Game World of Warcraft: The Eastern Kingdoms (town+indie victory!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
Tiger said:
Nova
Juan
Shark Skin
Melodie
A I Z E N
Didi

Final mafia should be here. If not, we have a deep wolf.

Nova needs to claim. Didi said the other day he can get himself vouched for. Might be a good plan @Didi
Click to expand...

Didi said:
I mean cmon Law
I said yesterday I could be vouched for
Then I also made a reply in which I knew all about the recruitment of Pou to the mason group

And then just earlier I made a post saying I was sure about Aizen being town



do I need to spell it out?

@poutanko back me up sis
Click to expand...

Nova
Juan
Shark Skin
Melodie

@Ratchet would you agree with this shorter list?
 
Didi said:
I mean cmon Law
I said yesterday I could be vouched for
Then I also made a reply in which I knew all about the recruitment of Pou to the mason group

And then just earlier I made a post saying I was sure about Aizen being town



do I need to spell it out?

@poutanko back me up sis
Click to expand...

i get you JoJo Hand

but also

do you think either bunny or aizen could maybe be a SH infiltrator?

to have all 5 silver hand masons be town

thats...incredibly strong :hm

Tiger said:
If Nova claims and it's remotely legit, I am comfortable following a Melodie lynch.
Click to expand...

absolutely same
 
is a said:
Also, I have a case for Melodie being Gurubashi.

Here are two of the night convos from Night 1:





At some point in the game, Melodie did soft suggest that the mention of her by potential anti-town increased her likelihood to be perceived as town.

We established quite swiftly on Day 2 that the second message was Gurubashi in origin since they're the ones that rolecrushed me, so even if the message was referring to a hostile action targeting her it wouldn't have been from the faction she's being suspected from.

Fun Fact: She only mentioned or talked about the confirmed Dead Gurubashis, Dr. White and Katsuargi, ONCE EACH the entire game!



Her only namedrop of Dr. White, ever.



Her only namedrop of Katsu before he died (defending him!)

Her list, if you would recall is the following:



Conveniently, only listing Scarlet Crusade scum!

Of course, she could very well be Town. Sure, its possible.

But I think I have presented fairly decent circumstantial evidence as to why she can just as easily be Gurubashi.
Click to expand...

Personally I think Nevan is potentially the last green and he is also caught in my chain that I posted. Also Nevan is the one that said that about me; I never suggested such other than posting that it seems like mafia wanted to target me. I talked to bunny about that thoroughly.
 
is a said:
i get you JoJo Hand

but also

do you think either bunny or aizen could maybe be a SH infiltrator?

to have all 5 silver hand masons be town

thats...incredibly strong :hm



absolutely same
Click to expand...


Nah, Pou's recruitment was a one-shot of my role, if she was an infiltrator my role becomes INCREDIBLY underwhelming as I don't do much as it is


Plus she's been easily the most active and helpful member in the chat (and also in the thread tbh)
don't believe for a sec she isn't town



Aizen? Lol maybe
he's been 100% inactive tho so doesn't really matter either way
 
90f.png
 
basically how this is gonna work is nova needs to eat the lie detect, if he beats it we move to melodie for the lynch

now that we've established that the Silver Hand masons are:

Ratchet (confirmed)
Mystic (confirmed/dead)
Bunny (Recruited into Silver Hand as delayed game start action?)
Didi
A I Z EN

We should also eventually consider the tinfoil that 1 of the bottom 3 are an infiltrator, possibly Balnazzar.

Saidan Dathrohan is the guise Balnazzar uses but that may not be his actual guise in the Silver Hand mason group. He may very well be using another guise for mechanical reasons. But Balnazzar being the SH infiltrator is very much a possibility.
 
Melodie said:
Personally I think Nevan is potentially the last green and he is also caught in my chain that I posted. Also Nevan is the one that said that about me; I never suggested such other than posting that it seems like mafia wanted to target me. I talked to bunny about that thoroughly.
Click to expand...

yes but the suggestion of which, if you're scum, is a good way to subliminally persuade others to think "well if she was declared as a target of scum it must mean she's not scum!"
 
Didi said:
Nah, Pou's recruitment was a one-shot of my role, if she was an infiltrator my role becomes INCREDIBLY underwhelming as I don't do much as it is


Plus she's been easily the most active and helpful member in the chat (and also in the thread tbh)
don't believe for a sec she isn't town



Aizen? Lol maybe
he's been 100% inactive tho so doesn't really matter either way
Click to expand...

uh

is that one-shot a passive or active
 
Melodie said:
Also @is a pardon the massive WIFOM but why in the hell would I target the most suspicious/background players as mafia in my chain instead of prominent/confirmed posters? getting rid of scum as another faction while is a good town credit it is far from the optimal play at that stage of the game.
Click to expand...

i dont know the details of your mechanics it could be conceived that you're basically just making shit up and you listed four names with perhaps one you had info on (platinum) to lend credence to your alleged ability (this list of 4 contains at least 1 scum)
 
@Ratchet

[One Shot Active - House Fordring] - As one of the last surviving northern lords, Tirion can hang another player in his family's castle. For 1 day the Knights can cast votes in Light's Hope Chapel. Whoever has the most votes at the end of the day is lynched alongside the regular lynch. If the Knights use this ability to hang an innocent player, Tirion will be exiled from the game.

is it time iyo?
 
Oddjutsu said:
Lynch bad guys but I have to share a vote with a guy who gets a bonus for not lynching anyone
Click to expand...

Oddjutsu said:
Charity please
Click to expand...

Hilarious.

Can I feasibly give you some gold in some way? Something that has to go through Nitty? One steam to another. If you hop on my ship I'm sure my captain won't mind sharing some of our next booty.

'Long as you help us take out the Bloodsails.
 
is a said:
i get you JoJo Hand

but also

do you think either bunny or aizen could maybe be a SH infiltrator?

to have all 5 silver hand masons be town

thats...incredibly strong :hm



absolutely same
Click to expand...
Don't forget Pou was added to the game. Much easier balance wise to add one town than one scum. That was an ability used by Evil, now Dede. I'm locking Pou in as town.

A I Z E N I believe to be town too. Don't want to say why because it's part angleshooty but I would be somewhat surprised if he was a traitor. But if there is one in the group, it would be him.
 
is a said:
:dank

well thats a good meme

well then...if SH has infiltrator i guess its either Didi or AIZEN but thats not a top priority atm i suppose
Click to expand...

Like you said not that it matters
but I'm the leader of the group
so that'd be big lol memes


so yeah it's Aizen if it's anyone
but I don't think it is


I have another possible recruit ability btw but if I use it on an evil person I die by the hands of that person
so that kinda fits with traitor theme?
 
is a said:
i dont know the details of your mechanics it could be conceived that you're basically just making shit up and you listed four names with perhaps one you had info on (platinum) to lend credence to your alleged ability (this list of 4 contains at least 1 scum)
Click to expand...

If you think she's gurubashi

how would she have gotten info if their invest role died fairly early

only thing that could make sense is that she guessed one of the 4 people could be scum, she'd be capable of that imo
 
1. novaselinenever - Claimed former Kirin Tor now Forsaken
2. Oddjutsu - Claimed Steamwheedle.
3. Juan - ?
4. Leeroy Jenkins - Claimed/Pseudo-confirmed Chromie (With Town Win Con).
5. Kvothe Kingkiller - Forsaken, likely.
6. A Optimistic - Confirmed Azerothian
7. is a - Confirmed Azerothian
8. Tiger - Claimed Steamwheedle.
9. Shark Skin - ?
10. Sworder - Forsaken, not Sylvanas.
11. Wild - Claimed Forsaken, Sylvanas
12. Melodie - ? (Town points for the hunting of Platinum and Kira)
13. Nevan - ? (Claimed Khaz'Modan by Tiger)
14. A I Z E N - Confirmed Silver Hand
15. WPK - Confirmed Kirin Tor
16. Okosan - Confirmed Town (by me)
17. Oreki - Claimed Khaz'Modan. Lie detected as Town.
18. Underworld Broker - ? (Lie Detected as Town).
19. Expo - ? (Claimed Town by Tiger)
20. Didi - Confirmed Silver Hand
21. Poutanko - Confirmed Silver Hand
22. Ratchet - Confirmed Town Silver Hand

In this list we have approximately 3-5 scum left. Scarlet Crusade likely has two members left at most (Balnazzar + Herod?) while Gurubashi has 1, maybe two more left.

The only other possible scum would be a Katrana Prestor becoming Onyxia.

Update on the list.
 
is a said:
@Ratchet

[One Shot Active - House Fordring] - As one of the last surviving northern lords, Tirion can hang another player in his family's castle. For 1 day the Knights can cast votes in Light's Hope Chapel. Whoever has the most votes at the end of the day is lynched alongside the regular lynch. If the Knights use this ability to hang an innocent player, Tirion will be exiled from the game.

is it time iyo?
Click to expand...
I mean if people want that, sure. Needs to be right though as the longer scum don't remove me the harder the game gets for them by virtue of me being confirmed. Don't want to make it easy for them but with votes becoming stretched I would accept it.
 
Ratchet said:
I mean if people want that, sure. Needs to be right though as the longer scum don't remove me the harder the game gets for them by virtue of me being confirmed. Don't want to make it easy for them but with votes becoming stretched I would accept it.
Click to expand...
If you accidentally exile yourself that leaves me free to vote as I please, no more being handcuffed to you like a buddy movie
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
Back
Top