Game Favorites '22 - GROUP 1

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
oh and @JoJo

[VOTE LYNCH Flower]

if she flips scum, lynch me tomorrow

if she flips town, you're getting the noose bby

djoDYMT.gif
Sorry, but I don't buy that you would say this line without trying to get some town cred. Only reason for you to do so.
 
Why not ask people who are more familar with my scum play, then?
two things:

1) outside perspectives can often find things that someone familiar may miss
2) unlike most mafia players, I could give two shits about meta. I can change my behaviour when typing, I know several others who can as well. Meta might be somewhat useful, but should not always be used as a smoking gun.
 
two things:

1) outside perspectives can often find things that someone familiar may miss
2) unlike most mafia players, I could give two shits about meta. I can change my behaviour when typing, I know several others who can as well. Meta might be somewhat useful, but should not always be used as a smoking gun.
So why did you let other people‘s meta reads influence your take on Vanya, then?
 
It was the wrong move though. Just an FYI.
I have those regrets too. Where I pointed out scum, convinced people to vote for him, but then second guessed myself and changed my vote turns out I correctly called out scum didn't vote him, he still gets lynched at least and then I get thoroughly questioned the next day for not going through with it. Been there, done that.
 
I have those regrets too. Where I pointed out scum, convinced people to vote for him, but then second guessed myself and changed my vote turns out I correctly called out scum didn't vote him, he still gets lynched at least and then I get thoroughly questioned the next day for not going through with it. Been there, done that.
I'm just saying its slightly different in this game because of lynch mechanics. We can't rely on the usual tells surrounding the lynch.
 
it wasn't their meta reads, it was their town reads.
Which were based on…? Clearly not on Townie behaviour because acc to you Vanya wasn‘t acting like Town and you suspected him. So why believe sth you didn‘t agree on? If I can‘t see where somebody‘s coming from, why believe in that?

Fwiw [Unvote].

I actually think you‘re not scum here. After our back and forth you gave me the impression that you‘re more of an overly paranoid Townie who should have more faith in people and what they say.
 
Fair enough, of the people who didn't change their vote, who do you find most suspicious? Or do you want to wait on that until more of your questions are answered?
I posted it fairly early in the day, but Laix, Alwaysmind, and TravelingSwordsman all were around at EOD and didn't have their vote on LG, and combined with their lame reasoning, they are all on my radar. Legend also was part of this group at EOD D1, but he has yet to post today to answer.
 
Which were based on…? Clearly not on Townie behaviour because acc to you Vanya wasn‘t acting like Town and you suspected him. So why believe sth you didn‘t agree on? If I can‘t see where somebody‘s coming from, why believe in that?

Fwiw [Unvote].

I actually think you‘re not scum here. After our back and forth you gave me the impression that you‘re more of an overly paranoid Townie who should have more faith in people and what they say.
you really haven't been reading, as I've rehashed this over and over again.

I didn't 100% believe that Vanya was town, even with my town leans reading him town, but I still pressed him without voting for him. your equating scumreads and voting and pressuring needing to be on the same person here is why I feel there's a disconnect between what we're saying to each other.
 
I posted it fairly early in the day, but Laix, Alwaysmind, and TravelingSwordsman all were around at EOD and didn't have their vote on LG, and combined with their lame reasoning, they are all on my radar. Legend also was part of this group at EOD D1, but he has yet to post today to answer.
legend is probably one of the coasting scum. puts on a vote to look like he's doing something and then recedes into the background

also

@Shrike when you get a chance to read the dayphase, thoughts?
 
I posted it fairly early in the day, but Laix, Alwaysmind, and TravelingSwordsman all were around at EOD and didn't have their vote on LG, and combined with their lame reasoning, they are all on my radar. Legend also was part of this group at EOD D1, but he has yet to post today to answer.
On one hand, lynching a no poster is kind of risky. If we didn't get lucky, I think a serious drawback is everyone is questioning you the next day of "why did you switch to them?" When in all seriousness, you won't potentially have a good reason for doing so and would end up looking scummy and end up being available to be on the chopping block.

Like you said, we can't necessarily go off of our regular voting conclusions. I think in some cases if a player has a decent town or scum role etc. there's still probably at least a tiny inkling to want to protect it, and avoiding the main wagon is a way to do it.

Yes, it's scummy that they were there and didn't switch, but I think more than one conclusion can be drawn here.

But like you are doing, we do need to ask more and more questions and get answers.
 
Which were based on…? Clearly not on Townie behaviour because acc to you Vanya wasn‘t acting like Town and you suspected him. So why believe sth you didn‘t agree on? If I can‘t see where somebody‘s coming from, why believe in that?

Fwiw [Unvote].

I actually think you‘re not scum here. After our back and forth you gave me the impression that you‘re more of an overly paranoid Townie who should have more faith in people and what they say.
adjusting reads based on your town core's consensus is very reliable.
 
Tho ill still go for draeke and laix post flower
Aside from them voting for DDL, what's scummy about Draeke? He might be a bit tryhard, but idk if I see a definite reason to vote for him. I'd have reread again; they seem to be really solvy to me.

From my reads list from yesterday, Lind has moved into to null or slight scum. When I asked in the thread about Lind being in both groups, I was wondering if that was typo or if the mod had copied the wrong name over since Lind was somehow listed as 17 in both spots with it being alphabetically order if memory serves.

But with it not being a typo and I haven't seen Lind yet [vote lynch Lind]

We need to get some wagons going so that people have time to actually think about voting for people instead of just last minute, cause clearly not everyone is willing to switch last minute.
 
So I'm writing this early in the morning of the night phase but hard apologies for not being around after. I thought it was 48 rather than 24 so when I went to check the thread at the like 27 mark, day was over. My bad. Writing the catchup now tho

I didn't like Draekke's answer in P#585 due to "Trying to make my thoughts clear to the group to help Town" and "It was a plan to get reactions all along" aren't the same thing. One is saying that they were just meant to help in themselves and the other is saying they were setup and overall it feels like a bollocks way to read someone. @AndrewGreve Resonse to P#609

Also, I should probably say now, I did see the flip of LG was a wolf. I know the other guy is Town but I don't know who they are so I'm not gonna check and just try and work as purely as I can within that.

51 PAGES AND I'M AT 21? Fuck me.

Owner's reply in P#657 is really Townie. Feels honest and makes the read in the first place feels legit and a personal way they actually used to find JoJo's alignment.

Owner reads list Owner reads list Owner reads list

Drakkae one sucks but ofc it does for me. Wanna have Lind explained cause I didn't really pick up anything on them yet. I'll try keep an eye out for them now tho. I'm kinda happy with AG being in the TRs tbh. nfc is a gut read so /shrug. @Owner Of A Lonely Heart Is there anything specific about why you SR Vanya?

Fuck me, JoJo actually gives proper shit... (P#715)

Let's read.

Alright, the Flower one is a lot of words and can be rounded up to "They're fluff posting" which isn't anything new.

Do kinda like tho that they started making reads on the top posters first.

AG: Yeah, nah. I don't think AG's read on Drakke is TMI. I think they're most of the time same alignment. If they're ever not the same alignment, I think AG is just wrong and Draekke is a wolf. I don't see it as AG's a wolf TMI'ing Draekke. That's a strange hill to die on as he didn't hard TR Drakkae earlier and I don't think a wolf would ever try and make pressure on a townie go away, even if they TR them. If you're doing a TMI villager read, you'd give the read and go on with your day and claim credit later. That feels like a kinda shitty read from JoJo, no offence.

Bro, P#729

I don't like the thought of getting burned if Vanya ever does flip wolf but cmon...

Looking at Vanya/Drakkae on page 25 vs Vanya/AG on page whatever, I think Draekke is actually wolfy unlike I did AG. With AG it felt like a clash of ideals or personalities or summat like I said earlier. This time it does actually feel like a clash of alignments. and I don't think this is Kundo's unconscious scumread of Draekke kicking in. It probably doesn't help but I do think Draekke looks bad from this.

@JoJo P#746

Aye, it feels like you fuck around a lot. Memey, wolfy. idk how to explain it properly so I'm just gonna lump it on someone else. @Mich It's like Manti from MU.

AG, all that part of the scumread from you is "I'm not here" and if that's your reasoning for SR'ing me when you asked me questions or stuff happened when I wasn't here, piss off.

@Flower P#766

Why the Fuji SR? Just vibes? I really dislike that Alibaba read from you purely cause "No scum tells" doesn't exactly mean Town lean. Do like your hesitancy to that tho with "Maybe"

Flower, the amount of reads you have listed to the actual reads is really fuckin low, dude.

I still probably have you as Town cause I have liked you mostly.

This thing between Admiral and Flower is really fuckin boring BTW and it's just going in circles.

Do I want to TR DDL cause man is blantly just following me? (P#813) Yeah, tbh. I do. I don't know anything about him *but* I think that if it's AI at all, it's villa indicative.

BRO

Lind is towny as shit. (P#814) Jfc.

What's that now: Vanya/Lind/Flower/Owner/Always(?)/DDL(?)

I do actually like that group.

Fuck me, catching up is a pain in the arse.

HELL YEAH, MICHELLE WALL.

AND IT'S ABOUT ME

@Mich The "I tried" thing was that, I couldn't even try to lie about being able to get a read there. At that point in time, I didn't see a single thing I could properly read him for.

Is Michelle actually improving on reading me? You going back into Godread territory?

Maybe.

We'll see another game.

I should probably reread the wall to get a read on Mich FML.

I'll be real, none of P#871 is nothing you can't fake but I did like it.

Laix isn't townie. I ain't calling them scum but if someone has a TR on them before P#909 I'd love to hear the reasoning to it.

ACTUALLY SHIT

So

I don't have a read on Karma. Ain't actually read P#932 yet but I do remember Karma specifically as "This guy was at LG's throat for like literally no reason" and now considering LG's flip, I'm going to just assume Karma as villager.

Time to actually read the post tho.

@Karma Why have/had you got Flower/AG as your highest towns?

That thing on AM actually is nice to know. Doesn't help a bit cause it means he's more likely scummy and I would rather have been right on my read but is nice to know.

Centurion's read abut killing Vanya and Flower is pain.

P#953 from AG is kinda bad. I get being annoyed but that line specifically just feels bad.

P#983 is maybe bad when there's a scum lynch at EoD. This is a reach read tho so take it lightly.

Really really liked P#1018 from nfcnorth

I know I keep bitching about catching up but fuck me, I'm on 35 and I still have like 16 to go.

Shit, Vivo's gaming?

Mich feels much more statement-y rather than inquisitive or ready but meh. I don't have a decent read on her yet. (As of P#1080)

BTW, confident that JoJo/Mich isn't W/W. Unsure if either are properly wolf (maybe JoJo but that would be a reach now) but if either do flip wolf, the other isn't partners.

P#1085 from Hidden is the exact type of shit a wolf would say about their partner.

P#1140 doesn't make sense with a previous pst of JoJo's when they're going at Mich saying shit like "Are **you** scum buddies with Lukundo?" Either they don't believe the read or it isn't a read and it's straight up shade. Again, I don't have a read on Mich but I really dislike this from JoJo. The other post I'm talking about BTW is: P#1101

I do not like Hidden's EoD. - Shit like P#1194.

This shit ain't townie.

Hidden can go after Draekke and JoJo.

10 PAGES LEFT BBBBBBBBBBBBB!!!

bruh, EoD Lind townier than Vanya tbh. Get fucked.

Gotta love AG literally asking Michelle for their reads on me, seeing them, TR'ing Michelle and then while acknowledging that Mich can read me better, proceeds to not TR me.

I do not get @Rottkins read on Vanya in P#1282 You give a couple of town points, one question mark and then lean him scum?

"AG defending Vanya"? wut.

I does kinda vibe with Rottkins apart from that Vanya thing tho.

Looking at the stuff tho in P#1309

Hidden and JoJo are both on LG.

Two of my SRs are on the voted scum.

BUT

I like my reasons for voting them more.

So fuck you.

AND DRAEKKE?

Am I just playing horribly this game?

I might be wrong on JoJo out of any SRs IMO. Every time I see a Laix post, more parts of me and more parts of me are digging to SR it. I can't find a valid reason so as of yet, I'm not but my head wants to and idk why.

But that gut shit that's going on, if right, probably would mean JoJo is Town cause I don't think I've seen anyone give a slightest SR on Laix apart from JoJo.

At day end now so I want to list my reads. Also seeing DDL was the townie that got lynched is rough but it is what it is.

Lind is my top town. Every time they speak they feel townie. I fuckin love it. Hard TR

Vanya is close up there too for a lot of the same reasons. But more to Vanya is that vs Drakkae, they felt like Town. Their words were townie, their posts were townie. I really liked it. Hard TR

Then is probably Owner. I really liked their response about their JoJo read. Felt genuine af and gets them at hard town lean.

Now it's Flower. Liked him early game and I felt a decent chunk of what he said wouldn't come from scum. Decent TL.

Karma is town as well.

Why?

Cause LG flipped wolf.

Then is Always. I'm taking in context from someone saying that uncooperative AM is town but I do feel that he is just townie. It isn't a lot but it's enough.

For scum we have Draekke/JoJo/Hidden. In that order.

Disliked Draekke early day. Disliked JoJo with Mich, disliked Hidden EoD.

Alright.

That's it. Show's over.

Good job I'm not dead to post this shit cause this took me over a fuckin hour.

What's the story, Balamory?
 
What do you think so far? I enjoy playing with you, so I wanna talk.
I think Drakke needs to chill out a bit.

I honestly want to see what becomes of you as the day go on. I’m wary of you but that’s out if respect.

im catching up still and getting into the game. Give me time. I actually have time to play for a bit.

oh I did notice Jojo. I like them. They aren’t as aggressive as Drakke but they’re definitely on it and poke for information in a town like way so I’m liking them.
 
So I'm writing this early in the morning of the night phase but hard apologies for not being around after. I thought it was 48 rather than 24 so when I went to check the thread at the like 27 mark, day was over. My bad. Writing the catchup now tho

I didn't like Draekke's answer in P#585 due to "Trying to make my thoughts clear to the group to help Town" and "It was a plan to get reactions all along" aren't the same thing. One is saying that they were just meant to help in themselves and the other is saying they were setup and overall it feels like a bollocks way to read someone. @AndrewGreve Resonse to P#609

Also, I should probably say now, I did see the flip of LG was a wolf. I know the other guy is Town but I don't know who they are so I'm not gonna check and just try and work as purely as I can within that.

51 PAGES AND I'M AT 21? Fuck me.

Owner's reply in P#657 is really Townie. Feels honest and makes the read in the first place feels legit and a personal way they actually used to find JoJo's alignment.

Owner reads list Owner reads list Owner reads list

Drakkae one sucks but ofc it does for me. Wanna have Lind explained cause I didn't really pick up anything on them yet. I'll try keep an eye out for them now tho. I'm kinda happy with AG being in the TRs tbh. nfc is a gut read so /shrug. @Owner Of A Lonely Heart Is there anything specific about why you SR Vanya?

Fuck me, JoJo actually gives proper shit... (P#715)

Let's read.

Alright, the Flower one is a lot of words and can be rounded up to "They're fluff posting" which isn't anything new.

Do kinda like tho that they started making reads on the top posters first.

AG: Yeah, nah. I don't think AG's read on Drakke is TMI. I think they're most of the time same alignment. If they're ever not the same alignment, I think AG is just wrong and Draekke is a wolf. I don't see it as AG's a wolf TMI'ing Draekke. That's a strange hill to die on as he didn't hard TR Drakkae earlier and I don't think a wolf would ever try and make pressure on a townie go away, even if they TR them. If you're doing a TMI villager read, you'd give the read and go on with your day and claim credit later. That feels like a kinda shitty read from JoJo, no offence.

Bro, P#729

I don't like the thought of getting burned if Vanya ever does flip wolf but cmon...

Looking at Vanya/Drakkae on page 25 vs Vanya/AG on page whatever, I think Draekke is actually wolfy unlike I did AG. With AG it felt like a clash of ideals or personalities or summat like I said earlier. This time it does actually feel like a clash of alignments. and I don't think this is Kundo's unconscious scumread of Draekke kicking in. It probably doesn't help but I do think Draekke looks bad from this.

@JoJo P#746

Aye, it feels like you fuck around a lot. Memey, wolfy. idk how to explain it properly so I'm just gonna lump it on someone else. @Mich It's like Manti from MU.

AG, all that part of the scumread from you is "I'm not here" and if that's your reasoning for SR'ing me when you asked me questions or stuff happened when I wasn't here, piss off.

@Flower P#766

Why the Fuji SR? Just vibes? I really dislike that Alibaba read from you purely cause "No scum tells" doesn't exactly mean Town lean. Do like your hesitancy to that tho with "Maybe"

Flower, the amount of reads you have listed to the actual reads is really fuckin low, dude.

I still probably have you as Town cause I have liked you mostly.

This thing between Admiral and Flower is really fuckin boring BTW and it's just going in circles.

Do I want to TR DDL cause man is blantly just following me? (P#813) Yeah, tbh. I do. I don't know anything about him *but* I think that if it's AI at all, it's villa indicative.

BRO

Lind is towny as shit. (P#814) Jfc.

What's that now: Vanya/Lind/Flower/Owner/Always(?)/DDL(?)

I do actually like that group.

Fuck me, catching up is a pain in the arse.

HELL YEAH, MICHELLE WALL.

AND IT'S ABOUT ME

@Mich The "I tried" thing was that, I couldn't even try to lie about being able to get a read there. At that point in time, I didn't see a single thing I could properly read him for.

Is Michelle actually improving on reading me? You going back into Godread territory?

Maybe.

We'll see another game.

I should probably reread the wall to get a read on Mich FML.

I'll be real, none of P#871 is nothing you can't fake but I did like it.

Laix isn't townie. I ain't calling them scum but if someone has a TR on them before P#909 I'd love to hear the reasoning to it.

ACTUALLY SHIT

So

I don't have a read on Karma. Ain't actually read P#932 yet but I do remember Karma specifically as "This guy was at LG's throat for like literally no reason" and now considering LG's flip, I'm going to just assume Karma as villager.

Time to actually read the post tho.

@Karma Why have/had you got Flower/AG as your highest towns?

That thing on AM actually is nice to know. Doesn't help a bit cause it means he's more likely scummy and I would rather have been right on my read but is nice to know.

Centurion's read abut killing Vanya and Flower is pain.

P#953 from AG is kinda bad. I get being annoyed but that line specifically just feels bad.

P#983 is maybe bad when there's a scum lynch at EoD. This is a reach read tho so take it lightly.

Really really liked P#1018 from nfcnorth

I know I keep bitching about catching up but fuck me, I'm on 35 and I still have like 16 to go.

Shit, Vivo's gaming?

Mich feels much more statement-y rather than inquisitive or ready but meh. I don't have a decent read on her yet. (As of P#1080)

BTW, confident that JoJo/Mich isn't W/W. Unsure if either are properly wolf (maybe JoJo but that would be a reach now) but if either do flip wolf, the other isn't partners.

P#1085 from Hidden is the exact type of shit a wolf would say about their partner.

P#1140 doesn't make sense with a previous pst of JoJo's when they're going at Mich saying shit like "Are **you** scum buddies with Lukundo?" Either they don't believe the read or it isn't a read and it's straight up shade. Again, I don't have a read on Mich but I really dislike this from JoJo. The other post I'm talking about BTW is: P#1101

I do not like Hidden's EoD. - Shit like P#1194.

This shit ain't townie.

Hidden can go after Draekke and JoJo.

10 PAGES LEFT BBBBBBBBBBBBB!!!

bruh, EoD Lind townier than Vanya tbh. Get fucked.

Gotta love AG literally asking Michelle for their reads on me, seeing them, TR'ing Michelle and then while acknowledging that Mich can read me better, proceeds to not TR me.

I do not get @Rottkins read on Vanya in P#1282 You give a couple of town points, one question mark and then lean him scum?

"AG defending Vanya"? wut.

I does kinda vibe with Rottkins apart from that Vanya thing tho.

Looking at the stuff tho in P#1309

Hidden and JoJo are both on LG.

Two of my SRs are on the voted scum.

BUT

I like my reasons for voting them more.

So fuck you.

AND DRAEKKE?

Am I just playing horribly this game?

I might be wrong on JoJo out of any SRs IMO. Every time I see a Laix post, more parts of me and more parts of me are digging to SR it. I can't find a valid reason so as of yet, I'm not but my head wants to and idk why.

But that gut shit that's going on, if right, probably would mean JoJo is Town cause I don't think I've seen anyone give a slightest SR on Laix apart from JoJo.

At day end now so I want to list my reads. Also seeing DDL was the townie that got lynched is rough but it is what it is.

Lind is my top town. Every time they speak they feel townie. I fuckin love it. Hard TR

Vanya is close up there too for a lot of the same reasons. But more to Vanya is that vs Drakkae, they felt like Town. Their words were townie, their posts were townie. I really liked it. Hard TR

Then is probably Owner. I really liked their response about their JoJo read. Felt genuine af and gets them at hard town lean.

Now it's Flower. Liked him early game and I felt a decent chunk of what he said wouldn't come from scum. Decent TL.

Karma is town as well.

Why?

Cause LG flipped wolf.

Then is Always. I'm taking in context from someone saying that uncooperative AM is town but I do feel that he is just townie. It isn't a lot but it's enough.

For scum we have Draekke/JoJo/Hidden. In that order.

Disliked Draekke early day. Disliked JoJo with Mich, disliked Hidden EoD.

Alright.

That's it. Show's over.

Good job I'm not dead to post this shit cause this took me over a fuckin hour.

What's the story, Balamory?
I skimmed through this because uh, gonna be honest it's not in a super easily readable format, but just so you know Lind is probably indie tbh. They're in both games and tbh they're probably never mafia because of that, but they're also probably just some indie or something. But I don't really care enough to push the slot or anything tbh lol
 
I skimmed through this because uh, gonna be honest it's not in a super easily readable format, but just so you know Lind is probably indie tbh. They're in both games and tbh they're probably never mafia because of that, but they're also probably just some indie or something. But I don't really care enough to push the slot or anything tbh lol
Acknowledged but ignored tbh.
 
I am still struggling to understand how Mafia rolecopping someone and targetting them for death at the same time makes sense, that + still voting them for a lynch ( as flower claimed her pushers had scum in it). Like it doesnt compute from a mafia POV to do something like this if Flower is town as she claims, because the first waste of ressources is rolecopping and targetting for death then added to that it would be pushing said woman for a lynch when they can easily just go for someone else and leave her to die. As for her using her ability tonight they would just have to do the same thing they did tonight to her again.

And lastly but this is mostly thinking rationally why would mafia even attempt to kill Flower when she's been one of the main suspects for a lot of people?
 
btw I explained why I pivoted to lg but I guess no one reads rip
I gave a lit of like, 6 people I'd be alright voting and said I was going to pivot to the person with the highest number of votes on that list when the next vote count came out

-----

People I'd go for? Probably LG, Traveling Swordsman, Maaaybe Laix or AM but honestly I'm not really feeling those and it's more them being null-ish or literally impossible to read, or just any inactive
I'm probably gonna vote whichever person I would be alright going that is the highest when kvothe posts the vc and then bounce ngl
Vote count as of post #1,257



Leaderboard
Flower - 4
DDL - 4
Ishmael - 3
LG - 2
Laix - 2
Vanya - 2
Karma - 1
Alwaysmind - 1
Fujitora - 1
Mich - 1
Jojo - 1
TAC - 1​

REMINDER: Everyone who doesn't vote is considered to be casting two votes against themselves

Let me know if I made a mistake
[Vote Lynch LG]
 
a dozen posts of just pure fluff which is normal for day 1 but also straight up admitting they didnt read the rules gives me town vibes

as a host of huge mashup games, nobody reads the rules and questions you on the mechanics more than the scum team



1. it was a day 1 lynch

2. they died anyway

3. if you think im scum, do something about it cowboy

1sBQcgO.gif
I am really fucking here for Laix vs JoJo.

They ain't W/W but I don't think either are towny so getting a wolf flip on one would be awesome!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top