Game Members Mafia 4 (indies win!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
SinRaven said:
OK, give a proper explanation on both of your scumreads please. Also, why didnt you mention me in your first response to being asked about your reads?
Click to expand...

Because I am lazy

As for Iwan I don't know how to explain it other than a feeling of insincerity in his posts.

As for you it's the same vibe thing, I don't have any concrete examples to give but for the moment it's just slight leans.
 
Something else that I've been thinking about. I initially penned Rem as a town quite awhile ago (and I still do) largely because I didn't feel like it would be economical for mafia to come out of the gate so strong. However, a few pages ago there was some discussion about my namesake role likely being hard to kill which could indicate it being a mafia role. If that is the case, it's not that risky to be an active poster in the game. After all, in the game where I was deemed "Badaroach" I was hard to kill and was basically the most active player in the game. It's just something I thought about when I read Hero's post about people being quick to believe people just because they are posting a lot.
 
Scumdesu said:
Anyway
So far
Townish reads

Laix- looks solid so far
Flower (just because i think she is the brodcaster and seems like an unlikely scum role, this is a nitty game tho)


Null/should be looked at (maybe gonna do an iso or something)
DDL (lets see how he plays out)
Melodie (danger girl)
Is a (he usually coasts as scum but the truth is that he is good enough to fake such meta)
Lord Genome (again, lord genome is a good town and a monstruos scum)

Null/scummy
Cooler(tipical day 1 coasting of his, got remchu on his tracks so lets see how this plays)
Bada- Liked some of his posts, disliked others but nothing extraordinary so far,

Scummy reads
Remchu (he could do everything he is doing as town tho)
Click to expand...

This is really funny because it’s sort of been somewhat true in recent times but I used to be the numba one power wolf as scum :del

Laix said:
I think he was trying to argue WAD provides nothing as town so let’s lynch and if we hit scum then that’s a bonus
Click to expand...

Ouch

Scumdesu said:
@is a
@Melodie
@Lord Genome

You guys are either good town or terribly scary scumswhich of those are you this time around ?
Click to expand...

>good town

imagine a wad that doesn’t lead his own town to his doom :doggokek

but yeah im town i am p sure lg is town and i hard lean scum on melodie but too biased to lynch her d1
 
Pool Party Nitty said:
The game has been divided into 3 groups. These groups are:

Aragorn
Babby
Badalight
Cooler
Worm Juice
Flower
Go D. Usopp
Hayumi
Hero
is a
Kvothe Kingkiller

Iwandesu
John Wayne
Juan
Karma
Kira Yagami
Laix
Legend
Lord Genome
Lord Melkor
Melodie
Nessos

Nevan
nfcnorth
Owner Of A Lonely Heart
Natalija
Ratchet
RemChu
Santi
SinRaven
Underworld Broker
WolfPrinceKiba
Dragon D. Luffy

During the night phase, you will only be able to target players who are in your group, so plan your actions accordingly.
Click to expand...
Damn don patch
 
Kvothe Kingkiller said:
I think I'm satisfied for now.

@ kenny
top town read is Laix and Remchu currently
Scum, not sure yet. Would watch out for Broki cause when she was godfather, she laid low pretty well. @Scumdesu why did you want Remchu to claim?
Click to expand...
Easy
Remchu was overral extremely scummy, overeacting and omgusing everywhere.
I gotta say i also never said "claim or die" or somehing like that just "we might need a remchu claim".
 
Kira Yagami said:
Does John Wayne seem a bit odd so far or is it just me? A quick skim through his posts and id assume he were scum if i were to jump the gun
Click to expand...
Cooler said:
I cba to quote his posts individually but this search has them all.

https://www.narutoforums.org/search/47762704/

He's keeping his posts very low key. Couple of small observations on the game but that's it. Not trying to ruffle feathers maybe?
Click to expand...
Activity is not indicative on John Wayne alignment but anytime he rolls indie/scum he can't help but actively coast and be careful
 
Scumdesu said:
tfw this game has actually 30+ players

Anyway lets do some quick rundown on the bottom players

Anyway Hero actually posted for god knows why reason
This likely doesnt mean anything but anytime hero rolls serial killers/mafia or cultists he AFKs
And when he rolls town he gets modkilled :dank
So...yeah i dunno



Aragorn has posted....literally nothing of substance the entire game :dank
Also he asked 2 players if they had post restrictions (which should be a thing on this kind of games but why keep asking about them ?)




Aragorn has posted....literally nothing of substance the entire game :dank
Also he asked 2 players if they had post restrictions (which should be a thing on this kind of games but why keep asking about them ?)


Aragorn has posted....literally nothing of substance the entire game :dank
Also he asked 2 players if they had post restrictions (which should be a thing on this kind of games but why keep asking about them ?)

Babby has...not posted



Lord genome only relevant post is a roleclaim of his dm :dank


Nothing from substance from juan as well (nothing unheard off but be aware, he can be dangerous eventually)


Legend most relevant post is saying he has no double post restriction...


This is a normal wpk opening post
means nothing aside from mafia is going to vig him during the night.


Go d usopp has 2 posts and one of them is protecting wad, if wad flips god should be looked at.


Melodie only relevant post was a psedo suspect at wad, so far everything else is fluffy.



This is the only post Kvothe has that has any short of substance and it is just rolefishing, kvothe is usually great at coasting so she might be scum.


My veredict is
[Lynch Kvothe Kingkiller]
For now a pressure vote, but it might lead somewhere

I can go with worm juice, sin, natalya or Lord genome as well (i know it almost got me mislynched at throne of lies but i will reiterate if lord genome does not conribute to town he is a big liability from the sheer risks he offers as scum).
It is worth noting wad has been the point of contention of a couple posters, i would need to look at him latter.
Click to expand...
If Natalya, has not begin to contribute I really don't like the implications for her usual meta.
Melodie and brokie wouldn't do anything anyway day 1 but they really should
 
is a said:
This is really funny because it’s sort of been somewhat true in recent times but I used to be the numba one power wolf as scum :del

Ouch

>good town

imagine a wad that doesn’t lead his own town to his doom :doggokek

but yeah im town i am p sure lg is town and i hard lean scum on melodie but too biased to lynch her d1
Click to expand...
Tbh scum LG would have not too much reason to claim "EU LG" so I could see him as town yeah
 
Scumdesu said:
Easy
Remchu was overral extremely scummy, overeacting and omgusing everywhere.
I gotta say i also never said "claim or die" or somehing like that just "we might need a remchu claim".
Click to expand...
but why though ? Remchu wasn't in danger of getting lynched or anything and having remchu claim a role wouldn't mean much alignment wise unless we start seeing the write ups of that person.
 
SinRaven said:
Tinfoil: what if quoting the broadcasted messages/questions is some Zyra-esque shit? :catshivers
Click to expand...
nitty said he stopped doing that :caticon

Pool Party Nitty said:
6. As I said last year, I have temporarily suspended post quoting mechanics and death millers from my games. There are no death millers in this game, and you may freely quote other players without worrying about triggering an ability of theirs.
Click to expand...
 
Kvothe Kingkiller said:
but why though ? Remchu wasn't in danger of getting lynched or anything and having remchu claim a role wouldn't mean much alignment wise unless we start seeing the write ups of that person.
Click to expand...
It was preemptorious so other people had time to engane and drop their thoughts on it
Again this "iwan is trying to get people to claim" i ignores that 1)it was not a clear cut "claim or die" 2) it was made after a series of bad posts from him 3) it was not even a strong push
 
Scumdesu said:
It was preemptorious so other people had time to engane and drop their thoughts on it
Again this "iwan is trying to get people to claim" i ignores that 1)it was not a clear cut "claim or die" 2) it was made after a series of bad posts from him 3) it was not even a strong push
Click to expand...

:thunk

I still don't understand the reasoning mainly because I don't agree on point 2 but I'll drop it for now.
 
Cooler said:
@Owner Of A Lonely Heart why did you ask about lie detectors earlier?
Click to expand...

Because whenever I play favorites over here there is almost always a lie detector role. I was wondering if the non-favorite games featured lie detector roles often or not. This is mainly the only site that I think I have really played with lie detectors roles. So I ask you is this sort of role generally a standard inclusion or not?

It wouldn't necessarily make sense in this game as I don't necessarily know anyone who can for sure pick out lies like everytime, but I also wouldn't call it out of the question, when designing a game this size.
 
Hayumi said:
It could just be me, but I don’t like how you just soft defended WPK based on one post he made when like literally anyone could do or has done something similar where they ask a question or bring attention to one particular thing and end up being scum looking for something to grab at. You in particular, do this a lot when scum I’ve noticed, and I don’t think that makes WPK look any better at all in my honest opinion.


:distracted
Click to expand...
I like that WPK is reading the thread or interacting with me at least. But I also kind of expected WPK to be on me fairly early in response to favorites.
 
Dragon D. Luffy said:
Ok caught up.

I feel like scum is lurking while town is overeager to get into each other's necks.

Wad vanished after yesterday.

Hayumi is sort of whatever.

Jw is sort of whatever but he seems to be low activity as any alignment.

Worm juice is open wolfing.

I don't feel anything about Sin and I usually feel his alignment so maybe h's scum.

Everyone else is town/null
Click to expand...

Catching up, but Wormjuice is always like this and she was town in last several games.
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
Back
Top