Game Warcraft III: Eternity's End (mafia wins!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
Superman said:
I was unfairly replaced just to put it out there.
Click to expand...
you seem to love flags
so riddle me that
of what country is this flag???
latest
 
Dragon D. Luffy said:
You are overanalysing what is the normal reaction of a player who doesn't know SK to seeing SK.
Click to expand...
Drago was the host of my just concluded first game and knows I'm new to Mafia in general and NF Mafia in particular. He also shouldn't be surprised that I decided to lynch someone for claiming Scum since I do policy lynches.

I wonder why he'll react the way he did to expected behaviour. :thunk
 
Franky said:
Honestly, I feel the people using that as an easy ride are looking more and more scummy, especially the newer people who wouldn't be as aware of him claiming it all the time.
Click to expand...
I don't understand your logic.
Why would newer players who don't know that SK is apparently a troll (we shouldn't engage his trollishness), and decide to. lynch him based on him claiming Scum appear Scummy?

SK's behaviour is ordinarily Anti Town behaviour irrespective of his alignment. If a new player is unaware that SK's trollish play is tolerated, then why wouldn't they vote to lynch him.
 
Vote Count

Jayjay - Mr. Waffles
WolfPriceKouga - Luck
Cinera - SupremeKage
Dragon D. Luffy - Franky
Lewd - Cooler
RemChu - Luck
SupremeKage - SupremeKage
Cooler - Dragomir
MAD - Franky > SupremeKage
Jjcb - Cooler
Novaslinenever - Mr. Waffles
Franky - Cinera
Phantom Thief - Jayjay
Mexikorn - Luck
Alwaysmind - Luck
Avito - Nova
Dragomir - Agent Washington > Mr. Waffles
Mr. Waffles - SupremeKage
Maerala - Jayjay

Luck - 4
SupremeKage - 4
Mr. Waffles- 3
Cooler - 2
Jayjay - 2
Franky - 1
Dragomir - 1
Nova - 1
Cinera - 1

Self votes

@Luck
@Legend
@Oddjutsu
@Katsuargi
@Stelios
@Kira Yagami
@Lord Genome
@MyMind
@Dr. White
@Hyperion1O1
@shade0180
@Agent Washington
@Sweet Home

There are 4.5~ hours left until in the phase.​
 
Last edited:
MAD said:
yes
what mafia games have we >actually< policy lynched SK on Day 1

there might be like 1 game that i can’t recall but the ‘half dozen’ number seems blown way out of proportion

imo SK actually rolled scum this time and the amount of ppl defending his shitty antics is indicative of teammate defenses
Click to expand...

Wait are ppl defending the SK?
 
Shizune said:
:thunk
Click to expand...

Shizune said:
If day 1 were the normal 24 hours, you would already have missed it. I started extending my day ones specifically so that I could replace inactives as early as possible. If I weren't gonna start replacing people at the 24 hour mark I would just make day 1 24 hours... which you would have missed and gotten replaced anyways... do you see the problem?
Click to expand...

Fuck you. You know I was good on activity. You tucking doubted me with no tucking cause.
 
SupremeKage said:
Also just to point out, if I were actually scum I wouldn’t say I’m scum, even as a joke. Scum needs every support they could get. They would most likely check up on me before I even uttered a word in this thread.
Click to expand...

see the problem is if you only did this as town i would be like "this is just SK's trollerdog town meta"

but

SupremeKage said:
He is lamenting. I dropped the ball, I am scum :uguu
Click to expand...

MAD said:
1. SupremeKage Bruiser
2. Dr. White Leader
3. Reznor Fodder
4. iwandesu
5. Lord Genome Fodder
6. Stelios Moonlight Vigilante
7. Didi Pacifist
8. Roman Elite Bodyguard
9. Darth
10. RemChu Minion
11. Shiny Fodder
12. Kira Yagami Fodder
13. WolfPrinceKouga Assassin
14. Crugyr Survivalist
15. Mr. Waffles Bully
16. ~Mystic Serenade~ Motion Detector
17. jayjay32 ???
18. Melodie Mimic
19. Mohit Fodder
20. Nevan Extortionist
Click to expand...

so its time to claim if ur not
 
MyMind said:
Finally home and have read the thread. Seems like SK is getting lynched for trolling. But Cooler is more of a suspect for me. His proposal of getting a suspect vig kill and getting someone else lynched doesn't benefit town. It benefits scum.
Click to expand...

Bandwagoning a guy for trolling just seems like the easy way out. How many players have jumped on without contributing any reads or scumhunting? It's the coasters lynch for most part in my opinion. I stand by what I said, WPK made a good point about how scum could use this to protect SK - but I definitely wouldn't stick my neck out like this to protect SK.
 
SupremeKage said:
Also just to point out, if I were actually scum I wouldn’t say I’m scum, even as a joke. Scum needs every support they could get. They would most likely check up on me before I even uttered a word in this thread.
Click to expand...

99% of the time when SK is town he doesn’t defend himself and just stays on trolling. He said he’d be releasing his reads but jumps to debunk his trolling first.

Those, IMO, are better reasons to vote him.

[change vote Lynch Supremekage]
 
Agent Washington said:
So no one else even looked up Illidan? I'm not sure he's someone that would qualify as "evil" but he certainly sounds like the kind of person that could very well be a miller.
Click to expand...

Illidan doesn't betray anyone in the lore, in fact he was the one who killed Tichondrius to break the BL offensive on Mt Hyjal.

He just fucks off and leaves.
 
Agent Washington said:
From what I gathered he got branded a betrayer because he didn't tell anyone what the hell he was doing and wanted to undermine the Legion from within.
Click to expand...

Nah, he was branded Betrayer for doing the Well of Eternity shit. The Kaldorei were just salty with that issue.

He didn't try to even fight his big bro on the moment of banishment, just left after killing Tichondrius.

So Illidan's not evil (in this arc), just obsessed with power.
 
Cooler said:
Bandwagoning a guy for trolling just seems like the easy way out. How many players have jumped on without contributing any reads or scumhunting? It's the coasters lynch for most part in my opinion. I stand by what I said, WPK made a good point about how scum could use this to protect SK - but I definitely wouldn't stick my neck out like this to protect SK.
Click to expand...

Yes I agree that SK's an easy lynch and scum can easily bandwagon on it. However your solution to it screamed scum to me and you haven't really justified it so I'll be voting for you today.

[Vote lynch Cooler]
 
Cinera said:
Drago was the host of my just concluded first game and knows I'm new to Mafia in general and NF Mafia in particular. He also shouldn't be surprised that I decided to lynch someone for claiming Scum since I do policy lynches.

I wonder why he'll react the way he did to expected behaviour. :thunk
Click to expand...
Since when have you ever done policy lynches? You never talked anything about policy lynches in my game.

What expected behaviour? This is the first time I've seen you vote for someone for such a reason.

Cut the bullshit Cinera
 
MyMind said:
No you didn't. You only referred to WPK. You never said why you thought it was a good idea iirc.

It's scummy because the probability of getting two townies killed without scum moving a finger is high. SK gets vig killed and someone else gets lynched. Potential to kill two birds with no stone.
Click to expand...

I said why I thought it was a good idea :fitz9tail Read the thread man...

IMO it's a waste of a lynch to go for someone who's just going to troll and coast, we lynch SK and we have a vote where anyone can hide instead of actually scum hunting. If SK wants to troll then then he can be vigged, the day phase is the only time we have to interact and scumhunt we lose that advantage if people can just hop on the SK wagon with two lines of text.
 
Cooler said:
I said why I thought it was a good idea :fitz9tail Read the thread man...

IMO it's a waste of a lynch to go for someone who's just going to troll and coast, we lynch SK and we have a vote where anyone can hide instead of actually scum hunting. If SK wants to troll then then he can be vigged, the day phase is the only time we have to interact and scumhunt we lose that advantage if people can just hop on the SK wagon with two lines of text.
Click to expand...

Well thats a reason though not sure I agree with it. For two reasons.

1. In most mafia vig kills are limited no? Assuming thats the case in this game as well so why waste it on a known troll?

2. Lets assume we actually do decide on vigging SK. What now? Who do we have a strong case against? Anyone else that gets lynched has a high chance of being a townie because we don't have any leads atm.

You proposition is a dream play for scum. Sorry man but my vote stays.
 
MyMind said:
Well thats a reason though not sure I agree with it. For two reasons.

1. In most mafia vig kills are limited no? Assuming thats the case in this game as well so why waste it on a known troll?

2. Lets assume we actually do decide on vigging SK. What now? Who do we have a strong case against? Anyone else that gets lynched has a high chance of being a townie because we don't have any leads atm.

You proposition is a dream play for scum. Sorry man but my vote stays.
Click to expand...

1. I think it's better for any potential vig to eliminate a troll rather than pick names out of a hat and potentially hit a townie who is actually willing to contribute.

2. Well when I made those comments there was still plenty of time in the day phase, if the SK lynch hadn't have been such an easy wagon we might have ended up with other leads.

I really don't see how what I said is a dream play for scum but suit yourself.
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
Back
Top