-
Xenforo 2.3 Licences Campaign
Donations here
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
I still think Sworder should be allowed another day tbh. Execute Mello instead 
Soul
Agent of Justice
I agree with people if they make sense. There was a point in the game where it did make sense to execute Santi. The game changes based on what people post
Why? Either missed your reasoning or you haven't posted it.
I would agree that if we kill Santi and he is mafia Fang is next, but don't see why we would kill a now active Santi on the execute now.
Please elaborate, I am willing to reconsider.
I’m finally awake! I was up late last night getting my ******* **** filled ***** and ***** with a fork, plus ******* inside the *** ******, Warhammer orcs, big **** ***** *******, and we didn’t even used condoms!
Votes locked in one hour
Votes locked in one hour
Soul
Agent of Justice
[Vote Execute Franky], by the way.
Which in hindsight might not be a big deal after all that night phase was awful.
No he is not, he is one of the 5 that lynch, and they need 3 votes to get the lynch, anything less and we lose the night lynch.
Which in hindsight might not be a big deal after all that night phase was awful.
Soul
Agent of Justice
Maybe... WORM JUICE?
FUCK.
Ok. Can you elaborate on what you have? Haven't seen it and it could help the night lynch people do their job.
Getting my filled and with a fork, plus inside the warhammer orcs, big, and we didn't even used condoms
What did you do with the Warhammer orcs.
He said he can't be killed and keeps avoiding being on the main wagon. How else do we get rid of him?
Test his theory of not being lynchable?
We can't lynch him if he's not on a wagon.
Do the impossible, see the invisible, row row fight the powah.
Soul
Agent of Justice
Personally, this is the first night that Bada reads somewhat scum to me.
Anything but WJ, regardless of what she ends up being, is wrong. This is why she has this many votes.
My train of thought is see what he does at night and then continue to form an opinion on the subject. If he votes for something else than the consensus on Day 4, he might be targeted and would just be suspected further. He will be available for being killed eventually, thinking that he can't die ever makes no sense.
Speaking of, didn't know that claiming you can't die means you are immortal. Someone can just test his theory.
In short: He will be made available to be kill, just like anyone playing.
Make a solid case for him being scum and others should follow if you make sense, because right now it doesn't feel that you have much.
If you are afraid of what influence he could have on the night lynch you can just push to kill one of the other 4 and then that lynch would disappear. There's always a way.
There's more than one way to die, Ratchet.
nessis can invite one person every night
lynching badalight doesn't cuck us out of a night lynch
lynching badalight doesn't cuck us out of a night lynch
also nessos invite me to the fucking night chat
wpk is inactive as fuck
wpk is inactive as fuck
Soul
Agent of Justice
Fuck forgot about that one.
But if that's the case then the night phase shouldn't be as bad as yesterday.
I feel like the words I'm using don't seem to be getting conveyed to you. I never once said he MUST be unkillable at Night. He claimed it. You can assume that if he is scum faking it, they probably have a way to protect him. So the bolded comment is worthless.
Why are you assuming that my fear is his supposed influence on the Night lynch? In fact, what even is this argument? I suggested he was a target for the night lynch, as he's relatively scum read by several players and otherwise cannot be lynched, and allegedly cannot be killed. Why on earth would I want any one of the *other* players to be killed off first just to prevent the night lynch instead of suggesting the night lynch just be used on him? How is taking away the night lynch a better move here? Can you explain this one to me please. Because I see no reason for a townie to believe that, instead of removing a suspect player, it would instead be better to remove someone else to prevent the sole tool that can be reliably used on the suspect player from being employed. It really actually makes no sense at all.
I don't really need to make a solid case. Ducking the wagons for three days in a row, using the mislynches that he avoided as a tool to brag and then flagrantly admit that his concern is survival over finding scum are all scummy characteristics in their own right, especially the last one, which is quite literally the main concern for scum.
I'm sorry but I'm going to need you to defend yourself on this, because I'd go as far as to say this is almost open-wolfing.
Day 3 Semi-final vote count
Spoiler: Lynch votes
Lynch leaderboard
Worm Juice - 14
SinRaven - 3
Didi - 2
Worm Juice - 14
SinRaven - 3
Didi - 2
Spoiler: Execution votes
Execution leaderboard
Franky - 7
Melodie - 3
Sworder - 3
Santi - 2
Anyone who doesn't vote will cast 2 votes against themselves.
Votes lock in just under 30 minutes.
Franky - 7
Melodie - 3
Sworder - 3
Santi - 2
Anyone who doesn't vote will cast 2 votes against themselves.
Votes lock in just under 30 minutes.
did you, though
Incoming action...
oh fucking hell
An investigation result from last night is being broadcasted into the game thread!
[Vote Execute Franky]
Lind hasn't cast a vote. 
Soul
Agent of Justice
Yup, driving right now.did you, though
Thank God Mexico doesn't care about texting and driving.
He kept being pushed on by Ekko and a few others for details about his role and actions but generally never posted much of anything nor gave any insight on anything or anyone other then to say he's town iirc.
did he claim otherwise?
votes are almost locked so we can talk about this tomorrow
Yo Tan Wa
Soar to the Sky in first try
Nat is dead, & 5 is required for night lynch. So Nessos would invite Nat replacement tonight, not Badalight's.
Lord Melkor
Well-Known Member
Change vote Wormjuice
yes
so they have 5 right now
4 when bada is lynched
then 5 again after tomorrow's replacement is added
do u guys not know math
Apparently so.
Yo Tan Wa
Soar to the Sky in first try
Apparently no.
Numbers are alien.
Use words.
Use words.
Lord Melkor
Well-Known Member
What was purpose of that exchange? Santi thought that I am better invest target than Badalight?
It's always vote lynch, LM. Vote lynch or change vote lynch. The vote lynch phrasing is very important
Soul
Agent of Justice
Jesus Christ
I assumed that was your fear because I don't get why you would being worried about Bada right now. WJ is definitely the play today, and you have all of the night phase to further evaluate his behavior.
I don't think he is a good night Lynch target because I don't think that the other 4 can come to a consensus based on what happened last night phase, and he will be there to defend himself, too.
No clue what open-wolfing is, please elaborate.
Lord Melkor
Well-Known Member
Change vote Execute Santi
Yo Tan Wa
Soar to the Sky in first try
Lord Melkor
Well-Known Member
Ok, Change vote Lynch Wormjuice
Soul
Agent of Justice
And yeah, as I said before Bada does seem suspicious based on last night and this day phase. My point is that his claim on not being killable means little to me.
Lord Melkor
Well-Known Member
I mean that @Fang apparently wanted to invest Baroxio but Santi made a deal so I was invested instead?
charles101
hot dog doodie
I'll just [Vote Lynch WormJuice] I guess
You assumed that was my fear when I explicitly said that he night lynch remains the single most viable way to deal with him? How does that compute? If there would be any fear there, it would be the inability to remove him from play easily. I don't think I ever said he should be lynched today, over Worm Juice, because... he can't be, as he didn't vote. Your argument does not hold up at all here.
You don't think he's good target because he can defend himself? Wouldn't that make him a better target? You wuld want to have someone who can engage with suspicion, surely, over someone who can only be silent? I'm not sure how the other 4 being able to form a consensus makes him a bad night lynch target too.
Can you address this please, because I'm growing increasingly concerned about the strength of your arguments.
charles101
hot dog doodie
hey, that wasn't 1h .-. it was 20 minutes
Change your execute target from Santi to Franky.
charles101
hot dog doodie
oh, nvm, i saw final vote count and thought these are locked
Lord Melkor
Well-Known Member
Is there any info on Franky? Ekko is sure Santi is scum and his threadplay is suss to me as well.
Firestormer
Well-Known Member
Keep reading you'll get to the good part soon
charles101
hot dog doodie
Usopp was sure based on what's said to be misunderstanding.
It's between Melody, Franky and Sworder rn. Franky is the least active one (1 post, early game). That's the reasoning I believe
You can catch up later, change it please.
Votes are locked
Lord Melkor
Well-Known Member
Change vote execute Franky
Melkor better pray that there are no shenanigans here. Sant cleared via an investigation, why does Town!Melkor think Scum!Santi does this?
You will not be getting a reprieve on this. Let's see the flips.
charles101
hot dog doodie
He's either town or immune to investigations. If you believe Santi is town, he also apparently got innocent result on LM.
That's exactly what I'm saying, yes.
charles101
hot dog doodie
Reasoning being - he's probably just behind. Neither scum LM nor town LM with full intel would have any reason to vote person who cleared him. There's been mass notification saying to vote him, there wasn't one to switch to Franky. No reason to jump into conclusions imo
Lord Melkor
Well-Known Member
I was also considering him as scum, you have seen his cop claim though?
Firestormer
Well-Known Member
Kinda love the idea of executing the person trying to clear you when most of the game sussed you though, very mercenary
Soul
Agent of Justice
It doesn't compute. I missed where you said that. I agree that, with that info, that section of my post doesn't add up.
I also misspoke there. He could be a good Lynch target, I just have little to no faith in the night group, or what they may accomplish.
Yup, didn't make a good argument because I missed vital information on your side. I stand corrected, as per this post.
Day 3 Final vote count
Spoiler: Lynch votes
Lynch leaderboard
Worm Juice - 15
SinRaven - 2
Didi - 2
Worm Juice - 15
SinRaven - 2
Didi - 2
Spoiler: Execution votes
Execution leaderboard
Franky - 9
Melodie - 3
@Franky will be executed, and @Worm Juice will be ly-- wait... what's that? This can't be right... it says here that due to shenanigans, @Nessos is going to be lynched instead! @Oddjutsu , did you do this to get back at him for the night lynch?!
Well anyway that's just terrible! Now we have no lynch pool for tomorrow!
Tomorrow's lynch will be open to everyone, like day 1's was.
Franky - 9
Melodie - 3
@Franky will be executed, and @Worm Juice will be ly-- wait... what's that? This can't be right... it says here that due to shenanigans, @Nessos is going to be lynched instead! @Oddjutsu , did you do this to get back at him for the night lynch?!
Well anyway that's just terrible! Now we have no lynch pool for tomorrow!
Tomorrow's lynch will be open to everyone, like day 1's was.
Lord Melkor
Well-Known Member
Yes, I am leaning not scum on Santi right now after catching up. Could be indie maybe.
Scum could clear people as town to gain creditbility though.
Firestormer
Well-Known Member
jesus christ
Lord Melkor
Well-Known Member
Agreed, Bada is the best lynch target right now to me as well.
Soul
Agent of Justice
Nessos
"HighFiveNight" - News
RIP night lynch 
Was a funny game especially the nightshift!
GL Town, @Group1 keep on and carry the Game!
Was a funny game especially the nightshift!
GL Town, @Group1 keep on and carry the Game!
day 1 wagon
8 plat voters: didi, juan, hero, lind, melkor, ratchet, sk, xadlin
6 worm voters: rej, yo tan, ekko, kira, baroxio, prof
5 didi voters: WPK, worm, plat, tinky, hammer
worm flipping scum here does not mean didi is not scum too. if either of them were town, mafia would of gladly taken that wagon for free then lynched plat after instead of derail for no reason and put blood on their hand
plat's voters:
- melkor made it clear that he is going for didi over worm. worm scum flip implicates him more than a didi scumflip, although from my past experience with melkor i dont think he defends a scum buddy this openly. if both didi and worm flip scum then perhaps didi might have a weaker role and thats where melkor was going for but i doubt it. also he has a green cop check on him. sin also tried to pin melkor as scum buddy of worm over the night with barely analyzing it so a sin scum flip probably just clears melkor for me altogether bc shading a player at night might cause night actions to harm them. leaning town.
- juan looks townie from general tone and play. he is being vocal against worm much more than against didi, and he pushed xadlin lynch day 2 which saved didi (which is more of a misplay from xadlin). i'd tie juan to a didi scumflip more than a worm scumflip. hes basically the reverse of melkor.
- hero started the game looking townie but his play has been falling off in the recent phases, plus he started the wagon on plat. hero is town reading didi altogether and has no notable interactions with worm / did not display a strong lean eitherway on them. this slot needs to be checked upon either flip scum tbh
- lind is a tossup for me. he started the game looking townie but kept going downhill in the recent phases in both games. i can cut him some slack since hes gotta play 24/7 but there is not much in depth solving coming from him other than town reading players and staying at a safe distance from the sideline, which is pretty indie like behavior. he preferred a worm lynch over didi in day 1 but then pushed for plat's lynch and tagged others to vote him by the end of the day. if hes like a super godfather he would be trying to find the scum teams on his own so his scum hunting can come off as genuine, yet reserved to his own self at the same time. might need to be lynched in one of the games at some point
- sk vote on plat is probably the worst of the bunch if we assume he knew worm/didi was leading or almost leading then voted plat to tip the scale off, bc if sk voted worm there he would of made the wagon 7-7 tied and there could be a would worm gets lynched assuming no vote shenanigens. sk is a good player and idk what tf he was doing. id expect them to bus worm here if shes scum if anything instead of incriminate themselves over it. need to see more convincing gameplay otherwise can go / get checked.
worm voters look better overall:
- prof - town
- baroxio - town. gameplay, tone, watcher claim, and got targeted by the superkill.
- rej - leaning town. his day 1 was on town meta. hes vocal against worm but not much against didi. would only start looking into this slot if worm flips town
- yo tan - null/lean town. seems too disengaged with the game / posting in past tense for most of the time, like soul (not sk) but overall good tone and raising good points. would look into him more in depth if worm flips town. good vibes for now. can maybe tie him to a didi scum flip more than a worm one due to lack of interactions with didi, yet voting worm over didi.
- kira - null/lean scum - wud probs look here for a scum that wanted to bus worm day 1 for cred / parked vote on her but was not there in EoD to move it. hes the only person in worm's wagon im not confident enough to give him a clear look if worm flips scum.
didi voters are more nullish/scum:
- WPK - leaning town on him. good tone and posts. also targeted by superkill. MIA in day 3.
- worm - most prob just outed scum open wolfing and trolling at this point. shuda been yeeted day 1 or on night lynch
- tinky - nullish/leaning town. doesnt have much contributions. just from tone probably leaning inactive townie than inactive scum. could be indie too staying safe.
- hammer - scum. ive explained it multiple times in thread. also the claim to vote silence 2 people and can roleblock is super scummy. he feels self aware of his actions and contributes nothing but defensive and dismissive replies to questions and has not been part of the main wagons the entire game.
the flip order here should be worm > didi. i dont believe in that a worm lynch clears didi even if she flips scum and vice versa
also down to do worm > sin maybe worm > sk
hero, hammer, lind, kira need to be checked under worm/didi scum flips
8 plat voters: didi, juan, hero, lind, melkor, ratchet, sk, xadlin
6 worm voters: rej, yo tan, ekko, kira, baroxio, prof
5 didi voters: WPK, worm, plat, tinky, hammer
worm flipping scum here does not mean didi is not scum too. if either of them were town, mafia would of gladly taken that wagon for free then lynched plat after instead of derail for no reason and put blood on their hand
plat's voters:
- melkor made it clear that he is going for didi over worm. worm scum flip implicates him more than a didi scumflip, although from my past experience with melkor i dont think he defends a scum buddy this openly. if both didi and worm flip scum then perhaps didi might have a weaker role and thats where melkor was going for but i doubt it. also he has a green cop check on him. sin also tried to pin melkor as scum buddy of worm over the night with barely analyzing it so a sin scum flip probably just clears melkor for me altogether bc shading a player at night might cause night actions to harm them. leaning town.
- juan looks townie from general tone and play. he is being vocal against worm much more than against didi, and he pushed xadlin lynch day 2 which saved didi (which is more of a misplay from xadlin). i'd tie juan to a didi scumflip more than a worm scumflip. hes basically the reverse of melkor.
- hero started the game looking townie but his play has been falling off in the recent phases, plus he started the wagon on plat. hero is town reading didi altogether and has no notable interactions with worm / did not display a strong lean eitherway on them. this slot needs to be checked upon either flip scum tbh
- lind is a tossup for me. he started the game looking townie but kept going downhill in the recent phases in both games. i can cut him some slack since hes gotta play 24/7 but there is not much in depth solving coming from him other than town reading players and staying at a safe distance from the sideline, which is pretty indie like behavior. he preferred a worm lynch over didi in day 1 but then pushed for plat's lynch and tagged others to vote him by the end of the day. if hes like a super godfather he would be trying to find the scum teams on his own so his scum hunting can come off as genuine, yet reserved to his own self at the same time. might need to be lynched in one of the games at some point
- sk vote on plat is probably the worst of the bunch if we assume he knew worm/didi was leading or almost leading then voted plat to tip the scale off, bc if sk voted worm there he would of made the wagon 7-7 tied and there could be a would worm gets lynched assuming no vote shenanigens. sk is a good player and idk what tf he was doing. id expect them to bus worm here if shes scum if anything instead of incriminate themselves over it. need to see more convincing gameplay otherwise can go / get checked.
worm voters look better overall:
- prof - town
- baroxio - town. gameplay, tone, watcher claim, and got targeted by the superkill.
- rej - leaning town. his day 1 was on town meta. hes vocal against worm but not much against didi. would only start looking into this slot if worm flips town
- yo tan - null/lean town. seems too disengaged with the game / posting in past tense for most of the time, like soul (not sk) but overall good tone and raising good points. would look into him more in depth if worm flips town. good vibes for now. can maybe tie him to a didi scum flip more than a worm one due to lack of interactions with didi, yet voting worm over didi.
- kira - null/lean scum - wud probs look here for a scum that wanted to bus worm day 1 for cred / parked vote on her but was not there in EoD to move it. hes the only person in worm's wagon im not confident enough to give him a clear look if worm flips scum.
didi voters are more nullish/scum:
- WPK - leaning town on him. good tone and posts. also targeted by superkill. MIA in day 3.
- worm - most prob just outed scum open wolfing and trolling at this point. shuda been yeeted day 1 or on night lynch
- tinky - nullish/leaning town. doesnt have much contributions. just from tone probably leaning inactive townie than inactive scum. could be indie too staying safe.
- hammer - scum. ive explained it multiple times in thread. also the claim to vote silence 2 people and can roleblock is super scummy. he feels self aware of his actions and contributes nothing but defensive and dismissive replies to questions and has not been part of the main wagons the entire game.
the flip order here should be worm > didi. i dont believe in that a worm lynch clears didi even if she flips scum and vice versa
also down to do worm > sin maybe worm > sk
hero, hammer, lind, kira need to be checked under worm/didi scum flips
This means there will be no night lynch from here on too. We *have* to lynch Badalight tomorrow.
wtf happened why no night lynch
Nessos
"HighFiveNight" - News
I am going to get lynched....
Firestormer
Well-Known Member
lynch was redirected
Nessos
"HighFiveNight" - News
@Alibaba Saluja sadly I didn't survived Till the groups merged, I would have added you immediately to the nightshift....
anyway this confirms worm 99.999% scum and maybe a really strong role too
Can treat Sin as outed scum, too.
charles101
hot dog doodie
So basically votes on WJ means nothing, since they wanted to redirect it anyway. Maybe not early ones.
finally you see it too
if badalight scum as well then this perfectly explains the council bullsht