Game World of Warcraft: The Eastern Kingdoms (town+indie victory!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
John Wayne and Nevan overlap on both of the scum lists so they're definitely good targets

I'll try to remember to go through some of their posts later in the night phase

I also still think Melodie is scum. She's a strong scumhunter but all she's really done is go after Leeroy. Not to say Leeroy aint mafia, he's done absolutely nothing in the game, but it's also one of her weakest games so far
 
Kvothe Kingkiller said:
The one thing about John Wayne that bothers me and I'll check him when I get home but he got a vote count of 3 and there were 4 in total (Pou, broki, katsu, and nobles). If he is part of the faction itd make sense but pou broki and katsu have a higher post count than him.

The question now is what nobles?
Click to expand...

Sorry, this was a mistake that I just corrected. John Wayne had 4 votes cast against him, like you said.
 
I don't trust Wad's list, tbh. He basically listed every non-replacement player with less than 50 posts, Melodie and Nevan excluded. I don't see this as very reliable for the purpose of scum hunting and, at best, him doing more response-fishing for role purposes. The tinfoiler in me wants to also connect his uncharacteristically reckless use of abilities to him role fishing, again for his role purposes.
 
Leeroy Jenkins said:
I don't trust Wad's list, tbh. He basically listed every non-replacement player with less than 50 posts, Melodie and Nevan excluded. I don't see this as very reliable for the purpose of scum hunting and, at best, him doing more response-fishing for role purposes. The tinfoiler in me wants to also connect his uncharacteristically reckless use of abilities to him role fishing, again for his role purposes.
Click to expand...

What are your thoughts on Melodie then?
 
Kvothe Kingkiller said:
What are your thoughts on Melodie then?
Click to expand...

I honestly don't recall her pressing anyone else after switching to focusing me. Obviously the counter to me speaking about Melodie is the almighty omgus, but I think it's rather convenient that Oreki had all this pressure on him and as soon as she gained control of grilling him, she was able to redirect it entirely to me when an opportunity presented itself. Oreki immediately pounced on it not skipping a beat.

I recall tinfoiling publicly that it might be that Oreki and her are scum partners. Masons are another possibility, but why the fuck would you ever on D1 try something like fake reading your mason partner as scum as a scum hunt strat?

Everyone else followed suit. DDL's ridiculous plot blowing up in his face saved me, along with the equally ridiculous wpk train springing up.
 
Shizune said:
Vote count

Stormwind House of Nobles - John Wayne
Tiger - Dragon D. Luffy
A Optimistic - Dragon D. Luffy
Dragon D. Luffy - Nevan
shade0180 - Dragon D. Luffy
Oreki - Ratchet
Melodie - Dragon D. Luffy
Ratchet - Dragon D. Luffy
Lord Genome - Dragon D. Luffy
sworder - Dragon D. Luffy
Underworld Broker - Ratchet > John Wayne
Santi - A Optimistic > Kvothe Kingkiller > Cooler
Leeroy Jenkins - Dragon D. Luffy
Dr. White - Dragon D. Luffy
WolfPrinceKouga - Dragon D. Luffy
Juan - Dragon D. Luffy
poutanko - WolfPrinceKouga > Shark Skin > John Wayne
Nevan - Cooler
Expo - Dragon D. Luffy
Okosan - Dragon D. Luffy
Shark Skin - Oddjutsu
Katsuargi - John Wayne

Dragon D. Luffy - 13
John Wayne - 4
Cooler - 2

Self votes

Novaslinenever
Cooler
Kvothe Kingkiller
WAD
A I Z E N
Degaforce
Evil C.C.
John Wayne
Platinum
Kira Yagami
Oddjutsu

~Mystic Serenade~ is exempt from the self-vote penalty due to joining late.​
Click to expand...

Shark Skin for Oddjutsu, DDL for Nevan, and Oreki for Ratchet isn't counted here. Are these before reset or do counts of 1 don't really matter? @Shizune
 
How do you guys feel about Wayne lynch? Am I the only one that went through his posts?

I went through Nevan's posts, he did give some reads:

Nevan said:
I don't like how Lord genome refused to give his reads, but whatever.
I would suggest.

Cooler
Leeroy
Shark skin
Jhon wayne

I would also like some discussion on Santi and Okosan.
Click to expand...

over half his post count is him just asking people "what are your reads" over and over, it seems like a fake way to look like you're scumhunting but I don't know how he plays the game

I wouldn't be opposed to a lynch on him.
 
sworder said:
How do you guys feel about Wayne lynch? Am I the only one that went through his posts?

I went through Nevan's posts, he did give some reads:



over half his post count is him just asking people "what are your reads" over and over, it seems like a fake way to look like you're scumhunting but I don't know how he plays the game

I wouldn't be opposed to a lynch on him.
Click to expand...

Wayne one is a little iffy for me. I'm not too sold on him yet but I'm still going over the thread. I have a feeling like some people on the WPK train are scum because they want to waste the reveal + more like investigations and stuff. Going after an inactive makes it easy because they wouldn't have to worry about the Azeroth bonus. The whole DDL thing was a little odd because there were vote silence and vote + in play.

I'm not opposed to Nevan either. I've only played one game with Nevan, and he sort of did the same thing there and he ended up being scum. One game isn't a good sample size though.
 
Nevan might be some lie detector now that I looked over his posts plus looking at Dr. White's post, it seems like Nevan's playstyle. I hope I'm not second-guessing myself.

Nevan - Well he's being nevan. A bunch of prodding without ever getting anywhere with it. I'd wait on it for now, as I'd like to see where he takes his "pressuring".
Click to expand...

I'll go with John Wayne. I'm not going in order of his posts but just what hurts him in more of evidence from top to bottom.

[Vote Lynch John Wayne]

John Wayne said:
Dude you pretended to be a complete newbie and wasted everyone's time. Either you're a troll or you're scum trying to confuse people.
Click to expand...

John Wayne said:
@Santi

Can't say too much this early but so far Oreki is coming off really town, but could also be really scum not entirely sure rn, but I'll be keeping my eyes open there.

Then there's WAD, he's up to something, pretty much admitted it by with how vague he was being there with all his blitz posting yet denying going for Kingdom of Azeroth faction bonus. Why would you deny going for that? It's a powerful town claim, very sus either way.
Click to expand...

Somewhat conflicting and this was brought up before by WPK on the second quote but JW never addressed this.

Dr. White says he would lynch JW no problem and JW's response to that is oh yeah, you're town Dr. White. And there was a little back and forth but JW just drops it.

John Wayne said:
Dr. White claims I'm 100% scum based on "dry posting" which I assume means that I haven't hard pressured anyone which is like true for more than half of the players.

Perhaps he thinks my "emotional reaction" to that was overplayed, well duh I just act that way in general so you'd see the same whether I was scum or not. Then there's the fact he could even put pressure me, so yeah his read on me feels very half asssed.

Other then that we DDL which I'm pretty sure I don't need where he fucked up.

I'm pretty certain there's something shady going around with the situation around Oreki, a lot of people say he's certainly town and others say he's definitely scum. Feels like someone is deliberately trying to draw attention to it.

I'm honestly shocked Katsuargi gets ignored in every game even tho I'm 90% certain he's a super indie.
Click to expand...

Gets pinged for reads by Nevan. Didn't give shit. Talked about Katsu as an indie and then saying "a lot of people saying he's certainly town" and "others say he's definitely scum" "feels someone is trying to draw attention to it"

Very vague and doesn't point to anyone.

John Wayne said:
WTF is going on???? Using a time reset to bring back an inactifag, I'm actually disgusted. If I find out that was a townie I'm bringing them down.
Click to expand...

Lastly, I mentioned this before as a joke but no scum would do a time-reset on a town on town kill. Not only do you get a confirmed town back, but WAD could use his ability again. Not sure why you would get too upset at it, seems a little over the top. Even if WPK was fully inactive, he would get replaced and the person replaced would be a confirmed town.

@Lord Genome yo help us out james :dank
 
Lord Genome said:
Sorry have some irl stuff thats kinda taking my attention at the moment

Ill look over John Wayne's stuff, tbh I entered the night phase ready to make a push on leeroy but since he's apparently forsaken that is out the window
Click to expand...

There might be some scum that can night post according to @sworder

For now I think we can wait and see if scum decides to target any one of us or leaves one of us alone.
 
Lord Genome said:
Personally I read nevan as town so I wouldn't want to Lynch him

John wayne had floppy post especially about oreki, but idk if that makes him a super strong scum read for me. Would Lynch him over nevan for sure.

There's a couple others is probably prefer(platinum and a couple other under the radar posters) but I don't have a strong enough feel or the time to push one of them tonight
Click to expand...

How are you reading Wad right now?
 
Kvothe Kingkiller said:
:drake
Click to expand...

that was @ the shade part.

Anyways, we also don't need to end our discussions here even though we concluded our vote on JW.

I do find Shark Skin a little suspicious. He opted for Oddjutsu or a Cooler lynch possibly. Oddjutsu off of a miller claim when Tiger has also hinted being part of it as well but I suppose we'll see more in the day phase.
 
Night 1 - John Wayne (Falstad) is lynched
  • Index
    • Vote count

    sworder - nevan > John Wayne
    Kvothe Kingkiller - John Wayne
    Leeroy Jenkins - John Wayne
    Lord Genome - John Wayne

    John Wayne - 4

    John Wayne (Falstad Wildhammer) was lynched!

    Shizune said:
    uHUkgPe.png


    Falstad Wildhammer
    Lord of Aerie Peak
    faction: Wildhammer Clan
    class: Shaman
    wincon: eliminate all threats to the town

    "Those rough-hewn hills that look like my grandmother, beard and all? Aye, 'tis a good choice! We'll descend toward those!"

    [Passive - Reverberation] - Falstad can only use 1 ability each night, and his abilities gain the effect of the ability he used the night before.

    [One Shot Active - Healing Wave] - Falstad can cleanse another player with magical water, protecting them against kills for that night.

    [One Shot Active - Frost Shock] - Falstad can inflict another player with frostbite, roleblocking them that night.

    [One Shot Active - Chain Lightning] - Falstad can electrocute another player, killing them.

    [One Shot Active - Nature's Guidance] - Falstad can commune with the nature spirits to investigate another player, learning their alignment.

    [One Shot Active - Elemental Mastery] - Falstad can restore 1 of his used one shot abilities.
    Click to expand...
    ​

    Do not post yet    ​
     
    Day 2 start
  • Index
    • The Scarlet Crusade killed Degaforce (Drek'thar)!

    kUyj5Qj.png


    Drek'Thar
    The Farseer
    faction: Frostwolf Clan
    class: Shaman
    wincon: eliminate all threats to the town

    "We allied with the humans at the Battle of Mount Hyjal. Our two races have been at peace ever since. Still, it's strange that they would venture so far into our lands."

    [One Shot Passive - Spirit Walk] - Drek'Thar can conjure the ghosts of his ancestors for advice. If another member of the Frostwolf Clan dies, Drek'Thar gains the ability to communicate with them outside the thread.

    [One Shot Active - Sentry Totem] - Drek'Thar can place a magical ward near another player, permanently telling Drek'Thar who targets them.

    [Active - Far Sight] - During the night Drek'Thar can use scrying magic to watch another player, learning who targets them.
    Click to expand...

    The Cult of the Damned killed Santi (Captain Galvangar)!

    AQbUYPI.png


    Captain Galvangar
    The Blademaster
    faction: Frostwolf Clan
    class: Warrior
    wincon: eliminate all threats to the town

    "I'll never fall for that, fool! If you want a battle it will be on my terms and in my lair!"

    [One Shot Passive - Berserker Rage] - When another member of the Frostwolf Clan dies, Galvangar can avenge them by attempting to kill another player.

    [One Shot Active - The Dire Wolves] - Galvangar can send his pet wolves to follow another player, permanently telling Galvangar who they target.

    [Active - Footprints in the Snow] - During the night Galvangar can track another player's steps, learning who they target.
    Click to expand...

    [???] attempted to kill [???], but it failed.

    The realm has fallen on hard times and resources seem to become scarcer by the day. Ratchet and Oddjutsu are forced to share a vote. If they cannot agree on who to vote for, their vote will not count at all.

    Several lines of gossip have leaked from private discussions:

    I can go with Melodie tho
    Click to expand...

    ... rather keep that secret also I don't think it'll make a dent one way or the other at this stage of the game.
    Click to expand...

    I agree with the neutering of wad.
    Click to expand...

    The Stormwind House of Nobles has voted for A Optimstic.

    Votes lock 24 hours from now, at 6:50 PM CST on August 11th.

    Day 2 start. You may post.    ​
     
    Last edited:
    :hm


    These were Degaforce's only posts, he only interacted with WPK.
    Degaforce said:
    WPK's list is incredibly accurate, to be fair

    DDL outed himself as traitor.
    John Wayne's reactions seem disengeniuos and exaggerated.
    Leeroy Jenkins is playing exactly the same as he played Favorites: being totally lost. Except this is a much simpler and smaller game. Get a grip.
    Cooler stays in the back shouting remarks and retreats to his cave when the kitchen gets hot.
    Nevan has a pretty agresive style that seems like scum tryharding to look like a competent scumhunter. I'd like to see the results of his attacks to see if his aim is true. Best case scenario he busses a teammate to save face.
    LG is LG.

    I disagree with the other three, though
    Kira seems too out in the open to be scum. He's usually the lurker type, he would have retreated back at this point.
    I found myself agreeig with most of what sworder said, so I'm inclined to trust him.
    UB feels genuine to me.

    Point is: if you feel that you NEED to target someone, aim for that list.
    Click to expand...

    Degaforce said:
    It is:cantrustleme

    And I am:cantrustleme
    Click to expand...

    Degaforce said:
    One more read before I hit the sack: what are your thoughts on Dr. White and Shark Skin?
    Click to expand...
     
    Shizune

    Users who are viewing this thread

    Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
    Back
    Top