Game Favorites '22 - GROUP 1

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Why is the game divided in 2 btw?
Too many players to have it balanced properly is my guess. There were dome pretty wild suggestions as always this year.
 
To make it more playable and less chaotic. Just imagine 70 players playing in one thread.
That and it’s easier for players to read 30 pages then 70.
 
???????????????????

115735.jpg
 
Favs 5 had 50% town, but that game had 3 scum factions. This one has 2, so I expect between 60% and 70% town

The more scum factions, the less townies.

The more powerful roles are overall, the less townies.
I just hope there's no team merger like in Aries games. Stuff like that is so annoying to deal with.
 
What are your first impressions?

Nobody really jumps my eyes as scum (I'm not great at reading ppl).

Draekke is okay-ish but not that hard for scum to fake. Lukundo is more organic. Not sure about Andrew my vote is kind of a placeholder. Everybody else is mostly fluffing or didn't catch my radar so I dunno.

When are the host posts full of actions gonna start? This is Favs not vanillafia.
 
Nobody really jumps my eyes as scum (I'm not great at reading ppl).

Draekke is okay-ish but not that hard for scum to fake. Lukundo is more organic. Not sure about Andrew my vote is kind of a placeholder. Everybody else is mostly fluffing or didn't catch my radar so I dunno.

When are the host posts full of actions gonna start? This is Favs not vanillafia.
So you have no opinion on the top posters yet?
 
I did not check the list of top posters before saying that. So I guessed the 2nd and 3rd (Vanya and AM).

So Flower is the first, huh. I don't remember thinking anything about you, though. Now I'm suspicious. Feels like you have been kinda participating but kinda fluffling at the same time.
That's how I roll :catjam .
 
See this is kind of stuff why I like to fluff to early.

Because there is always someone that takes early fluff and getting to know everyone as core gameplay and decides to make reads based on it.

It serves no purpose what so ever to do that and make judgements this early, it only serves to sow dissent and later on undoubtedly lead to a fluff lynch

These reads aren't even reads, it is just retelling of what happened
I've always been a proponent that there is no fluff necessary in a mafia game, and as such I will always poke and prod those who fluff. If you're not scumhunting, then you're not doing your job as town. You're right, I didn't have much read to base anything on, as I mentioned. I just posted the few people who I was able to get any kind of pattern or learn any information on.

And guess what - I feel like I've learned a ton about several players since I posted that. Put out bait, let people take it, reel in information. I'm going to answer a few questions and responses people had for me, then I'll sum up what I feel I've learned.
 
Page one has never really been a serious page. Which is also why I unvoted on Page 1.

And I don't see how defending Rome constitutes as "don't contribute". If you think so, I might need to classify you as a collaborator into this Rome bashing treason.
I said it wasn't a contribution, because I see no real reason to just randomly claim to believe Vanya, just based on himself dropping the word town in connection to a persona he's putting on.
 
Catching up was quite fun. I go for the glory of rome!


Most of these don't tell us what you're reading the player as except for maybe Jojo.

But since you're confused about each players style, yes, it's quite normal for TAC and Ali to start with fluff and role play. The others start with fluff, too. And honestly, I believe fluff at least gets the game going and introduces the players to each other.

I would have actually liked a read on Owner of a lonely heart if you wanted to do this since they seem to have a post or two trying to ascertain the alignment of players.


Oh, why is that?
Thanks for the heads up, that's fair. I really dislike fluff for fluff's sake, but I know it's a part of the game. I use that as stepping stone to pressure people though.
 
I'm talking about you

Here is first defence of Draeke followed by statement we can ignore his slot for now. That's wasnt a suggestion or an opinion, it was a statement and a soft command to steer the game away from draeke


Your second defense of Draeke

Your third defense of Draeke

You are defending Draeke quite a bit over simplest of lines of questioning we have for him. You are sure he is town yet you don't wanna wait for him to come and defend himself and you "suggest" us to not pursue it further

Draeke read i had at first was slim but enough to go for, but seeing you now makes me way more interested in Draeke than i was before

So what is it? Scum Buddies or You scum "protecting" a townie you can call back on if things go south=
I guess I'm biased, since AG's read on me is town, but dude is one of the only others in this thread that seems to be trying to analyze posts and scumhunt, so I have AG as town for now.
 
I note that @Karma is not on this list who had 2 posts when you made the list, however, @Saturday only had 1 and yet found itself on it.

Kind of odd to mention one low poster and ignores another in such a detailed summary of Day 1 so far.
Fair, I included Saturday because of a one post vote drop and out. Wanted to see how they would react. I never said I only posted those with more than 1 post, just that many others didn't catch my interest.
 
Fair enough, but FWIW, all of this "follow Rome, he's obv town" stuff makes me feel nervous. Anyone can throw in some RP and claim town. Makes me trust him less.
Fair enough. Though I‘ve played quite a number of games with the guy and know his meta quite well (we started playing on the same site a few years ago). I say he‘s Town. At least I haven‘t seen any of his scum tells yet.
 
Fair enough, but FWIW, all of this "follow Rome, he's obv town" stuff makes me feel nervous. Anyone can throw in some RP and claim town. Makes me trust him less.
I think vanya's body of work so far this game shows a town mindset. I think his push on you was prob NAI, but interactions and push on me was very towny.

I basically ignored his flavor/fluff, aside from being worried it wasnt going to end.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top