Game Favorites '22 - GROUP 2

[SinRaven]

Also didn't say anything about your alignment there silly

The reason I suspect you is because you flip flop all over the place. You're trying to derail town a LOT, pushing for chaos mate

Also you being scum completely aligns with my hard tunnel on WJ and the people trying to save her

 

[Firestormer]

anyway if we're not gonna execute santi can we pls execute iwan instead

Melodie, sworder or Franky are up for this one. He got enough posts to avoid it somehow

 

[Ekkologix]

vote execute melodie

 

[charles101]

Okay we can probably move the execution away from Santi today. Someone mass tag please.

Hmmm? Now I'm kinda confused. Usopp's result stays and neighbour=/=trade thing stays. What changed?

 

[Ratchet]

Get rid of Franky IMO.

 

[Ratchet]

Hmmm? Now I'm kinda confused. Usopp's result stays and neighbour=/=trade thing stays. What changed?

You're free to read the thread.

 

[Ekkologix]

vote execute franky

actually this is better. his name was in worm's posts multiple times

 

[charles101]

anyway if we're not gonna execute santi can we pls execute iwan instead

It's Santi/Franky/Melody/Sworder

 

[Santí]

okay then was that hard to clarify when being asked about it?

Yes, I don't trust you and you were being cryptic as hell. I'm not going to answer questions about my role unless I know the answer will help town.

I had no idea what your alignment or intentions were, ofc I'm going to blow you off.

 

[Juan]

hes not up for execution

oh

wtf

can someone vig him then

 

[Juan]

[Vote Execute Franky]

 

[Santí]

oh

wtf

can someone vig him then

Let's make a deal

 

[Ratchet]

Yes, I don't trust you and you were being cryptic as hell. I'm not going to answer questions about my role unless I know the answer will help town.

I had no idea what your alignment or intentions were, ofc I'm going to blow you off.

Who are you voting for the execution?

 

[Santí]

Who are you voting for the execution?

Melodie atm.

 

[charles101]

You're free to read the thread.

I did. You went from tagging everyone to 1 for 1 Santi to switching because maybe Fang used wrong term on accident. That's kinda out of nowhere

 

[Juan]

Let's make a deal

oh, you and i making a deal

is precisely what i'm counting on

 

[charles101]

I mean sure, I won't argue with confirmed town, but that whole thing makes little to no sense for me.

[Change Vote Execute Franky] @Shizune @Kvothe Kingkiller change again, sorry for mess

 

[Ekkologix]

Also didn't say anything about your alignment there silly

The reason I suspect you is because you flip flop all over the place. You're trying to derail town a LOT, pushing for chaos mate

Also you being scum completely aligns with my hard tunnel on WJ and the people trying to save her

that is so untrue for my gameplay this game, in fact i am being suspected for the lack of it. where is this coming from even

 

[DrProfessor83]

I did. You went from tagging everyone to 1 for 1 Santi to switching because maybe Fang used wrong term on accident. That's kinda out of nowhere

Is it? Juan collaborates Santi’s story that it isn’t a chat, which is the entire reason for that proposed 1 for 1. If you remove the chat aka the point of conflict, then why wouldn’t things change?

[Change Vote Execute Franky]

 

[Ratchet]

I did. You went from tagging everyone to 1 for 1 Santi to switching because maybe Fang used wrong term on accident. That's kinda out of nowhere

There is a clear progression of Juan offering information that serves as a counterbalance here. is there a good reason for you to be neglecting to mention that?

 

[Firestormer]

sure

[Vote execute Franky]

 

[Ekkologix]

Yes, I don't trust you and you were being cryptic as hell. I'm not going to answer questions about my role unless I know the answer will help town.

I had no idea what your alignment or intentions were, ofc I'm going to blow you off.

misunderestanding came from fang using incorrect word to describe what happened
anyway now thats cleared
any scum reads?

 

[Ekkologix]

I did. You went from tagging everyone to 1 for 1 Santi to switching because maybe Fang used wrong term on accident. That's kinda out of nowhere

juan vouched for santi's ability as not a chat
do u have scum reads charlie?

 

[Juan]

is badalight voting worm juice btw i can't be assed to check myself

 

[Ekkologix]

is badalight voting worm juice btw i can't be assed to check myself

i dont think hes voting any1

 

[Ratchet]

Badalight is, once again, avoiding the wagon. He's a good night lynch target.

 

[Juan]

i dont think hes voting any1

@Badalight vote worm juice

 

[DrProfessor83]

Lean Scum on @charles101

What do you think about these posts? Seemed like something scum wouldn’t really think to flip out about and has potential to be an attention drawer. Especially after his gambit in your game backfired on him. Would expect him to be more cautious of landing in another situation right after (not exactly the same situation though).

Now I'm getting paranoid af.

These are literally my actions from N1 and N2.

Like, maybe that's too much tinfoil from me, but what are the chances that 2 people got results on same 2 people back to back? Am I crazy here or something?

Basically what makes me paranoid

1 - you have exact same investigation results as me on D3
2 - you say Santi it's from Santi who's top1 target to get executed
3 - Santi showed up when day started, shared his results with you and decided to not post them in thread for some reason (you could say he didn't want to claim, but then why would you do that)

Like, that's weird af tbh.

Can more people say something about it?

Well, I'm just paranoid because I remember having "steal investigation results" abilities as scum a couple times. Welp, at least I can confirm LM's innocence (unless he's GF).

Should've probably stayed quiet

Had me thinking he was probably town when I first read through. But I don’t like his posts around Ekko/Santi.

 

[Firestormer]

jfc I am not doing this anymore

I am not putting myself up for lynch because it's the only surefire way to kill me. I have a tanky af role, like usual. Because that's kind of my thing on this site. There's a reason my nickname is Badaroach.

Vig me if you want. It will fail. I don't care. I will not be putting myself up for lynch unless I am confident in the person. So far I have been right about all of the kills anyway - except Odd but I already discussed my hands were kinda tied there.

He's probably not going to join it, if he's ever lynched it's only going to happen at night

 

[Nessos]

vote execute franky

actually this is better. his name was in worm's posts multiple times

 

[Juan]

He's probably not going to join it, if he's ever lynched it's only going to happen at night

@Nessos @Ekkologix @SinRaven

get his ass tonight sil vous plait xoxo

 

[Ratchet]

What do you think about these posts? Seemed like something scum wouldn’t really think to flip out about and has potential to be an attention drawer. Especially after his gambit in your game backfired on him. Would expect him to be more cautious of landing in another situation right after (not exactly the same situation though).






Had me thinking he was probably town when I first read through. But I don’t like his posts around Ekko/Santi.

Eh that's true. It would be somewhat out of the scum range I have for him.

 

[Ekkologix]

 

[Santí]

any scum reads?

Bada's been my top scum read since D2. His behavior is just abhorrent.

Don't really have any other strong inclinations at this point.

 

[Ekkologix]

Bada's been my top scum read since D2. His behavior is just abhorrent.

Don't really have any other strong inclinations at this point.

take a look at sin and tell me what u see

 

[Nessos]

[change vote execute Melodie]

 

[Santí]

take a look at sin and tell me what u see

a loud bird.

 

[charles101]

Is it? Juan collaborates Santi’s story that it isn’t a chat, which is the entire reason for that proposed 1 for 1. If you remove the chat aka the point of conflict, then why wouldn’t things change?

There is a clear progression of Juan offering information that serves as a counterbalance here. is there a good reason for you to be neglecting to mention that?

Juan explains that trade is a thing and it's not a chat. That doesn't explain why Fang called in neighbour chat. Like, it's really specific term.

 

[Ratchet]

Juan explains that trade is a thing and it's not a chat. That doesn't explain why Fang called in neighbour chat. Like, it's really specific term.

Yes but on reflection it doesn't even really matter. Certainly not enough to establish a 1:1 here.

 

[Ekkologix]

[vote execute santi]
[vote lynch ekko]

this is scum btw

 

[Ekkologix]

cant get any more blatant really

 

[Ratchet]

cant get any more blatant really

If only you had a night lynch where you got to put your posturing to the test.

 

[charles101]

Yes but on reflection it doesn't even really matter. Certainly not enough to establish a 1:1 here.

Usopp's claimed results stay though. Santi could be frammed, but there's no way Didi and Usopp got different result when they both investigated him. Also that would add up to my tinfoil from earlier.

If I'll ever investigate anyone and get guilty result, feel free to 1:1 me on that.

 

[Didi]

>santi push
>now franky push
yeah I'm starting to feel good about my scumread on sworder

 

[Ratchet]

Usopp's claimed results stay though. Santi could be frammed, but there's no way Didi and Usopp got different result when they both investigated him. Also that would add up to my tinfoil from earlier.

If I'll ever investigate anyone and get guilty result, feel free to 1:1 me on that.

Who said Ekko investigated him?

 

[Ratchet]

>santi push
>now franky push
yeah I'm starting to feel good about my scumread on sworder

Why do you think Franky is Town?

 

[Didi]

Why do you think Franky is Town?

I have a complete null read on Franky because he has like 1 post

 

[Ratchet]

I have a complete null read on Franky because he has like 1 post

Right, hence why I think he's a fine execution target.

 

[Ekkologix]

If only you had a night lynch where you got to put your posturing to the test.

yall gotta cut me some slack tbh
who would u have pushed for last night in my position?

Usopp's claimed results stay though. Santi could be frammed, but there's no way Didi and Usopp got different result when they both investigated him. Also that would add up to my tinfoil from earlier.

If I'll ever investigate anyone and get guilty result, feel free to 1:1 me on that.

i never investigated him ur way off the mark here
i just claimed that if he started a chat with fang last night he is scum.

 

[Didi]

Right, hence why I think he's a fine execution target.

Not saying he's not a good target

just a bit suspicious that there seems to be an aversion on executing sworder

 

[charles101]

i never investigated him ur way off the mark here
i just claimed that if he started a chat with fang last night he is scum.

You said you have mechanical evidence that he's scum

i have mechanical evidence at u being scum

 

[Ratchet]

yall gotta cut me some slack tbh
who would u have pushed for last night in my position?

My top scum reads.

Not saying he's not a good target

just a bit suspicious that there seems to be an aversion on executing sworder

I can't say I've noticed that.

 

[Ekkologix]

My top scum reads.

those being?

 

[Didi]

You said you have mechanical evidence that he's scum

could just be something like 'passive - u get notified/added to/a few random replies for every chat that gets created this game' or something like that

not worth fishing for details

 

[charles101]

Not saying he's not a good target

just a bit suspicious that there seems to be an aversion on executing sworder

To be fair, you can say exact same thing about Melody.

 

[Ratchet]

those being?

At this point probably Sin.

 

[Ekkologix]

You said you have mechanical evidence that he's scum

does not imply i investigated him. mechanical means its ability/result related. does not have to be an investigation but i can see the line of thought here as an aries player with bunch of mech stuff being investigations

 

[charles101]

does not imply i investigated him. mechanical means its ability/result related. does not have to be an investigation but i can see the line of thought here as an aries player with bunch of mech stuff being investigations

so this "i have mechanical reason" was this whole chat/trade/santi/fang/juan thing?



nvm, don't respond

Buuuuut, again, if you're so sure on hammer being scum and he claims being immune to lynches, why aren't you pushing for putting him sightly ahead of WJ to test that or something?

 

[Ekkologix]

At this point probably Sin.

no fook at this point
what about yesterday during the night
wud u have dunked on bada worm didi or whoever there? too many options. who of those were ur top scum reads?

i admit i may have played the night a bit lackluster due to being tired for most of it and not feeling like isoing and all but i indented to yeet scum there. nessos opposed sin bc he wanted the night lynch to keep going and nat opposed worm/hammer since they r inactive. the compromise i can give here was either didi, or odd that nessos was proposing and i stuck with didi even tho he was at some point a TR of mine. the expectation that im supposed to defend odd doesnt make sense there even if i played the night lynch bad. i had no town read of him nor does he earns himself any charitable attempt from me to spare his slot there granted his gameplay. i made myself clear if they r confident in his scum flip they can go for it, otherwise im sticking with the flips that gives most momentum being didi/worm. them not listening is not something in my control. the votes were parked and dipped

 

[Ekkologix]

so this "i have mechanical reason" was this whole chat/trade/santi/fang/juan thing?



nvm, don't respond

Buuuuut, again, if you're so sure on hammer being scum and he claims being immune to lynches, why aren't you pushing for putting him sightly ahead of WJ to test that or something?

no what? worm goes first
has hammer really claimd lynch immunity? i thought he was just asking about it but not claiming it

 

[Ekkologix]

hammer is not even eligible today

 

[Ekkologix]

sin terrifies me because i learned mafia basics from him. i have to ascend and break this barrier and overcome my sensei

 

[Firestormer]

so this "i have mechanical reason" was this whole chat/trade/santi/fang/juan thing?



nvm, don't respond

Buuuuut, again, if you're so sure on hammer being scum and he claims being immune to lynches, why aren't you pushing for putting him sightly ahead of WJ to test that or something?

Why do you wish to lynch hammer over WJ?

 

[Didi]

sin terrifies me because i learned mafia basics from him. i have to ascend and break this barrier and overcome my sensei

>he learned how to play mafia from sin
I take back my mental disability comments, this explains everything

 

[Fang]

he just said its not, but never felt the need to correct fang earlier. feels like backtracking now that hes caught

@Fang were u in a chat with santi or no?

He offered a trade and I accepted. I never said me and Santi chatted.

 

[Juan]

man did nitty really disappear to go get his back blown out

 

[Fang]

i... actually don't know

maybe fang is misusing terms or something? i think we got the same offer and there was no neighbor chat for me

Yeah, it wasn't a chat. I don't know what the exact term was but I recieved an offer in night 2 from Santi and that's how I got him to cop/investigate Melkor in exchange for something on my end.

 

[Ekkologix]

He offered a trade and I accepted. I never said me and Santi chatted.

the use of the term neighbourizer implies an out of game chat where u guys can talk. he just sent you an offer message via the host, not a neighbourizer.

stilll not an indicative of santi's alignment bc gifts can be scum abilities too. its just my ability no longer incriminates him directly.

 

[Ekkologix]

>he learned how to play mafia from sin
I take back my mental disability comments, this explains everything

u gna let this slide @SinRaven ?

 

[Kira Yagami]

At this point I'm starting to lean towards the scum team being mostly active posters

U gotta be more specific than that

 

[Nessos]

Didn't know @SinRaven and @Ekkologix had sich a deep relationship

 

[Soul]

Still catching up, at page 98

This isn't really the time to cut corners

Fairly straightforward but sure.
*She is not contributing in any meaningful way, annoying posters instead, yet she keeps avoiding our lynches by doing nothing.
*She escaped the night lynch AGAIN for some unexplainable reason by the night voters.
-This also leads me to believe that at least 1 night voter in the night phase are mafia.
*Her votes make no sense, derailing useful conversation.

Not sure why you would question this vote, to be honest. I guess ghosts get bored, too.

what the fuck is happening in this game

lmao hiii

 

[Kira Yagami]

I was asking for a reason.

i wanted a reason he thought that cause i dont recall him having anything to do with WJ or the lynch unless i missed something

 

[SinRaven]

sin terrifies me because i learned mafia basics from him. i have to ascend and break this barrier and overcome my sensei

Wtf no I'm not responsible for this idiocy

 

[Nessos]

Wtf no I'm not responsible for this idiocy

Thinking about it a bird raising someone with a slingshot is actually stupid af, what have you done

 

[SinRaven]

>he learned how to play mafia from sin
I take back my mental disability comments, this explains everything

Who in their right mind would pick me as a sensei

He definitely is mentally disabled lmao

 

[SinRaven]

Didn't know @SinRaven and @Ekkologix had sich a deep relationship

I think he's confusing me with someone else

 

[charles101]

Why do you wish to lynch hammer over WJ?

Tbh if he's lynch immune town, lynch would go to WJ anyway.

 

[Soul]

I do not see Santi contributing a lot today. Your defense of him is noted.

He isn't contributing as much as other, but he is definitely contributing enough to not be executed:
He confronted me on my vote for him, which I explained in depth, Answered my question for reads and voted for Worm (making himself available for next lynch phase).
Fang also vouched for him in this same day phase, which helped clear some suspicion since his explanation makes sense (this is one of many posts on the subject).

In short, keep in mind that I wanted him dead for not doing shit, then he started pitching in. No reason for me wanting him dead now.
Please note those details as well.

 

[charles101]

Yeah, it wasn't a chat. I don't know what the exact term was but I recieved an offer in night 2 from Santi and that's how I got him to cop/investigate Melkor in exchange for something on my end.

Neighbour chat is private PM. Like your role PM but with neighbour, other person.

Mason chat would be the same thing except you're both confirmed town, I'm pretty sure.

What you're describing here is just a message