Game Favorites '22 - GROUP 1

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
AndrewGreve said:
jojo, you think ishmeal or mich?
Click to expand...
I want mich to respond to me before I say them. I think it’s pretty obvious I’m not jester and then they try and misrepresent why I voted someone else when there’s quite a few reasons why someone would, like to have less votes when they’re a lead, to see how that person might react to vote, etc.

I actually believe it’s just a lapse in judgment and they read the situation wrongly. I.e. It’s a paranoid townie and they over read it. that’s my hope at least

Ish, i barely realized he even posted. He just came in and voted the most active poster and I can’t remember if he actually gave a good reason. That’s pretty sus and leans more scum than mich for me
 
Hidden said:
lol reading alwaysmind you're funny
Click to expand...
@nfcnorth be like:

1380163634-tumblr_m92g4pCSbK1ru96bco1_1280.jpg
 
Mich said:
I was working myself all day long and I try to find answers in my own way.
Yesterday I came home after Sod, when I posted my first post.
I don't w

I didn't have time to read much, I worked like a slave these days (i can give details but really doesn't matter why).
My bad, I took it the wrong way.

I would better sheep you if
Click to expand...
What i thought i deleted the first part. Oh wrll
 
AndrewGreve said:
the issue currently is that we need the scummy players to stack on the lynch, but thats not going to happen. Flower goes free gets two nights no problem.
Click to expand...
yeah lowkey I'm not sure if I'm a fan of the, only players who vote for the lynch can be voted, thing. I don't see much of a consequence for if mafia just refuses to vote together unless town has insane amounts of kills.
 
Hidden said:
yeah lowkey I'm not sure if I'm a fan of the, only players who vote for the lynch can be voted, thing. I don't see much of a consequence for if mafia just refuses to vote together unless town has insane amounts of kills.
Click to expand...

I dont want to gripe about the mod, after all the work they put into the game, but I dont understand what that mechanic it is trying to aside from change up the game.

I quite like the slank lynch tho
 
Hidden said:
yeah lowkey I'm not sure if I'm a fan of the, only players who vote for the lynch can be voted, thing. I don't see much of a consequence for if mafia just refuses to vote together unless town has insane amounts of kills.
Click to expand...
Such are the rules we need to live by, and honestly since nobody is consolidating their votes, aside from a few of us, things are going to be fucking difficult.
 
nfcnorth said:
There was an innocent child role in favorites once and no one trusted it not even a little bit just saying.

Also not very hard for mafia to say player x is town outside of their faction to buy towns trust which is often worth more than having a "confirmed" towine. Which is why it the combination of good old scum hunting and abilities that need to used not just one.
Click to expand...
An innocent child being doubted by the player base is the incompetence and paranoia of the player base.

Your second point about mafia saying player x is town can be judged further down the line. There's no need to tinfoil it right now and assume he's lying straight off the bat is my point here.

AndrewGreve said:
Ive played a lot of games with mich, and I believe she thought it was a scum peek.
Click to expand...
I'm going to be honest here.

I don't believe Ish of all players reads the rules or the opening posts of any games. In our PMs our roles are color coded and out wincon doesn't exist. At least for town. The alignment - color combo is in the opening post. So Ish coming in and saying he doesn't know if he is town or scum since his alignment isn't listed in his role PM is something I perceive as a town slip from him.

That's my belief.
 
AndrewGreve said:
the issue currently is that we need the scummy players to stack on the lynch, but thats not going to happen. Flower goes free gets two nights no problem.
Click to expand...
flower, ish, vanya (?), laix, DDL

all people i don’t mind seeing go

it doesn’t make sense to put a question mark next to someone i don’t mind seeing go, but i actually think they’re lying about “i can confirm myself tomorow!” but i’m probably gonna have to suck it up and avoid lynching them because if they’re useful then it’s too big of a loss for us

laix is screaming sus lmao, always loud but needs excuses for why they can’t contribute today. 100% scum or indie vibes from him.
 
Lind said:
An innocent child being doubted by the player base is the incompetence and paranoia of the player base.

Your second point about mafia saying player x is town can be judged further down the line. There's no need to tinfoil it right now and assume he's lying straight off the bat is my point here.


I'm going to be honest here.

I don't believe Ish of all players reads the rules or the opening posts of any games. In our PMs our roles are color coded and out wincon doesn't exist. At least for town. The alignment - color combo is in the opening post. So Ish coming in and saying he doesn't know if he is town or scum since his alignment isn't listed in his role PM is something I perceive as a town slip from him.

That's my belief.
Click to expand...
How many games he played?
I mean for a noob I can see this as true, but if he played few games, i can't
 
Rottkins said:
Zrzut_ekranu_2022-07-15_o_18.53.51.png

My sincere reaction, sorry didn't knew I will be absent away from home for so long
Click to expand...
The funny thing is I was just about to ask where you were.
 
Lind said:
An innocent child being doubted by the player base is the incompetence and paranoia of the player base.

Your second point about mafia saying player x is town can be judged further down the line. There's no need to tinfoil it right now and assume he's lying straight off the bat is my point here.


I'm going to be honest here.

I don't believe Ish of all players reads the rules or the opening posts of any games. In our PMs our roles are color coded and out wincon doesn't exist. At least for town. The alignment - color combo is in the opening post. So Ish coming in and saying he doesn't know if he is town or scum since his alignment isn't listed in his role PM is something I perceive as a town slip from him.

That's my belief.
Click to expand...
My larger point is that one action claim on an invest doesn't make a player. Rather their whole body of work or lack thereof in some cases should be used. People need to earn town cred in more than one way or else they aren't helping town as much they can be.
 
Hidden said:
My thing is like, we have 7 minutes to change from ishmael if it's going tobe someone else. There's not enough time unless like, everyone wants to pivot to LG RIGHT NOW
Click to expand...
Nitty just said that we have more time. Also, if we're going for LG who's a total null here, then we might as well go for any inactive since every role in the game has a 50% chance of flipping town / scum.

In that case, I might as well reduce the player base that refuses to contribute like the total inactives. Then we execute one more tomorrow and at least we're reducing the number of players that don't contribute anything that way.

Mich said:
How many games he played?
I mean for a noob I can see this as true, but if he played few games, i can't
Click to expand...
He's played a few, but I'm judging this from a personality point of view.

Hidden said:
to be fair there was an inno child that turned scum in a favorites game I played in I think lol
Click to expand...
Wouldn't that be kinda bastard lol? Unless he was converted of course.
 
Lind said:
Nitty just said that we have more time. Also, if we're going for LG who's a total null here, then we might as well go for any inactive since every role in the game has a 50% chance of flipping town / scum.

In that case, I might as well reduce the player base that refuses to contribute like the total inactives. Then we execute one more tomorrow and at least we're reducing the number of players that don't contribute anything that way.


He's played a few, but I'm judging this from a personality point of view.


Wouldn't that be kinda bastard lol? Unless he was converted of course.
Click to expand...
you're not wrong we could go for any inactive, but lg was the one with momentum behind it so when I thought we had 5 minutes left that seemed like the only actually viable alternative to ish
 
Dragon D. Luffy said:
[vote lynch DDL]

When I got fired from my first job, in 2017, my boss told me I spent too much time on my phone. I was mostly playing mafia.

I will never let that happen again. Ever.

And now in 2022 people keep trying to make me feel bad for not being active during work hours, though, every game I play. Here, and in the syndicate. I tell someone I will miss EoD and suddenly I'm scummy for that.

But I won't give in. This game is not more important than my life. It can't be.

Fuck off you all. I dont want to play mafia ever again.
Click to expand...
this was so emotional and so real. thank you for sharing!

[CHANGE VOTE LYNCH DDL]
 
Alwaysmind said:
Did you get to catch up @Rottkins ?
If so what are your thoughts?

might not, better post a few more so that you don’t become a lie poster
Click to expand...
I'm right now catching, I'm on 25th page, for now the most interests me I think Jojo and Vanya but it is just curiosity of where they go.


Mich said:
I love this drawing, you did it?
Click to expand...
yeah that's my work, I am the clown of mafia who mostly is a comedy relief while play :doggokek
 
Draekke said:
There's been plenty of examples of "innocent" roles being mafia and anti-town over the years. To assume any role is any alignment in a non-thematic role madness game is silly.
Click to expand...
Innocent roles as in host confirmed innocent child roles? I'm sure those games would have a bastard warning in the rules in that case.

I know that flavor =/= alignment in non-thematic games. I assumed that @Hidden was telling me about host confirmed innocent child roles in the thread. If he wasn't then my apologies for misunderstanding.

nfcnorth said:
My larger point is that one action claim on an invest doesn't make a player. Rather their whole body of work or lack thereof in some cases should be used. People need to earn town cred in more than one way or else they aren't helping town as much they can be.
Click to expand...
In this case, I believe we need to know what kind of result Vanya has on DDL to actually know if it was an investigation. I believe Vanya meant he that he knows DDL is town in a way that's beyond traditional investigations since he used the word "TMI".
 
JoJo said:
i don’t mind sheeping a wagon bc game mechanics

but voting for a player with no substance to analyze gets us nowhere tomorrow

mislynching a player and then seeing their posts with everyone > mislynching an inactive with nothing to go
Click to expand...
in a normal game 100%

we do have like a million night actions to lean on and like 1/3rd the game is super low content currently, we focus on players that are playing and you end up late game with a bunch of ??? players left.
 
AndrewGreve said:
in a normal game 100%

we do have like a million night actions to lean on and like 1/3rd the game is super low content currently, we focus on players that are playing and you end up late game with a bunch of ??? players left.
Click to expand...
I didn’t say vote active people the entire time. This bandwagon is just sus and feels like a way to distract from any real progress. Town always perform best when we have public information and actual confirmation. Whether ish, DDL, me, etc got lynched is inconsequential to the fact that despite this very low content we’ve actually had lots of minute interactions where people always shilled for another person or strongly against another

i can be too aggressive a player, but lynching an afk is a yawn fest. we can nuke them from orbit in the future.

and i hate to say this bc of what i just said, but yeah i’ll wagon today for the mechanics but i feel like we can do better
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 5 (members: 1, guests: 4)
Back
Top