Game Members Mafia 4 (indies win!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
Ratchet said:
I see reason. It provides some discussion to start the game off with, and the role is *likely* town, so can help to shorten the lynch pool immediately.
Click to expand...

I agree.

is a said:
wouldnt a baseline discussion on the role being town or scum be sufficient enough to initiate discussion rather than going to the lengths of searching for the individual behind it :kannasip
Click to expand...

We don't necessarily need to look for the individual, but we could start discussing possible roles that it would fit with.
 
RemChu said:
Like you can read my first post or third post in git gud mafia pm and see I was not confident.
My vote on AM was also stupid and performed under pressure when you said "Are you not okay with being the final nail in the coffin?"

How does any of that scream confidence. My play was anything but confident in the thread, it was just haphazard. The fact you can't see that is kind of concerning. Very weak scum mask I had in that game.

So guessing you are scum looking for an easy push on me this game. Since you are putting min effort in that push there. @Cooler

I'm up in arms because I'm hunting mafia. If you are scum I'm coming for your neck. Just giving me a whiff of a reason to approach you is enough. This is called hunting and you are the prey.
Click to expand...
Hardcore omugusing :hmm
 
FWIW Rem seems town to me


Scumdesu said:
Hmmm
Im not sure how you could have answered to my post in a more suspicious way lol
Click to expand...

I can think of at least 3 ways.

Hayumi said:
Also y’all this is off topic but I just went through the player list out of curiosity and checked who posted, and the broadcaster person has to be either Babby, Nevan or Flower.
Click to expand...

What's your reasoning behind this? It's a bit hard for me to make those connections since I only play like one game a year, but my initial feeling was Laix or maybe someone who hosts a lot (Iwan, Santi, ...?)
 
Badalight said:
FWIW Rem seems town to me




I can think of at least 3 ways.



What's your reasoning behind this? It's a bit hard for me to make those connections since I only play like one game a year, but my initial feeling was Laix or maybe someone who hosts a lot (Iwan, Santi, ...?)
Click to expand...
I was going off the assumption that the broadcaster can’t use regular posting format but I could be wrong.

:distracted

If I’m right tho, it could only be one of the three I listed.
 
Hayumi said:
I wouldn’t be surprised at all tbf. He always seems scummy to me tho so I can’t really talk.


But then again...he’s usually scum.


:doggokek
Click to expand...

I'll start toasting him later and see how he reacts, but I don't think he's scum this game

However I also do genuinely believe RemChu to be town now

Badalight said:
What's your reasoning behind this? It's a bit hard for me to make those connections since I only play like one game a year, but my initial feeling was Laix or maybe someone who hosts a lot (Iwan, Santi, ...?)
Click to expand...

We've all posted

It's probably Flower as she's the only active player who hasn't posted yet
 
Laix said:
I'll start toasting him later and see how he reacts, but I don't think he's scum this game

However I also do genuinely believe RemChu to be town now



We've all posted

It's probably Flower as she's the only active player who hasn't posted yet
Click to expand...

Sorry, I was talking about the roles, not the players.

Nitty is a masochist if they made a role that could only communicate through announcements.
 
Laix said:
Either way, there's not much value in trying to figure out who the broadcaster is as they are 99.9% most likely to be town. Abilities to communicate via the thread are usually one-shots when scum abilities.

Really, the only discussion to have atm is do people want to hang Cooler or RemChu?
Click to expand...

I agree that it's more than likely a town role, especially if we are assuming it's a posting restriction. It might still be beneficial to know what role is doing it though, but yeah I don't think we should necessarily be trying to figure out the person with the role.
 
Badalight said:
I agree that it's more than likely a town role, especially if we are assuming it's a posting restriction. It might still be beneficial to know what role is doing it though, but yeah I don't think we should necessarily be trying to figure out the person with the role.
Click to expand...

Well actually, the OP says:

7. Role revealing is allowed, but not recommended.
Click to expand...

Considering we will very quickly deduce who the broadcaster is since they wouldn't have posted yet not be modkilled, trying to figure out exactly what their role is only benefits scum, and I'm going to be side-eyeing anyone who seems really eager to know what role they are.
 
Laix said:
Well actually, the OP says:



Considering we will very quickly deduce who the broadcaster is since they wouldn't have posted yet not be modkilled, trying to figure out exactly what their role is only benefits scum, and I'm going to be side-eyeing anyone who seems really eager to know what role they are.
Click to expand...

That's a good point if in fact the role has a posting restriction. But you're right, we may have pushed this as far as we should for the moment. Let's put it on hold til the remaining players do or don't post.
 
I was only pointing out who the player itself could be out of my own pure interest, not to like hunt them out or anything. Discussing what their actually role might be is just open role fishing in a game that may punish role revealing.


:jerrykek


By the way, I got a private message from the broadcaster saying “I’m not Flower” just remembered lmao. Not sure if they’re lying or not but it wouldn’t surprise me with her paranoid ass
 
Hayumi said:
I was only pointing out who the player itself could be out of my own pure interest, not to like hunt them out or anything. Discussing what their actually role might be is just open role fishing in a game that may punish role revealing.


:jerrykek


By the way, I got a private message from the broadcaster saying “I’m not Flower” just remembered lmao. Not sure if they’re lying or not but it wouldn’t surprise me with her paranoid ass
Click to expand...
What if it is Flower and they are trying to confuse you :harley
 
RemChu said:
HOLY SHIT IWANDESU

I WILL STRANGLE STOP DOING THAT.

JUST BULK QUOTE ME AND POST YOUR FUCKING THOUGHTS BRO.
Click to expand...
RemChu said:
Tired of it. Just fucking shoot him. -_-
Click to expand...
Good you are melting SOOO hard im actually getting curious
I dont think you would do this as mafia
Could you be the indie ?
Is that why you were asking "hmm i wonder if there are any indies ?"
 
RemChu said:
Holy shit.
Click to expand...
What
RemChu said:
catch up meta, quote 1 post.
add 1 liner.

nah fam. Get to the point this ain't a brainstorming session. Speak if you have something to say.
Click to expand...
Do
RemChu said:
Tired of it. Just fucking shoot him. -_-
Click to expand...
You
RemChu said:
That shit triggers me.
Click to expand...
Mean
RemChu said:
You should go back and read the game from the start. Most of all the posts have been friendly one liners, so it's not hard. Thank you. It'll take you like four minutes to catch up.

Do. not. quote. every. post.
Click to expand...
:blush
 
Anyway
So far
Townish reads

Laix- looks solid so far
Flower (just because i think she is the brodcaster and seems like an unlikely scum role, this is a nitty game tho)


Null/should be looked at (maybe gonna do an iso or something)
DDL (lets see how he plays out)
Melodie (danger girl)
Is a (he usually coasts as scum but the truth is that he is good enough to fake such meta)
Lord Genome (again, lord genome is a good town and a monstruos scum)

Null/scummy
Cooler(tipical day 1 coasting of his, got remchu on his tracks so lets see how this plays)
Bada- Liked some of his posts, disliked others but nothing extraordinary so far,

Scummy reads
Remchu (he could do everything he is doing as town tho)
 
Scumdesu said:
Anyway
So far
Townish reads

Laix- looks solid so far
Flower (just because i think she is the brodcaster and seems like an unlikely scum role, this is a nitty game tho)


Null/should be looked at (maybe gonna do an iso or something)
DDL (lets see how he plays out)
Melodie (danger girl)
Is a (he usually coasts as scum but the truth is that he is good enough to fake such meta)
Lord Genome (again, lord genome is a good town and a monstruos scum)

Null/scummy
Cooler(tipical day 1 coasting of his, got remchu on his tracks so lets see how this plays)
Bada- Liked some of his posts, disliked others but nothing extraordinary so far,

Scummy reads
Remchu (he could do everything he is doing as town tho)
Click to expand...
So you have no read on me yet- I have feelings Iwan.


:catshivers
 
RemChu said:
90% chance he is GODFATHER, CULTIST, OR HOSTILE INDIE.
[VOTE LYNCH IS A]

If you think otherwise, debate me.
-He will not be active and so will add nothing to scum hunting.
-People if he is scum will protect him.
-if he is scum he will provide empty reads.

Good day 1 lynch.
Click to expand...

I could debate but I don't see an argument in this post to debate against.

He is scum because...?
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
Back
Top