Game Favorites '22 - GROUP 2

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Bread crumb for my future hostile indie claim.

635-D2-C32-C3-FE-414-F-A530-6-C5-CDE2942-C0.jpg
alfie-solomons-thinking.gif
 
Day 2 vote count

Spoiler: Lynch vote count
1. @Badalight
2. @Baroxio - Xadlin
3. @charles101 - Xadlin
4. @Didi - Xadlin
5. @DrProfessor83 - Xadlin
6. @Ekkologix - Xadlin
7. @Fang
8. @Firestormer - Didi > Xadlin
9. @Franky
10. @hammer - Didi
11. @Hero - Xadlin
12. @Iwandesu
13. @John Wayne
14. @Juan - Xadlin
15. @Kira Yagami - Xadlin
16. @Lind - Xadlin
17. @Lord Melkor - Didi > Xadlin
18. @Melodie
19. @Natalija - Didi
20. @Nessos - Xadlin > Didi > Xadlin
21. @Oddjutsu - Didi
22. @Rej - Nessos > Xadlin
23. @Salah WG
24. @Santí - Xadlin
25. @SinRaven - Didi > Xadlin
26. @Soul - Xadlin
27. @SoulKiller - Xadlin
28. @sworder
29. @tinky winky - Ekko > Didi > Xadlin
30. @WolfPrinceKiba - Didi - Xadlin
31. @Worm Juice Didi
32. @Xadlin - Oddjutsu > Worm Juice > Lord Melkor
33. @Yo Tan Wa


Lynch leaderboard

@Xadlin - 19
@Didi - 4


Spoiler: Execution vote count
1. @Badalight - Santi
2. @Baroxio - Santi
3. @charles101 - Salah WG
4. @Didi - Franky > Salah WG
5. @DrProfessor83
6. @Ekkologix - Santi
7. @Fang
8. @Firestormer - Salah WG
9. @Franky
10. @hammer
11. @Hero - Salah WG
12. @Iwandesu
13. @John Wayne
14. @Juan - Santi
15. @Kira Yagami - Santi
16. @Lind
17. @Lord Melkor - Santi
18. @Melodie
19. @Natalija - Santi
20. @Nessos - Salah WG
21. @Oddjutsu - Salah WG
22. @Rej - Salah WG
23. @Salah WG
24. @Santí - Salah WG
25. @SinRaven - Melodie
26. @Soul - Santi
27. @SoulKiller - Salah WG
28. @sworder
29. @tinky winky - Salah WG
30. @WolfPrinceKiba
31. @Worm Juice Franky
32. @Xadlin
33. @Yo Tan Wa


Execution leaderboard

@Salah WG - 10
@Santí - 8

Anyone who doesn't vote casts 2 votes against themselves.

Votes lock in 30 minutes.
You missed my vote :naruramen
 
Tinky is also null for me as it stands. He seems more aggressive here than I’d expect as scum but taking credit for starting the Didi wagon, while also calling it not a serious scum read was odd.
Yes, it's not a serious scum read from Tinky if you saw his post. He just said Didi bitched and complained and just voted. You think a scum would take credit for starting a wagon and then saying it was for luls when we don't know the flip and when a portion of the game also views Didi as scum?

And why would that make Tinky null for you?
 
Executing Santi instead of Salah might veer a bit on the side of using it for the purpose of an extra lynch, which those of you who have read Nitty's posts regarding the mechanic should know is not the intention and that they'll alter/remove the execute if it is being used in that way. Though fuck Santi he actually tried to us this argument earlier despite having almost zero game content. I would hope Nitty's thought process there was thinking of low post count, but high post content players like me potentially being up for execution and getting killed off over actual inactives.
 
Yes, it's not a serious scum read from Tinky if you saw his post. He just said Didi bitched and complained and just voted. You think a scum would take credit for starting a wagon and then saying it was for luls when we don't know the flip and when a portion of the game also views Didi as scum?

And why would that make Tinky null for you?
Because on tone I lean him more town. But that odd behavior pulled him down to null. That’s generally how a lot of my null reads work.

Using starting a not serious wagon for why you aren’t scum is odd.

However looking back he was arguing *against* being a bandwagoner. Which is a more coherent position. I was reading very fast before work after avoiding this day phase yesterday. He can have a slight town read on tone.

Is that the only read that stood out to you Lind?

A574-EA3-F-8-DF9-498-B-A055-E0131-C720-A5-D.jpg
 
Executing Santi instead of Salah might veer a bit on the side of using it for the purpose of an extra lynch, which those of you who have read Nitty's posts regarding the mechanic should know is not the intention and that they'll alter/remove the execute if it is being used in that way. Though fuck Santi he actually tried to us this argument earlier despite having almost zero game content.
Santi has been pretty much 100% inactive for all practical purposes except in this post:
I mean, personally I don't think we should be trying to weaponize the execute mechanic to such a degree unless the content of the individual is pretty sus and scummy enough to warrant being lynched in and of itself. You're effectively suggesting to retool an anti-inactivity system to punish the least inactive among the inactive (in this case me) for putting just a little more effort than the other 3 candidates.

If I were scum and any of my mates were up on the execute board, I just fucking might take advantage of the execute to target someone higher profile and effectively get a double mislynch for the town :oya
Where he is stating we shouldn't kill him

Continuation of WPK's post
I would hope Nitty's thought process there was thinking of low post count
It seems to be, see the bold texted from the OP:

If the execution truly goes awry from my plans and I think my mistake is causing a very active player to be undeservedly executed, I may even intervene to modify the rules and save that player. That is the worst case scenario, and I don't think it's likely, but I want to be clear about why I made this mechanic and how I will moderate it. The execution was made as a player-controlled replacement for activity-based modkills, not as a second lynch. You should be strategic about your execution choices, and town members should try to execute the most suspicious players, but if the execution does not fulfill its purpose of targeting inactive players then I will most likely change it.
Santi definitely fits that description. Don't see anything wrong with executing him based on what was written in the OP.
 
I don't think Odd has made any attempts at scum hunting so far lol. Even though he can be very good if he tried.

@Oddjutsu wanna share your thoughts?


I believe that was the same Rej post you replied to yesterday where you said you found it weird that he was buddying you or something.

I may be wrong.

What's your read of Rej now?
I still get a slimy feel from them, need to ISO them hopefully during some night posting as I have tonight off work to get some extra work done *nudge nudge wink wink* @Nessos
I have a statement and I'm interested to see if people agree: If Worm Juice isn't eligible for the lynch again tomorrow she should just be shot this night
Either any way they should be shot.
First thought around Xadlin is it looks bad for Odd if Xadlin is indeed Scum.
Oddjutsu is a busser whose too afraid to stick his neck out to save scummates, last I saw of him as a host when he played in one of the Get Goods.

oh, whatever

i'm town, first of all

second, i'm unlynchable. i will never be eligible for the lynch, even if i vote on the correct wagon every single dayphase. that's what nitty's mistake was about, he forgot to take me out of the options bc he was swamped with actions

even if i somehow get the lynch thrown on me (which nitty confirmed could theoretically happen in my PMs, so we likely have lynch redirect abilities and shit), it won't get me, it'll hit whoever has the most votes right after

if you have any more questions make them now, i guess :sag
I know where I'm aiming my kill tonight :jackal
An unlynchable scum? What is this, favorites 3?!!
Favorites 3 was funner than this game :tomato
Well since I’m gonna be lynched anyway, I’m just gonna say, town be towning hard.

made a couple of mistakes and such so yeah, that’s a shame.

but that’s the way of mafia. I accept my death.

But yes I misspoke. I had odd on my mind since I had voted for him.

my target was worm, Melkor and iwan.

good luck town

coverforever.jpg
At least try to push for an alternative, but I can understand if you don't want to lead the charge on your scummate Didi :kthumb
oh

who the fuck made favorites 3 what the fuck is that kind of bullshit
To be fair, Badalight's role was the Godfather of his faction which was smaller than the others, and being unlynchable was almost all that role had going for it (it also had a one-shot lynch redirect). That was only my second game hosted, and if made today that role would have been unlynchable only until the rest of it's mafia was dead.
the game cant handle this
Yeah we would all quit the game
Okay a quick recollection of the votes on Plat for my own sanity

Okay so Hero started the Platinum wagon with this post. Sounds like a pressure vote that amounted to not much else until the wagon gained traction.

Should note Hero defending Didi here a bit. Tho Hero has been very adamant later in stating Didi was a town read of him, maybe too sure for D1

This is the second vote on Platinum.

Honestly, looking back at this, I don't see this vote as Xadlin trying to save Worm Juice, because at the time Didi was in the lead and by changing his vote off Didi onto Platinum, WJ came closer in votes to Didi and was more at risk of being lynched.

The reason I could see for this vote change as scum is that Xadlin was afraid of being a lynch candidate if Didi was lynched, but I don't see why he wouldn't change his vote again later then.

Third vote on Platinum and at this point Didi and WJ were tied. It seemed pretty clear that there were a lot of people against the Didi lynch at this point and the WJ wagon gained some traction so to me this is the first vote that could be seen as a counterwagon to WJ (if we assume that's why plat was lynched)


Note that LM followed Hero's word blindly

Next vote on Plat and this is at the point that WJ is in the lead and Didi is losing votes

Wonder why Juan doesn't seem to consider Worm Juice


Ratchet directs attention to the Plat lynch.

Didi follows, not feeling the WJ lynch I guess?

The option of WJ and Didi being scummates is still open. The Plat lynch mightve been an attempt to save them both.

This vote deffo looks like an attempt to save WJ

__

Worm Juice needs to get offed lmao, her death will unfold a lot of info, but we can say the same about Didi. I feel like Didi contributes more and I do get town vibes from him this phase so he gets a pass and we can't lynch WJ

After this recollection and the way votes went Xadlin looks a lot better to me and it actually is Melkor that looks more suspicious to me the way the votes happened.

I didn't really follow the claim stuff closely, but the way Xadlin reacted to being caught in a weird claim seemed townlike to me (I think townies are more likely to slip up and make a mistake while mafia will try to make sure everything checks out)

That said, I have to look into Melkor more to consider changing onto him + maybe it's not a good idea to change at all as we want more people on the lynch to keep most people being lynch candidates
SinRaven actually putting in effort?

old-boomer.gif

I’ve finally caught up and read this entire day phase! (In one sitting I might add and it was rather exhausting haha)


Xaldin, it seems you not only accidentally listed Odd as a target once, but twice! Once I may can accept as an honest mistake. Twice seems unlikely wouldn’t you say?

The number of things going against you now are starting to pile up haha.

1.) You seemed to be CWAC on D1 which had you as my strongest scum read at days end.
2.) You claims you aren’t very good at reading people and prefers to be a right hand and follow orders. You also claims you think D2 is much more useful for getting reads. I must say, those two things make amping a role block into a role crush to target 3 people N1 quite strange. If I weren’t confident in myself to make good reads, and don’t think D1 is that useful for gathering them, I’m very unlikely to blow my load on people N1 in such a manner.
3.) As I generously pointed out to you at the start, you mixed your targets up on two separate occasions.

-
Worm Juice I also think is scum, and I noticed quite a lot of people going after Didi on the basis that Plat was the counter wagon to save him and ignoring that it was actually Worm that was leading and saved by the Plat wagon. If Worm flips scum those people need to be looked at. Also I could see the reason to Xaldin’s mix up if he’s scum being he tried to slip Worm Juice in his action list for distance but he never targeted them at all. But that part is irrelevant until one flips scum. And regardless I think both are individually likely to be scum.

Also I find Worm’s vote on Didi today to be terrible.

91-A2-D460-6053-4-BAE-AF1-D-E08423-E7-E205.webp
Kind of a bad look to come back only to further push onto two of the three most suspected players, one of which is the already cemented lynch for the day

Also am i the only one that feel this is scum favouring mechanism? Active town would continue stay in focus.. either get mislynched or shot at night. I'd likely avoid voting unless it is my strong scum reads or my town reads ask me to vote along them.
It is most definitely scum favored, though it seems from the other game that there are roles that can add people to the lynch pile that didn't vote on the lynch wagon the prior day
 
Santi has been pretty much 100% inactive for all practical purposes except in this post:

Where he is stating we shouldn't kill him


It seems to be, see the bold texted from the OP:


Santi definitely fits that description. Don't see anything wrong with executing him based on what was written in the OP.
Yeah fair enough, that Santi post has my blood boiling enough that I want him dead :

[Change Execute Santi]
 
@WolfPrinceKiba @Natalija

If you guys want to survive the night, don't forget that you guys have access to a FLASH one-shot that if used defensively may help ensure your survival.

If mafia want to get through it, they'd have to also use Flash, and that's generally a trade that's worth it, I think. Plus, they'd have to pick only one of you to Flash towards, while the other remains generally safe.
???? No clue what you’re talking about :pepethunk
 
we shud execute santi
salah would of already being subbed of scum. santi is clearly trying to avoid the execute platform
I really don't like Santi's lack of action in this thread thus far. Only posting enough to escape execution but not actually contributing much is pretty scummy, IMHO.
???? No clue what you’re talking about :pepethunk
Apparently, I made a mistake. Flash won't help you now.
 
Because on tone I lean him more town. But that odd behavior pulled him down to null. That’s generally how a lot of my null reads work.

Using starting a not serious wagon for why you aren’t scum is odd.

However looking back he was arguing *against* being a bandwagoner. Which is a more coherent position. I was reading very fast before work after avoiding this day phase yesterday. He can have a slight town read on tone.

Is that the only read that stood out to you Lind?
Your null reads work on odd behavior which doesn't make much sense to come from scum?

Using starting a not serious wagon for why you aren't scum is odd only in vacuum. Here the wagon being Didi, whom quite a few have scum read shouldn't be applied imo unless you know Didi is just town. What can be technically true, can just be nonsense contextually.

Yeah, I skimmed it and felt like only replying to this.
 
Day 2 - Final vote count
Day 2 Final vote count

Spoiler: Lynch vote count
1. @Badalight
2. @Baroxio - Xadlin
3. @charles101 - Xadlin
4. @Didi - Xadlin
5. @DrProfessor83 - Xadlin
6. @Ekkologix - Xadlin
7. @Fang - Xadlin
8. @Firestormer - Didi > Xadlin
9. @Franky
10. @hammer - Didi
11. @Hero - Xadlin
12. @Iwandesu
13. @John Wayne - Xadlin
14. @Juan - Xadlin
15. @Kira Yagami - Xadlin
16. @Lind - Xadlin
17. @Lord Melkor - Didi > Xadlin
18. @Melodie
19. @Natalija - Didi
20. @Nessos - Xadlin > Didi > Xadlin
21. @Oddjutsu - Didi
22. @Rej - Nessos > Xadlin
23. @Salah WG
24. @Santí - Xadlin
25. @SinRaven - Didi > Xadlin
26. @Soul - Xadlin
27. @SoulKiller - Xadlin
28. @sworder
29. @tinky winky - Ekko > Didi > Xadlin
30. @WolfPrinceKiba - Didi - Xadlin
31. @Worm Juice - Didi
32. @Xadlin - Oddjutsu > Worm Juice > Lord Melkor
33. @Yo Tan Wa


Lynch leaderboard

@Xadlin - 21
@Didi - 4


Spoiler: Execution vote count
1. @Badalight - Santi
2. @Baroxio - Santi
3. @charles101 - Salah WG
4. @Didi - Franky > Salah WG
5. @DrProfessor83
6. @Ekkologix - Santi
7. @Fang - Salah WG
8. @Firestormer - Salah WG
9. @Franky
10. @hammer
11. @Hero - Salah WG
12. @Iwandesu
13. @John Wayne
14. @Juan - Santi
15. @Kira Yagami - Santi
16. @Lind
17. @Lord Melkor - Santi
18. @Melodie
19. @Natalija - Santi
20. @Nessos - Salah WG
21. @Oddjutsu - Salah WG
22. @Rej - Salah WG
23. @Salah WG
24. @Santí - Salah WG
25. @SinRaven - Melodie
26. @Soul - Santi
27. @SoulKiller - Salah WG
28. @sworder
29. @tinky winky - Salah WG
30. @WolfPrinceKiba - Santi
31. @Worm Juice Franky
32. @Xadlin
33. @Yo Tan Wa


Execution leaderboard

@Salah WG - 11
@Santí - 9

@Xadlin will be lynched, and @Salah WG will be executed.
 
Last edited:
Day 2 Final vote count

Spoiler: Lynch vote count
1. @Badalight
2. @Baroxio - Xadlin
3. @charles101 - Xadlin
4. @Didi - Xadlin
5. @DrProfessor83 - Xadlin
6. @Ekkologix - Xadlin
7. @Fang
8. @Firestormer - Didi > Xadlin
9. @Franky
10. @hammer - Didi
11. @Hero - Xadlin
12. @Iwandesu
13. @John Wayne - Xadlin
14. @Juan - Xadlin
15. @Kira Yagami - Xadlin
16. @Lind - Xadlin
17. @Lord Melkor - Didi > Xadlin
18. @Melodie
19. @Natalija - Didi
20. @Nessos - Xadlin > Didi > Xadlin
21. @Oddjutsu - Didi
22. @Rej - Nessos > Xadlin
23. @Salah WG
24. @Santí - Xadlin
25. @SinRaven - Didi > Xadlin
26. @Soul - Xadlin
27. @SoulKiller - Xadlin
28. @sworder
29. @tinky winky - Ekko > Didi > Xadlin
30. @WolfPrinceKiba - Didi - Xadlin
31. @Worm Juice - Didi
32. @Xadlin - Oddjutsu > Worm Juice > Lord Melkor
33. @Yo Tan Wa


Lynch leaderboard

@Xadlin - 20
@Didi - 4


Spoiler: Execution vote count
1. @Badalight - Santi
2. @Baroxio - Santi
3. @charles101 - Salah WG
4. @Didi - Franky > Salah WG
5. @DrProfessor83
6. @Ekkologix - Santi
7. @Fang - Salah WG
8. @Firestormer - Salah WG
9. @Franky
10. @hammer
11. @Hero - Salah WG
12. @Iwandesu
13. @John Wayne
14. @Juan - Santi
15. @Kira Yagami - Santi
16. @Lind
17. @Lord Melkor - Santi
18. @Melodie
19. @Natalija - Santi
20. @Nessos - Salah WG
21. @Oddjutsu - Salah WG
22. @Rej - Salah WG
23. @Salah WG
24. @Santí - Salah WG
25. @SinRaven - Melodie
26. @Soul - Santi
27. @SoulKiller - Salah WG
28. @sworder
29. @tinky winky - Salah WG
30. @WolfPrinceKiba - Santi
31. @Worm Juice Franky
32. @Xadlin
33. @Yo Tan Wa


Execution leaderboard

@Salah WG - 11
@Santí - 9

@Xadlin will be lynched, and @Salah WG will be executed.

you missed my execution vote, I changed to Santi, in the proper format
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top