Game Favorites '22 - GROUP 1

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
Catching up was quite fun. I go for the glory of rome!

Draekke said:
This - we should be trying to hunt people, not just chat randomly with each other.

The fuji vote is dumb. It's completely valid to dislike Rome.

My early reads (not much yet):
Alwaysmind - wanted to use stats to vote, flip flopped once pressure was put on them. Serious mode to imply they are trying, but don't contribute after that.
Jojo - Don't agree with blind playing, if that's truly what they are doing. Personally it sounds more like a way to hide, and those who want to hide aren't town.
Flower - posting lots of fluff, allying themselves with Vanya for some reason
Saturday - Votes legend then drops off. Will they be back?
Admiral Fujitora - fluff posts and emotes early on. Fighting with Vanya/Rome
Vanya - I don't know your playstyle, perhaps this is normal for you, but your Latin/Rome speak is odd. Not sure what to think.
The Ancient Centurian - similar to Vanya, you seem to be RPing JFK. Is this normal for you?
Alibaba Saluja - lots of fluff posts, chatting with people, not contributing anything.

Nothing too in depth or anything, but throwing my thoughts out of those who are active so far. Several others have just poked their heads in, but it's still pretty early.
Click to expand...
Most of these don't tell us what you're reading the player as except for maybe Jojo.

But since you're confused about each players style, yes, it's quite normal for TAC and Ali to start with fluff and role play. The others start with fluff, too. And honestly, I believe fluff at least gets the game going and introduces the players to each other.

I would have actually liked a read on Owner of a lonely heart if you wanted to do this since they seem to have a post or two trying to ascertain the alignment of players.

AndrewGreve said:
this dude is ez D1 town read.
Click to expand...
Oh, why is that?
 
Though with Tiger not playing Shizune missed a golden opportunity to have the intro flavor text be about him and other crossed out names, if we doing any pre-game story as to why we all came together here it would totally be Tiger got shot first that really sets a tone. But then you'd probably would want to get permission first to use their names etc. And then you would maybe over-commit to flavor text for the whole game, so maybe it's for the best...

I need doing some cooking in a moment
 
Vanya said:
See this is kind of stuff why I like to fluff to early.

Because there is always someone that takes early fluff and getting to know everyone as core gameplay and decides to make reads based on it.

It serves no purpose what so ever to do that and make judgements this early, it only serves to sow dissent and later on undoubtedly lead to a fluff lynch

These reads aren't even reads, it is just retelling of what happened
Click to expand...
drekke is obv villa based on that reads list and the post I quoted earlier. We can safely ignore the slot for a few days.
 
Lind said:
Thanks.

It's from Spy x Family. A pretty great series and totally recommend for its wholesomeness.
Click to expand...
ff071a4fd2b54825a769c4da3232a115.jpg
 
Lind said:
Catching up was quite fun. I go for the glory of rome!


Most of these don't tell us what you're reading the player as except for maybe Jojo.

But since you're confused about each players style, yes, it's quite normal for TAC and Ali to start with fluff and role play. The others start with fluff, too. And honestly, I believe fluff at least gets the game going and introduces the players to each other.

I would have actually liked a read on Owner of a lonely heart if you wanted to do this since they seem to have a post or two trying to ascertain the alignment of players.


Oh, why is that?
Click to expand...
he fits very nicely into a player archetype I have seen many times, and the posting all felt very genuine. So very easy to slot into town read for Day 1 and reevalutate later if it becomes necessary.
 
Vanya said:
Yawn, at least try to hide you single me out the moment Andrew voices a dislike on me
Click to expand...
I'm flipping back and forth between old and current posts and haven't looked at his yet. All I'm seeing from Andrew is the family chat stuff.

You're the one who was so gun ho as to be like "why didn't you respond back to me?" Well, you want that attention or it felt like you were trying to set someone up, well here you go, not related to Andrew's thing, I'm suspicious of you.
 
AndrewGreve said:
I am stating my opinion on it all.
Click to expand...
That wasn't an opinion. It was a statement.

There is legitimate interested to question Draeke and we have plenty of time, your insistence on us not doing that doesn't help that interest at all ,it only provokes it more because if you dont have anything to hide you have nothing to fear.

You are protective of Draeke 2 or 3 times by now, if you trully believe he is fine then don't interfere with us asking question
 
Owner Of A Lonely Heart said:
I'm flipping back and forth between old and current posts and haven't looked at his yet. All I'm seeing from Andrew is the family chat stuff.

You're the one who was so gun ho as to be like "why didn't you respond back to me?" Well, you want that attention or it felt like you were trying to set someone up, well here you go, not related to Andrew's thing, I'm suspicious of you.
Click to expand...
Set someone up with that? With love of Rome?

Please, make a genuine case then we can talk lmao
 
Vanya said:
That wasn't an opinion. It was a statement.

There is legitimate interested to question Draeke and we have plenty of time, your insistence on us not doing that doesn't help that interest at all ,it only provokes it more because if you dont have anything to hide you have nothing to fear.

You are protective of Draeke 2 or 3 times by now, if you trully believe he is fine then don't interfere with us asking question
Click to expand...
Ill keep playing the way I play. your line of questioning of drekke was innane and I pointed it out.
 
Owner Of A Lonely Heart said:
[vote lynch Vanya] can't make heads or tails of what he's saying beyond the quirk or self-imposed personality skit

I'm not caught up,

But I would love to see the rest of you think of him, Vanya feel free to respond too
Click to expand...
Do you think he'd actively draw so much attention to himself with speech patterns that aren't really understood by most of us here as scum?

I think he'd try a bit harder to blend in at least. His current posts come off as disinterested in your pushes .

I wouldn't really scum read someone just for having fun tbh.
 
AndrewGreve said:
fair, I was prob crying about too much fluff/flavor too soon.

actually, I was almost certainly crying to soon, since he is very active with what looks like real attempts at solving.
Click to expand...
I think fluff is a good way to solve, too. Because you can see who is fluffing just to post and who is fluffing and simultaneously trying to solve the game.
 
AndrewGreve said:
Ill keep playing the way I play. your line of questioning of drekke was innane and I pointed it out.
Click to expand...
I'm a little interested in knowing why his questioning of Draekke seems inane to you. You liked Draekke's efforts to form some reads while Vanya actually analysed those reads and came to the conclusion that Draekke was simply summarising what each player had done.

In this regard I like Vanya's point of view more since he tried to analyse the contents of the post and not merely the effort of the post.

Not disagreeing with your Draekke read, but I don't think you need to criticise Vanya for having an opposite read compared to yours.
 
I made a stance that drekke is an easy D1 town read

I made a stance your read was garbage

I made a stance your line of questioning was worthless

where did I back down? when I said it was an opinion? like of fucking course its an opinion. I dont know for sure, well I suppose I know your read is bad regardless of drekke's alignment cuz it wont find mafia more often than rand.

again, I will continue to play how I play, if you give a shit read and I have an opposing read. I will defend my town reads and call your reads bad when they suck
 
Lind said:
Do you think he'd actively draw so much attention to himself with speech patterns that aren't really understood by most of us here as scum?

I think he'd try a bit harder to blend in at least. His current posts come off as disinterested in your pushes .

I wouldn't really scum read someone just for having fun tbh.
Click to expand...
I personally find it comes down to personality of the person. Some people absolutely come in and boss the thread around as scum as soon as possible. People who are confident they can make people see them as town no matter what. I can think of quiet a few players who would do that if they are in the right mindset and not afk not caring moods. Not famliar enough with Vanya to really know what type of personality he is yet.
 
AndrewGreve said:
what are you talking about?
Click to expand...
I'm talking about you
AndrewGreve said:
drekke is obv villa based on that reads list and the post I quoted earlier. We can safely ignore the slot for a few days.
Click to expand...
Here is first defence of Draeke followed by statement we can ignore his slot for now. That's wasnt a suggestion or an opinion, it was a statement and a soft command to steer the game away from draeke

AndrewGreve said:
pushing a player for that reads list after his first few posts is silly.
Click to expand...
Your second defense of Draeke
AndrewGreve said:
he fits very nicely into a player archetype I have seen many times, and the posting all felt very genuine. So very easy to slot into town read for Day 1 and reevalutate later if it becomes necessary.
Click to expand...
Your third defense of Draeke

You are defending Draeke quite a bit over simplest of lines of questioning we have for him. You are sure he is town yet you don't wanna wait for him to come and defend himself and you "suggest" us to not pursue it further

Draeke read i had at first was slim but enough to go for, but seeing you now makes me way more interested in Draeke than i was before

So what is it? Scum Buddies or You scum "protecting" a townie you can call back on if things go south=
 
Lind said:
I'm a little interested in knowing why his questioning of Draekke seems inane to you. You liked Draekke's efforts to form some reads while Vanya actually analysed those reads and came to the conclusion that Draekke was simply summarising what each player had done.

In this regard I like Vanya's point of view more since he tried to analyse the contents of the post and not merely the effort of the post.

Not disagreeing with your Draekke read, but I don't think you need to criticise Vanya for having an opposite read compared to yours.
Click to expand...
meh

I am over this whole thing.
 
Vanya said:
I'm talking about you

Here is first defence of Draeke followed by statement we can ignore his slot for now. That's wasnt a suggestion or an opinion, it was a statement and a soft command to steer the game away from draeke


Your second defense of Draeke

Your third defense of Draeke

You are defending Draeke quite a bit over simplest of lines of questioning we have for him. You are sure he is town yet you don't wanna wait for him to come and defend himself and you "suggest" us to not pursue it further

Draeke read i had at first was slim but enough to go for, but seeing you now makes me way more interested in Draeke than i was before

So what is it? Scum Buddies or You scum "protecting" a townie you can call back on if things go south=
Click to expand...
if either he is my mafia partner, OR I am mafia protecting a townie for cred.

its pretty obvious you whould be more interested in me?
 
AndrewGreve said:
this reminds me on trying to save flower in our first game together, when flower was unbeliveably town, and people didnt get it and lynched such an ez slot to read and ignore.
Click to expand...
#IAMKOON moment.

We all have those.

I was Koon and they didn't believe me and now towns for years had to suffer the consequences of AM 2.0.
 
The Lukundo said:
I'd rather not read back but ig I could
Click to expand...
read and catch up now while it is still a small game because this will balloon to 100 pages pretty quickly.


Vanya said:
You crumbled like a fooking cruton already
Click to expand...
Croutons are not supposed to crumble. If they do, you got bad ones.
 
Flower said:
Yeah, the previous owner of this account was such an easy read every game.
Click to expand...
not trying to insult your play in general, but that moment in that game, the way you responded to the pressure was obvious

and everyone jumped down my throat for defending a town read. as though I have an obligation to ignore players until they finish their line of questioning.



Pushing drekke for a level 0 reads list, when they provided it unsolicited is silly

either

- They are the type of player to actually put substance in reads about players over posting fluff early d1, which would be an easy town read.

or

- They are going to display more nuanced thoughts/reads later which would then make the reads list very suspicious.

so far they have appeared very genuine so pushing d1 is dumb.
 
AndrewGreve said:
not trying to insult your play in general, but that moment in that game, the way you responded to the pressure was obvious

and everyone jumped down my throat for defending a town read. as though I have an obligation to ignore players until they finish their line of questioning.



Pushing drekke for a level 0 reads list, when they provided it unsolicited is silly

either

- They are the type of player to actually put substance in reads about players over posting fluff early d1, which would be an easy town read.

or

- They are going to display more nuanced thoughts/reads later which would then make the reads list very suspicious.

so far they have appeared very genuine so pushing d1 is dumb.
Click to expand...
Ngh, I was still a newbie back then. It's okay lol.
 
AndrewGreve said:
Pushing drekke for a level 0 reads list, when they provided it unsolicited is silly
Click to expand...
Read list that isn't even a read list but a summary of events that happened so far

AndrewGreve said:
- They are the type of player to actually put substance in reads about players over posting fluff early d1, which would be an easy town read.
Click to expand...
What possible reads can he get so early based on fluff? What plays did he make out of it? Did he push anyone? Call anyone scum? Vote? Anything?

No, because it isn't a read list

AndrewGreve said:
- They are going to display more nuanced thoughts/reads later which would then make the reads list very suspicious.
Click to expand...
Oh so that doesn't sound as townie the way you paint him to be?
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 3 (members: 1, guests: 2)
Back
Top