Game Holy Shōnen Trinity 4 (mafia wins!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
>Calls us Pussies
>Flaming
>Baiting
>Spite Lynch
>Policy Lynch

Child's 'cause we can't take an L from you. Plays Mafia Unethically. The Latter is the true statement I guess the Former can also be correct but it's Losing due to your own Team Mate Game Throwing 'cause of their own Ego. Difference, I for one have you seen first hand you be detrimental to Town's Win-Con or at least your own Win-Con where it is borderline Game Throwing. I've even seen the DN game and that was just, uhh what?

There are No Lies and which we are speaking you are not as good as you believe you are then again you are a NF Speciman.

I want Crugyr around 'cause if johit starts looking scummy to me I know he'll back me.

Actually I was the one who mentioned SK being Scummy for defending Gifted and Referring to all Votes as a Scum tell.

Obviously Crugyr was correct in establishing you are not correctly reading the thread.

I realize that after I made my comment haha

WAD & @iwandesu do you think it would be effective if we asked MG for a certain Flavour - Since I submitted Urahara/Aizen - Maybe we can ask if one player is in Say "Is Urahara Kisuke a Flavour?" to help us just narrow down whom is in and isn't in the game we can even ISO the Scum Entry Names such as Madara, Aizen etc the more Obvious Scum Flavours.
We could
Dunno How broad we can make this question.
Maybe make a list of each characters picks
Like the five who Go make two lists each with one of their 2 submits
Then ask
"Among those lists which is the one with the biggest amount of characters in the game"
 
Supremekage - Madara, Sanji
2. Shade0180 - Minato, Gol D. Roger
3. Avito - Isshio, Sabo
4. Superman - Kuma, Kaguya
5. Stelios - Itachi, Jiraiya
6. Crugyr - Doflamingo, Gaara
7. Priscilla - Riruka, Vivi
8. C A N T I - Aizen, Urahara
9. Gifted - A, Ichigo
10. Novaselinenever - Jinbe, Gai
11. Luck - Kakashi, Zaraki
12. Kira Yagami - Pain, Ace
13. nfcnorth - Orihime, Enel
14. WolfPrinceKouga - Askin Nakk Le Vaar, Obito
15. jayjay³² - Shukuro Tsukishima, Kugo Ginjo
16. Ishmael - Pein, Kakuzu
17. Iwandesu - Ivankov, Pacifista
18. Mr. Waffles - Tenten
 
Supremekage - Madara, Sanji
2. Shade0180 - Minato, Gol D. Roger
3. Avito - Isshio, Sabo
4. Superman - Kuma, Kaguya
5. Stelios - Itachi, Jiraiya
6. Crugyr - Doflamingo, Gaara
7. Priscilla - Riruka, Vivi
8. C A N T I - Aizen, Urahara
9. Gifted - A, Ichigo
10. Novaselinenever - Jinbe, Gai
11. Luck - Kakashi, Zaraki
12. Kira Yagami - Pain, Ace
13. nfcnorth - Orihime, Enel
14. WolfPrinceKouga - Askin Nakk Le Vaar, Obito
15. jayjay³² - Shukuro Tsukishima, Kugo Ginjo
16. Ishmael - Pein, Kakuzu
17. Iwandesu - Ivankov, Pacifista
18. Mr. Waffles - Tenten
this is from the signup thread
 
Day 1 - Vote count #1
Vote Count

Avito - Gifted
Shade0180 - Gifted > Jayjay
C A N T I - Gifted > Avito > Jayjay
Priscilla - Gifted > Avito
iwandesu - Gifted
Crugyr - Avito > Jayjay
SupremeKage - Crugyr
Mr. Waffles - Jayjay
MAD - Priscilla
Stelios - Priscilla
Santi - Crugyr
Jayjay - Crugyr
WolfPrinceKouga - Crugyr

Jayjay - 4
Crugyr - 4
Priscilla - 2

@Superman , @Luck , @Kira Yagami and @nfcnorth have not voted yet. This is a reminder that failing to vote counts as 2 votes toward yourself.

Nova asked to be replaced due to time constraints, so he was excluded from this vote count. I'm looking for his replacement right now.

There are 24 hours left in this day phase, and I'm pleased to find that nobody is inactive.
 
ngl
i don’t understand what iwan or nfc is trying to say at all
I took what Iwandesu was saying as we could split the possible roles somehow and ask oracle based questions off that. So if we go about that one way to do it is ask a question based on submissions. I.e is there more roles in first submissions or second or something to that effect. Not sure how useful that would be but is another possible line of questioning.
 
We could
Dunno How broad we can make this question.
Maybe make a list of each characters picks
Like the five who Go make two lists each with one of their 2 submits
Then ask
"Among those lists which is the one with the biggest amount of characters in the game"
Hmm its have to be a little more specific not as specific as my example but something not to broad but not too accurate to give us a better sense.

Maybe compile the more obvious scum like:

Askin, Madara, Enel, Doffy among the most likely such as Pein, Obito, Itachi.

Like among these how many are scum? Or does group A outlay Group B in amount of Scum Roles.
Maybe we could take everyone's first submission and ask something around that?
Refer to response above
I just hope if Askin made it in he's not on the mafia team, that would be a pain.
He'd for sure be Scum. He and Kaguya would be the most troublesome of the bunch I believe.

World Bender - Essentially Immortal.
I don't know if that is better or worse than any other question we can ask or if it is even worth asking in the first place but if we are looking at possible questions than it is another train of thought which may or may not be good/bad.
Well one thing I noticed is how quick Majority were OK with agreeing with WADs plan while not questioning or actually representing any other alternative. This is Mafia and no one is confirmed so we already have scum easily trying to blend.

We should take these chances to narrow down scum as quickly as possible.

I like WADs proposition but I believe we can get more out of it. It was a smart initial plan from WAD collectively we can create a multitude of questions that will best help us narrow down scum quicker.
 
1. Fuck you for making me read
2. Fuck your plan
3. It is convoluted as fuck
4. If I were scum I would lie
5. No


@ 4

i dont think you've read my plan then

because scum would not be capable of lying when there are up to 5 people who could verify the same answer that said scum got

unless u wanna think that somehow ive grouped an entire mafia team of six in one of the groups
 
You may have grouped up one for scum. How would you know you did not? But then I guess you would say that group would be stupid to throw like the one or 2 non scum under the buss for the lynch which would expose them all.

I still stand by fuck you for making me work.:catflip

The groups are taken directly from Shizune’s op and separated in 3. No change in group order has been made by wad
 
Supremekage - Madara, Sanji
2. Shade0180 - Minato, Gol D. Roger
3. Avito - Isshio, Sabo
4. Superman - Kuma, Kaguya
5. Stelios - Itachi, Jiraiya
6. Crugyr - Doflamingo, Gaara
7. Priscilla - Riruka, Vivi
8. C A N T I - Aizen, Urahara
9. Gifted - A, Ichigo
10. Novaselinenever - Jinbe, Gai
11. Luck - Kakashi, Zaraki
12. Kira Yagami - Pain, Ace
13. nfcnorth - Orihime, Enel
14. WolfPrinceKouga - Askin Nakk Le Vaar, Obito
15. jayjay³² - Shukuro Tsukishima, Kugo Ginjo
16. Ishmael - Pein, Kakuzu
17. Iwandesu - Ivankov, Pacifista
18. Mr. Waffles - Tenten
Excellent
Like
"Madara
Minato
Issio
Kuma
Itachi
Doflamingo
Riruka
Aizen
A
Jinbe
Kakashi
Pain
Orihime
Askin
Shukuro
Ivankov
Tenten

Sanji
Gold
Cabo
Kaguya
Jiraya
Gaara
Vivi
Urahara
Ichigo
Gai
Zaraki
Ace
Enel
Óbito
Kugo
Kakuzu
Pacifista
Are there more characters in the game on the first list than in the second?"
 
Excellent
Like
"Madara
Minato
Issio
Kuma
Itachi
Doflamingo
Riruka
Aizen
A
Jinbe
Kakashi
Pain
Orihime
Askin
Shukuro
Ivankov
Tenten

Sanji
Gold
Cabo
Kaguya
Jiraya
Gaara
Vivi
Urahara
Ichigo
Gai
Zaraki
Ace
Enel
Óbito
Kugo
Kakuzu
Pacifista
Are there more characters in the game on the first list than in the second?"
is that really the best question we can ask though?
 
If we are going to use the oracle as a group, we need to fulfill 2 conditions. The first is that scum never get any benefit out of it (any cycle, ever). The second is that town benefits from its info every cycle.


After reading this I m having second thoughts.

@MAD If we all ask same questions and receive same answers , doesn’t that actually enable scum to just ask individual questions anyway and get different info and hide it?

If 3 groups ask same questions doesn’t that enable scum to actually cruise by, just claiming by that they got same information as others while town is on pursuit following a predetermined path of speculation thus giving room for scum to form a counter on this plan?

:dank
 
After reading this I m having second thoughts.

@MAD If we all ask same questions and receive same answers , doesn’t that actually enable scum to just ask individual questions anyway and get different info and hide it?

If 3 groups ask same questions doesn’t that enable scum to actually cruise by, just claiming by that they got same information as others while town is on pursuit following a predetermined path of speculation thus giving room for scum to form a counter on this plan?

:dank
Yes
But scum is going to use the mechanic Anyway
There is no way we can stop them from using the Oracle.
We can However make concentrated efforts as a group
 
After reading this I m having second thoughts.

@MAD If we all ask same questions and receive same answers , doesn’t that actually enable scum to just ask individual questions anyway and get different info and hide it?

If 3 groups ask same questions doesn’t that enable scum to actually cruise by, just claiming by that they got same information as others while town is on pursuit following a predetermined path of speculation thus giving room for scum to form a counter on this plan?

:dank
Also we could probably catch scum on a different answer after a bit if we have different people give the answer each time.

If we do different ones people can lie and we can’t really catch them tbh.
 
After reading this I m having second thoughts.

@MAD If we all ask same questions and receive same answers , doesn’t that actually enable scum to just ask individual questions anyway and get different info and hide it?

If 3 groups ask same questions doesn’t that enable scum to actually cruise by, just claiming by that they got same information as others while town is on pursuit following a predetermined path of speculation thus giving room for scum to form a counter on this plan?

:dank

its a risk

but if we believe we can trust the thing it can also be used as a scumhunting tool

i.e, if you think someone else in your group went rogue and asked a different question and suspect them, information from the oracle can be withheld until we FORCE someone to reveal their stuff first

i mean the way i envision it is we're gonna start with 3 large groups for now but eventually split and branch out so its more groups of less people

but never allow someone the agency of individual inquiry unless they are town confirmed in some way

does that make sense?
 
You know my role? That's not an admission of being canon or not BTW, I don't recognise my character.

I thought yours was a joke vote but now the cut goes even deeper.
Pretty sure Vasto was continuing your Marvel vs DC, saying you're not apart of the canon of the game. You look to preemptively defend whether or not your character is from canon, when that doesn't matter to alignment necessarily. Uses the word "admission".

[Change Vote Lynch Cooler]
 
Reads for now

Liking canti, gets a little cranky and seems to be pushing and questioning which is good for him usually. Townish read

Thinking Priscilla is town for now so prefer to let her go.

Was scum reading Ishmael on his defense and how he was participating with discussion but I like mad a bit more. So neutral for now but still watching.

Nova is always quiet wen scum but he did sub so not meh. But cooler has been giving much so slight scum.

Jayjay actually slight scum mostly becuase of content. But also the fact his vote is because I joined a wagon at 3 when he did the same on me for that reason. But never really understood him. At least he is active.

Stelios still too fluffy for my liking so slight scum.

Avito way more talkative with Town so slight scum hope he talks more

Wpk is more active so slight town imo, keeping up and such.

So I’m good for a cooler, jayjay, avito lynch atm
 
Wuts ur opinion on Jayjay and Crugyr? Currently Jayjay is in the lead with 4 votes followed by Crugyr with 3.

Some of the people who pushed the wagons are more sus to me than either of the 2 imo

im sort of tempted to lynch jayjay since he's a loose cannon but i actually think he has the makings of a great player unlike priscilla (who im still currrently affixed to but seeing as how ppl are giving her a last chance seemingly ill probably switch off that soon)

crugyr comes off as dismissive and aloof but i dont think thats his usual scum play, im not sure what the initial case was maybe its cuz admittedly i didnt read the first couple of pages before i subbed in outside of the OP so i should prolly get on that

ideally i dont wanna lynch either of the two on d1 since theyre potential assets to town

which ppl do u have in mind?
 
Reads for now

Liking canti, gets a little cranky and seems to be pushing and questioning which is good for him usually. Townish read

Thinking Priscilla is town for now so prefer to let her go.

Was scum reading Ishmael on his defense and how he was participating with discussion but I like mad a bit more. So neutral for now but still watching.

Nova is always quiet wen scum but he did sub so not meh. But cooler has been giving much so slight scum.

Jayjay actually slight scum mostly becuase of content. But also the fact his vote is because I joined a wagon at 3 when he did the same on me for that reason. But never really understood him. At least he is active.

Stelios still too fluffy for my liking so slight scum.

Avito way more talkative with Town so slight scum hope he talks more

Wpk is more active so slight town imo, keeping up and such.

So I’m good for a cooler, jayjay, avito lynch atm
 
Reads for now

Liking canti, gets a little cranky and seems to be pushing and questioning which is good for him usually. Townish read

Thinking Priscilla is town for now so prefer to let her go.

Was scum reading Ishmael on his defense and how he was participating with discussion but I like mad a bit more. So neutral for now but still watching.

Nova is always quiet wen scum but he did sub so not meh. But cooler has been giving much so slight scum.

Jayjay actually slight scum mostly becuase of content. But also the fact his vote is because I joined a wagon at 3 when he did the same on me for that reason. But never really understood him. At least he is active.

Stelios still too fluffy for my liking so slight scum.

Avito way more talkative with Town so slight scum hope he talks more

Wpk is more active so slight town imo, keeping up and such.

So I’m good for a cooler, jayjay, avito lynch atm

so im guessing im null? :catsad
 
I don’t really care about getting spite lynched. My abilities are mostly mid to late game unfortunately.

I also have a vote power of 2 and don’t really want to lynch Crugyr. I was on the counter wagon because the timing of the votes on me were incredibly sus. That being said, I’m not gonna change my vote. Gonna stick with Cooler because that shit is definitely suspect.
 
im sort of tempted to lynch jayjay since he's a loose cannon but i actually think he has the makings of a great player unlike priscilla (who im still currrently affixed to but seeing as how ppl are giving her a last chance seemingly ill probably switch off that soon)

crugyr comes off as dismissive and aloof but i dont think thats his usual scum play, im not sure what the initial case was maybe its cuz admittedly i didnt read the first couple of pages before i subbed in outside of the OP so i should prolly get on that

ideally i dont wanna lynch either of the two on d1 since theyre potential assets to town

which ppl do u have in mind?
If JJ can make the turnaround to a great player he would be the next AJ, which I wouldn't mind.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top