Game Favorites '22 - GROUP 2

[Yo Tan Wa]

Don't have any opinion on Badalight so far, but not rly liking Yo Tan Wa getting sussed by him and immediately going "no YOU'RE the suspicious one for this, FoS!!!" weird vibes there

How'd you read a player that twist all your posts? Townie?

Look into the posts bit more to get clarity here.

 

[John Wayne]

I'm not that sick.

Evidence suggest you are in fact that sick.

 

[Hero]

Red team in group 1, purple team in group 2.

it's either didi or the person who pushed didi, heck with multiple mafia it could be both. should go after whoever started the lynch

Maybe I’m wrong, but are you implying there are multiple mafia factions in this thread bc you’re wrong.

 

[John Wayne]

Kira Yagami is giving me good vibes, also

Vote Lynch Worm Juice

Kira is giving you good vibes so youre bandwagoning?

 

[Firestormer]

How'd you read a player that twist all your posts? Townie?

Look into the posts bit more to get clarity here.

Well it would depend on the context, if it seems like they are legitimately trying to scumhunt then yeah I probably would read a person sussing me as town. Your response seemed more tailored to discredit sus on you than to discuss it, if that makes sense.

I don't feel strongly on this read or anything, but it gave me weird vibes is all.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Kira is giving you good vibes so youre bandwagoning?

I'm the first one that pointed out the Worm Juice focus on inactives,

Why were you checking post counts of players, did ya gain anything from doing this?

I wanted to follow up on that from before, was simply waiting for his reply. But been few hours now

Kira thoughts allign with mine and he's voting Worm so yeah why not.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Well it would depend on the context, if it seems like they are legitimately trying to scumhunt then yeah I probably would read a person sussing me as town. Your response seemed more tailored to discredit sus on you than to discuss it, if that makes sense.

I don't feel strongly on this read or anything, but it gave me weird vibes is all.

I don't if i see a player twisting everything i post to paint me scum yeah not townie in my eyes.

You should properly iso me then i guess.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

they are legitimately trying to scumhunt

I didn't felt so at all

 

[Didi]

I don't feel it's fair to say that Badalight was 'twisting everything you post to paint you scum'
Feels like a dramatic overreact

have you heard of the term OMGUS?

 

[Firestormer]

I didn't felt so at all

Fair enough lol, you are entitled to that opinion

 

[Rej]

That makes no sense lol I wouldn't have announced it to the world, but lying low with an excuse to live later is a pretty safe strategy in these games.

You're trying covering for your teammate or something? Or are you trying to get some townie points when we lynch him, and he flips town?

no I genuinely tried to give a read on a controversial slot, because this is something I like to do, especially when I see things, like micro management within the posts

there is no scum mate or anything else because Rej is town

 

[Rej]

You've been posting a lot but haven't been added anything of real substance, Rej. You just put out some feelers. Your WG tricks won't save you here. Who do you want to lynch?

I literally did the same as others, point feelers, even some town reads, now it's time to look for some scumreads? I have to catch up 11 more pages, until then I will place my vote for sure somewhere, my eyes are mainly on Didi

but if you are a good and experienced mafia player, then you should be aware of the fact that it's easier to find townies than finding scum

 

[Didi]

until then I will place my vote for sure somewhere, my eyes are mainly on Didi

just because I called your gimmick annoying? Grow up m8

 

[Rej]

respect wg mafia pal .

I respect noone, I am a sas, it's the other way around, do something and I respect you.

For example be like Ekko, have a huge insight on yourself and try to refine your mafia mojo, realize that you caused alot of problems and start gitting gud. As a result the Rej will respect you lmao.

 

[Rej]

just because I called your gimmick annoying? Grow up m8

I am already grown up. I can't help you with that demand.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

I don't feel it's fair to say that Badalight was 'twisting everything you post to paint you scum'
Feels like a dramatic overreact

have you heard of the term OMGUS?

You are allowed to disprove that with the posts, my friend

 

[Rej]

What’s the purpose of twisting that story as scum?

Inserting dominance and your own truth.

 

[jinri]

u really arent reading lol

I'm giving you the benefot of the doubt because the alterbate reading of that response is a filler question.

I believe this would have been more valuable if you told us what you thought about Soul Killer using that strategy first, and then move on to Rej probably saving a teammate or buddying a townie.

Because you said that it’s a safe strategy and left it at that. What’s your read on Soul Killer using it?

People saying that they will not be so active can be indicative or either town or scum since I've seen both do that. However, it's clear that they won't be helpful, so depending on what happens on D2 or D3, then it might be good to throw some abilities at them. I don't like that they said that and then argued about it though.

I’m pretty sure Melkor was talking about Rej, Juan and Hero in that post lol. Why did you misinterpret it like this?

I misread "them" as "me."

Not happy with DDL's decision to quit the game with that role of his

Hey, Odd. What's going on here? Your posts are, like, 99% odd comments.

@DrProfessor83



In case you haven't seen this, it's great analysis/appreciation video for Pariston

Oh! It's a Paris Hilton parody. I didn't realize that.

Also, IIRC Xadlin likes to coast when he's scum, and plan from behind the scenes. It's what he did as Makima last favorites and he was able to clean clocks because of it. If he only posts like 2-3 times every day phase, he's a good pressure option.

Then let's do that:

[vote change lynch Xadlin]

I honestly don't think Didi is the way.

Vote lynch Lalisa

Well, you got your answer above. Still want to keep this vote?

I literally did the same as others, point feelers, even some town reads, now it's time to look for some scumreads? I have to catch up 11 more pages, until then I will place my vote for sure somewhere, my eyes are mainly on Didi

but if you are a good and experienced mafia player, then you should be aware of the fact that it's easier to find townies than finding scum

True. I'm also just throwing out feelers. Don't sweat it. I'm not voting for you yet.

 

[Rej]

Asking Rej not to be a weeb is like asking a fish not to swim or Melkor not to roll scum in an event game. It just is contradictory to their nature.

I like that post, @Ekkologix lets towncore Platinum

There was once a time Rej played serious, but He always got destroyed. There are some examples out there that Mafia isn't healthy

I can't deny that, my behaviour is mostly a result of multiple coinflips. +1 on you for not serving a twisted piece of history

 

[charles101]

Ash is a role that was claimed in the other group and I hardly doubt anyone here would have info on it.

You were in G1, right? Can you just post claims we got there here? To end this whole G1 discussion (also i want to know if my sub was there).

replaces some inactifag scum immediately, then we kill him again and get scum.

As far as I know dead players can't sub in.

Btw, i don't want to be this person, but mafia's have to be massive right? In game with over 30 players.


Also @whoever votes inactive, don't waste your Lynch, there's separate execution mechanic to deal with them. Also because of that I believe scums will do all they can to at least post here. To escape being candidates for execution

 

[Rej]

What are your thoughts on this game? Stop reading the other thread, it has no relevance to us at this time and can only serve to distract and confuse us by getting things mixed up between threads.

agree here, it makes WormJuice look really really bad and WPK mentioning this is a really good look

 

[Rej]

it's either didi or the person who pushed didi, heck with multiple mafia it could be both. should go after whoever started the lynch

this post looks terrible, even less informed than I am and I try to be at the lower end of town
this spot is uncontested, so hammer must be on the lower end of mafia kekw

Rej threw 100-faced dice Reason: For how accurate this read is Total: 18

 

[Rej]

the dices are rigd since I woke up...huh

 

[Badalight]

How'd you read a player that twist all your posts? Townie?

Look into the posts bit more to get clarity here.

omg I isoed you cry me a river

jk let's be friends

(The thread was moving at a snail's pace and wagon was firmly on Didi at that point. Was being productive and looking into low-posters that had not been engaged with much yet rather than sit around and waste the end of the phase. Clicked on your posts. Saw some things that often are scum tells. Obviously if you're town you're going to read this as me "twisting your posts" but you have to admit that the "omg I am new here" is something scum do a lot as well as the implying to be town without expressly saying it as to avoid lie detectors. Also NGL the overly defensive post to the iso does not help your case tbh but I'm glad you replied to me k thx bye <3)

 

[Badalight]

the dices are rigd since I woke up...huh

ooh do me next

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Then let's do that:

[vote change lynch Xadlin]

There's going to be Execution lynch for inactives next day forward,

Tell us, who'd you actually want to lynch this phase

 

[Rej]

page 17, I need to take it slow, mafia is such a time sink, I am inclined to think that JW is towny with his idgaf-vote against Nessos, just a bit meta on this

I am taking a small break then getting back to answeringg ya guys but I know whom I will vote
[Vote Lynch WormJuice]

lets start the real gamberu

 

[Rej]

ooh do me next

Bada is town

Rej threw 100-faced dice Reason: For how accurate this read is Total: 97

 

[Firestormer]

Also @whoever votes inactive, don't waste your Lynch, there's separate execution mechanic to deal with them. Also because of that I believe scums will do all they can to at least post here. To escape being candidates for execution

To be fair there's still a few players who haven't posted here yet, so putting pressure on some of the lesser posting players can net some good intel. Someone like Xadlin (last person I noticed get voted with few posts) has made just enough posts to be clear of the execution next round without being involved, so I don't think voting them or players with a similar post count is necessarily bad here.

 

[Badalight]

Bada is town

good guy confirmed

 

[Juan]

For example be like Ekko,

lmao

 

[Badalight]

Also preemptively sussing anyone who is waiting until the last minute to get enough posts to not be included in the execution

 

[Firestormer]

To be fair there's still a few players who haven't posted here yet, so putting pressure on some of the lesser posting players can net some good intel. Someone like Xadlin (last person I noticed get voted with few posts) has made just enough posts to be clear of the execution next round without being involved, so I don't think voting them or players with a similar post count is necessarily bad here.

just checked and:

Iwandesu
Melodie
Salah WG
sworder

ok exactly 4 haven't posted unless I missed one, so anyone who has posted at all is technically posting enough to avoid the chop right now and can be considered a valid option for a vote

 

[Juan]

i'm on a bus omw to college right now so my contributions will be sporadic for a while btw

so expect to wait an hour or two if you want to talk to me

also don't lynch one of the best shitposters in the game on day 1 ffs

 

[jinri]

There's going to be Execution lynch for inactives next day forward,

Tell us, who'd you actually want to lynch this phase

It doesn't look like Xadlin will be among the four, so my vote stays parked for now.

 

[jinri]

What players do you want to kill today, @Yo Tan Wa ?

 

[charles101]

just checked and:

Iwandesu
Melodie
Salah WG
sworder

ok exactly 4 haven't posted unless I missed one, so anyone who has posted at all is technically posting enough to avoid the chop right now and can be considered a valid option for a vote

Well 5 people will be candidates do atm IT would be these people and Franky. I saw someone voting Franky i'm pretty sure.

And as I said, mafia teams are most likely massive. Like 8+. There's no way nobody in this team hasn't read rules. So unless they have one of sworder, Salah, Melodie and Iwan here, all their mates know they have to post SOMETHING to escape execution. I assume all execute targets will be town tbh.

 

[Firestormer]

Lynch two will be referred to as "the execution," and may only be applied to the four living players who had the lowest post count at the beginning of that day.​

It's only 4 unless I'm missing something?

But I agree with your main point of the scum at least posting once or twice to avoid the Execution, that's why I'm saying voting lower posters is not a bad thing since it'll force discussion from people just active enough to avoid it. I do think your point of the Execution likely just being townies is valid

 

[Firestormer]

Anyway moving past that, do you have any other reads atm @charles101 ? And what is your take on the Didi votes?

 

[charles101]

Oh btw I don't have really strong scum reads do far.
Only person i'm iffy on by myself do far is Prof with that whole PR thing. Kinda reminds me him acting as Hohenheim in FMA game. Idk.
I disagree with Ratchet on his voting idea but it doesn't necessary mean he can't be town.
Could go with WJ based on Franky vote and liking Kira's ISO.
Linda is just indie imo. His defense against Ratchet made sense though. Maybe non-hostile. Tbh, he should just claim if he's indie imo. Like there's no way he's mafia.

People i'd town lean (i don't town read anyone tbh) would be SK, Lalisa, Nat, Kira, Hero... And that's it probably.

I have no idea what to think about Didi.

Nothing really based on my TMI. I can't use any abilities before night anyway

 

[charles101]

Anyway moving past that, do you have any other reads atm @charles101 ? And what is your take on the Didi votes?

Oh, here xd

 

[charles101]

I think the worst vote on Didi would be tinky. He kinda showed up, voted and dipped

 

[Firestormer]

Thank you god bless

 

[Xadlin]

god i forgot how i hated inactives

I play my way.

 

[Fang]

[Vote Lynch DrProfessor83]

He feels off. Or maybe its cause I don't like the rat guy from HxH. One of those two reasons I suppose. Also @Santí why you so quiet, boy?

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

omg I isoed you cry me a river

jk let's be friends

(The thread was moving at a snail's pace and wagon was firmly on Didi at that point. Was being productive and looking into low-posters that had not been engaged with much yet rather than sit around and waste the end of the phase. Clicked on your posts. Saw some things that often are scum tells. Obviously if you're town you're going to read this as me "twisting your posts" but you have to admit that the "omg I am new here" is something scum do a lot as well as the implying to be town without expressly saying it as to avoid lie detectors. Also NGL the overly defensive post to the iso does not help your case tbh but I'm glad you replied to me k thx bye <3)

Issue was not the iso there rather how it was done badlight. I feel better about the players i quoted and pointed the anomaly out of, but you ignored that and brought some unknown narratives. Questioning hammer on the joining the wagon. Worm juice focus on pointing the post count and not going anywhere with that info.

As for thread being slow and wanting to contribute means you bring in proper content, if you do half ass or bad job your intentions are going to be questioned obviously.

 

[Hero]

I think the worst vote on Didi would be tinky. He kinda showed up, voted and dipped

Between Tinky & Platinum, who looks worse

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

It doesn't look like Xadlin will be among the four, so my vote stays parked for now.

You gonna go with someone with no posts?

What players do you want to kill today, @Yo Tan Wa ?

Yeah might just be you actually

What are your skoom reads among the actives?

 

[Xadlin]

Between Tinky & Platinum, who looks worse

Plat.

love you still bro

 

[Didi]

Between Tinky & Platinum, who looks worse

I myself was inclined to see Plat's vote on me as just a friendly jab between old friends, not a real vote

 

[Didi]

Like when I saw that one I didn't see it as a vote that would stay until the end of the day

 

[Lind]

Is Rej trying to roleplay as their role or are they just Like That? I also feel weird about them town reading SoulKiller for not caring? Idk. I get sus vibes from them so far.

Rej role plays depending on his mood. He’s role played before as town mainly as I can’t remember if I’ve seen him role play as scum.

It’s one of the reasons I could see him being town here tbh.

Same to DrProfessor with whoever his anime character is, is this normal for those two or unique to this game?

This is probably my first time seeing Prof role play here.

 

[Badalight]

Issue was not the iso there rather how it was done badlight. I feel better about the players i quoted and pointed the anomaly out of, but you ignored that and brought some unknown narratives. Questioning hammer on the joining the wagon. Worm juice focus on pointing the post count and not going anywhere with that info.

As for thread being slow and wanting to contribute means you bring in proper content, if you do half ass or bad job your intentions are going to be questioned obviously.

Are you misspelling my name on purpose!!!!!!!! :'(

I don't know what you're referring to by this "unknown narrative" business. Do you not agree that the things you said are often said by scum players? Because they totally are. I'm not saying you are scum, but like... that's the game of mafia my friend. Pointing out posts that look suspicious.

The "lol I am new here ;3" type of post is a super common scum tell. I don't think anyone would disagree with that? Doesn't mean everyone who says it is scum, but it's a mistake that many scum make.

The posts were you implied being town without saying you are town is also another very common this that scum do. Obviously since then you came out and literally said "I am town" but you cannot blame me for pointing out that very suspicious and dodgy wording of that original post.

Then as for the bandwagon thing, I can't say that is a normal scum tell because this game has unique lynch mechanics. That said, due to those mechanics there is reason to be suspect of anyone who does not get on the bandwagon because that means they are immune from the next day's lynch. You making that post early in the day phase almost sounded like giving yourself cover for not going with the bandwagon that had not even formed yet.

The only reason you see my logic as flawed is either A) I am right and you are a mafia or B) you are a town so you are going to be critical of anyone who susses you. Both understandable reactions, but my logic is not flawed for pointing out those posts.

 

[SinRaven]

Is there a way to search posts in chronological order? Why tf is it ordered random lmao

Tryna figure out why this Didi bandwagon happened

 

[Hero]

Plat.

love you still bro

what is your opinion of hammer/tinky winky/plat

I myself was inclined to see Plat's vote on me as just a friendly jab between old friends, not a real vote

You don’t think the timing and placement is odd? I think for his first post and the second vote on your wagon, it doesn’t look good at all.

i am of the opinion that between hammer, tinky fucking winky, and Plat, one or 2 are scum.

 

[Hero]

Is there a way to search posts in chronological order? Why tf is it ordered random lmao

Tryna figure out why this Didi bandwagon happened

I quoted it and everyone ignored it.

 

[Yo Tan Wa]

Oh btw I don't have really strong scum reads do far.
Only person i'm iffy on by myself do far is Prof with that whole PR thing. Kinda reminds me him acting as Hohenheim in FMA game. Idk.
I disagree with Ratchet on his voting idea but it doesn't necessary mean he can't be town.
Could go with WJ based on Franky vote and liking Kira's ISO.
Linda is just indie imo. His defense against Ratchet made sense though. Maybe non-hostile. Tbh, he should just claim if he's indie imo. Like there's no way he's mafia.

People i'd town lean (i don't town read anyone tbh) would be SK, Lalisa, Nat, Kira, Hero... And that's it probably.

I have no idea what to think about Didi.

Nothing really based on my TMI. I can't use any abilities before night anyway

Why'd neutral or a pro town Indie Lind refuse being an Indie so many times? I think he's just town here. if Indie not going to be a good one i believe. Based on his posts he make sense to me so leaning townie so far,

Can i get detailed post why you town reading these, if they are gut feels just point what you liked.

 

[SinRaven]

Lot of hedgy wording here

[Vote Lynch Didi]

Lmao wpk lynching Didi for saying "so far" "maybe" and "but"??

Is this what mafia has come to lmao

 

[Didi]

what is your opinion of hammer/tinky winky/plat


You don’t think the timing and placement is odd? I think for his first post and the second vote on your wagon, it doesn’t look good at all.

i am of the opinion that between hammer, tinky fucking winky, and Plat, one or 2 are scum.

I think it looks bad if he doesn't change his vote, yes
but I expect him to change


Like if for instance Jojo was in this game my first post would've also been a vote on Jojo, before even reading the thread most likely so could've also been a second vote on a wagon then without my intention
if you get what I mean

 

[SinRaven]

How did you make this mistake

I think this is the first Vite for Didi I found starting where I left off yesterday and from memory of the previous pages. Not entirely suspicious but it is a random vote dressed up in a lighthearted attitude imo that dissociates from an agenda.

He was my submission I believe. I don’t remember. @Shizune shot down a lot of my entries so idk who actually got in

[Vote Lynch Platinum]

Is this your first post in the game? And your first post is also a vote upon Didi?

Clearly you’ve been reading the thread closely enough to place an unsubstantiated 2nd vote on Didi when the principal one was a “joke”

Not us arguing about semantics

And this is Didi’s 3rd vote out of 4. I’ll continue reading but these things glaringly stood out to me and I couldn’t go any further without posting them.

LMAO these votes are WILD but I guess that's normal for a random D1 bandwagon

Honestly so far I think people are maybe looking too much into this random ass bandwagon

 

[jinri]

You gonna go with someone with no posts?

They have 6 posts but go off. They're in the "not low enough to be in the elimination but enough to coast" territory.

Yeah might just be you actually

What are your skoom reads among the actives?

Vote me up then.

I noticed that you totally avoided answering me when I asked the same thing. When you answer me, I may answer you.

 

[Hero]

LMAO these votes are WILD but I guess that's normal for a random D1 bandwagon

Honestly so far I think people are maybe looking too much into this random ass bandwagon

So you don’t think scum would have tried to hop somewhere on this bandwagon? Imo it’s the only lead we have.

how many votes does Didi have now? Who is in the lead? @Shizune @Kvothe Kingkiller

 

[Didi]

So you don’t think scum would have tried to hop somewhere on this bandwagon? Imo it’s the only lead we have.

how many votes does Didi have now? Who is in the lead? @Shizune @Kvothe Kingkiller

p sure I am in the lead

though the vote that Xadlin tried to pull on me might not count cuz they messed up the formatting

 

[Nessos]

Lmao wpk lynching Didi for saying "so far" "maybe" and "but"?

Sounds like a good reasoning

 

[Oddjutsu]

I myself was inclined to see Plat's vote on me as just a friendly jab between old friends, not a real vote

Any thoughts on you being the only one to show up in the vote count?

 

[Didi]

Any thoughts on you being the only one to show up in the vote count?

bit odd
has nothing to do with my own role at least

Sounds like a good reasoning

damn you bird

 

[SinRaven]

So you don’t think scum would have tried to hop somewhere on this bandwagon? Imo it’s the only lead we have.

how many votes does Didi have now? Who is in the lead? @Shizune @Kvothe Kingkiller

I mean maybe probably, but also Didi could be scum so maybe not

I don't think any of those votes look too suspicious for d1

 

[Didi]

I mean maybe probably, but also Didi could be scum

 

[Hero]

I could be tunneling the idea that Didi is town, but I’m willing to die on that hill.

Lind - town lean, Ratchet - town, Mr. Professor - town af are my biggest town reads.

I’m also willing to die on the hill that Tinky god damn winky, fucking hammer, and Plat are mafia. One or two of them bitches

 

[Nessos]

damn you bird

Who looks worse for you ScumRaven or WPnoFangsK?

 

[Oddjutsu]

I wonder is Didi is already lynched and we're talking to a dead man

 

[Hero]

I have no opinion on Lalisa. They’ve posted a lot but I couldn’t tell you a damn thing they’ve said.

I also find usopp so oddly quiet and no one seems to care. I guess I haven’t played here in a while and y’all reeled his tinfoiling in?

 

[Hero]

I also feel like I’m talking to myself and no one is taking me seriously bc I’m Hero the inactifag

 

[Firestormer]

Using Trump gifs in 2022 the year of our lord? Maybe the voters had a point

Also I am willing to vote one of those bandwagoners, so I'll vote the one whose vote was the weirdest to me:

[Change vote lynch hammer]

 

[Didi]

Who looks worse for you ScumRaven or WPnoFangsK?

Scumraven

WPK has voted me over silly hunches before

I wonder is Didi is already lynched and we're talking to a dead man

take your meds odd

 

[Oddjutsu]

I also feel like I’m talking to myself and no one is taking me seriously bc I’m Hero the inactifag

Don't think that

 

[Hero]

Also @Juan how do you have more posts than me. Wtf have you said

 

[Oddjutsu]

Scumraven

WPK has voted me over silly hunches before

take your meds odd

Hey man, if I'm right and votes against other people don't count then you're kind of fucked here

 

[Nessos]

Hey man, if I'm right and votes against other people don't count then you're kind of fucked here

Did I muss something?

 

[Firestormer]

I think you're reading into a vote count too much, they likely just didn't want to bother checking every vote over the majority number.

If votes for everyone except the target truly don't count though, lol. Sure way to make posting feel pointless and kill a game immediately, so I am gonna assume this host is competent.