Game Favorites '22 - GROUP 1

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Vanya - has been very defensive whenever someone confronts them, or goes against their thought process (re AG v Rome). AG has been nothing but a town read, and you seeing him disagree with your thoughts about me for some reason made you go on the defensive. And then you called him out for backing off and called him weak. Why is that? The Ancient Centurion also didn't like your shtick and you got defensive there too.

Alwaysmind - unsure about how I feel about AM, tbh. I don't like the fall-in with Vanya, and believing in the slight claim. But I don't necessarily feel scum from them either yet. You also kinda put words into Saturday's mouth about what he was saying was annoying - are you projecting?

Jojo - I feel that at the very best, a blind strategy hurts town, and at worst covers for mafia. Hope your posts change soon.

Laix - nothing I haven't seen from Laix before, seems to be the same playstyle I've been used to, albeit slightly toned down so far

Flower - honestly, and this may sound bad, but I do not get a town read from Flower. He's been posting mostly fluff, and when he doesn't, it's regurgitating the Rome shtick. I don't like this. Maybe mafia, maybe indy. Could be town, but I think his posts have been not helping.

LG - posting nothing at this point. Feigning ineptitude or lack of desire? I know you to be a strong player, but I know you to start slow as well.

Karma - few posts, don't have much of a read yet. Don't think your question about my profile pic was odd like AG. But I suppose its a good way to deflect.

Saturday - Feel good about your second stint in the thread so far.

Admiral Fujitora - Honestly the thing that gives me the best read on you so far is that the Rome crew is after you lol. And to answer your question, I'm Canadian, so I'm not exactly keen on US taking over lol.

Alibaba Saluja - 99.9% fluff posts, and has said they are happy that they have a higher post count than the mod. Trying to make sure you look active without contributing. Others have said it's your style, but do you have any reads or anything to add?

The Ancient Centurion - full town read right now. Trying to sus out scum, calls out fluff. I like your style sir.

Lind - reads town based on their responses to some of the reads and calmly discussing people.

AndrewGreve - full town read again for now. Questions the Rome wagon and gets steamrolled for it. Trying to learn info. Helpful to town.

The Lukundo - I think town read for now, but your reads are all opposite mine. Again though, you're trying, and that's helpful.


That's all I got for now.
 
If this is true, you're trusting Vanya too much.
Until proven wrong, I see no reason why the eternal city should be scum. We are all townies until proven otherwise. If anything, Rome is indie that will try to conquer us one by one.
 
@Flower I think ultra is fine so far.

is there something specific you looking from him, or just need more in general?

curious as to why you have been pestering that slot for more
It‘s because Ultra has a certain tell. I think he‘s alright so far, too. As scum he usually makes some weak push on me and then dips. That he‘s interacting with me is a good sign lol.
 
I don't know, when someone comes out right out the gate claiming town, that reads scum to me. But not the obvious scum, the WIFOM scum that assumes you won't make that assumption.
It’s more that scums don’t reveal flavour day 1, you know,
 
I feel that some people rely too heavily on meta. It's not THAT hard to adjust your game slightly once you learn of it.
That’s why I dislike MU, everyone is « what’s your meta? I don’t know you!!!! »
 
@Ultra what are your reads so far?
I could have sworn he made a post with them? Unless I confused two profile pics. The curse of playing in a phone.
Hefty assumption. I know several people who would use that against you.
I mean you can call out my bad read of Rome as town but we can also go back to your bad reads as well.
 
Hefty assumption. I know several people who would use that against you.
How many are there in that scum chat? Just curious. You said you know many people, which implies that there are more than 5
 
I could have sworn he made a post with them? Unless I confused two profile pics. The curse of playing in a phone.

I mean you can call out my bad read of Rome as town but we can also go back to your bad reads as well.
Correct, this is how we progress the game. Make reads, call out bad reads, etc. My bad reads have been that they weren't really reads. Your read here is that you are believing someone who alignment claimed Day 1. It's one thing to assume all are townies until otherwise discovered, but to believe a claim like his so quickly is rather sus to me.
 
Correct, this is how we progress the game. Make reads, call out bad reads, etc. My bad reads have been that they weren't really reads. Your read here is that you are believing someone who alignment claimed Day 1. It's one thing to assume all are townies until otherwise discovered, but to believe a claim like his so quickly is rather sus to me.
I simply do not think scums would reveal flavour of their role Day one and bring attention to them. Now alignment wise, I had completely forgotten about the possibility on indiehood, so Rome could be indiescum and as such a threat to town.

it’s also strange that Rome didn’t react to my Brennus comment earlier. Really, really strange.
 
Nice try, but I'm talking about posters in general, like my brother Law, some of the OG members like WAD or LG could easily make this strategy work.
I broke WAD 6 years ago lol
 
Everyone always calls me scum there except for dya and Ratchet lol. But I‘m literally always Town.
Sorry again I ever doubted you lol
 
Ofc I am. I haven‘t been scum all year and it pisses me off.
You are pissed that you are town?

does not feel like a loyal townie to me.
 
I feel both of your answers aren't the same reasoning. That you didn't have an actual reason. That didn't feel townie
My reasoning to share my opinion starts and stops with "the more information the group has, the better." Best way I can show my usefulness to town is to speak my mind and to let others pick it apart if that's the case. Day 1 reads will always be lacking, but can still be useful - even if you think I'm lying, it's STILL useful information to have; if I get steamrolled for speaking my mind, and drop as town, then you'll know who to look at. If I drop as scum, then again you'll have information to use.
 
For example, if @Kvothe Kingkiller is lynched on day 1, then on day 2, only people who voted for Kvothe are eligible for the lynch
What happens if all of the players who vote Kvothe are confirmed town ? (based on night activities for example, investigation, tracking, etc). It is guaranteed we would have a misslynch
Lynch two will be referred to as "the execution," and may only be applied to the four living players who had the lowest post count at the beginning of that day
Same what happens if those 4 players with the least post count are town confirmed because of night activities (investigation, tracking ability, etc) we would have another misslynch

If there are confirmed scums who have post count more than those 4 players and don't vote for Kvothe, can we vote them?
 
What happens if all of the players who vote Kvothe are confirmed town ? (based on night activities for example, investigation, tracking, etc). It is guaranteed we would have a misslynch

Same what happens if those 4 players with the least post count are town confirmed because of night activities (investigation, tracking ability, etc) we would have another misslynch

If there are confirmed scums who have post count more than those 4 players and don't vote for Kvothe, can we vote them?

No, the rules are clear.
 
Scrawny, give me more meat.

I'll have two number 9s, a number 9 large, a number 6 with extra dip, a number 7, two number 45s, one with cheese, and a large soda.
Bruh, it‘s 3am. I ain‘t writing a wallie now.

Those are just my strongest first impressions so far. I tell you more tomorrow when I wake up.
 
@Shizune Hey I like petite too, it's just not the moment for it.

Bruh, it‘s 3am. I ain‘t writing a wallie now.

Those are just my strongest first impressions so far. I tell you more tomorrow when I wake up.
I'll hold you to that.

WALL-Eposter.jpg
 
I see so if there is a confirmed scum on day 2 (based on night activities like tracking, investigation on night 1) and that player doesn't vote on day 1 and has the highest post count that player cannot be lynched
Yes so Imo paying attention to who's avoiding votes EOD tbh, ideally be nice if everyone voted the same wagon when we get to it.
 
Yes so Imo paying attention to who's avoiding votes EOD tbh, ideally be nice if everyone voted the same wagon when we get to it.
it really shifts the game to encouarge consolidating on one wagon EOD, and town would ideally punish players that avoid the EOD wagon with kill power.

idk the lynch thing is complicated in a really complicated game. Prob just mafia sided since town would really need to organize to punish anything mafia did to take advantage of it.
 
What happens if all of the players who vote Kvothe are confirmed town ? (based on night activities for example, investigation, tracking, etc). It is guaranteed we would have a misslynch

Same what happens if those 4 players with the least post count are town confirmed because of night activities (investigation, tracking ability, etc) we would have another misslynch

If there are confirmed scums who have post count more than those 4 players and don't vote for Kvothe, can we vote them?
I see so if there is a confirmed scum on day 2 (based on night activities like tracking, investigation on night 1) and that player doesn't vote on day 1 and has the highest post count that player cannot be lynched
Day 1 is important. If there is no scum who vote for popular wagon and no scum among 4 players with the least vote count, tomorrow is a guarantee misslynch even if someone finds who is scum based on night action.
Am I going crazy or have you been repeating the same general thing.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top