nevan is a 50/50 to me, his questions on ruffruff appeared strange at first and an attempt to appear as town and now if ruffruff flips scum he may think "more people will think i'm town because a pressured a scum" .. seems a good strategy to fly out of the radar to me and avoid the lie detector

If you think RuffRuff is the only one I pressured you're either blind or scum.

And I'm hardly off the radar considering I'm 6th in number of posts in the thread, but if it pleases you.

I'm town.

Now give an additional read for that 2/10 effort.

 

[Melodie]

Nice of you to finally do something on your own Melodie, without feebly waiting for others to suspect me first.

It's how I have generally actually played, to be honest. actually playing, excluding the hella inactive/coasting games. Which is fairly a lot lately, but yeah

Except your suspicion isn't reasonable at all... which is the whole point I made. You trying to paint me as something I was clearly not being is not reasonable suspicion. It is shoddy scumhunting and poor play.

Not at all. Those posts were made when it was just me and Dr White agreeing that something might be up, and then Reznor came out and said he was an innocent child with some lore fluff and I left it at that. This also completly ignores that my tinfoil on this was that he is a townie that might possibly turn due to the flavor. The fact that you think this is completly impossible and illogical is just completly stupid when the context of Shizune's opening post paints the flavor as a religiously heavy town, which can indicate corruption in the church.

It is, though. Objectively everyone that participated in that discussion is suspicious, it is simply a matter of whether a person finds it worth noting or not. In some mafia game types, it would be more up to discussion, in vanilla iterations, not really. You can regard context of opening posts and flavor, but this doesn't mean much to me in a fairly generic game.

Bullshit. You haven't painted me as an empty worded fluffer?



That's you, talking about me, saying i'm trying to give the impression of contributing without saying anything, again ignoring everything else i've done in the game. Seems like you trying to paint me as an empty worded fluffer to me. Did you miss this post too in your thorough reading? Or do you not read your own posts, in addition to W's, in this game?

I interpret fluff as continuously posting in the game thread without relating anything much to the actual game, which isn't what you have done, and therefore no, I don't consider it as empty worded fluffer.

Oh please. "oh not sure about Platinum and Darth, tell me what you think W" sure sounds like buddying to me.

Never happened.

Nope. That's not how it works. Mafia is a two-way street. You don't get to say 'lul, you the one being pressured not me!' and act like that gives you immunity to questioning.



Not even. I have not followed W's reads at all in this game, and I even pressured him early in the phase (maybe you didn't read that, understandable). Using his reads on me as a point against you isn't me trying to paint Wad as a confirmed townie.



This is a lovely low-effort attempt to paint what I did as a slip. The only way what I did could be a slip, is if it is actually true and I had knowledge of it. Yet, your whole case against me, is that the very notion of what I suggested is ridiculous and unlikely. So your very argument is inherently contradictory. Either I knew it was true and for some reason I was a complete moron to bring up this possibility to a thread that would never consider it, or I don't know its true, and thus it can't be a slip.

It's a two-way street, but suspecting people for the sake of being suspected is absolutely something worth noting. Nobody said it's immune to questioning or whatsoever. The origin of suspicion is important, even though, fairly speaking, my contribution to the game has been almost entirely regarding this subject due to tunnel vision, but yeah.

I suppose that's true regarding slips, but I interpreted it as when it feels a player made their alignment most visible, which from my perspective, the small discussion regarding it, is pretty anti-town, and I don't think I'm alone in this; It's simply a matter of whether the person finds it worth noting or not.

I'm fine with continuing this discussion but I have no interest in continuously going through lengthy quotes, fairly time consuming and puts the attention on only one person, leaves less room for me specifically to participate in other discussions.

@Melodie : Why the focus on Plat with no mention of Didi and Dr.Whites part in that speculation? They come off worse in my view, in part because scum prefer to follow in such situations, though more so that Plat as a host is going to have more natural tinfoil, especially given the nature of his own game and experience with Nitty's prior games.

Honestly? Tunnel vision. I suspect those as well, but I'm pretty bad at arguing or pushing on several people at a time, and Didi looked pretty bad when he decided to quickly backpedal and reference another flavor to compare to that discussion. I don't think the nature of Platinum's game or Nitty's prior games have much to do with this type of game.

Like... if I am hosting a game you can be damn sure the miller will fool LDs. SO I don't see why I would ever say the opposite.

I agree to this, in the games i participated in millers or any variations of the role is interpreted as anti-town through any actions. Those games weren't vanilla however, but I don't see why would there be any difference in how they work, regardless of the game type.

I

AM

NOT

FEIGNING

EFFORT

Call me scum if you want, but telling me I am feigning effort when I do this is offensive.

If you can make this list next day without reading every page in the thread I'll give you a blowjob.

This doesn't make sense. People will call you scum due to feigning effort, it shouldn't be offensive, it's how the game is played and is an aspect of playing as mafia. and the rest of these chain of posts feels kinda forced, idk DDL. You looking scummy.

 

[Melodie]

[Vote lynch RuffRuff]

Cool, what are your reads?

RuffRuff
Didi
DDL

Scum reads, that is.

 

[Melodie]

Platinum too wtf

 

[Didi]

>literally only comment on how the flavour intro text seems similar to hot fuzz (mostly because I fucking love hot fuzz)
>everyone still trynna pretend I was part of some big discussion where we all tried to discredit Reznor even though I also immediately said he's superlikely just innocent child


I wish people would read the game and times that stuff was posted instead of meme'ing their own incorrect version of events smh

 

[Melodie]

 

[A Optimistic]

anyways im gonna need the doc to protect me tonight while I do....something interesting

 

[Didi]

I wasn't even there when those fuckers posted that

I just came into the thread a few hours later (when I woke up), read the intro, immediately posted that cuz I was like 'yo this flavour is gucci' and then read further and saw their take on it

 

[Platinum]

It is, though. Objectively everyone that participated in that discussion is suspicious, it is simply a matter of whether a person finds it worth noting or not. In some mafia game types, it would be more up to discussion, in vanilla iterations, not really. You can regard context of opening posts and flavor, but this doesn't mean much to me in a fairly generic game.

Doesn't matter what it means to you. It matters what it means to me. If it is something I consider, but wouldn't be something you ever consider, that doesn't mean that my way of thinking is wrong and yours right. As a game host myself, I am more likely to consider flavor hooks and host intentions than someone who isn't a host.

I interpret fluff as continuously posting in the game thread without relating anything much to the actual game, which isn't what you have done, and therefore no, I don't consider it as empty worded fluffer.

Nice of you to finally say that now I guess.

Never happened.

I'm conflicted about Darth and Platinum tbh.


I'd like to ask you about Platinum, Shiny and Nevan.

Guess the part about you asking W for the read on Darth an error on my part, that came from mashing your two points together, but saying it 'never happened' is disingenous.

It's a two-way street, but suspecting people for the sake of being suspected is absolutely something worth noting. Nobody said it's immune to questioning or whatsoever. The origin of suspicion is important, even though, fairly speaking, my contribution to the game has been almost entirely regarding this subject due to tunnel vision, but yeah.

Except I wasn't suspecting you? I was refuting your points, since you were tunneling on me. I never voted for you or told other people to vote for you.

I'm fine with continuing this discussion but I have no interest in continuously going through lengthy quotes, fairly time consuming and puts the attention on only one person, leaves less room for me specifically to participate in other discussions.

If you aren't interested in that stuff, why even bother responding? I'm not going to let you get the last word in, just because you can't be assed to focus on more than one person. This was a dead discussion you revived.

 

[Platinum]

You are doing a lot of overjustification on something that only Melodie (and WPK kinda) really care about Didi.

 

[Didi]

You are doing a lot of overjustification on something that only Melodie (and WPK kinda) really care about Didi.

I ignored it at first when Reznor earlier in the phase was like 'hurr u gonna discredit me again durrr?' but now that Melo started too, I got irked

I don't like it when people spout blatant misinformation about me, and I will not just take it

first wpk
then ava
then reznor
now melo

I have had ENOUGH

 

[A Optimistic]

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

 

[A Optimistic]

[Vote change lynch Shiny]

Votes lock in 3 hours.

 

[Didi]

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Reese’s in pieces ruff squared

 

[A Optimistic]

stop rating my posts funny shiny...you're scaring me

you better not be a bomb

 

[Nevan]

Vote lynch ruffruff

Vote properly.

 

[Nevan]

Or don't, whatever.

 

[Nevan]

@Shiny What are your thoughts on Dr. White, Didi and Psychic?

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

[Change Vote Lynch RuffRuff]

The lesson to take away from this newbie is to never answer questions about alignment in any game so you can never get caught by lie detectors. It's what I do

 

[Dr. White]

Or don't, whatever.

Dude calm the fuck down.

[vote lynch ruffruff]

 

[Shiny]

@Nevan i didnt pay attention on them, i must reread their post

 

[Melodie]

Who did you pay attention to

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

 

[Shiny]

Who did you pay attention to

Everyone that i talked about?

 

[Shiny]

A game where wad isnt the top poster

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

ava is powerful

someone get the top poster count for the CB mafia thread

i sectioned myself from there np

 

[A Optimistic]

I'm always the top poster.

 

[A Optimistic]

1,949 posts

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

1,949 posts

and the next highest was...?

 

[A Optimistic]

and the next highest was...?

jojo at 929

and whitewolf at 494

 

[Nevan]

@Nevan i didnt pay attention on them, i must reread their post

Do it then.

 

[Nevan]

1,949 posts

Jesus.

 

[Nevan]

We need to have a backup lynch in case RuffRuff is modkilled.

 

[A Optimistic]

Yeah that's why I voted Shiny.

They should both die.

 

[A Optimistic]

and the next highest was...?

I thought you would be asleep by now.

Staying awake to see 2 mafia die?

 

[Psyche]

I like a didi lynch

[vote lynch didi]

 

[Psyche]

@Shizune, can you add threadmarks....easier to read the game.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

 

[A Optimistic]

what happens if there is a tie with shiny and didi

random generator decides who dies im guessing?

 

[Jeroen]

[Vote Lynch RuffRuff]

 

[A Optimistic]

more votes for ruff ruff? im afraid i don't see why

even if by some miracle ruff does show up and meet the posting requirements, he still has way to many votes on him that he will be the majority

so shouldn't be focus on who should get the second most votes?

 

[Melodie]

 

[Melodie]

more votes for ruff ruff? im afraid i don't see why

even if by some miracle ruff does show up and meet the posting requirements, he still has way to many votes on him that he will be the majority

so shouldn't be focus on who should get the second most votes?

he'd be lynched and modkilled at the same time i think