Game Favorites '22 - GROUP 2

[Ratchet]

Okay skimming over it seems like Santi was actually the quick wagon and Salah the one who was leading and got derailed from late. Hmmm.

 

[Ratchet]

tells/meta r pretty easy to change. i know my scum tells i can play around them. if u can read me by tells u wudnt have almost ragequit in higurashi unable to find me

What purpose does this serve?

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

does vote silence affect executes? cuz im voting to execute santi and i was silenced

Nitty said in the OP that the execute votes are all equal and not affected by vote silence/manipulation/extra vote power

 

[John Wayne]

tells/meta r pretty easy to change. i know my scum tells i can play around them. if u can read me by tells u wudnt have almost ragequit in higurashi unable to find me

That had more to do with the gamedesign than how you were playing.

 

[John Wayne]

What purpose does this serve?

Feels like he's baiting me

 

[Ekkologix]

santi has that one wifom post that pinged me hard. cant belive hes not executed tbh. i definitely should of pushed this harder and realizing something was up after the silence

 

[Ratchet]

That had more to do with the gamedesign than how you were playing.

I mean not really? Unless it's where you made an assumption about immunity that was not even present?

 

[John Wayne]

santi has that one wifom post that pinged me hard. cant belive hes not executed tbh. i definitely should of pushed this harder and realizing something was up after the silence

Which one are you referring to?

 

[Ratchet]

Feels like he's baiting me

Well yes, that's a given.

 

[Ekkologix]

What purpose does this serve?

denying his attempts to read by meta/tells

 

[Ratchet]

denying his attempts to read by meta/tells

Do you believe you have no scum tells?

 

[Ratchet]

After being on a streak of getting caught D1 as Scum? Really?

 

[Shizune]

@Salah WG (Fushiguro Tōji) was executed!
​

Fushiguro Tōji
from Jujutsu Kaisen
durability rating: 3

[Innate - Time Vessel Association] - Tōji's affiliation with a criminal group causes him to appear guilty to alignment investigations.

[Passive - Zero Cursed Energy] - Tōji's unique body protects him against magical kills.

[Passive - Inventory Curse] - Tōji's cursed spirit enables him to store many different kinds of weapons in his body, protecting him against counters.
​

---

[Active - Tactical - Mastermind] - During the day, Tōji can set a trap around another player. That night, Tōji will learn the name of anyone who visits them, and Tōji will mark those players with [Marked for Death]. Tōji cannot use this ability 2 days in a row.

[Marked for Death] - Fushiguro Tōji knows this player's weakness. This mark expires at the end of the next night.

[Active - Physical - Sorcerer Killer] - During the night, Tōji can use one of his many weapons to kill one player marked by [Marked for Death]. If Tōji's victim survives, they will bleed.

[One Shot Active - Magical - Heavenly Restriction] - During the night, Tōji can push his body to its limits to upgrade [Sorcerer Killer] to a superkill. If Tōji is alive when the two Favorites games are recombined, he will gain an extra charge of this ability.​

@Xadlin (Mafia Host) was lynched!
​

Mafia Host
from real life
durability rating: 3

[Active - Tactical - The Chosen Few] - During the day, the Mafia Host can mark up to 3 players with [You're in my game now!].

[You're in my game now!] - This player's fate is being decided by the Mafia Host. This mark expires at the end of the night.

[Active - Magical - I make the rules!] - During the night, the Mafia Host can use this ability to either protect or roleblock everyone marked by [Youre in my game now!].
​

---

[One Shot Active - Tactical - Host Overreach] - The Mafia Host can try to rig the game, enabling them to use [The Chosen Few] on 4 players that day. If the Mafia Host is alive when the two Favorites games are recombined, it will gain an extra charge of this ability.

[One Shot Active - Tactical - Power Creep] - The Mafia Host can buff its own role to improve [I make the rules!]. If the Mafia Host protects its targets, they will also be healed. If the Mafia Host roleblocks its targets, they will be role crushed for that night and the next cycle instead. If the Mafia Host is alive when the two Favorites games are recombined, it will gain an extra charge of this ability.
​

---

[Two Shot Active - Magical - Player Engagement] - The Mafia Host will try to appease unhappy players. During the night, the Mafia Host can use this ability on 3 players to cure them of any poisons and/or role crushes affecting them. If the Mafia Host is alive when the two Favorites games are recombined, they will gain 2 more charges of this ability. The Mafia Host cannot use this ability 2 nights in a row, and if the Mafia Host dies with unused charges of this ability, those charges will be randomly distributed out as one-shot abilities to living innocent players.​

@Xadlin, you are a true, original NFer. You were a joy to host for, and though this may not have been your game, I hope you remain part of the fabric of NF mafia for many years to come. And tell the OBD that we in the mafia section say hi!

Now, sashay way.

Night 2 start

@Nessos, @Natalija, @Ekkologix, @SinRaven and @Badalight can all post during the night. In fact, the night posters have now accumulated enough members that they can hold their own lynches at night.

Night posters will vote for a lynch with the same commands as during the day, and at the end of the night, the player who got the most votes will be lynched.

However, night posters require at least 3 votes on one person to lynch them.

Everybody else, no more posting.​

 

[Didi]

you missed my execution vote, I changed to Santi, in the proper format

@Shizune @Shizune @Shizune

 

[Ekkologix]

Do you believe you have no scum tells?

i do, and thats why they r easy to change if i try to
this whole argument is pointless
both games i was lynched day 1 i missed most of the day and just posted EoD (ToG and big 3). third one i was super lie detected (fuji's wow game)

there is also hypocrisy about saying i tunnel more as town/scum, but its not true. it depends on who i scum read and how confident i am of my read on them. i do this as either alignment. ppl will use this as a scum tell or town tell to match what they wanna say. i tunneled u as town in BB, and tunneled nat as scum in FF. we can yeet this scum tell off the window

 

[Shizune]

@Shizune @Shizune @Shizune

Sorry about that, but it wouldn't have made a difference anyway since Salah self-voted.

 

[Ekkologix]

welp

 

[Ekkologix]

@Nessos, @Natalija, @Ekkologix, @SinRaven and @Badalight can all post during the night. In fact, the night posters have now accumulated enough members that they can hold their own lynches at night.

Night posters will vote for a lynch with the same commands as during the day, and at the end of the night, the player who got the most votes will be lynched.

do we have to lynch among platinum/xadlin voters or anyone

 

[Shizune]

do we have to lynch among platinum/xadlin voters or anyone

You can lynch anyone.

 

[Nessos]

do we have to lynch among platinum/xadlin voters or anyone

Anyone but limited to our group

Thats BIG NEWs isn't it @Didi

 

[Ekkologix]

i dont get the idea behind rage quitting as town, specially when u have a good role. ur spitting on the host face tbh

vote lynch worm

 

[Shizune]

ur spitting on the host face tbh

Just to clear up any confusion, this is actually my kink

 

[Ekkologix]

Anyone but limited to our group

Thats BIG NEWs isn't it @Didi

op
go hammer/worm they avoided main wagon

 

[Nessos]

@Natalija thats actually the reason why I Pick my top townreads

Sry @WolfPrinceKiba couldn't effort to loose 2 members tonight

 

[Nessos]

op
go hammer/worm they avoided main wagon

Its a normal lynch we have the whole night to discuss.


Btw wouldn't mind protection tonight

 

[Nessos]

Whats up @Alibaba Saluja do you keep Up with group 2?

Any suggestion for our Lynch?

 

[Nessos]

I hope group 2 manages to hit a mafia today it's not fair we're forced to carry them smh

We have a lynch this night phase, feel free to start carrying!
We actually need it cause we failed again

 

[Natalija]

Me again

 

[Nessos]

Me again

Not again, once part of the nightshift always part of the nightshift.
Maybe you do understand now why I thought I am CL after I skimmed through my role the First time xDD


Tonight it makes sense to discuss our game, since we have lynch!

 

[Ekkologix]

im reconsidering my town read of didi

 

[Nessos]

im reconsidering my town read of didi

How do you about an @Oddjutsu or @Rej lynch?

 

[Ekkologix]

Not again, once part of the nightshift always part of the nightshift.
Maybe you do understand now why I thought I am CL after I skimmed through my role the First time xDD


Tonight it makes sense to discuss our game, since we have lynch!

love ur attitude nessos
i wish u can be more active during the day like at night phase lol

 

[Nessos]

love ur attitude nessos
i wish u can be more active during the day like at night phase lol

I am to busy to handle big groups... Thus I really like my ability discussion with a few.

In general I like small games more then big ones.

 

[Ekkologix]

How do you about an @Oddjutsu or @Rej lynch?

not optimal
hammer/worm/didi have to be flipped for game to move forward atp
specially the 2 who avoiding joining main wagon

 

[Ekkologix]

Me again

ur stuck with us forever nat, until death separates us apart!

 

[Nessos]

not optimal
hammer/worm/didi have to be flipped for game to move forward atp
specially the 2 who avoiding joining main wagon

Odd also avoided the main wagon D1 and D2.
But yeah Rej would be waste since He joined Xadlin lynch.

 

[Nessos]

ur stuck with us forever nat, until death separates us apart!

Hope someone managed to protect her

 

[Nessos]

@Nessos

Between Odd and and Kira there might be scum there

Thanks

@Alwaysmind also wanna share your thoughts?

 

[Ekkologix]

Odd also avoided the main wagon D1 and D2.
But yeah Rej would be waste since He joined Xadlin lynch.

im nullish on odd. could be anything
rej's lynch wud be a complete surprised to the scum team if he was one, but i dont think he is rn. also hes available as a wagon tomorrow so that too

 

[Natalija]

Not again, once part of the nightshift always part of the nightshift.
Maybe you do understand now why I thought I am CL after I skimmed through my role the First time xDD


Tonight it makes sense to discuss our game, since we have lynch!

We’re a cult, got it

Very annoying how the Xadlin lynch turned out.

Who shall be the lynchees tomorrow? Maybe we should lynch outside that circle.

 

[Ekkologix]

fuck game 1 tbh
kinda salty

 

[Ekkologix]

Very annoying how the Xadlin lynch turned out.

w8 how is it "very annoying" for you when u barely helped out with it / suggested something else during the day nattie

 

[Ekkologix]

flowa winner reacted the lynch flip

u know this is a declaration of war right?

stop helping game 1

 

[Natalija]

w8 how is it "very annoying" for you when u barely helped out with it / suggested something else during the day nattie

I was traveling, couldn’t be helpful. Besides I’m dying

 

[Natalija]

[vote lynch Ekkologix]

 

[Ekkologix]

I was traveling, couldn’t be helpful. Besides I’m dying

we gotchu nat, i hope
we dont let our nakama die

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Only these people can post right now in this thread
@Nessos, @Natalija, @Ekkologix, @SinRaven and @Badalight

 

[Ekkologix]

completely forgot u guys actually dying
this aint looking pretty ngl
maybe i rly need to go past 1%

 

[Ekkologix]

I actually kinda believe Xaldin ability wise because it sounds mechanically similar to how some of my stuff works and how some of the revealed roles work. That said, it doesn't necessarily mean he is town.

You said you find me sus. You provide no reasoning. The burden of proof is not on me mate. No town has down anything worthwhile this game.

I am not trying to protect him. I even pushed him on multiple things such as how his ability seems very over powered for a town role and how it seems really dumb to fire off 3 random rule-crushes on day 1. All I was saying is his ability mechanically sounds similar to mine and I'm not diving into that further because I'd have to give more specific info on how my role works. That is to say, I don't think he is completely lying. Of course, the best lies are ones with truth mixed in so take that for what you will.

I will look into Melkor more.

Justify my vote going there? I haven't voted either for or against him. I was asking questions to get him to reveal information, which he did. And if anything, my posts were far more suspicious of Didi than Xadlin so this is a weird interpretation.

Also why would I discredit the only confirmed townie? I was just saying if you think I am scum you'd be wrong for the second time, mostly tongue in cheek (because you would be, because I am town).

this reaction when ratchet was pressuing badalight looks towny to me given xadlin's flip. happens to me alot when i am town and someone tells me that im defending someone thats commonly scum read and i dont really know how to feel about them myself or prefer to lynch someone else. i will be town in games where X player has like votes piling on him and i get nervous that if he flips scum i will look bad for it, even though im not part of their team. specially happens when ratchet keeps asking me these kind of questions why am i defending so and so or defense of so and so is noted so i start justifying how i am not defending that player and voice my concerns on them from the sideline, all the while still joining the majority on their decision. scum badalight knows that xadlin is town here so probably commits more to the defense / tries to set up mislynches based on xadlin's flip, instead badalight here was trying to extend some sort of helping hand to xadlin, but you can sense the nervousness/defensivenss in his responses after seeing all of us scum reading xadlin and felt left out so felt the need to provide a reason why he scum reads xadlin like in the bolded because hes afraid that if xadlin flips scum, he will be suspected too / put in an awkward position. this reaction looks genuinely uninformed of xadlin's alignment. leaning town on a badalight off this

 

[Ekkologix]

The following reads are unsorted, and of varying degrees of strength -

Town:
Baroxio - Town
charles101 - Town
DrProfessor83 - Town
Ekkologix - Town
Fang - Town
Hero - Town
Juan - Town
Natalija - Town
Nessos - Town
Rej - Town
Soul - Town
SoulKiller - Town
tinky winky - Town
WolfPrinceKiba - Town

Indie:
Lind - Indie (probably not outwardly hostile I think)

Nulls:
Firestormer - Null
Franky - Null
Kira Yagami - Null
Melodie - Null
Salah WG -Null
Santí - Null
sworder - Null
Yo Tan Wa - Null

Scum:
Didi - Scum*
Badalight - Scum
hammer - Scum
Iwandesu - Scum
John Wayne - Scum*
Lord Melkor - Scum
Oddjutsu - Scum
SinRaven - Scum
Worm Juice - Scum
Xadlin - Scum

* - I'm not satisfied with JW being here, and I can come around to him being Town I think. Didi is in a similar boat, where I've liked some of his content but holistically it doesn't look all that great, but I could also come around to him being Town. I'm expecting between 6-8 scum here, hoping for at least 4 in the scum list.

Can someone (or multiple) discuss these with me? I think Vigs need to be looking in here. Interested to see how many townies I'm misreading in that list too. Would like discussion there as well.

just saw this list. there r couple i disagree with. im gna iso all the scum reads over the night and give u my thoughts on them. gna take a break now

 

[Shizune]

Hello hello,

I just want to remind everyone about two important mechanics in play tonight:​

@Natalija and @WolfPrinceKiba were marked for death! They will both be superkilled tonight. However, other players can visit them tonight disperse to the damage out among themselves and save them. Beware that those of you who choose to help them may take some damage in the process!

@SinRaven and @Yo Tan Wa were booby trapped. Anyone who visits them tonight will be role crushed for the next cycle.​

TL;DR:

Use abilities on @Natalija and @WolfPrinceKiba tonight to help save them from the impending superkills, but in doing so you may receive some damage too.

Avoid using abilities on @SinRaven and @Yo Tan Wa, or you will be role crushed next cycle.​

 

[Natalija]

Didi, Juan, Ekko there you go, scumhunting

Interesting.

I do think the fact that the townie with the ability has already been revealed makes it less likely that there are multiple others of the same alignment, though.

Which townie is that? You believe Juan is automatically a townie?

I am a firm believer that Didi is not scum. What is even the basis for all of that? Looking back at Day 1, his wagon was started by Tinky Winky and was bullshit. He literally said let’s get rid of an old ^ (not the meaning of the word "respect".) and people followed.

[Vote Lynch Xadlin]

He on the other hand does have suspicious voting behavior and reasoning documented in the thread. Although he’s been forthcoming with his abilities, he hasn’t exactly claimed town or from my knowledge answered who he used his abilities on. He’s also brushed me aside with my critiques of his gameplay.

[Vote Execute Salah WG]

At least Santí has posted.

What do you mean hasn’t claimed town or who he used his abilities on? He has

WJ, hammer, iwan

So inactive inactive and inactive.

These are super lazy reads. The entire scum team cannot be inactive, especially not since their kill(s) imply that they’re on top of things.
t

Yeah that's obviously a possibility as well. Mind you tho that this post happened at the moment the votes locked so that to me indicates SoulKiller was eager to put in his vote. I don't see why a townie would be so eager to quickly put his vote in before day ends.

Honestly WJ flipping would give us so much info

What “info” would WJ flipping give us, Sinnie?

 

[Natalija]

I have a feeling we’re on a goose chase and scum is leading it by pushing us onto inactives.

I’m more worried about them being the top posters…

@Badalight you had some doubts about Xadlin, who would you lynch now after their flip?

 

[Natalija]

Nat out

 

[Ekkologix]

okay i lied, dont feel like isoing sht . exhausted af
just wanna sht talk now

whose scum @Natalija @Nessos @Badalight ?
why did u add sin here? u trust him?

 

[Ekkologix]

I have a feeling we’re on a goose chase and scum is leading it by pushing us onto inactives.

I’m more worried about them being the top posters…

@Badalight you had some doubts about Xadlin, who would you lynch now after their flip?

got any names nat?

 

[Ekkologix]

@Ratchet i dont thnk melkor scum

or badalight

or didi ... tho conflicted on this one because of how self aware he feels in his posts yet seems uninformed at the same time. he just wants to survive the lynch. inb4 indie

rest of the list can go

i think we can do worm or hammer today since they r not in the lynch list tomorow

odd is also a suggestion. though i prefer flipping one of the first 2 as they provide more info moving forward

iwan/santi can go. hopefully tomorrow's execute

whose left

 

[Ekkologix]

sin had some posts EoD but didnt feel like he added much to the discussion
like firestormer/yotan summaries

idk why nessos felt the need to add him here

birds together stronk and all that kek

who we yeeting tonight sin?

 

[Badalight]

Oh cool I can night post. I will catch up in a few hours and then be around for awhile if other people are around.

 

[Badalight]

Oh god we have a night lynch? Clarification, who is eligible for this lynch? Also does lynching someone at night make us eligible for a future lynch? If so, is that in the day or night?

 

[Ekkologix]

deep wolf wud be kira or hero

 

[Badalight]

Also whoever voted for Salah over Santi is dumb imo

 

[Ekkologix]

Oh god we have a night lynch? Clarification, who is eligible for this lynch? Also does lynching someone at night make us eligible for a future lynch? If so, is that in the day or night?

we can lynch anyone tonight

next day the lynch will still be among xadlin's voters

pls confirm the 2nd line @Shizune

 

[Ekkologix]

Also whoever voted for Salah over Santi is dumb imo

salah voters

3. @charles101 - Salah WG
4. @Didi - Franky > Salah WG
7. @Fang - Salah WG
8. @Firestormer - Salah WG
11. @Hero - Salah WG
20. @Nessos - Salah WG
21. @Oddjutsu - Salah WG
22. @Rej - Salah WG
24. @Santí - Salah WG
27. @SoulKiller - Salah WG
29. @tinky winky - Salah WG

atleast 4 scum here imo

odd/santi need to be purged in this list most prob

 

[Shizune]

we can lynch anyone tonight

next day the lynch will still be among xadlin's voters

pls confirm the 2nd line @Shizune

Correct

 

[Badalight]

Correct

But let's assume there is a lynch tomorrow night.

Are we then choosing to lynch between the 4 of us?

 

[Shizune]

But let's assume there is a lynch tomorrow night.

Are we then choosing to lynch between the 4 of us?

What

You can lynch anyone it doesn’t have to be in your night posting group

also you need 5 night posters alive to lynch, Less than that and you can’t lynch

 

[Badalight]

What

You can lynch anyone it doesn’t have to be in your night posting group

also you need 5 night posters alive to lynch, Less than that and you can’t lynch

So it follows different rules than the day lynch. As in, let's say for example we voted to lynch Shizune and we all agreed. Tomorrow night we can still choose between anyone and not just those of us who voted for Shizune?

 

[Shizune]

So it follows different rules than the day lynch. As in, let's say for example we voted to lynch Shizune and we all agreed. Tomorrow night we can still choose between anyone and not just those of us who voted for Shizune?

No, night lynch can lynch anyone

 

[Ekkologix]

So it follows different rules than the day lynch. As in, let's say for example we voted to lynch Shizune and we all agreed. Tomorrow night we can still choose between anyone and not just those of us who voted for Shizune?

yo stop talking to the host and talk to us lol
who we yeeting tonight?

 

[Ekkologix]

 

[Ekkologix]

im bored sm1 do smth

 

[Badalight]

yo stop talking to the host and talk to us lol
who we yeeting tonight?

I haven't caught up yet. Gimme a sec. I'll be here all night. But prior to me catching up I think fang might be worth taking a look at but also I don't even know who is up for lynch and execution tmr gimme a sec.

 

[Ekkologix]

I haven't caught up yet. Gimme a sec. I'll be here all night. But prior to me catching up I think fang might be worth taking a look at but also I don't even know who is up for lynch and execution tmr gimme a sec.

fang is available for yeet tomorow. he voted xadlin

[Vote Lynch Xadlin]

I tried

this vote isnt in the vote count. but fang shud be up for lynch

 

[Badalight]

okay caught up now

Santi is who I voted for in the execution and I have had suspicions since D1. Fang I also made a post calling him out but no one paid attention to it. He said something to the effect of "this will make me look scummy but I targeted Lalisa last night." To me that sounds like a scum trying to throw shade on themselves in order to hide in plain sight, so to speak. Like the logic would be that by saying that people will think "oh, he can't be scum because he brought attention to himself." Either way, by his own admission he is now useless because of his actions so it wouldn't be the worst mislynch even if we went in that direction.

That's all I've got. I'd like to look more into Charles and Hero.

 

[Badalight]

Oh, also think we should consider SK, Sworder, and Iwan.

Sworder and Iwan are even more scummy than Santi in that they are posting just enough to not be up for execution and they are not voting to lynch anyone (correct me if I am wrong here but I believe this is the case).

SK I am still not forgetting that weird interaction at the start. Why did SK get replaced when DDL got modkilled in the other game? It makes no sense.

Fang, Santi, SK, Sworder, Iwan

Those are my top atm

 

[Ekkologix]

quick look at fang

[Vote Execute Salah WG]

I don't see the issue. Someone can vig Santi in the night phase, Salah has been less active then Santi in comparison. Brother, don't be a hothead here.

this kinda looks bad if santi flips scum with bulletproof/benefits from kills
if he scum reads santi to the point where he is redirecting vigs to shoot him, then he shud have no problem with executing santi today bc salah still remains in the execution platform tomorrow while santi likely does not, so we lose the chance to yeet him

Has Sworder even posted?

@Melodie

Whose Franky

couple of his day 2 posts r gated towards inactives
overall involvement with the day were pretty lackluster aside from one liners, questions about inactives, the claim about wasting an ability on lalisa, and filler back and forth about my full power

 

[Badalight]

What do you think about SK?

 

[Ekkologix]

You haven't been posting much

people forget we all live in different timezones

Its like 4am in his part of Europe

im being serious here, I had so many people in the past accuse me of ignoring them and got a 10+ wagon before I woke up

So am I.

this interaction is shallow and went nowhere
i havent played much with fang. does he always just post one liners?

 

[Badalight]

Aside from the weird replacement thing with SK which is a bit metagamey but w/e...

He has been doing a lot of buddying up with people. Did it with me, Soul, etc... He also keeps saying "I will be more active tomorrow" and stuff of that nature but never delivers. A lot of his suspicions have been hedges as well, and he has been bandwagon voting.