Game Favorites '22 - GROUP 2

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
anyone but me the town MVP

just lynch Melkor or Hammer those fuckers are literally always scum anyway

also Santi also seems to be on him 'I'm scum and I stay silent in the background' meta rn
Same for Kira and Franky


also where the fuck is Badalight. And Melodie where's that bitch??
hammer can get executed, and Melkor hasn't truly pinged me yet. Nessos, Worm Juice and yourself are my current top lynch choices.
 
My contingency plan, if no other leads open up and Didi unleashes his mvp tenacity to sway the gullible masses would be as follows.

Lynch Melkor, for this has 1 of 2 options.

1. Melkor is obv forever scum and we kill scum

or

2. Melkor is town, but then replaces some inactifag scum immediately, then we kill him again and get scum.

While the second option is not as ideal, it would result in us killing Melkor twice, which has benefits as well.
 
got any reads yet?

No tbh I don't have jack shit. The only slightly weird thing that even kind of caught my eye was Hero being like "omg who is the new player SoulTaker" and I'm like "how the fuck are you calling SoulTaker new this guy has been here since like favorites 1?"

Not even a scum read just a wtf moment.

I like kind of read Ratchet's plan but it was very complicated so I just kinda ignored it.
 
No tbh I don't have jack shit. The only slightly weird thing that even kind of caught my eye was Hero being like "omg who is the new player SoulTaker" and I'm like "how the fuck are you calling SoulTaker new this guy has been here since like favorites 1?"

Not even a scum read just a wtf moment.

I like kind of read Ratchet's plan but it was very complicated so I just kinda ignored it.

really, nothing?

unhelpful, but surprisingly honest maybe
 
Oh I will say that SoulTaker is like a super good player and that interaction at the start of the game was kind of weird. Makes me wonder if his "omg I don't care about this game" was an act and then Nitty replaced him and then ST pmed Nitty and was like "hey wtf that was just part of my gameplan" which is why he was subbed back in. IDK the whole thing was weird but I think Nitty said to not talk about it anymore???????
 
No real reads yet.

Rejs posts are annoying.
WPK reaction to Ekkologix accusation caught my attention.
And I am waiting for the scummy bird to return :blobkcop


And what are your reads so far?
How do you think about odds natural enemys @Worm Juice reads you as Indie? :bloblick
I’m gonna need to go find that Susopp interaction.

I find a few people like you, Melkor and Lind iffy, but I’m still on the lookout

Worm probably thinks it because of what I’ve said about being scum, I dunno. However, I’m just town
 
anyone but me the town MVP

just lynch Melkor or Hammer those fuckers are literally always scum anyway

also Santi also seems to be on him 'I'm scum and I stay silent in the background' meta rn
Same for Kira and Franky


also where the fuck is Badalight. And Melodie where's that bitch??
Ngl this post was quite funny. I do like that Didi is willing to add comedic relief to his posts while under a few votes. I'm a sucker for posts that make me laugh and it tells me that he's still quite chill about the pressure to joke around.

No tbh I don't have jack shit. The only slightly weird thing that even kind of caught my eye was Hero being like "omg who is the new player SoulTaker" and I'm like "how the fuck are you calling SoulTaker new this guy has been here since like favorites 1?"

Not even a scum read just a wtf moment.

I like kind of read Ratchet's plan but it was very complicated so I just kinda ignored it.
Definitely sounds comfortable and very honest. Townie points for this.
 
I'm the King of Comedy
kingofcomedy-1600x900-c-default.jpg
 
To me*
This no editing rule is going to be pretty annoying to deal with by the way
fuck

Regarding Dr Professor, my only memory of him is that he is an extremely competent scum player and mechanic savvy, going by his interactions in the last game I hosted. He's someone to note when flips come about.
I honestly don't have anything better from today so far. Piling on Didi to kill him now would be the easy way out, but I don't see what WPK and others see.

Oh I will say that SoulTaker is like a super good player and that interaction at the start of the game was kind of weird. Makes me wonder if his "omg I don't care about this game" was an act and then Nitty replaced him and then ST pmed Nitty and was like "hey wtf that was just part of my gameplan" which is why he was subbed back in. IDK the whole thing was weird but I think Nitty said to not talk about it anymore???????

Yeah I was surprised about FakeSoul's opening game as well.
It was somewhat out of character for someone that has played this game for a long time, especially in a game this big. I'd think he will get called out on it 10/10 times with these many people.
 
Ratchet's first post had him make a case for having a small group of people decide the Lynch, what's to say such a group doesn't just become scum majority. Or if that's not the case, the smaller number makes it easier for such a group to be affected by Vote manipulation which Nitty is known for giving scum.


Pretty sus.


Dr. Professor is doing some weird Pariston RP and is being intentionally vague, and he's clashing withNatialija, could be different factions or a bussing strat.

More reads TBD when I've enjoyed coffee
What even is this? I don’t think I’ve ever seen you write a post this long.
 
Hey can you give me a tldr on what the fuck u were talking about in regards to you being in both days and your role being janitored or some shit? I didn't read the other game thread and I'm very confused plz help.
Basically this year's favorites is divided into 2 groups each consisting of its own mafia teams - Red and Purple. The player base is divided evenly into these two groups and each town in these 2 groups face off against their respective scum teams in their groups.

I am able to post in both groups.
 
Basically this year's favorites is divided into 2 groups each consisting of its own mafia teams - Red and Purple. The player base is divided evenly into these two groups and each town in these 2 groups face off against their respective scum teams in their groups.

I am able to post in both groups.

Oh but you didn't die in the other game? I swear I saw you talking about your role being janitored or something.
 
Oh I will say that SoulTaker is like a super good player and that interaction at the start of the game was kind of weird. Makes me wonder if his "omg I don't care about this game" was an act and then Nitty replaced him and then ST pmed Nitty and was like "hey wtf that was just part of my gameplan" which is why he was subbed back in. IDK the whole thing was weird but I think Nitty said to not talk about it anymore???????
LMAO.

Also, I think you're getting confused about the player. This one is SoulKiller not Taker. I believe the two players are different and SoulKiller is not from NF and this is probably his first favorites.
 
what do you think about John Wayne

Pretty neutral at the moment. Is this about him dipping when you asked him? It's a little sus, but I'm waiting with bated breath for those promised after coffee other reads for something more definitive. The eventual first read he gave was okayish, but extrapolating a little too much for this early in the game imo. Townies clash more often in day 1 then scum and indies, who are usually more focused on either provoking the reactionary day 1 wagons, or trying to jostle for town leader position. In a favorites game especially.
 
Pretty neutral at the moment. Is this about him dipping when you asked him? It's a little sus, but I'm waiting with bated breath for those promised after coffee other reads for something more definitive. The eventual first read he gave was okayish, but extrapolating a little too much for this early in the game imo. Townies clash more often in day 1 then scum and indies, who are usually more focused on either provoking the reactionary day 1 wagons, or trying to jostle for town leader position. In a favorites game especially.

Extrapolating be the name of the game, you try having solid reads mid day 1
 
Ratchet's first post had him make a case for having a small group of people decide the Lynch, what's to say such a group doesn't just become scum majority. Or if that's not the case, the smaller number makes it easier for such a group to be affected by Vote manipulation which Nitty is known for giving scum.


Pretty sus.


Dr. Professor is doing some weird Pariston RP and is being intentionally vague, and he's clashing withNatialija, could be different factions or a bussing strat.

More reads TBD when I've enjoyed coffee

oh I am just blind
sorry
 
Has there really been no day abilities used in this Favorites? Or does this count as the "Night" Phase due to the game split?

[Vote Lynch Lord Melkior]

IIRC, he was the one who specifically told us he'd be going to bed, which isn't really necessary unless you're scared of being lynched, which shouldn't really be a thing on Day 1, IMHO.

on the one hand I'm all for a melkor lynch cuz foreverscum

on the other hand
I once got d1 lynched as town over this exact bullshit argument and I'm still a little bit mad about it
 
Oh but you didn't die in the other game? I swear I saw you talking about your role being janitored or something.
No I'm still alive. If I die in any of the games, my role will be janitored until I die in both games.

What I see in your posts is a lot of time spent to carefully explain yourself and your place here.

I don’t honestly feel your town aloofness at all
Nat, this is a pretty weak read here. Carefully explaining my place here is what I should do as I was questioned on it by going even beyond the rules. Did you read the opening post with the rules? I'm in both groups tackling both mafia teams and the rules state that both teams will not merge.

Unless you wanna tinfoil that the rules are wrong which Nitty stated 3 times - Sign up thread, this thread and group 1 thread that this is a multiball and that red and purple will team will be enemies. I have no idea why I have to revisit this again with you.
 
No I'm still alive. If I die in any of the games, my role will be janitored until I die in both games.


Nat, this is a pretty weak read here. Carefully explaining my place here is what I should do as I was questioned on it by going even beyond the rules. Did you read the opening post with the rules? I'm in both groups tackling both mafia teams and the rules state that both teams will not merge.

Unless you wanna tinfoil that the rules are wrong which Nitty stated 3 times - Sign up thread, this thread and group 1 thread that this is a multiball and that red and purple will team will be enemies. I have no idea why I have to revisit this again with you.
Did you not understand at all what I’m saying? You seem keen on surviving, A LOT.
 
I think you’re saying it with a host mindset, not based on his threadplay alone (which matters to us here).

I mean his threadplay in that game was pretty great too, but eh, no real point in convincing you of my own perception of someone. I don't play enough games here anymore to know if that has held up the last 7 months or not.

It's just something to keep in mind. Way I see it is that abilities tend to be clumped onto certain people in these types of games, and the ones who are able to thread the needle are the ones who get far in favorites. He's someone who can do that is all.
 
I mean his threadplay in that game was pretty great too, but eh, no real point in convincing you of my own perception of someone. I don't play enough games here anymore to know if that has held up the last 7 months or not.

It's just something to keep in mind. Way I see it is that abilities tend to be clumped onto certain people in these types of games, and the ones who are able to thread the needle are the ones who get far in favorites. He's someone who can do that is all.

I've lost the thread, who's the 'he' in this post?
 
I mean his threadplay in that game was pretty great too, but eh, no real point in convincing you of my own perception of someone. I don't play enough games here anymore to know if that has held up the last 7 months or not.

It's just something to keep in mind. Way I see it is that abilities tend to be clumped onto certain people in these types of games, and the ones who are able to thread the needle are the ones who get far in favorites. He's someone who can do that is all.
I do agree about your Dr_Professor read, though. He is able to utilize abilities and maintain a proper thread presence as scum too. He's very good!

I've lost the thread, who's the 'he' in this post?
Professor.
 
The Soulkiller one. It doesn't feel quote natural to me that that was something you felt you had to respond to.

I hate those types of posts is all. People tend to be more forgiving of them than I like, and it is often an easy crutch for people who want to stay in a scum, but not put in any effort, to fall back onto day 1 by setting low expectations knowing that the top posters just like to go at each other, and the conversation will naturally shift away as people come up with new talking points and analysis. The will they won't they stay thing kinda muddied the water for me on it as I Iwandesu'd my way through the thread though.
 
Do I need to read the other group? Probably. Will I? Probably not. But I see talk about how Lind can post in both places and needs to read both? Sorry you have to go through that.

I do feel like a role that functions that way is more likely to be town or indy though and as such have decided to ignore it, if it is mafia then it's going to be legitimately scumhunting in one of the groups anyway since I think I remember reading that the red/purple are separated by group? Or maybe I am misremembering it's been a hot minute since I read the signup thread.
 
I hate those types of posts is all. People tend to be more forgiving of them than I like, and it is often an easy crutch for people who want to stay in a scum, but not put in any effort, to fall back onto day 1 by setting low expectations knowing that the top posters just like to go at each other, and the conversation will naturally shift away as people come up with new talking points and analysis. The will they won't they stay thing kinda muddied the water for me on it as I Iwandesu'd my way through the thread though.

I agree and despite me definitely not mixing SK up with another prominent player my point from however many pages ago still stands.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top