Game Members Mafia 4 (indies win!)

[Underworld Broker]

I am. It's a hard town read for me due to finding myself agreeing with some of Laix's posts and reads as well as a meta read from the games we've played together. Tone and posts are similar in sandwich and aragorn's game recently.

[Vote Lynch Hero]

Okey, next question: whats his scum meta like since you're already mentioning his tone and posts

Yes playing loose and relaxed.

Does this mean you're scum reading Laix?

Not particularly reading him as scum, just not a fan of him asking if someone is hinting at their role + i had to check and earlier this phase he was also tryna guess/find the broadcaster which is giving me weird vibes ever since

 

[John Wayne]

You posting nothing but one liners is what makes me weak.

No that would be Juan

 

[John Wayne]

Who...?

Geez I wonder maybe look at what I quoted

 

[Hayumi]

No that would be Juan

I mean I won’t deny itttttt.Thankfully he has something else much longer then his posts...very long...

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Okey, next question: whats his scum meta like since you're already mentioning his tone and posts

This is off of maybe one or two games I've seen him as scum but he tends to powerwolfs and tunnels onto a player pretty early on. He is also the type of player to bus them for his own benefit. I don't see that here so far.

 

[Hayumi]

Geez I wonder maybe look at what I quoted

No I meant like, who asked?

 

[John Wayne]

No I meant like, who asked?

Are you being obtuse on purpose?

 

[Hayumi]

Oh damn, Nat legit has 47 posts and I literally can’t remember any of them at all.


@Laix @Kvothe Kingkiller @Flower @Cooler thoughts on Natalija?

 

[Hayumi]

Are you being obtuse on purpose?

So you really didn’t understand-
Nevermind

 

[Cooler]

Oh damn, Nat legit has 47 posts and I literally can’t remember any of them at all.


@Laix @Kvothe Kingkiller @Flower @Cooler thoughts on Natalija?

I remember her posting but not the content lol. She didn't set off my scum senses at the time but her activit levels are waaaaay lower than the last couple of games where she's been town which worries me.

@Natalija are you reading the game? What are your thoughts?

 

[Juan]

Ok I haven’t catched up fully but did several ISO’s on people of interest and here’s my take on people I didn’t see too discussed from where I left off: Kvothe, is a and Juan are scum.

I’m on mobile so please forgive the no quotes.


Also I’m down to vote either Bada or Hero this dp. And JW if he stays contributing absolutely nothing, could be a mislynch but at least we’re only using a number and not an actual “player” for town.

oh, babe, i'm hurt.

you're gonna have to make this false accusation up to me.

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Oh damn, Nat legit has 47 posts and I literally can’t remember any of them at all.


@Laix @Kvothe Kingkiller @Flower @Cooler thoughts on Natalija?

Previously had a null read on her.

Looking through her posts again, I am leaning towards a scum lean. I don't like the sin vote very much considering she says sin looks better but not good enough to vote someone else and then goes off to name DDL as one of the targets she wants to lynch but doesn't want to vote.

 

[Natalija]

I remember her posting but not the content lol. She didn't set off my scum senses at the time but her activit levels are waaaaay lower than the last couple of games where she's been town which worries me.

@Natalija are you reading the game? What are your thoughts?

Yeah, I'm just about to read the last 20 pages, brb.

 

[Badalight]

Yeah, I'm just about to read the last 20 pages, brb.

Convenient timing.

 

[Lord Genome]

Bada who should I Lynch or iso

 

[Natalija]

Convenient timing.

I just happened to arrive home, hold your horses mister

 

[Hayumi]

Convenient timing.

Almost as bad a look as you throwing shade at literally every little post or thing you can throw attention to.

 

[Badalight]

Bada who should I Lynch or iso

my vote is on John Wayne atm because he's sus and also to save myself

I'd say iso Laix but I don't want to put you through that. The two that I have mentioned a few times today are Juan and Go D. usopp, though they've both had a few people come out in their defense. Could either be mafia teammates moving the conversation along, or perhaps they picked up on a role hint that I didn't.

 

[Badalight]

Almost as bad a look as you throwing shade at literally every little post or thing you can throw attention to.

Almost as bad as you misrepresenting me. Also funny coming from the person who listed a million scum reads with no reasoning to any of them and just said things like "Ohh I think this person is scum, but I could also lynch this person, or maybe this person, I'm good with anything guys :>"

 

[Laix]

I’d love someone to ISO me I’m in the mood to debate

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

@Flower why PM me tho

 

[SinRaven]

Oh damn, Nat legit has 47 posts and I literally can’t remember any of them at all.


@Laix @Kvothe Kingkiller @Flower @Cooler thoughts on Natalija?

You didnt ask me but I'll answer anyway:

Literally don't remember anything by Nat except her vote on me. Dont think she ever really stated any reasons for it aside from agreeing with the people that thought I was coasting. Tbf, I think Nat is the actual one that is coasting. Possibly scum.

 

[SinRaven]

ITT: people dropping in within like one minute of being named

 

[SinRaven]

Bada who should I Lynch or iso

Lord Genome

 

[Hayumi]

Almost as bad as you misrepresenting me. Also funny coming from the person who listed a million scum reads with no reasoning to any of them and just said things like "Ohh I think this person is scum, but I could also lynch this person, or maybe this person, I'm good with anything guys :>"

Wow somebody seems a little pressed, my bad for speaking straight facts sweetie. The only substantial post you’ve given this whole game was a ramble related to melodie and referencing small comments you’ve made to appear more town-ish. Literally not a good look at all. Regardless of your alignment, you aren’t much use sorry not sorry. You wanted to try coming for me? Prepared to get your wig snatched and dragged sweetie.

 

[Natalija]

You didnt ask me but I'll answer anyway:

Literally don't remember anything by Nat except her vote on me. Dont think she ever really stated any reasons for it aside from agreeing with the people that thought I was coasting. Tbf, I think Nat is the actual one that is coasting. Possibly scum.

Looool where is all this coming from suddenly.

I also have to sleep and work

 

[Badalight]

Wow somebody seems a little pressed, my bad for speaking straight facts sweetie. The only substantial post you’ve given this whole game was a ramble related to melodie and referencing small comments you’ve made to appear more town-ish. Literally not a good look at all. Regardless of your alignment, you aren’t much use sorry not sorry. You wanted to try coming for me? Prepared to get your wig snatched and dragged sweetie.

You've done a lot this game. Like....

Oh.

 

[Shizune]

Broadcast message:

Lynch Badalight, thank me later . Dude's like super defensive rn and didn't like his play anyway.

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

this is some really weird foreplay

 

[Hayumi]

You've done a lot this game. Like....

Oh.

Oh? I don’t remember asking for your opinion. If you come with weak ass posts like “oH ReALLy WeLL Y-you” nah gtfo with that. Why’d you get so defensive? Literally you anytime someone posts anything: [Insert any sly comment that makes you sound dumb in order to divert away from you]

If you’re town blame yourself. Honestly wtf.


[Vote Lynch Badalight]

 

[Underworld Broker]

@Badalight whats your case on Usopp, need your thought process on why you think hes scum

 

[Hayumi]

Broadcast message:

Period

 

[SinRaven]

Looool where is all this coming from suddenly.

I also have to sleep and work

Its not really sudden when Hayumi asked people about you like

 

[Badalight]

Oh? I don’t remember asking for your opinion. If you come with weak ass posts like “oH ReALLy WeLL Y-you” nah gtfo with that. Why’d you get so defensive? Literally you anytime someone posts anything: [Insert any sly comment that makes you sound dumb in order to divert away from you]

If you’re town blame yourself. Honestly wtf.


[Vote Lynch Badalight]

I've had my eye on you since you soft defended Juan.

@Badalight whats your case on Usopp, need your thought process on why you think hes scum

After the don patch shenanigans he made a weird rolefishing post, got called out on it, and then continued to try.

 

[Lord Genome]

Lord Genome

 

[Lord Genome]

I’d love someone to ISO me I’m in the mood to debate

I got you fam

Unless day ends before I get stuff together cause I'm doing this on phone at work

Which if that happens rip

 

[Hayumi]

I've had my eye on you since you soft defended Juan.




After the don patch shenanigans he made a weird rolefishing post, got called out on it, and then continued to try.

“Soft defending” Did you just learn that term today? Him posting fluff isn’t a good angle to take when scum hunting him because he will fluff all day every day regardless of alignment.

 

[Hayumi]

If you consider that defending thennnn....? I can’t help you?

 

[Hayumi]

In case anyone asks: I’m still scum leaning on Juan based on his activity levels and familiarity with his tone.

 

[Badalight]

“Soft defending” Did you just learn that term today? Him posting fluff isn’t a good angle to take when scum hunting him because he will fluff all day every day regardless of alignment.

It wasn't just fluff, it was him saying he's too busy to catch up while simultaneously being one of the top posters. I don't use meta arguments because I don't play enough games with everyone to do so.

 

[Underworld Broker]

After the don patch shenanigans he made a weird rolefishing post, got called out on it, and then continued to try.

Wouldn't he immediately drop that topic if he was scum tho?

i feel like a newbie scum would panic and stop pushing it

 

[Shizune]

Broadcast message:

@Badalight you're outed scum, anything to say before your lynch?

 

[Badalight]

Wouldn't he immediately drop that topic if he was scum tho?

i feel like a newbie scum would panic and stop pushing it

Is he newbie scum? I'm not familiar enough.

 

[Santí]

Quick Rundown on the Badaroach lynch.

 

[Natalija]

Its not really sudden when Hayumi asked people about you like

Of course, everyone has the right to ask.

But YOU least of all should preach because for the first 50 pages you were like mimimimi I'm working. Yet when someone else is busy, it's weird? Talk about double standards

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

i'm gonna keep playing this way no matter what any of you say

so do something productive, drop a vote if you're that set and follow one of the cases that will actually matter

/\ jester imo

 

[SinRaven]

Of course, everyone has the right to ask.

But YOU least of all should preach because for the first 50 pages you were like mimimimi I'm working. Yet when someone else is busy, it's weird? Talk about double standards

I mean several people stated they don't even remember what you posted in your 51 posts, so this is not about you being busy but about you seemingly coasting while you were active.

Don't worry, you're on my to ISO list so I'll get back to it later

 

[Natalija]

I mean several people stated they don't even remember what you posted in your 51 posts, so this is not about you being busy but about you seemingly coasting while you were active.

Don't worry, you're on my to ISO list so I'll get back to it later

Okay. Bring the SinRage

 

[Hero]

This is off of maybe one or two games I've seen him as scum but he tends to powerwolfs and tunnels onto a player pretty early on. He is also the type of player to bus them for his own benefit. I don't see that here so far.

Who tf are you talking about?

 

[Shizune]

Broadcast message:

Anyone remember anything from Flower? Why is nobody calling her out yet ?

 

[Kvothe Kingkiller]

Who tf are you talking about?

I am talking about Laix

 

[Natalija]

Broadcast message:

I... Aren't you Flower??

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Play with active hero a little bit more

And how are we even supposed to do that.

Hack NF?

Build a time machine?

Type a cheat code into the thread?

Sacrifice Sin on an altar to some ancient god?

 

[Underworld Broker]

Is he newbie scum? I'm not familiar enough.

i think he's a new player to mafia idk how many games he's played tho if thats what youre asking?

 

[Lord Genome]

Aren't we all flowers

 

[Lord Genome]

Wouldn't he immediately drop that topic if he was scum tho?

i feel like a newbie scum would panic and stop pushing it

Not always depends how much pressure he's getting especially in a game this big with the votes changing as often as they do

 

[Shizune]

Broadcast message:

@Natalija I'm Kenny.

 

[Badalight]

i think he's a new player to mafia idk how many games he's played tho if thats what youre asking?

Oh, I thought you were saying he was new and you'd expect him to make a newbie mistake - and you don't perceive him pushing the issue to be something a new player would do.

 

[Hayumi]

I... Aren't you Flower??

OMG Is ThAt RolE FisHINg?

 

[Shizune]

Broadcast message:

I'm still working btw. Those many pages of documents just don't wanna translate themselves.

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Maybe I should try a Persuasion Check?

@Hero be more active at mafia.

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Meh

 

[Underworld Broker]

Not always depends how much pressure he's getting especially in a game this big with the votes changing as often as they do

You have a point

 

[Hero]

And how are we even supposed to do that.

Hack NF?

Build a time machine?

Type a cheat code into the thread?

Sacrifice Sin on an altar to some ancient god?

Send nudes

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Ok I haven’t catched up fully but did several ISO’s on people of interest and here’s my take on people I didn’t see too discussed from where I left off: Kvothe, is a and Juan are scum.

I’m on mobile so please forgive the no quotes.


Also I’m down to vote either Bada or Hero this dp. And JW if he stays contributing absolutely nothing, could be a mislynch but at least we’re only using a number and not an actual “player” for town.

And this kids, is how you say a bunch of stuff in a single post while also saying nothing.

 

[Ekkologix]

rly badalight

 

[Hayumi]

And this kids, is how you say a bunch of stuff in a single post while also saying nothing.

Instead of pulling a Iwan, read my next posts to see if I respond to any of your unwanted concerns and comments. Pls and thanks sweetie.

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

One of Melo and Bada is scum

One of Hayumi and Bada is scum

Bada is in both groups so he has 2x higher chance of being scum

Ez gg

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

The above logic is perfect shhhhhh

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

Maybe I should try a Persuasion Check?

@Hero be more active at mafia.

i roll intimidate on DDL for no other reason other than to flex and reiatsu crush him for the memes

 

[FLORIDA MAN]

fuck is with these 8s

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

kind of want to roll with Bada and lynch JW too, tbh

 

[Natalija]

Gonna pull an iwandesu, please forgive me.

Did you guys witness any taboo word ? Please keep an eye on it.

What... What are you talking about?

Is host playing the game ? I am legit confused by their action.

*looks into role list *

Are you really that confused? You're very experienced, and this reaction felt like acting to me.

I think I'm leaning scum on any player that has expressed bewilderment at Shiz defending Melkor here. Everyone and I mean everyone knows that Shizune isn't going to sabotage their own game like that, so I'm left to conclude that it's scum unsure of how to react.

This being one of the textbook examples of the above.

[Vote Lynch Hero]

No, I think that kind of thinking is overblown. Obviously everyone had no clue what was happening. For a second there I thought the host was actually pitying LM.
It looks to me like you're forcing a narrative.

@Natalija and @Hayumi already feel like they've been here for years, and both have dragged and been dragged. It's part of the birthing process

Awwww, that's too sweet, thank you for accepting me!!

I do have a few traumas, but I have loads of fun here.

Badalight I am scum But hesitant since I sus you and you are hard sussing him

Slip?

I love how flower is my biggest fan after laix

I'm your biggest fan!! You're such great scum!!

 

[Ekkologix]

my vote is on John Wayne atm because he's sus and also to save myself

I'd say iso Laix but I don't want to put you through that. The two that I have mentioned a few times today are Juan and Go D. usopp, though they've both had a few people come out in their defense. Could either be mafia teammates moving the conversation along, or perhaps they picked up on a role hint that I didn't.

After the don patch shenanigans he made a weird rolefishing post, got called out on it, and then continued to try.

I think juan is an indie, i was just trying to see if someone could slip and leak having my role, who I think is an indie role most likely. I am also interested asfk to know why are we divided in 3 groups like that? are we not supposed to interact with the players who are our roles or what? thats something very natural to think about and is not rly role fishing. The only fishing I did was to know about my own usopp role.

@Badalight whats your case on Usopp, need your thought process on why you think hes scum

hes a bit overprotective to hero who i've been suspecting since the start of the game, its likely natural for him to want to redirect lynches to me.

Not always depends how much pressure he's getting especially in a game this big with the votes changing as often as they do

i dont get swayed easily xd, i do what i want to do most of the time lol

 

[Hayumi]

For clarification: I sus you, Juan and is a as scum reads. But Bada, JW, and Hero are who I would vote for a lynch today

@Dragon D. Luffy this is the tldr for what I was trying to say in my post, but my extra ass had some unneeded fluff mixed in the original.

 

[Ekkologix]

One of Melo and Bada is scum

One of Hayumi and Bada is scum

Bada is in both groups so he has 2x higher chance of being scum

Ez gg

id like to add one or two of hero and bada is scum

now u do the math

 

[Hayumi]

id like to add one or two of hero and bada is scum

now u do the math

I low key could see both of them being scum.

 

[Badalight]

I think juan is an indie, i was just trying to see if someone could slip and leak having my role, who I think is an indie role most likely. I am also interested asfk to know why are we divided in 3 groups like that? are we not supposed to interact with the players who are our roles or what? thats something very natural to think about and is not rly role fishing. The only fishing I did was to know about my own usopp role.



hes a bit overprotective to hero who i've been suspecting since the start of the game, its likely natural for him to want to redirect lynches to me.



i dont get swayed easily xd, i do what i want to do most of the time lol

Whether it's your role or not, it's still fishing. Your post wasn't about your role though. You were asking the entire thread a question that would help narrow down our roles. I'm also not sure why you'd want to be indie hunting on day 1. As for Hero, pretty sure he's voting to lynch me right now. I don't let that affect my judgement of his alignment though.

 

[Ekkologix]

Whether it's your role or not, it's still fishing. Your post wasn't about your role though. You were asking the entire thread a question that would help narrow down our roles. I'm also not sure why you'd want to be indie hunting on day 1. As for Hero, pretty sure he's voting to lynch me right now. I don't let that affect my judgement of his alignment though.

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Usopp's thing seems more like a newbie coming up with an impractical plan than a scum player maliciously trying to fish a bunch of roles tbh