Game Members Mafia 4 (indies win!)

[Badalight]

I dunno if I agree with that sentiment. I feel like Iwan's post was negative towards Hayumi and mine was on the positive side?

 

[Shizune]

Message broadcast:

I feel like one of Badalight and Iwan is scum.

And one of Sin and Cooler.

Worm juice is kinda meh, but if that's how he plays, then I'm buying it for now.

 

[Shizune]

Message broadcast:

@RemChu I'm somewhat of a ghost, too.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

just skimming through the thread so far. gut reads, feels like Remchu is town. I once tinfoil the idea of remchu being scum in a previous game and he sorta blew up on me. His posts are similar to what was more towards there.

I don't know about Cooler yet, he normally pings me early but in this case, I don't have that same feeling

 

[Hero]

I’m between lynching Remchu & Badalight

 

[SinRaven]

Based on?

Mostly a feeling like I already said, but most of your posts feel OoC for Town!Cooler. Feel like you would be pressuring harder from the get go, instead you've been fluffing a lot which I don't think fits your townself.

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

I could lynch Bada he's sort of whatever.

Plus last time Bada was not lynched the moon literally crashed on us.

 

[Iwandesu]

• Aragorn​

• Babby​

• Badalight​

• Cooler​

• Dragon D. Luffy​

• Flower​

• Go D. Usopp​

• Hayumi​

• Hero​

• is a​

• Iwandesu​

• John Wayne​

• Juan​

• Karma​

• Kira Yagami​

• Kvothe Kingkiller​

• Laix​

• Legend​

• Lord Genome​

• Lord Melkor​

• Melodie​

• Natalija​

• Nessos​

• Nevan​

• nfcnorth​

• Owner Of A Lonely Heart​

• Ratchet​

• RemChu​

• Santi​

• SinRaven​

• Underworld Broker​

• WolfPrinceKiba​

• Worm Juice​

tfw this game has actually 30+ players

Anyway lets do some quick rundown on the bottom players

Anyway Hero actually posted for god knows why reason
This likely doesnt mean anything but anytime hero rolls serial killers/mafia or cultists he AFKs
And when he rolls town he gets modkilled
So...yeah i dunno

So @Flower do you have post restrictive i see you are active in the game ? Is there some 5d chess going on with her ?

@wormhole do you have post restriction ?

Aragorn has posted....literally nothing of substance the entire game
Also he asked 2 players if they had post restrictions (which should be a thing on this kind of games but why keep asking about them ?)

So @Flower do you have post restrictive i see you are active in the game ? Is there some 5d chess going on with her ?

@wormhole do you have post restriction ?

Aragorn has posted....literally nothing of substance the entire game
Also he asked 2 players if they had post restrictions (which should be a thing on this kind of games but why keep asking about them ?)

So @Flower do you have post restrictive i see you are active in the game ? Is there some 5d chess going on with her ?

@wormhole do you have post restriction ?

Aragorn has posted....literally nothing of substance the entire game
Also he asked 2 players if they had post restrictions (which should be a thing on this kind of games but why keep asking about them ?)

Babby has...not posted

@is a
@Melodie

So like if you are mafia I'm hella inting probably but it's too meme not to say

I'm EU LG

nitty doesnt know about this joke

I'm upset it happened

Lord genome only relevant post is a roleclaim of his dm

oh, i'm well aware of what we're both... packing.

Nothing from substance from juan as well (nothing unheard off but be aware, he can be dangerous eventually)

Laix's game got me out of my semi retirement.

and I dont have a double talking post restriction this time

Legend most relevant post is saying he has no double post restriction...

Role WPK is certainly going to be an inferior version of myself, for all Nitty is my friend they know jack about me as a player.


I'm the power top of the Discord server, so come join us


Why are you asking this question out of the blue?

[Vote Lynch Owner of a Lonely Heart]


Were you asking your earlier question in preparation for Nevan trying to force people to give exact town claims?


Here I was all excited to hop into bed with Ooh La La

This is a normal wpk opening post
means nothing aside from mafia is going to vig him during the night.

WAD has like more posts here on the first day than he did on the entire super smash mafia

hes likely town this time eh

Go d usopp has 2 posts and one of them is protecting wad, if wad flips god should be looked at.

You were contemplating what to post due to being guilty and bailed out, then decided to quote a person and forgot the meme post you were going to make was still in the posting draft.

Melodie only relevant post was a psedo suspect at wad, so far everything else is fluffy.

saying it now, whoever has the iwan role is scum

This is the only post Kvothe has that has any short of substance and it is just rolefishing, kvothe is usually great at coasting so she might be scum.


My veredict is
[Lynch Kvothe Kingkiller]
For now a pressure vote, but it might lead somewhere

I can go with worm juice, sin, natalya or Lord genome as well (i know it almost got me mislynched at throne of lies but i will reiterate if lord genome does not conribute to town he is a big liability from the sheer risks he offers as scum).
It is worth noting wad has been the point of contention of a couple posters, i would need to look at him latter.

 

[Magic]

I’m between lynching Remchu & Badalight

Oooooh please do enlighten us on your reasoning. The floor is yours to speak.

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Also I remember Nitty being VERY tiltled for the moon tthing.

What is the chance he makes a reference to it in the Badalight role.

 

[Iwandesu]

just skimming through the thread so far. gut reads, feels like Remchu is town. I once tinfoil the idea of remchu being scum in a previous game and he sorta blew up on me. His posts are similar to what was more towards there.

I don't know about Cooler yet, he normally pings me early but in this case, I don't have that same feeling

tfw you begin to post while im isoing you so i miss this post
What do you think about wad, genome and melodie ?

 

[Iwandesu]

Also I remember Nitty being VERY tiltled for the moon tthing.

What is the chance he makes a reference to it in the Badalight role.

i think very high tbh

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Badalight role is either ridiculously hard to kill, or will make the moon crash on us if not lynched fast enough.

Either way I'd argue it's a scum role.

 

[Worm Juice]

It doesnt make him scum (certainly not over worm juice buddying)
But worm juice is definitely the kind of player to mindless buddy

Such accusations. :blu

 

[Badalight]

I won't drop a moon this time.

My namesake role however...

 

[Worm Juice]

I like the bromance between Dragonluffy and scumdesu

 

[Hero]

You are often right so I will jump on your wagon



[Vote Lynch Scumdesu]

Not someone following a Laix town lead

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

that iwan post was a joke You even rated it funny.

tfw you begin to post while im isoing you so i miss this post
What do you think about wad, genome and melodie ?

I literally just woke up so I am still reading the thread but hmm hard to say about those three. I would need to see more from them but judging from LG's initial post it seems like he role revealed to WAD and Melodie.

I am not sure if thats an indication of anything but WAD backed off of his LG vote after that. Imo in orders of who i think would be scum is melodie->wad->lg but its not much.

They're very good town leaders though so I would wait and see. Why did you ask my thoughts on them?

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

@Hero
@John Wayne

And anyone else who might be interested. Link to the discord:

https://discord.gg/mFkVCH3

 

[Worm Juice]

Not someone following a Laix town lead

Laix seems town to me this game. Usually their activity is way lower when scum. Though I might be wrong. And Laix has a better scum read than I have, especially the first day like this. So I just follow Laix for today.

 

[Iwandesu]

Badalight role is either ridiculously hard to kill, or will make the moon crash on us if not lynched fast enough.

Either way I'd argue it's a scum role.

I doubt nitty is going to literally programm a game bomb tho (he hates those)
Anyway for now it is just conjectures
But if I had to bet
Badalight, Wad, Iwan, Laix
Are off to a decent mafia team (or some weird indies)

 

[Natalija]

90% chance he is GODFATHER, CULTIST, OR HOSTILE INDIE.
[VOTE LYNCH IS A]

If you think otherwise, debate me.
-He will not be active and so will add nothing to scum hunting.
-People if he is scum will protect him.
-if he is scum he will provide empty reads.

Good day 1 lynch.

Wwhy are you so sure so early?

Third point is stupid, everyone provides empty reads as scum. And we also have other people who fit point one.

There are no girls on the Internet. Just men, and honorary girls.

enough of this

the fact iwandesu and iwandesu (the role) will both have to do that shit

Omg imagine landing iwandesu

 

[Natalija]

My scum hunting partner @Flower, noooo

Also, let's try this

[vote lynch SinRaven]

 

[Laix]

tfw this game has actually 30+ players

Anyway lets do some quick rundown on the bottom players

Anyway Hero actually posted for god knows why reason
This likely doesnt mean anything but anytime hero rolls serial killers/mafia or cultists he AFKs
And when he rolls town he gets modkilled
So...yeah i dunno



Aragorn has posted....literally nothing of substance the entire game
Also he asked 2 players if they had post restrictions (which should be a thing on this kind of games but why keep asking about them ?)




Aragorn has posted....literally nothing of substance the entire game
Also he asked 2 players if they had post restrictions (which should be a thing on this kind of games but why keep asking about them ?)


Aragorn has posted....literally nothing of substance the entire game
Also he asked 2 players if they had post restrictions (which should be a thing on this kind of games but why keep asking about them ?)

Babby has...not posted



Lord genome only relevant post is a roleclaim of his dm


Nothing from substance from juan as well (nothing unheard off but be aware, he can be dangerous eventually)


Legend most relevant post is saying he has no double post restriction...


This is a normal wpk opening post
means nothing aside from mafia is going to vig him during the night.


Go d usopp has 2 posts and one of them is protecting wad, if wad flips god should be looked at.


Melodie only relevant post was a psedo suspect at wad, so far everything else is fluffy.



This is the only post Kvothe has that has any short of substance and it is just rolefishing, kvothe is usually great at coasting so she might be scum.


My veredict is
[Lynch Kvothe Kingkiller]
For now a pressure vote, but it might lead somewhere

I can go with worm juice, sin, natalya or Lord genome as well (i know it almost got me mislynched at throne of lies but i will reiterate if lord genome does not conribute to town he is a big liability from the sheer risks he offers as scum).
It is worth noting wad has been the point of contention of a couple posters, i would need to look at him latter.

You made some points and good on you for calling out coasters, but I think

[VOTE LYNCH SinRaven]

would be a better choice.

He usually fluffs a lot D1. The fact he's quiet is very telling.

@SinRaven are you hiding something? What do you think of Iwandesu? Cooler? Hayumi? I know you're reading.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

I doubt nitty is going to literally programm a game bomb tho (he hates those)
Anyway for now it is just conjectures
But if I had to bet
Badalight, Wad, Iwan, Laix
Are off to a decent mafia team (or some weird indies)

??? youre putting yourself on there?

 

[Iwandesu]

Laix seems town to me this game. Usually their activity is way lower when scum. Though I might be wrong. And Laix has a better scum read than I have, especially the first day like this. So I just follow Laix for today.

She being town does not mean you must blind less follow her reads ...

 

[Laix]

Not someone following a Laix town lead

I've actually been on a good town streak. Just got scum lynched in my last game.

 

[Laix]

??? youre putting yourself on there?

I think he was talking about the roles.

 

[Magic]

Wwhy are you so sure so early?

Third point is stupid, everyone provides empty reads as scum. And we also have other people who fit point one.

Years of experience. Educated guess as a hardened veteran. If you've been in my shoes, and seen the things I've seen from wad. You would be a believer too.

if he is quiet it holds more weight of being true.

Debate me.

 

[Iwandesu]

??? youre putting yourself on there?

Im obviously talking about roes not player

 

[Cooler]

Mostly a feeling like I already said, but most of your posts feel OoC for Town!Cooler. Feel like you would be pressuring harder from the get go, instead you've been fluffing a lot which I don't think fits your townself.

Ya'll expect so much from me lol. I need to get some day one fluff out the way too. Not like I didn't poke Rem with a vote when I scumread him either.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

I think he was talking about the roles.

Im obviously talking about roes not player

ya but you're voting me (a joke post) on that same basis

 

[Natalija]

Years of experience. Educated guess as a hardened veteran. If you've been in my shoes, and seen the things I've seen from wad. You would be a believer too.

if he is quiet it holds more weight of being true.

Debate me.

Lol okay. I can't debate that because I don't know who wad is

 

[Iwandesu]

I can totally go with sin
He is the short of player who can be pushed and will at least make arguments on his defense as well
[Vote Lynch sin Raven]

 

[Magic]

Lol okay. I can't debate that because I don't know who wad is

Super metagamey but more often than not he rolls a PR of something.

 

[Iwandesu]

ya but you're voting me (a joke post) on that same basis

Actually I was voting you because you only had joke posts

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Actually I was voting you because you only had joke posts

So why not others who did the same?

 

[Iwandesu]

So why not others who did the same?

Because I knew you would answer while the remaining ones could ignore me
Now that I got your attention and you are actually reading the game what do you think of Natalya and sin Raven ?

 

[Hero]

Laix has a better scum read than I have

That’s not really saying much at all

 

[Iwandesu]

I like the bromance between Dragonluffy and scumdesu

You should check out platinum stand off games
Me and Luffy are always either partners or rivals

 

[Hero]

[Vote Lynch Badalight]

 

[Iwandesu]

am not sure if thats an indication of anything but WAD backed off of his LG vote after that. Imo in orders of who i think would be scum is melodie->wad->lg but its not much.

They're very good town leaders though so I would wait and see. Why did you ask my thoughts on them?

Because you are the fourth "good town, danger scum," on the list.
You just don't know it yet

 

[Hero]

This game has been relatively quiet action wise

 

[nfcnorth]

I don't recall MangaMaid having a Members Mafia?

Wad got it right it was a viole game near the end. I think it might have been a game where someone mega tunneled wad in and I found it annoying. Think my role won though as hostile indie. I know I did get killed by my role and it was one of the few roles that no one ever claimed

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Because I knew you would answer while the remaining ones could ignore me
Now that I got your attention and you are actually reading the game what do you think of Natalya and sin Raven ?

Natalija's posts are a bit null. In small games, she's very clear as town. Hard to say in here because she got lost in Manga Mashup however I would give her more time.

Sin's posts are underwhelming. He's sussing cooler and asking people to vote for him but not placing the vote on Cooler at all.

 

[Natalija]

This game has been relatively quiet action wise

Fuck, I forgot about those

 

[Shizune]

Broadcast message:

I wonder what the abilities of my namesake role are gonna be .

 

[Shizune]

This game has been relatively quiet action wise

I’m quieter about actions than most hosts here. I usually don’t give actions writeups unless it’s necessary for some reason. I don’t like when games turn into mass claims and players start using writeups to soft-confirm themselves. I meant to put something in the OP about this, but I never got around to it.

 

[Shizune]

Incoming action...

 

[Cooler]

Sin's posts are underwhelming. He's sussing cooler and asking people to vote for him but not placing the vote on Cooler at all.

Glad someone else picked up on this. Like he's calling for people to lynch me but he's not starting the wagon himself. Feels like maybe he thought he could capitalise on my back and forth with Remchu but doesn't want to be seen as the reason I get lynched.

 

[Shizune]

Would like to see a more active WPK, blessing us with his immense insight. But alas miracles like that are rare.

This wish has been granted.

@WolfPrinceKiba minimum activity requirement for this phase has been increased to 10 posts. If WPK does not meet this requirement, he will be modblocked tonight.

 

[Ratchet]

Remchu is playing with passive aggressive in todays game compared to his usual one i saw in smash and get good.

And what conclusion do you draw from it?

 

[Cooler]

Also...this is the first game in a while where I'm not scum reading Wad.

 

[Shizune]

Incoming action...

 

[John Wayne]

Also...this is the first game in a while where I'm not scum reading Wad.

So you were scum reading him in Get Good 3 but didn't say anything??

 

[Cooler]

So you were scum reading him in Get Good 3 but didn't say anything??

I scum read him until he claimed cop. Then I couldn't fathom it being a fake claim.

 

[Ratchet]

@is a
@Melodie
@Lord Genome

You guys are either good town or terribly scary scums
which of those are you this time around ?

I'm offended I'm not included. I'm on like a 4 or 5 game win streak as scum.

 

[Laix]

What’s a Kylie Minogue stan?

 

[Ratchet]

[Vote Lynch SinRaven]

 

[Shizune]

The game has been divided into 3 groups. These groups are:

Aragorn
Babby
Badalight
Cooler
Worm Juice
Flower
Go D. Usopp
Hayumi
Hero
is a
Kvothe Kingkiller

Iwandesu
John Wayne
Juan
Karma
Kira Yagami
Laix
Legend
Lord Genome
Lord Melkor
Melodie
Nessos

Nevan
nfcnorth
Owner Of A Lonely Heart
Natalija
Ratchet
RemChu
Santi
SinRaven
Underworld Broker
WolfPrinceKiba
Dragon D. Luffy

During the night phase, you will only be able to target players who are in your group, so plan your actions accordingly.

 

[Kira Yagami]

Town lean on remchu, i like his agressive play style so far, seems genuine


Currently null read on cooler but i dont think he handled remchus pushback very well and withdrew too easily so might be leaning more towards scum than town here

 

[Badalight]

Not this don patch shit again

 

[SinRaven]

I like the bromance between Dragonluffy and scumdesu

Are they the next LG and Psychic?

 

[Laix]

Are they the next LG and Psychic?

bitch are you scum

 

[Shizune]

Broadcast message:

I feel like a lot of people are buddying me on my reads, despite me legit just being a ghost .

 

[Hayumi]

Sweetie i didnt get flower to roleclaim
I literally said "wtf guys, it is clearly flower"
the first one to "fish" for broadcast was like hayumi or something (and she even received a message from flower because of that)

Sorry, had to respond to this while I have time to scroll back through between classes. Sooo, this was actually a blatant lie, because I straight up said “hey guys observation since you all were wondering earlier: the broadcaster is one of the three following people:” then everyone else was like “WhY ARe You SpeCuLating On ThE RoLES” when I was talking about the actual players and not anybody’s role/alignment. But some people seriously lack reading comprehension.

 

[Magic]

The game has been divided into 3 groups. These groups are:

Aragorn
Babby
Badalight
Cooler
Worm Juice
Flower
Go D. Usopp
Hayumi
Hero
is a
Kvothe Kingkiller

Iwandesu
John Wayne
Juan
Karma
Kira Yagami
Laix
Legend
Lord Genome
Lord Melkor
Melodie
Nessos

Nevan
nfcnorth
Owner Of A Lonely Heart
Natalija
Ratchet
RemChu
Santi
SinRaven
Underworld Broker
WolfPrinceKiba
Dragon D. Luffy

During the night phase, you will only be able to target players who are in your group, so plan your actions accordingly.

Will this apply to scum as well? Well the faction kill implicate them?

Very interesting.

 

[Shizune]

Broadcast message:

Getting slowly more Town vibes from Cooler. I think he's the Town between him and Sin. I hope he is active this game and gives his thoughts.

 

[Magic]

Will* the faction

 

[Laix]

Will this apply to scum as well? Well the faction kill implicate them?

Very interesting.

Ooh! So whoever gets faction killed, we will have a narrow list of suspects...

Nitty usually has faction kills performed by a member too, not as a faction

 

[Natalija]

Pretty cool

 

[Hayumi]

In other words, no way was that anything comparative to role fishing, which was what Iwan was doing.

 

[Laix]

In other words, no way was that anything comparative to role fishing, which was what Iwan was doing.

drag, bag and TAG that panda!

 

[SinRaven]

You made some points and good on you for calling out coasters, but I think

[VOTE LYNCH SinRaven]

would be a better choice.

He usually fluffs a lot D1. The fact he's quiet is very telling.

@SinRaven are you hiding something? What do you think of Iwandesu? Cooler? Hayumi? I know you're reading.

I'm not hiding lol, I was working as I made clear in my earlier posts. Sometimes I can post a lot during work, but today was a busy day so I mostly was just lurking. There is no ulterior motive to my posting habits here

Iwandesu is meh. Have no read on him yet. His posts didn't ping me either way yet.
I dont remember Hayumi outside of fluffing earlier this day and I dont think thats out of his usual MO, so no
I already made my statements on Cooler. He didn't fluff that much as I said in my earlier post (did a quick ISO on him after it), but I definitely feel like he is pressuring people less than his regular townself. The push on RemChu was weak imo, Cooler usually goes all in when he finds something scummy (like he did with Flower in Get Good D1). Here he was just like 'meh I think Rem is scum' imo. He's the one who pings me most right now.

 

[Magic]

@Dragon D. Luffy
Well oh well... looks like we can target each other tonight.
Keep each other company.

 

[Badalight]

In favorites our scum team had to follow the don patch rules during faction kill. Diff game, but ya know.

 

[SinRaven]

I dont remember Hayumi outside of fluffing earlier this day and I dont think thats out of his usual MO, so no

Didnt finish this sentence

...so no real read on her either.

I guess thats whats what I wanted to say

 

[Laix]

I'm not hiding lol, I was working as I made clear in my earlier posts. Sometimes I can post a lot during work, but today was a busy day so I mostly was just lurking. There is no ulterior motive to my posting habits here

Iwandesu is meh. Have no read on him yet. His posts didn't ping me either way yet.
I dont remember Hayumi outside of fluffing earlier this day and I dont think thats out of his usual MO, so no
I already made my statements on Cooler. He didn't fluff that much as I said in my earlier post (did a quick ISO on him after it), but I definitely feel like he is pressuring people less than his regular townself. The push on RemChu was weak imo, Cooler usually goes all in when he finds something scummy (like he did with Flower in Get Good D1). Here he was just like 'meh I think Rem is scum' imo. He's the one who pings me most right now.

hmm

@Scumdesu @Flower @Hayumi thots?

 

[Magic]

That's not a veiled threat.
Just sayin.
Don't be a stranger.

 

[Shizune]

Broadcast message:

Can everyone give their top Town and top scum reads so far, please?