Game Favorites '22 - GROUP 1

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Well unless Shizune says otherwise, I'm assuming we still have our execute - so again, it seems strange to actively execute a player who was already top of the chopping block, unless that's how their ability works, I guess? Still seems really strange to me.
The man died as soon as Ali exed him
And tagged Nitty. It would be quite the coincidence if the two are unrelated.

@Shizune can we still execute someone this phase?
 
The man died as soon as Ali exed him
And tagged Nitty. It would be quite the coincidence if the two are unrelated.

@Shizune can we still execute someone this phase?
Not saying its unrelated, and Nitty already answered yes.

I'm saying if AS was already leading the Execution, why waste an ability - unless Ali has the ultimate Vote Execute passive, I imagine they used an ability to do so.
 
She is the top lynch right now. Why would you intentionally waste an ability on her, if that's what you're implying?

Good for us that Ekko is hunting, but not good for us that people have town reads on him for it. Like Jojo
What we think of Ekko doesnt matter to Group 2 because we cannot influence them and everyone is aware this is a multiball anyways.
 
No. I think you have one role and your “speciality” or whatever you wanna call it is to keep tabs on both games so you can report back to your team information and reads when they combine.

I just don’t think you’re town. Probably more indie that combines with one team is my guess. But still effectively mafia.
A hypothetical mafia role like that would be subject to surviving one of the threads all alone without the backing of a team in the thread or the night actions.

Effectively only collecting information on one group to share with the other team is quite redundant as well since:
1) The thread is open and either mafia team is welcome to read both threads and collect information themselves.
2) Action wise, the mafia role will be left alone without enough support to through night actions as well.

If you still believe this tinfoil, then honestly I'll just ask you to judge my play yourself. I'm 100% town.

Last day phase he gave out small commentary from time to time and he weirdly tried to say the Vanya TMI on DDL could be wrong before trying to give it a fair chance. He termed it as an investigation when Vanya used "TMI" there and I thought he was trying to pull the weight of Vanya's vouch on DDL down.

Need to see more from him as well honestly.
 
The tag is probably unnecessary and he has an active or passive that says he can decide the execution target, like a veto of sorts? I can see that in a role tbh.
I'd find it hard to believe one player has a passive that allows them to single handedly control the execution continually. Especially since the execution was meant as an alternative to modkills.
 
The tag is probably unnecessary and he has an active or passive that says he can decide the execution target, like a veto of sorts? I can see that in a role tbh.
well the execute was already on AS

i figure that someone wanted to execute a different player and AS took their spot or something

idk i think it’s just poor play

that being said they shoulda killed flower
 
I'd find it hard to believe one player has a passive that allows them to single handedly control the execution continually. Especially since the execution was meant as an alternative to modkills.
Eh Ali said its a coincidence anyways, Im
Waiting to see if we can still exe.
well the execute was already on AS

i figure that someone wanted to execute a different player and AS took their spot or something

idk i think it’s just poor play

that being said they shoulda killed flower
If its an execute they couldnt have killed her, if its a vig kill yes. Im assuming its a veto exe because it happened to AS instead of any of the active players present rn.
 
A hypothetical mafia role like that would be subject to surviving one of the threads all alone without the backing of a team in the thread or the night actions.

Effectively only collecting information on one group to share with the other team is quite redundant as well since:
1) The thread is open and either mafia team is welcome to read both threads and collect information themselves.
2) Action wise, the mafia role will be left alone without enough support to through night actions as well.

If you still believe this tinfoil, then honestly I'll just ask you to judge my play yourself. I'm 100% town.


Last day phase he gave out small commentary from time to time and he weirdly tried to say the Vanya TMI on DDL could be wrong before trying to give it a fair chance. He termed it as an investigation when Vanya used "TMI" there and I thought he was trying to pull the weight of Vanya's vouch on DDL down.

Need to see more from him as well honestly.
Let me put it this way I don't even trust my own actions in favorites lol. I am paranoid like that.
 
To make my stance fully clear here.

[Vote Lynch Lind].

Claims he can't be Mafia as per game rules.
While the rules also say that when you're gone you're gone and he apparently has a second chance just like that. And then Town can also put somebody on the lynch platform when the rules say only voters are eligible? I'm calling fucking bullshit there. You wanna tell me whatever he has is a Town role and that Town can break all rules of the game? And then he says he can't be Maf per the game rules while he himself claims to be a walking rule break. Kek.

I'm dying already, but at least let me take this obv scum with me to hell.
 
OK so first thing first.

The list of active users who declined to vote for LG, thus removing themselves from the possible lynch candidates:

Alwaysmind voted for Karma
Traveling Swordman voted for The Ancient Centurion
Laix voted for Dragon D Luffy
Legend voted for Flower

~Vanya voted for Flower, but is confirmed town. But I'd still like to know why you thought not piling onto the vote wagon so as to make today's pool larger? This is by far the best chance that town has, confirmed or not. Feel free to pressure all you want, but the vote should go on the stack.

I'd like to hear from all of the above posters as to why they felt like not adding their name to the pool, and how that is supposed to benefit town.
Because I wasnt feeling the vote atm, and had scum vibes on Flower and from what ive read that hasnt changed in the day since.
I didn‘t even get any night results yet, bruh.
That doesnt sound logical unless your abilities were tampered with. But still a excuse that scum would use to extend their time in the game.
So my Flash got stolen and I‘m dying next night. Wonderful.

@AndrewGreve the ability was going to turn another Townie into Ash and I was going to become a pet like a Pokemon. This would have been announced in the thread as well. Basically somebody else would have gotten my role and full control over me and I could have just coasted.

Oh well, GG.
I still dont even understood why you claimed Day. If you are trelling the truth (which I doubt) you made yourself a obvious nightime target.
I dont know moon speak
wait the game is segregated???
racism wins again in 2022…
Hello old friend.
 
If flower flips town it is gonna be absurdly bad play from her and i have 0 regrets with the lynch

Flower from the start decided to coast, her own words. Is that something a townie would do or plan to do? Hey guys i have this town role but i'm gonna throw it in the trash and cuck my own team from early d1

Absolutely absurdly bad play if town and borderline game throwing
 
443b3d64eba10e742c40dbd4a9a1ea74.gif
 
Well

Laix and AM.

But main wagon
I had a town lean on Draekke from d1. D2 his play is all over the place, I like he gives us focus to the thread and events but every argument he has is actually mind numbing, there’s very little contribution to any new scum hunting, he’s very present but not particularly novel, and he seems to be very on edge when people pressure him. All this, plus I sometimes get the feeling that he’s constantly paranoid not about other players, but about what people do in relation to him.

Laix and AM are pretty much topping my list too. But i think they’re gonna go away from the lynch again this round lmao
 
Day 2 - Vote count
Vote count

Spoiler: Lynch votes
1. @Admiral Fujitora - Flower
2. @Alibaba Saluja
3. @Alwaysmind - Broki
4. @AndrewGreve - Flower
5. @Atlantic Storm
6. @Cooler
7. @Draekke - Lind > Flower
8. @FLORIDA MAN
9. @Flower - Flower > Draekke > Hidden > Lind
10. @Hidden - Flower
11. @Ishmael - Flower
12. @JoJo - Flower
13. @Karma - Hidden
14. @Laix - Flower
15. @Legend
16. @Lind - Flower
17. @MangoSenpai
18. @Mich - Flower
19. @nfcnorth - Flower
20. @Owner Of A Lonely Heart - Lind
21. @Revan Reborn
22. @Rottkins
23. @Sallucion
24. @Saturday - Flower
25. @Shrike - Flower
26. @The Lukundo - Draekke
27. @TheAncientCenturion
28. @Traveling Swordsman
29. @Ultra
30. @Underworld Broker
31. @Vanya - Flower
32. @Vivo Diez
33. @~Mystic Serenade~


Lynch leaderboard

Flower - 13
Lind - 2

Spoiler: Execution votes
1. @Admiral Fujitora - Atlantic
2. @Alibaba Saluja
3. @Alwaysmind - Atlantic
4. @AndrewGreve
5. @Atlantic Storm
6. @Cooler
7. @Draekke - Atlantic
8. @FLORIDA MAN
9. @Flower
10. @Hidden - Atlantic
11. @Ishmael - Atlantic
12. @JoJo
13. @Karma - Mysti
14. @Laix - Mango
15. @Legend
16. @Lind - Mysti
17. @MangoSenpai
18. @Mich - Atlantic
19. @nfcnorth
20. @Owner Of A Lonely Heart - Mysti
21. @Revan Reborn
22. @Rottkins
23. @Sallucion
24. @Saturday - Vivo > Mysti
25. @Shrike - Mysti
26. @The Lukundo - Mysti
27. @TheAncientCenturion
28. @Traveling Swordsman
29. @Ultra
30. @Underworld Broker - Mango
31. @Vanya - Atlantic
32. @Vivo Diez
33. @~Mystic Serenade~


Execution leaderboard

Mysti - 6
Mango - 2

For both the lynch and execution, any candidates who don't vote will cast 2 votes against themselves.

Votes lock in 2 hours.
 
To make my stance fully clear here.

[Vote Lynch Lind].

Claims he can't be Mafia as per game rules.
While the rules also say that when you're gone you're gone and he apparently has a second chance just like that. And then Town can also put somebody on the lynch platform when the rules say only voters are eligible? I'm calling fucking bullshit there. You wanna tell me whatever he has is a Town role and that Town can break all rules of the game? And then he says he can't be Maf per the game rules while he himself claims to be a walking rule break. Kek.

I'm dying already, but at least let me take this obv scum with me to hell.
Wasnt it Vanya who put you there?
 
[Vote Lynch Flowa]

being rather explosive doesn't look well so far
Vote count

Spoiler: Lynch votes
1. @Admiral Fujitora - Flower
2. @Alibaba Saluja
3. @Alwaysmind - Broki
4. @AndrewGreve - Flower
5. @Atlantic Storm
6. @Cooler
7. @Draekke - Lind > Flower
8. @FLORIDA MAN
9. @Flower - Flower > Draekke > Hidden > Lind
10. @Hidden - Flower
11. @Ishmael - Flower
12. @JoJo - Flower
13. @Karma - Hidden
14. @Laix - Flower
15. @Legend
16. @Lind - Flower
17. @MangoSenpai
18. @Mich - Flower
19. @nfcnorth - Flower
20. @Owner Of A Lonely Heart - Lind
21. @Revan Reborn
22. @Rottkins
23. @Sallucion
24. @Saturday - Flower
25. @Shrike - Flower
26. @The Lukundo - Draekke
27. @TheAncientCenturion
28. @Traveling Swordsman
29. @Ultra
30. @Underworld Broker
31. @Vanya - Flower
32. @Vivo Diez
33. @~Mystic Serenade~


Lynch leaderboard

Flower - 13
Lind - 2

Spoiler: Execution votes
1. @Admiral Fujitora - Atlantic
2. @Alibaba Saluja
3. @Alwaysmind - Atlantic
4. @AndrewGreve
5. @Atlantic Storm
6. @Cooler
7. @Draekke - Atlantic
8. @FLORIDA MAN
9. @Flower
10. @Hidden - Atlantic
11. @Ishmael - Atlantic
12. @JoJo
13. @Karma - Mysti
14. @Laix - Mango
15. @Legend
16. @Lind - Mysti
17. @MangoSenpai
18. @Mich - Atlantic
19. @nfcnorth
20. @Owner Of A Lonely Heart - Mysti
21. @Revan Reborn
22. @Rottkins
23. @Sallucion
24. @Saturday - Vivo > Mysti
25. @Shrike - Mysti
26. @The Lukundo - Mysti
27. @TheAncientCenturion
28. @Traveling Swordsman
29. @Ultra
30. @Underworld Broker - Mango
31. @Vanya - Atlantic
32. @Vivo Diez
33. @~Mystic Serenade~


Execution leaderboard

Mysti - 6
Mango - 2

For both the lynch and execution, any candidates who don't vote will cast 2 votes against themselves.

Votes lock in 2 hours.
:catdankv2: my man, I know that I mix with everything around so I will always understand missing me, don't worry
 
Why does a Town need Town cred?

Smh, we've been over this many times, Flower.

After reading the Mars role, why are Rome and Mars with Hades who is a Greek god?

@The Lukundo food for thought for you for when I‘m gone^.

Mars was the planet, when submit, not the Roman God. It's less of a reach for Hades to be with Rome than the planet Mars.

So nobody listens to a thing I say. Wonderful. I‘m logging off. Have fun with your shit mislynch, then, I don‘t give a shit anymore. You have every fucking evidence that I‘m
Town right before your noses. Just look how quickly votes pile on me, nobody‘s defending me and you fucking know I‘m not so fucking dumb to make a claim I can‘t prove.

But yeah, Bye.

Whether you're sincere or not, Flower, I mentioned to you before that your position is just really unfortunate. Your claim was either false, or you had the perfect storm of abilities hit you. Either way there's not much you can do to "prove" anything, so saying there is a lot of evidence is untrue.

Also: If you were going to die N2 anyways, why are you so salty about being lynched D2? Once again I state the town wincon includes you even if you are dead.

At the time of the vote, no particular reason other than my superior color of observation.

It's just my 6th sense. I mentioned this too when Fuji asked.

I would go more into detail, but I would have to do some more comprehensive reading for that.

Mostly skimmed through today.


Not sure what to make of the travelling swordsman interaction with him tho, but I tend to agree more with Swordsman, assuming his story is true; which I haven't fact checked

You say that you tend to agree with TS in the TS v Draekke showdown, but then you hedge by saying "assuming his story is true" - read the posts, his story is my story. He admits to being in the thread during EOD. There's no fake story, he just doesn't like how I've spotted him in the thread. Aside from his timing, it was the fact that he didn't vote LG that was my issue with him. He's the one that turned the discussion into a farce.

I hate everyone who switched to the LG for no reasoning, u trying to defend them by arguing "Only town would do it! " does affect how shitty their vote is. Mafia can just as easily sheep the main wagon.

I hard town read The Lukundo. Hes actually being inquisitive and giving explanations for his reads.

Vanya is mechanically town i guess

Dont like Shrikes drop in activity. Hes a good player and id like to see more from him.

I like Linds boost in activity, still think hes an indie tho


I will also assume ur mafia if Hidden flips mafia. Ur portrayal of him sounds completely contrary from wut ive seen :pepesmoke

Stated many times already, this game is different than most. You can't use vote switching to the main pile as a scum read. I'm not saying scum CAN'T be on the pile, in fact I assume at least one is. But in a game where its beneficial for scum to not vote the pile (so as to remove themselves from next day lynch), there is a clear path to which is more likely to pile on - town.

I explained what I saw in Hidden, and others have also agreed. Are they mafia too, if Hidden flips mafia now?

I saw some of him vs draekke and it felt like newbie scum with the whole EoD vote stuff



I wouldn't be surprised since this is nf and a lot of things are possible, it'll come down to how the other rome person plays and if smth shady is going on, tho would be cool to have @Vanya 's opinion on his mason

Vanya could care less about his teammates, and that has been shown many times. He gave up Vivo at a moments notice early D2.

Good, no NK! Either a good save or other mechanic, the result is important ^^
I can finally play for a couple of hours (i am not home for the weekend)


I will go to read the day, if anyone can help me with a tl;dr it will be much appreciated

No Night Kill was likely due to people having multiple lives - as per Vanya, he was attacked and was bleeding to start D2.

the started from the bottom now we’re here chanteuse is someone whom i wouldn’t necessarily lynch but would definitely ask questions. is he a super active townie or taking the flower situation as an opportunity to power wolf?

he tried it with me and i was thinking of knocking him down a peg

X4LvE6H.gif

Who says I don't like being pegged, Queen? Bring it.

thanks for the insight on mango as i’ve never played with him before

as i said before i agree with his negative read on draekke. but i think the outcome of the flower lynch will absolutely determine the next phase

Tell me again what a Flower flips town provides us with? You seem to be tunneling pretty hard about who you would suspect, but if you read the whole thread, it was Vanya, the confirmed townie, who made her even eligible for the lynch (and proceeded to not vote her until much later).

he was being voted for execute so i cut that shit before it happened like with DDL

Buth hades role is meh at best lmao So no biggie

You're such an ass. Even a vanilla townie/rolecrushed townie still has the right and power to influence a game. Your power trip is long and winding, isn't it?

Meme vote or not, it did help make him a target.

Again. Do you think that wolf!Karma would do that to someone he knows to be wolf?

You're running with the assumption that mafia who their mates, but it's quite possible that LG was not known to his scummates. Not confirmed or anything, but it's silly to use this assumption for your scum tells.
 
You're running with the assumption that mafia who their mates, but it's quite possible that LG was not known to his scummates. Not confirmed or anything, but it's silly to use this assumption for your scum tells.
Yeah it feels like no one reads smh. LG probably knew his teammates, but it's very possible scum didn't know him. Not guarenteed sure because LG could just tell them it sounds like, but still.
 
You're running with the assumption that mafia who their mates, but it's quite possible that LG was not known to his scummates. Not confirmed or anything, but it's silly to use this assumption for your scum tells.
OK then boss.

Karma still hasn't been wolfy.

I do admit, a hard fucking majority from Karma is their connection to the LG flip, but they still have been pretty decent itt.

Without LG, I'd put them barely above null but above null all the same
 
89 pages :jerrykek

Are any power rangers in this game?

@Hayumi @Ekkologix @Shrike @Natalija

Can I get a tl;dr :kumabread
Sorry bruv, I am behind myself, glad you appeared tho - I voted to execute Mystic because I could never off a power ranger :catsalute

it’s flower

also any preliminary thoughts before the lynch goes through?
Flower is in the lead
Good, already voting her then.

Not sure about the thoughts because I don't have more than the ones I had before.

What happened to Flower catching a disease or some shit?
 
Sorry bruv, I am behind myself, glad you appeared tho - I voted to execute Mystic because I could never off a power ranger :catsalute



Good, already voting her then.

Not sure about the thoughts because I don't have more than the ones I had before.

What happened to Flower catching a disease or some shit?
Flower claims someone stole her flash, stopped her ability from working, and gave her a disease, which kills her tonight even though disease isn't a common thing on the glossary.
 
Sorry bruv, I am behind myself, glad you appeared tho - I voted to execute Mystic because I could never off a power ranger :catsalute



Good, already voting her then.

Not sure about the thoughts because I don't have more than the ones I had before.

What happened to Flower catching a disease or some shit?
it’s gonna kill her eventually

to her credit, could be scum trying to prevent her confirmation

but considering how sus she is, it’s probably a townie who thinks she’s scum imo.

i’m hoping she’s scum and not town though
 
Vivo literally thanked me for clearing him

Try again

To what? Prove that you don't give a shit about town or the rest of us? You've already done so.

To make my stance fully clear here.

[Vote Lynch Lind].

Claims he can't be Mafia as per game rules.
While the rules also say that when you're gone you're gone and he apparently has a second chance just like that. And then Town can also put somebody on the lynch platform when the rules say only voters are eligible? I'm calling fucking bullshit there. You wanna tell me whatever he has is a Town role and that Town can break all rules of the game? And then he says he can't be Maf per the game rules while he himself claims to be a walking rule break. Kek.

I'm dying already, but at least let me take this obv scum with me to hell.

You make a fair point here, but again to Lind's counterpoint - if when the games merge and the mafia merges, they are a top candidate to be removed via lynch or town ability.

Because I wasnt feeling the vote atm, and had scum vibes on Flower and from what ive read that hasnt changed in the day since.

That doesnt sound logical unless your abilities were tampered with. But still a excuse that scum would use to extend their time in the game.

I still dont even understood why you claimed Day. If you are trelling the truth (which I doubt) you made yourself a obvious nightime target.

I dont know moon speak

Hello old friend.

Well I don't think that's a very good answer. Have you read the lynch rules? Are you town? Would you agree that town's best chance is having as many people in the lynch pool?

If flower flips town it is gonna be absurdly bad play from her and i have 0 regrets with the lynch

Flower from the start decided to coast, her own words. Is that something a townie would do or plan to do? Hey guys i have this town role but i'm gonna throw it in the trash and cuck my own team from early d1

Absolutely absurdly bad play if town and borderline game throwing

Yes, which we all have agreed with.

I had a town lean on Draekke from d1. D2 his play is all over the place, I like he gives us focus to the thread and events but every argument he has is actually mind numbing, there’s very little contribution to any new scum hunting, he’s very present but not particularly novel, and he seems to be very on edge when people pressure him. All this, plus I sometimes get the feeling that he’s constantly paranoid not about other players, but about what people do in relation to him.

Laix and AM are pretty much topping my list too. But i think they’re gonna go away from the lynch again this round lmao

I hear you JoJo, and I don't disagree - but I had three separate players tunnel the fuck out of me today, either by trying to incriminate me over themselves (Flower), trying to go on a scumhunt to end all scumhunts by assuming his own outcomes (The Lukundo), and Traveling Swordsman's flailing attempt to cast doubt on my reasoning for being suspicious of him. They all continued to argue for pages. I'm not about to back down and change my game style because some people don't like it. Between these discussions and the need to some RnR IRL, I feel I've done a decent job promoting people to hunt (even if they still want to vote me), and to share my reads with the group.

Agreed on your scum tops.

Worst case scenario we remove flower from the game and this talk about her can stop

Next stop is Draeke. This guy is scummy from his first 5 posts and i want that resolved.

Common denominator = you. You put Flower up for lynch, causing the day to be sidelined, you are the one who can't not tunnel me, despite everything, despite there being many other scummy players, despite me trying to play nice with you. How can I translate this for you? You are tunnel visioning yourself into a corner, assuming you're right because you're confirmed town, and going against your biggest frustration, instead of continuing to scumhunt.
 
To what? Prove that you don't give a shit about town or the rest of us? You've already done so.



You make a fair point here, but again to Lind's counterpoint - if when the games merge and the mafia merges, they are a top candidate to be removed via lynch or town ability.



Well I don't think that's a very good answer. Have you read the lynch rules? Are you town? Would you agree that town's best chance is having as many people in the lynch pool?



Yes, which we all have agreed with.



I hear you JoJo, and I don't disagree - but I had three separate players tunnel the fuck out of me today, either by trying to incriminate me over themselves (Flower), trying to go on a scumhunt to end all scumhunts by assuming his own outcomes (The Lukundo), and Traveling Swordsman's flailing attempt to cast doubt on my reasoning for being suspicious of him. They all continued to argue for pages. I'm not about to back down and change my game style because some people don't like it. Between these discussions and the need to some RnR IRL, I feel I've done a decent job promoting people to hunt (even if they still want to vote me), and to share my reads with the group.

Agreed on your scum tops.



Common denominator = you. You put Flower up for lynch, causing the day to be sidelined, you are the one who can't not tunnel me, despite everything, despite there being many other scummy players, despite me trying to play nice with you. How can I translate this for you? You are tunnel visioning yourself into a corner, assuming you're right because you're confirmed town, and going against your biggest frustration, instead of continuing to scumhunt.
It amazes me you can open your mouth so often and turds keep falling down every time
 
OK then boss.

Karma still hasn't been wolfy.

I do admit, a hard fucking majority from Karma is their connection to the LG flip, but they still have been pretty decent itt.

Without LG, I'd put them barely above null but above null all the same
Dude, they even admit in the thread that the LG vote was just random/meme. That you use this to justify your read on them is silly.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top