Game Members Mafia 4 (indies win!)

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

On WPK I actually like his first post/only post.

Mostly because he picked out on the weird "Hey are lie detectors in this game?" post from Owner Of A Lonely Heart. Feels like role fishing. Could be role related but I don't like it.

I guess you could call it role fishing. I'm not really looking for people to get defensive or anything. It's more of an attempt to get on more even ground and figure out if this is something that would be culturally normal to happen in games or if this is less likely to happen. I wasn't thinking about outing anyone, as that's where members games get boring or unbalanced is when there's a mass claim.

 

[Hero]

[Change Vote Lunch Remchu]

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

Imagine town reading Laix

do I really have to imagine it when it could be real?

 

[Natalija]

@Flower I don't know what to tell you about the reads, fam. I'm afraid of the inactive players, but that is just blind guessing and I hate doing it.

I'm pretty sure one or two top posters is one type of scum or the other, always is.

Willing to give you and RemChu a town pass. Sin looks better than at the start, but not good enough to vote someone else.

Kira Yagami, Melodie, Kvothe, is a and DDL I wanna see more of, but some of them is surely scum.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

I shouldn't get my hopes up.

 

[Natalija]

@Go D. Usopp @Underworld Broker @Santí

You town? You have any thoughts?

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

imagine a wad that doesn’t lead his own town to his doom

but yeah im town i am p sure lg is town and i hard lean scum on melodie but too biased to lynch her d1

so we just have hope that this particular wad isn't a doom!wad. *noted*

What about Melodie condemns them? (always forgets if melodie is she or he)

 

[Lord Melkor]

Aren't death notes and janitors sort of opposites?

What is the purpose of this post of yours? Janitor and death note would both be mechanics giving advantage to scum.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

Why are you asking this question out of the blue?

[Vote Lynch Owner of a Lonely Heart]

because I want to know if lie detector roles are culturally normal outside of favorites games, as those are the games I mostly play over here

Were you asking your earlier question in preparation for Nevan trying to force people to give exact town claims?

No, I'm not looking for claiming. Also, why would people really do it this early?

Geez and i thought of proposing you with owner of lonely heart song.

There goes owner of my broken heart

Here I was all excited to hop into bed with Ooh La La

sorry, taking a year off from dating, trying to get priorities straight, but the only man in my bed will be the one I marry, so I doubt anyone here is up for that

 

[Underworld Broker]

@Go D. Usopp @Underworld Broker @Santí

You town? You have any thoughts?

Yeah I'm town

my thoughts rn are i hope someone dies soon so discussion stuff picks up, feels at some parts here that ppl are kinda running in circles

also not really a fan of ppl for whatever reason having to ''out'' the broadcaster, is beyond me but welp, why it became a topic earlier this phase was scummy as shit

dont remember who was tryna find that person and why, but it's been quite some ppl iirc

 

[Natalija]

What is the purpose of this post of yours? Janitor and death note would both be mechanics giving advantage to scum.

I love playing with you

Kira Yagami, Melodie, Kvothe, is a and DDL I wanna see more of, but some of them is surely scum.

Wait. I forgot that sneaky Juan. And John Wayne who always feels scummy. But mostly Juan.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

So all the more reason to be able to identify them, then?

valid, but so far they seem to add energy to the thread, so I would prefer to see where this goes. But playing both sides of coin, we can still look for them. I just don't have a solid action plan of how to really find them.

 

[Ekkologix]

so many dem posts and active ppl this time

actually have no reads on anyone, but all imma say is be wary of ppl that changed their play style from last time like hero and wad

tho im actually down asfk to lynch afkers this time cuz they caused us alot of troubles last time

@Go D. Usopp @Underworld Broker @Santí

You town? You have any thoughts?

im town again

its the first day so not many thoughts yet lol, just barely caught up

 

[Iwandesu]

Broadcast message:

Thank you
I mean ratchet was basically saying "why ain't you suspecting me"
Not sure this means anything tho, ratchet is cocky

 

[Iwandesu]

I’ve literally been pressuring people all phase and gauging responses from people? Do you want me to tunnel you?

Just confirming geez

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

Dumb takes for 1000.

*buzzes in Hayumi feels like favorites self* (P.S. that wasn't really dumb; it's more I wanted to buzz in like on Jeopardy)

 

[Ekkologix]

btw @everyone

if it makes it easier, just call me gosopp or uso or short lol, usopp works too

 

[Iwandesu]

Catching up, but Wormjuice is always like this and she was town in last several games.

I think worm juice is one of those situations where the player is always either low effort townie or coasting scum

 

[Ekkologix]

I really wonder who has my role

how badass it would be if it was sick mafia

 

[Underworld Broker]

so many dem posts and active ppl this time

actually have no reads on anyone, but all imma say is be wary of ppl that changed their play style from last time like hero and wad

tho im actually down asfk to lynch afkers this time cuz they caused us alot of troubles last time

btw. ppl complaining about activity and buncha posts to catch up have flipped scum in the last game i was part of

there hasnt been that much going on here yet, in fact

 

[Cooler]

I guess you could call it role fishing. I'm not really looking for people to get defensive or anything. It's more of an attempt to get on more even ground and figure out if this is something that would be culturally normal to happen in games or if this is less likely to happen. I wasn't thinking about outing anyone, as that's where members games get boring or unbalanced is when there's a mass claim.

Does it scare you if a lie detector is in this game?

 

[Shizune]

Broadcast message:

@Natalija dw. I have no clue atm either. As I said, after further questioning a lot of players seem Town to me now. Probably one of the more active players is scum, but the rest is probably Town. I think looking into players like Broki that are just coasting is a good start for the next half of the DP.

 

[Ekkologix]

btw. ppl complaining about activity and buncha posts to catch up have flipped scum in the last game i was part of

there hasnt been that much going on here yet, in fact

lots of the scum in my last game where ppl that were viewing the thread but rarely saying anything lol, not even complaining

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

so many dem posts and active ppl this time

actually have no reads on anyone, but all imma say is be wary of ppl that changed their play style from last time like hero and wad

tho im actually down asfk to lynch afkers this time cuz they caused us alot of troubles last time



im town again

its the first day so not many thoughts yet lol, just barely caught up

[change vote lynch Go D. Usopp] the no reads on anyone is troublesome to me; it's like you want to wait and see what others do.

Like has Wad's and hero's playstyle changed from when they were last townie? or is this change a good thing, you think?

 

[Natalija]

so many dem posts and active ppl this time

actually have no reads on anyone, but all imma say is be wary of ppl that changed their play style from last time like hero and wad

tho im actually down asfk to lynch afkers this time cuz they caused us alot of troubles last time

How has Hero changed his play style?

 

[Cooler]

I think worm juice is one of those situations where the player is always either low effort townie or coasting scum

I've never seen scum Worm Juice, her meta is just inherently scummy - sheeps reads and votes, coasts etc...

 

[Ekkologix]

Broadcast message:

w8 are u rly not aware of who the players are?

w8 who is hosting the event

lmao

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

lots of the scum in my last game where ppl that were viewing the thread but rarely saying anything lol, not even complaining

Did you manage to win? or did the coasting scum win? Those lurker type games are harder to read imo.

 

[Ekkologix]

Did you manage to win? or did the coasting scum win? Those lurker type games are harder to read imo.

lurking cult won lol, yea thats why im down to lynch all lurkers early, and thats likely why they have to change their playstyle this time or they get rekt xd

How has Hero changed his play style?

he was like bottom 10 contributors to the thread, now hes top 10 lol

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

Does it scare you if a lie detector is in this game?

I'm more scared of what @WolfPrinceKiba might have in store for me regardless of alignment. lie detector vs WPK, WPK takes the cake.

 

[Ekkologix]

[change vote lynch Go D. Usopp] the no reads on anyone is troublesome to me; it's like you want to wait and see what others do.

Like has Wad's and hero's playstyle changed from when they were last townie? or is this change a good thing, you think?

ive made mistakes as a towny and killed townies last time, so im trying not to repeat it again lol

this time im eliminating lurkers asap, and will continue to push people to do so, so any scum lurkers will likely have to change their playstyle that's all

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

lurking cult won lol, yea thats why im down to lynch all lurkers early, and thats likely why they have to change their playstyle this time or they get rekt xd



he was like bottom 10 contributors to the thread, now hes top 10 lol

maybe he's less busy or has a fun role or is an indie? Idk Indies tend to be higher on the post count than some.

 

[Cooler]

I'm more scared of what @WolfPrinceKiba might have in store for me regardless of alignment. lie detector vs WPK, WPK takes the cake.

Oof that deflection.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

ive made mistakes as a towny and killed townies last time, so im trying not to repeat it again lol

this time im eliminating lurkers asap, and will continue to push people to do so, so any scum lurkers will likely have to change their playstyle that's all

It makes sense.

 

[Underworld Broker]

Usopp is new to mafia, right?

leaning town since fast replies and doesnt sound nervous

 

[Natalija]

I'm more scared of what @WolfPrinceKiba might have in store for me regardless of alignment. lie detector vs WPK, WPK takes the cake.

He has ONE post, of course he takes the cake

 

[Cooler]

@Natalija what are your reads right now?

 

[Ekkologix]

Usopp is new to mafia, right?

leaning town since fast replies and doesnt sound nervous

im not new lol

also u cant detect nervousness on a text can ya?

unless

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

Oof that deflection.

Says the person who asked the loaded question, regardless of what I say to you, you were intending to skew it to your benefit. And don't try to deny that you weren't doing that.

 

[Natalija]

@Natalija what are your reads right now?

I just talked about that:

@Flower I don't know what to tell you about the reads, fam. I'm afraid of the inactive players, but that is just blind guessing and I hate doing it.

I'm pretty sure one or two top posters is one type of scum or the other, always is.

Willing to give you and RemChu a town pass. Sin looks better than at the start, but not good enough to vote someone else.

Kira Yagami, Melodie, Kvothe, is a and DDL I wanna see more of, but some of them is surely scum.

Wait. I forgot that sneaky Juan. And John Wayne who always feels scummy. But mostly Juan.

What about yours Cooler?

 

[Ekkologix]

any thoughts on aragorn?

 

[Natalija]

any thoughts on aragorn?

Good point! Lol so many players, I forget.

@Aragorn you there pal?

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

He has ONE post, of course he takes the cake

I scum read people off ONE post. But I'm pretty sure he made a 2nd one.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

any thoughts on aragorn?

null for me, the ones I remember were just filler

 

[Natalija]

I scum read people off ONE post. But I'm pretty sure he made a 2nd one.

Nope. Just the one.

 

[Ekkologix]

I scum read people off ONE post.

ur a beast then

 

[Underworld Broker]

im not new lol

also u cant detect nervousness on a text can ya?

unless

i mean like

how many games have you played, more or less than 10? How often did you play as scum?

also the first post i quoted of you did sound like some weird newbie post a mafia would make, complaining about activity, putting attention on low poster to seem like you're contributing

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

Nope. Just the one.

There's 3 on my screen. Have you by chance taken a blue pill recently?

 

[Underworld Broker]

Aragorn was a lot more active in faves iirc, havent seen him post much yet actually

 

[Natalija]

There's 3 on my screen. Have you by chance taken a blue pill recently?

Could be because I'm busy with x stuff, but he's literally bottom poster with 1 post for me.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

ur a beast then

Sometimes, it is their first post too. But the problem with that is a first post is different from other posts in some regard. Sometimes, it has been well crafted over some time, but other times it is s joke resonates with them. But all and all, for me it depends on different requirements or tells for different patterns I've seen over time.

 

[Underworld Broker]

My fave alignment is indie btw

 

[Ekkologix]

i mean like

how many games have you played, more or less than 10? How often did you play as scum?

ye i meant like i'm not that new, but ur right im inexperienced af compared to alot of ppl here lol

also the first post i quoted of you did sound like some weird newbie post a mafia would make, complaining about activity, putting attention on low poster to seem like you're contributing

ive seen that alot lol, but u see its gna be my meta from now on down the line to always eliminate low posters that are always viewing the thread and somehow always up to date with whats happening lol.

in a way that encourages people to be more active, if everyone did that. ofcourse if someone active is outed scum with a very high chance, then we should shift to them instead of afkers, but u get the point.

low posters that arent even viewing the thread are different tho xd

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

Could be because I'm busy with x stuff, but he's literally bottom poster with 1 post for me.

It appears I looked at the sign up not the game thread. oof

 

[Cooler]

Says the person who asked the loaded question, regardless of what I say to you, you were intending to skew it to your benefit. And don't try to deny that you weren't doing that.

Well I was trying to pressure you obviously, there are responses you could have given me that would have satisfied me more. Your playful comeback wasn't the worst thing you could have said if that makes you feel better lol.

I just talked about that:





What about yours Cooler?

Think Laix and Flower are town. Town lean on Wad as well.

I'm kind of null on a lot of posters, feel like it's been the same people posting.

I'm fence sitting on Remchu now after he pinged me early on, scum leaning on JW and Hero - feel like Hero is kinda going with the flow, think was opportunistic earlier when he voted Rem basically because a few people were talking about him (Rem) at the time. I need to ISO him though.

Owner I find really weird for asking about lie detectors, not sure why it matters if they're in the set-up but weird for her to be just open wolfing and asking about it.

Infact...

[Change Vote Lynch Hero]

 

[Ekkologix]

Sometimes, it is their first post too. But the problem with that is a first post is different from other posts in some regard. Sometimes, it has been well crafted over some time, but other times it is s joke resonates with them. But all and all, for me it depends on different requirements or tells for different patterns I've seen over time.

i mean u voted lynch me off my like 2nd post so idk if i should trust that kind of judgment

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

Well I was trying to pressure you obviously, there are responses you could have given me that would have satisfied me more. Your playful comeback wasn't the worst thing you could have said if that makes you feel better lol.

4 hours of sleep combined with what felt like an unhealthy dose of stress about the bosses visiting and critiquing my area today, I'm still on edge or as of right now, it won't take much for me to go off on someone if they get really up in my business

my usual crap threshold doesn't leave much room for error today

 

[Juan]

I love playing with you


Wait. I forgot that sneaky Juan. And John Wayne who always feels scummy. But mostly Juan.

you know, that game was like a whole year ago

not that i don't appreciate the respect you keep putting on me but expecting me to perform on that level consistently is like expecting laix to not lust after santi

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

i mean u voted lynch me off my like 2nd post so idk if i should trust that kind of judgment

You said you didn't have any reads, even though said something about catching up. The reason to vote for you was triggered by you not being suspicious of anyone. I read as being frozen or not knowing what to do or say. That's suspicious.

 

[Juan]

also, whoever sent me that pm, lewding ppl is how i scum hunt, fuck u

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

I'm more scared of what @WolfPrinceKiba might have in store for me regardless of alignment. lie detector vs WPK, WPK takes the cake.

why would you be scared of wpk?

 

[Juan]

You said you didn't have any reads, even though said something about catching up. The reason to vote for you was triggered by you not being suspicious of anyone. I read as being frozen or not knowing what to do or say. That's suspicious.

hero and natalija have likewise said they're not scumreading anyone

why go aftet usopp and not either of them?

easier mark?

 

[Ekkologix]

You said you didn't have any reads, even though said something about catching up. The reason to vote for you was triggered by you not being suspicious of anyone. I read as being frozen or not knowing what to do or say. That's suspicious.

guess i had to word it better lol

Hero, Wad, and Aragorn are on top of my sus list as of now, in that particular order

 

[Natalija]

you know, that game was like a whole year ago

not that i don't appreciate the respect you keep putting on me but expecting me to perform on that level consistently is like expecting laix to not lust after santi

I'm only on this forum since June, smart ass

Expect you to perform on that level consistently? Lol anyone can coast, it's not that hard.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

why would you be scared of wpk?

because of my shot on him in favorites

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

guess i had to word it better lol

Hero, Wad, and Aragorn are on top of my sus list as of now, in that particular order

[change vote lynch Nevan] I'm still wary of you. But part where you talked about Hero being totally different feels like genuine read.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

I'm only on this forum since June, smart ass

Expect you to perform on that level consistently? Lol anyone can coast, it's not that hard.

have you played elsewhere?

 

[Natalija]

have you played elsewhere?

Only here and WorstGen.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

hero and natalija have likewise said they're not scumreading anyone

why go aftet usopp and not either of them?

easier mark?

I missed their posts about this. I haven't actually been reading the thread necessarily in order.

 

[Natalija]

Only here and *.

Wow, I got censored. Another forum then.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

I expect to quite literally be under the microscope lens for the time that both myself and WPK are in this game.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

So my main question now is Laix an indie or just that good?

 

[nfcnorth]

My favorite alignment is indie get the best of both worlds tbh.

 

[Ekkologix]

Only here and *.

Wow, I got censored. Another forum then.

oh thats the opposite of best gen lul

idk why it gets censored lol

 

[Cooler]

hero and natalija have likewise said they're not scumreading anyone

why go aftet usopp and not either of them?

easier mark?

That makes Hero's voting look all the worse. Totally voting with the wind.

 

[Hero]

The people who have never seen me active in a game really have a lot to say. Perhaps it’s new to you, but it’s not unfamiliar to players like Santí, DDL, Laix, WAD, WPK etc.

I haven’t been an active player in a long time, but what can you do when you decide to sign up for mafia games in medical school

 

[Ekkologix]

my fav alignment is indie if it was a sick win con lol

else town vig is probably my 2nd fav, or mafia i guess

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

laix for town or indie playing townsided
hayumi for town
broadcaster - is town like

cooler - slight town - this is more activity then most of the games where I think they were scum.
go d. usopp - null/slight town

hero - null I don't remember much about their playstyle

wpk - needs more posts

wad - has said some stuff, it's probably too early to have a definite sign as to his alignment

sinraven - don't remember what he's said/ will probably look there soon
nevan - I want him to contribute more. I'm not sure if he is quiet regardless of alignment or if that could be a scum tell..not sure

 

[Natalija]

oh thats the opposite of best gen lul

idk why it gets censored lol

Not to advertise other forums, it makes sense. I just didn't know.

Yas, that

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

hello mafia freinds lets have a good time

[Vote Lynch Lord Genome]

why the 180?