Game Members Mafia 4 (indies win!)

[Juan]

just making sure why are we prevented interactions with our roles

if i were me, id like to try and kill me u know

self-hate is a mental illness xoxo

 

[Iwandesu]

but they are still on the same bracket n

 

[Ekkologix]

If someone answers yes, their role is narrowed down greatly. Seems bad to ask.

i actually think everyone is a 'no'

the only reasons why some people's names don't fit there alphabetically is cuz it will make them on the same place as their roles, thats why the hosts swapped it

just a hunch

or do I take it that ur on the same group as ur role?

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Is this a joke, @is a?

No
You are probably thinking I haven’t seen the role I rolled
But I meant the wad role

 

[Laix]

Gonna take some wild guesses on the roles and what they may do

Cooler - can see him being a lie detector
Worm Juice - invisible, nexus
Flower - fights birds
Go D. Usopp -
Hayumi - roleblocks players with their bussy
Hero - Not allowed to post
is a - angry
Kvothe Kingkiller - something to do with ambiguous gender
Iwandesu - has to quote everything a page later
Juan - lovers with Hayumi
Laix - iconic, flawless, godfather, op, hax
Legend - something to do with being horny
Lord Genome - probably a scum role
Melodie - a player gets marked as "atlantic shitstorm" they then have to kill that player to win
nfcnorth - has to remove their avatar
Owner Of A Lonely Heart - jailer
Natalija - mafia strongman that fails against unconfirmed roles
Ratchet - can expose a player to the thread
RemChu - if they lynch a townie they become a generic or can redirect a lynch
Santi - can't be touched by any of us peasants
SinRaven - unlynchable
WolfPrinceKiba - can't post until the end of the phase
Dragon D. Luffy - jester who has to get lynched Day 1

amirite?

 

[Iwandesu]

wait I just noticed my name is out of place too

Are you in another bracket at least ?

 

[Kingslayer]

Good point! Lol so many players, I forget.

@Aragorn you there pal?

At work

Will respond in few hours

 

[Natalija]

Gonna take some wild guesses on the roles and what they may do

Cooler - can see him being a lie detector
Worm Juice - invisible, nexus
Flower - fights birds
Go D. Usopp -
Hayumi - roleblocks players with their bussy
Hero - Not allowed to post
is a - angry
Kvothe Kingkiller - something to do with ambiguous gender
Iwandesu - has to quote everything a page later
Juan - lovers with Hayumi
Laix - iconic, flawless, godfather, op, hax
Legend - something to do with being horny
Lord Genome - probably a scum role
Melodie - a player gets marked as "atlantic shitstorm" they then have to kill that player to win
nfcnorth - has to remove their avatar
Owner Of A Lonely Heart - jailer
Natalija - mafia strongman that fails against unconfirmed roles
Ratchet - can expose a player to the thread
RemChu - if they lynch a townie they become a generic or can redirect a lynch
Santi - can't be touched by any of us peasants
SinRaven - unlynchable
WolfPrinceKiba - can't post until the end of the phase
Dragon D. Luffy - jester who has to get lynched Day 1

amirite?

You didn't guess mine

 

[Natalija]

At work

Will respond in few hours

You work during the night???

 

[Laix]

You didn't guess mine

I didn't guess your role, or Natalija (Role)?

 

[Santí]

Santi - can't be touched by any of us peasants

I'm probably a vig role of some sort because I ban people

 

[Melodie]

Do I dare to pull an iwandesu and start catch up quote posting

 

[Natalija]

I didn't guess your role, or Natalija (Role)?

My role. I HOPE you guessed the Natalija role because me as cute mafia would be fantastic.

Don't get lynched, Natalija

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Are you in another bracket at least ?

what do you mean?

 

[Laix]

Well I know I guessed my role correctly. I'll let y'all figure out which one it is.

 

[Badalight]

Show how much I pay attention, lol. I saw the A's and B's at the top as instantly assumed it was alphabetical. Also, WPK incoming.

 

[Laix]

Do I dare to pull an iwandesu and start catch up quote posting

Do it sis we need some drama in here it's just been me providing it so far

 

[Kira Yagami]

[Vote Lynch John Wayne]

 

[Kingslayer]

You work during the night???

I work in hospital .

 

[Laix]

[Vote Lynch John Wayne]

 

[Lord Melkor]

Ok Owner maybe catch up before you start asking questions.

If you're that impatient: I was doing a quick few ISOs on Cooler, Hayumi and now lastly Kira. If you want, I can share my thoughts on them, but if not I'll just continue lurking.

Why would you not want to share your thoughts but ask people for permission instead?! You scum?

 

[Natalija]

I work in hospital .

man, hang in there

 

[Ekkologix]

No
You are probably thinking I haven’t seen the role I rolled
But I meant the wad role

were we ever given the chance to see our name roles?

Gonna take some wild guesses on the roles and what they may do

Cooler - can see him being a lie detector
Worm Juice - invisible, nexus
Flower - fights birds
Go D. Usopp -
Hayumi - roleblocks players with their bussy
Hero - Not allowed to post
is a - angry
Kvothe Kingkiller - something to do with ambiguous gender
Iwandesu - has to quote everything a page later
Juan - lovers with Hayumi
Laix - iconic, flawless, godfather, op, hax
Legend - something to do with being horny
Lord Genome - probably a scum role
Melodie - a player gets marked as "atlantic shitstorm" they then have to kill that player to win
nfcnorth - has to remove their avatar
Owner Of A Lonely Heart - jailer
Natalija - mafia strongman that fails against unconfirmed roles
Ratchet - can expose a player to the thread
RemChu - if they lynch a townie they become a generic or can redirect a lynch
Santi - can't be touched by any of us peasants
SinRaven - unlynchable
WolfPrinceKiba - can't post until the end of the phase
Dragon D. Luffy - jester who has to get lynched Day 1

amirite?

my role is likely indie asfk lol

u not knowing what to put makes it even clearer lol

 

[Worm Juice]

what makes Wad scummy? I don't recall his posts looking too bad.

Didn’t know it was based on avy. Thought the member wad was impersonating seemed scummy.

I think worm juice is one of those situations where the player is always either low effort townie or coasting scum

So mean

I've never seen scum Worm Juice, her meta is just inherently scummy - sheeps reads and votes, coasts etc...

Sometimes coasting get you further

I took a look at my role and nothing would indicate why I would be out of place. I didn't swap with anyone either compare to DDL and WJ

What’s this swap about?

 

[Laix]

@Pool Party Nitty

did I make it on to the Nitty Show?

 

[Santí]

@Underworld Broker do you like butter on your toast?

Answer with more than yes or no pls.

 

[Kira Yagami]

So...

Cooler was my number one scum read earlier, but he's looking better to me now. He pressured and questioned people more, like Hero and Owner, which I expect of his townself. Though me calling him out on his low effort pressuring might have been the trigger, so keeping my eye on him.

Hayumi regularly switches fluff and some contributive posts. I find myself agreeing with him, but sometimes I get the feeling his posts are too carefully constructed. Like how he was looking into the messenger's identity, but made it clear he was not fishing for his role several times. He also made no bold reads on anyone. Might be leaning scum on him.

Kira is a curious case. He names Laix, Cooler, LG and John Wayne as possible scums, but never really pressures them. Especially with John Wayne he asks others for their reads on him and then John Wayne himself too. He calls John's response a non-answer which I agree with, but I feel like that was a perfect time for him to form a case but he disappeared after. Maybe Im being impatient with him, but I feel like he is skating by with minimal contribution. Never really pushing for anything.
Also might be tunneling on him a bit because I am voting him

Sorry for not linking any quotes but that shit is annoying on mobile.

I never get too absorbed into a game till d2/d3 or when it starts getting interesting, Until then im usually not as invested and laid back so i wont fault u for that observation

 

[SinRaven]

[Vote Lynch John Wayne]

Yeah this timing makes you even more suspicious lol. As if you were reading the thread semi-actively and immediately pressure someone with a vote when being called out on putting minimal/no pressure on people. Wary much?

My vote remains solid on you

 

[Juan]

Juan - lovers with Hayumi

bitch i claimed this like a week ago when nitty was complaining about making the roles

if you really want to steal some credit, go fuck with a married man

 

[Lord Melkor]

So...

Cooler was my number one scum read earlier, but he's looking better to me now. He pressured and questioned people more, like Hero and Owner, which I expect of his townself. Though me calling him out on his low effort pressuring might have been the trigger, so keeping my eye on him.

Hayumi regularly switches fluff and some contributive posts. I find myself agreeing with him, but sometimes I get the feeling his posts are too carefully constructed. Like how he was looking into the messenger's identity, but made it clear he was not fishing for his role several times. He also made no bold reads on anyone. Might be leaning scum on him.

Kira is a curious case. He names Laix, Cooler, LG and John Wayne as possible scums, but never really pressures them. Especially with John Wayne he asks others for their reads on him and then John Wayne himself too. He calls John's response a non-answer which I agree with, but I feel like that was a perfect time for him to form a case but he disappeared after. Maybe Im being impatient with him, but I feel like he is skating by with minimal contribution. Never really pushing for anything.
Also might be tunneling on him a bit because I am voting him

Sorry for not linking any quotes but that shit is annoying on mobile.

Kira seems like his usual Meta- very short posts but to the point. I only remember playing with him as town, so leaning town for now.

You may have a point on Hayumi, his most serious posts so far was defending himself...

My biggest town read so far (have few pages to catch) is Laix, I also like Hero and Owner. I scumread Santi (he has that arrogance as scum and posted something that made me vote him earlier, though I forgot what it was), Remchu (he started by overreacting hard to vote on him by Cooler but now changed his style to nonchalant fluff.... tactical decision?) and Badalight (seems slimy and was rolefishing, also revenge for the Moon would be nice) mostly

 

[SinRaven]

Why would you not want to share your thoughts but ask people for permission instead?! You scum?

Because I wasn't sure if those thoughts were worth sharing yet because my uncertainty about them.
However, wasn't unwilling to share them either, which is why I asked. It was an open invitation, so I'm not sure why you see this as scummy.

 

[Juan]

anyway i don't see the point of speculating on what role does what, it's like "could this be an indie???" but in a game-wide state

i'd rather have us all concentrate on scumhunting, sil vous plaît?

 

[Badalight]

Kira seems like his usual Meta- very short posts but to the point. I only remember playing with him as town, so leaning town for now.

You may have a point on Hayumi, his most serious posts so far was defending himself...

My biggest town read so far (have few pages to catch) is Laix, I also like Hero and Owner. I scumread Santi (he has that arrogance as scum and posted something that made me vote him earlier, though I forgot what it was), Remchu (he started by overreacting hard to vote on him by Cooler but now changed his style to nonchalant fluff.... tactical decision?) and Badalight (seems slimy and was rolefishing, also revenge for the Moon would be nice) mostly

Hey now, Jinri is the one who activated the ability

 

[Kira Yagami]

Yeah this timing makes you even more suspicious lol. As if you were reading the thread semi-actively and immediately pressure someone with a vote when being called out on putting minimal/no pressure on people. Wary much?

My vote remains solid on you

I am semi lurking while reading this manga so you're right ig
Thought id contribute with a vote as i havent yet, was between cooler and JW for me, JW giving me the worse vibe of the two

 

[Lord Melkor]

No
You are probably thinking I haven’t seen the role I rolled
But I meant the wad role

Ah, okay then.

Thanks for soft clearing Lord Genome by the way.

 

[Santí]

bitch i claimed this like a week ago when nitty was complaining about making the roles

if you really want to steal some credit, go fuck with a married man

>NF hook-ups are still happening in 2020

I think I know more people who hooked up here than I know people who hooked up on Tinder.

We're missing out on a lot of cash by not taking advantage of this market.

 

[Kira Yagami]

I am semi lurking while reading this manga so you're right ig
Thought id contribute with a vote as i havent yet, was between cooler and JW for me, JW giving me the worse vibe of the two

mangas chainsawman btw, great so far would recommend

 

[Lord Melkor]

were we ever given the chance to see our name roles?



my role is likely indie asfk lol

u not knowing what to put makes it even clearer lol

No one wants to quess my role

 

[Lord Melkor]

I am semi lurking while reading this manga so you're right ig
Thought id contribute with a vote as i havent yet, was between cooler and JW for me, JW giving me the worse vibe of the two

John Wayne is typically town when I scumread though.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

>NF hook-ups are still happening in 2020

I think I know more people who hooked up here than I know people who hooked up on Tinder.

We're missing out on a lot of cash by not taking advantage of this market.

when Santisimo saw the breadth of his domain he wept, for there were no more THOTs to be slain

 

[Santí]

I scumread Santi (he has that arrogance as scum and posted something that made me vote him earlier, though I forgot what it was)

Mustn't have been that scummy then and you were just being opportunistic

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Kvothe Kingkiller - something to do with ambiguous gender

I hope it's not

Didn’t know it was based on avy. Thought the member wad was impersonating seemed scummy.


So mean


Sometimes coasting get you further


What’s this swap about?

It's in regards to the latest threadmark where people are being split up into groups. It seems alphabetical but you and ddl are swapped and I'm out of place. Don't know what that means tbh

 

[Laix]

anyway i don't see the point of speculating on what role does what, it's like "could this be an indie???" but in a game-wide state

i'd rather have us all concentrate on scumhunting, sil vous plaît?

J'étais juste en train de m'amuser? I've done more scumhunting than you this game

 

[Santí]

@Ratchet can tell you I'm plenty arrogant as town

 

[nfcnorth]

nfcnorth - has to remove their avatar

Just wondering how would that affect the game at all? Don't abilties for the most part have to do something in game?

 

[nfcnorth]

An actual common in game ability that makes more sense for me probably would be a janitor

 

[Laix]

Just wondering how would that affect the game at all? Don't abilties for the most part have to do something in game?

Could just be a posting/flavour mechanic, then your actual role is like roleblocker or something idk why is everyone taking that list seriously

 

[Juan]

J'étais juste en train de m'amuser? I've done more scumhunting than you this game

it was a general statement more meant to "oh i want my role to win" or "hey is your role on the same bracket" or "lololol i bet i'm an indie"

also i don't know french so uh, ur mom

 

[Laix]

it was a general statement more meant to "oh i want my role to win" or "hey is your role on the same bracket" or "lololol i bet i'm an indie"

also i don't know french so uh, ur mom

My mom is a MILF so where do we go from here

 

[Juan]

My mom is a MILF so where do we go from here

we go to u pming me her number, duh

 

[nfcnorth]

Could just be a posting/flavour mechanic, then your actual role is like roleblocker or something idk why is everyone taking that list seriously

I am not taking it to seriously just saying what I think

 

[Juan]

why is everyone taking that list seriously

it's being used as an excuse to coast by "discussing the game"!

 

[Santí]

[Vote lynch Lord Melkor]

I'd like to know more about this post I made which was so scummy you just had to vote me on it, but not scummy enough to remember.

 

[Laix]

we go to u pming me her number, duh

Spoiler:

חזיר מטונף, לעולם לא תתקרב לאמי. זרם אהבה מטופש מאת פעמיים.

 

[Ekkologix]

[Vote lynch Lord Melkor]

I'd like to know more about this post I made which was so scummy you just had to vote me on it, but not scummy enough to remember.

literally ninja'd me from saying that

not to mention hes also protecting hero

[vote lynch lord melkor]

care to explain why u read hero as town? @Lord Melkor

 

[Juan]

Spoiler:

חזיר מטונף, לעולם לא תתקרב לאמי. זרם אהבה מטופש מאת פעמיים.

look i don't speak ur weird LoL language or whatever other nerdspeak nitty's drilled into you

 

[Laix]

Finally some pressure!

[VOTE LYNCH Lord Melkor]

ANSWER SANTÍ NOW

 

[Juan]

oh wait it's hebrew

 

[Laix]

look i don't speak ur weird LoL language or whatever other nerdspeak nitty's drilled into you

It's witchcraft bitch I'm sacrificing the chickens as we speak

My demons gonna come for you

 

[Juan]

don't make me get all roman up in you

 

[Santí]

don't make me get all roman up in you

You mean Latin?

 

[Juan]

It's witchcraft bitch I'm sacrificing the chickens as we speak

My demons gonna come for you

ok azalea, go become irrelevant again

summon some with big tits tho

 

[Laix]

don't make me get all roman up in you

Roman Zolanski?

 

[Juan]

You mean Latin?

who killed jesus, santi?

 

[Laix]

ok azalea, go become irrelevant again

summon some with big tits tho

ok mr 2016 you're still in diapers around here

 

[Juan]

Roman Zolanski?

do i look nitty to you

 

[Santí]

who killed jesus, santi?

The Pharisees?

 

[Laix]

do i look nitty to you

Like you have headlice? Erm...

 

[Juan]

ok mr 2016 you're still in diapers around here

don't u have an oftalmologist check up to get to?

you know, to clean up that cum-in-eye infection?

 

[Juan]

Like you have headlice? Erm...

ew

 

[Juan]

The Pharisees?

they did?

 

[Lord Melkor]

literally ninja'd me from saying that

not to mention hes also protecting hero

[vote lynch lord melkor]

care to explain why u read hero as town? @Lord Melkor

Hero seemed genuine to me early phase - never seen him so active. Propably more a hunch than strong read but I find strong reads hard day one. I would also neven openly townread my scummate as scum.

I will check this post from Santi which made me vote him in a moment, Melodie also noticed it.

 

[Badalight]

Too much fluff these last few pages. Keep it topical people.

 

[Laix]

don't u have an oftalmologist check up to get to?

you know, to clean up that cum-in-eye infection?

At least someone's cumming on me

Too much fluff these last few pages. Keep it topical people.

Who disturbed your crypt Mr 2007

 

[Lord Melkor]

I'm not buying this "I can only post through announcements" claim at face value.

Smells like a lie, and we lynch all liars

Oh I found your post that made me vote you @Santi. What you wanted to achieve here? I do not like people that wasted town's time by hunting for the annoucer.

 

[Natalija]

Too much fluff these last few pages. Keep it topical people.

Feel free to add something of substance.

 

[Santí]

they did?

You have much to learn, my young Padawan. The Roman state carried out the execution, of course, but there's no political motivation for the Roman Emperor to care about some heretical Jew in the desert.

The Pharisees, on the other hand... Had all the motive, all of the political power in the region, and all of the intent

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

It's like Rem gets a burst of testosterone and adrenaline at once and then he starts playing by yelling and screaming and going FUCK YEEEAAAAH LET'S SCUMHUNT while also abandoning all semblance of critical thought and just going after his first suspect with extreme firepower.

But eventually this fails because every strategy will fail at mafia sooner or later, so Remchu's ego just shatters.

Every time you get on crack like this you usually aim your fury at me and not a single time you have apologized for it. So this time I'm resorting to passive agressively slandering you so at least others don't take you seriously and mislynch me again because of you.

Sure, do misvig me again. Been a while since I wrote another post-game thing making fun of you.

I wonder how long you'll quit this time if I do it. Until 2022?

This is definitely way too mean of an approach for town!DDL to be taking unprovoked, and I wouldn't call what happened a good while in the past worthwhile justification for this. RemChu's focus was on Cooler, yet DDL has spent the majority of his posts this phase slandering RemChu in claimed preemptive self-defense. Why care so much beforehand about an attack that isn't guaranteed to happen? It comes off to me like you have more worry and stress over your individual life than a townie should have. Also possible that you're trying to discredit RemChu so his push on Cooler isn't taken seriously.

[Change Vote Lynch Dragon D Luffy]

It could just be me, but I don’t like how you just soft defended WPK based on one post he made when like literally anyone could do or has done something similar where they ask a question or bring attention to one particular thing and end up being scum looking for something to grab at. You in particular, do this a lot when scum I’ve noticed, and I don’t think that makes WPK look any better at all in my honest opinion.

No, you're not the only scum to use such phrasing to diminish their own opinion if things go badly for them with a push. This is an overly fierce attack on someone who was just liking a point I made, as if I'm some major scum suspect to be pouncing on anyone who might be defending me.

Because whenever I play favorites over here there is almost always a lie detector role. I was wondering if the non-favorite games featured lie detector roles often or not. This is mainly the only site that I think I have really played with lie detectors roles. So I ask you is this sort of role generally a standard inclusion or not?

It wouldn't necessarily make sense in this game as I don't necessarily know anyone who can for sure pick out lies like everytime, but I also wouldn't call it out of the question, when designing a game this size.

Why do you particular care if there is a lie detector in this game? Based on your answers to Cooler/myself you don't seem interested in actually pressuring people into claiming town, so why would you if you're town ask about the role over any other? Why is it on your mind as one of the first things to post?

I'm more scared of what @WolfPrinceKiba might have in store for me regardless of alignment. lie detector vs WPK, WPK takes the cake.

I'm not a very spiteful person in mafia games, especially towards players I enjoy having around. If I am after you this game, it's solely because I legitimately think you're anti-town.

 

[Ekkologix]

Hero seemed genuine to me early phase - never seen him so active. Propably more a hunch than strong read but I find strong reads hard day one. I would also neven openly townread my scummate as scum.

I will check this post from Santi which made me vote him in a moment, Melodie also noticed it.

its that semi-reverse psychology

if i was inactive scum last time and i rolled scum again, i would definitely look up to be extra active than usual to not attract eyes again.

well townreading someone as a scum on day one doesn't really amount to much compared to doing it mid or late game. its just interesting how out of everyone that seemed genuinely town, you picked hero specifically.

 

[Badalight]

Feel free to add something of substance.

Worth looking into the fluff posters imo. Laix is prob town and being typical Laix but the people engaging (like Juan) deserve some scrutiny.