Fair enough, I guess. I just see a lack of a whole lot of things from you, it's mostly been answering easy questions especially mechanical ones and kind of mediating the game through those interactions. You're missing your notes, and theory crafting which I've become accustomed to from your town play. Speaking of notes, do you have any for this game? It might help, I'm also not really versed in WoW lore.
I don't have much. They're mostly threadmarks and some interactions but because Cooler and LG were solo factions (the only other interaction Cooler had was claiming Oreki is town), and Plat and Katsu's interactions were also at a dead-end for me. Plat didn't post much and the only interaction I really saw was with Sworder and and Katsu.. well there were people calling Katsu town off of D1 play. I had thought so at the time too so I didn't pay much attention to it.
Here's all really what I have and it's just really eh too cause it's already stuff we know tbh, I might be missing some stuff. I have zero knowledge in WoW compared to Yu-gi-oh so that doesn't help either.
Notes:
Sylvanas (Forsaken), Balnazzar (Saidan?), Magni are in the game.
The Knights of the Silver Hand - masons
Ratchet
Poutanko
Mystic Serenade
Kingdom of Azeroth
WPK
Wildhammer clan
John Wayne
Frostwolf clan
Degaforce
Santi
Forsaken
me
DDL
Gurubashi
Katsuargi
Scarlet Crusade
Platinum
The Steamwheedle Cartel
Tiger?
Oddjutsu?
1. Novaselinenever - The Kirin Tor?
2. Oddjutsu - Steamwheedle Cartel?
3. Dr. White / Dr. White - High Sorc Andromath / Kingdom of Azeroth? (knows Tiger, WAD, and Leeroy's roles. Can stop a lynch)
5. Juan - one shot ability to post at night
6. Leeroy Jenkins - Chromie (indie/town?)
7. Kvothe Kingkiller / fayt - Forsaken
8. A Optimistic - not silver hand. lie detector
10. is a / Goobius Maximus - Kingdom of Azeroth? (used superkill/reveal [one ability] d1)
12. Tiger - Steamwheedle Cartel? Thief? (took Juan's ability one shot, returned it. Took Oreki's magical armor)
13. Shark Skin
14. Sworder - Forsaken? (mailer checks him? truth serum ability)
15. Wild - Forsaken? (probably not mailer. subbed in. Can invite people into night posting/lynching).
16. Melodie - targetted and lists Platinum, Nevan, C.C(Didi), Kira. Singles out Platinum
17. Nevan
18. Ratchet (Tirion Fordring - Knights of the Silver Hand)
19. A I Z E N
21. ~Mystic Serenade~ (Raleigh the Devout - The Knights of the Silver Hand)
22. WolfPrinceKouga / Soneji (Archmage Theocritus - Kingdom of Azeroth)
23. Okosan (gooby claimed the bird is town)
24. Oreki - The Kingdom of Khaz Modan? (possible scum? scum evidence: mailer, has extra lives, Herod, or Mograine according to Tiger?. town evidence: cooler, lie detect, possibly magni?)
25. Underworld Broker - (assumes mailer is from wolf clan. got a fan mail)
26. Expo / Expo - (biggest plot twist if he turns out to be scum. doubt it.... got a fan mail)
28. Kira Yagami
30. Didi - (probably not mailer.. subbed in).
33. Poutanko - The Knights of the Silver Hand