Game Members Mafia 4 (indies win!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
RemChu said:
@Santí your list from yesterday, I was light red the day before. Has your read of me changed that much in one day. I'm dark red now? You do know regardless of alignment I would have the same posting tendencies and quirks as a player. Trying to use that as a confirmation bias to say I'm scum is rather, .... lazy. Think about that.


Who's your second strongest scum read and why. That's what I care about.
Click to expand...

I won't deny that it's lazy, but it's the best to go off of right now and I haven't yet read enough from you to give me reason to doubt my gut.

I still have a good deal of the dayphase left, but besides you I'm also not liking Hayumi.
 
Nice going town. I’m literally gone for like 12 hours and I’m now the leading wagon. Put me out of my misery is all I have to say. Nobody’s avoiding anything, when they WEREN'T EVEN READING THE THREAD FOR 12 WHOLE HOURS. If I’m lynched, just know that when I flip town all the people joining in because I was ahead on votes aren’t even trying to be low key about their scumminess. What the actual fuck.

:jerrykek
 
Owner Of A Lonely Heart said:
oof [change vote lynch Go D. Usopp]

The difference here is that you are still technically new. Or roughly how many games have you played? I need to know how new you are in order to gauge if your newness can override the tell. New players are prone to be scummier as they don't necessarily know the "culture?" of what makes town -> town and what makes mafia -> mafia etc. Or as mafia, there are things you should and should not do, but you more or less find that out through experience. Guides can help sometimes, but being in a game really matters for developing your style of play.

But the "interesting" tell is more a me thing than someone else, so you wouldn't necessarily learn about this sort of thing, unless you've played with me before.
Click to expand...
I dont think guy is new btw he has couple of games under his belt.

Eitherway what made you realise from single post when he just fluffed about their possible roles ?
 
RemChu said:
Experience? Do you think mafia would let town control the narrative solely?
That's a losing strategy if the townies can spot each other and have a good nose for scum.
Click to expand...
My possibility is that player with experience of good scum play can top the list.

Rest of em will try to blend the game by posting min req . John wayne was classic example people caught him scumming on day 1 with laix role .

80 percent of time in this format of game they will fake claim on their mechanical ability .
 
Aragorn said:
My possibility is that player with experience of good scum play can top the list.

Rest of em will try to blend the game by posting min req . John wayne was classic example people caught him scumming on day 1 with laix role .

80 percent of time in this format of game they will fake claim on their mechanical ability .
Click to expand...

Most of the players here are experienced. I always expect 1 mafia in the top posters. The face of the mafia team.
 
Hayumi said:
Nice going town. I’m literally gone for like 12 hours and I’m now the leading wagon. Put me out of my misery is all I have to say. Nobody’s avoiding anything, when they WEREN'T EVEN READING THE THREAD FOR 12 WHOLE HOURS. If I’m lynched, just know that when I flip town all the people joining in because I was ahead on votes aren’t even trying to be low key about their scumminess. What the actual fuck.

:jerrykek
Click to expand...

full claim
role, name, abilities, actions taken
and maybe ill vote melodie instead

this is a completely useless post otherwise
 
Hayumi said:
Nice going town. I’m literally gone for like 12 hours and I’m now the leading wagon. Put me out of my misery is all I have to say. Nobody’s avoiding anything, when they WEREN'T EVEN READING THE THREAD FOR 12 WHOLE HOURS. If I’m lynched, just know that when I flip town all the people joining in because I was ahead on votes aren’t even trying to be low key about their scumminess. What the actual fuck.

:jerrykek
Click to expand...
Sure this will make people change their minds :caticon
 
Broadcast message:

And again I ask. Where are the people that say a claimed Indie (Jojo) is a better lynch than somebody who...given his reaction...has a high chance of being Town? Somehow I can't shake the feeling that this is 1) because no scum is in danger (which makes me really suspicious of Badalight who was the leading wagon before the JW lynch) or 2) because Jojo is part of the scum team.


Pick your guess.
Click to expand...
 
Broadcast message:

Again, why so defensive? You come out right after being called out and only comment on Jojo instead of answering the question. W h y s o d e f e n s i v e? And her claim didn't seem like a lie to me, so I don't see how assuming she was not lying makes somebody dense, especially since I have no idea how Jojo plays as we only played a single game together. So there is that.
Click to expand...
 
nfcnorth said:
@Aragorn which of the top posters do you like the most and which do you like the least?
Click to expand...
Yea i am coming to do that

Remchu - scumhunting the game , overall not a positive reads on him with his hard tming from last post.

Iwan - He is active player irrespective of town but i have iwan is prone to mistake when he is town.

Leaning town on him from his last few posts he made. Town iwan is far more productive , he would go for a claim if he is in danger of getting lynched.

DDL - Didnt like their nataly and natalijia stuff he was using to create scenrios on players. Overall his play reminds me of his towny action in gg3.
 
Aragorn said:
Also this post is continuation of my last post , its either his lynch seems like "let lynch nvm but oh they are roleblocked " .

Nessos you are not coming clean on this dude.
Click to expand...
Oh, off topic here Fallen Prince, but I wanted to make this post earlier. Hopefully you don't think too badly of Juan, he's not malicious in the slightest, and I don't know what your issue with TMF is, but you're more than welcome to come join us to play Mafia there if you so wish.
 
@Owner Of A Lonely Heart : You get called out for not doing your normal style of play...then spend the rest of day 2 pointing out things you should have FoS'd d1 within your style. You're slipping under the radar Ooh La La, but your stank can't escape this nose :

tumblr_mn4px4yYBd1rdytaco1_250.gifv
 
Hayumi said:
They probably thought I was town acting scummy.


:robotkun
Click to expand...
Same can also be said of those pushing against your lynch, in order to hopefully gain credit when you do flip town (or so they thought). Isn't that right, @Flower? :^)

Scumdesu said:
Precisely.
My plays have nothing to do with alingment
They never do.
My "meta" says much more about my ability sheet than about my alignment
Click to expand...
So how is that an argument against your lynch?
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
Back
Top