Game Members Mafia 4 (indies win!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
Go D. Usopp said:
thats what we r doing

going bk to analyzing posts lol

can you explain nessos's quietness in this case? do u urself have any take on whats happening, because there is no way u make ppl just move on like that lol

ur post just makes it worst and now ppl will play more attention to it imo lol
Click to expand...

The problem is that you people are doing nothing but analyse every little possible role interaction, which you can't possibly guess right, when you could be talking about the players themselves.

We all thought Nessos looked town yesterday. I agreed with that. LG hasn't really been looking town. I agree with that. I think h's the better lynch. If Iwasn't voting Ratchet already.
 
Go D. Usopp said:
thats what we r doing

going bk to analyzing posts lol

can you explain nessos's quietness in this case? do u urself have any take on whats happening, because there is no way u make ppl just move on like that lol

ur post just makes it worst and now ppl will play more attention to it imo lol
Click to expand...
That's not how we should vote this DP either since split wagons jeopardize the player that gives voting power. His post coming right after I said that seems like he wants to lure out the vote gifter.
 
Go D. Usopp said:
thats what we r doing

going bk to analyzing posts lol

can you explain nessos's quietness in this case? do u urself have any take on whats happening, because there is no way u make ppl just move on like that lol

ur post just makes it worst and now ppl will play more attention to it imo lol
Click to expand...
That's not how we should vote this DP either since split wagons jeopardize the player that gives voting power. His post coming right after I said that seems like he wants to lure out the vote gifter.
 
Dragon D. Luffy said:
Hayumi def edited it.

And I'm thinking there was an indie claim from Santi I didn't see.
Click to expand...

well he didn't claim idnie, he just said im outed or smthing like that

could be referring to him outing himself as vig

more importantly why is hayumi changing indie to vig ?? @Hayumi

u r currently legend's role which could very well be an afk scum, so ur naturally high on the sus list xd
 
SinRaven said:
Can we just lynch Ratchet instead? There is already kinda incriminating evidence against him with the RemChu/DDL thing and I'm feeling his lynch way more than anyone else's. Dont like how he basically just came in to vote Aragorn on the second lynch wagon and then left again.

He's never trying to be apart of actual conversation.
Click to expand...
Can you explain the Ratchet/DDL thing.
For now I would still prefer to lynch LG.

Btw how do you think about Aragorn?
I mean there are 2 lynches.

[Vote lynch LG]
 
Dragon D. Luffy said:
Ok if @Santi's claim is of an indie one I wanna give him the time to prove himself.

Maybe vig Remchu since so much of this is based on Rem's claim.
Click to expand...
I just haven’t liked the tone of santi’s post in general when reading over them. He’s a vig, yet won’t read over at least some of the game to catch up and get his own reads? He instead is relying on others to give him random names to “kill” (if he’s telling the truth) when they could be scum/ he could be getting influenced by scum unknowingly.
 
Go D. Usopp said:
well he didn't claim idnie, he just said im outed or smthing like that

could be referring to him outing himself as vig

more importantly why is hayumi changing indie to vig ?? @Hayumi

u r currently legend's role which could very well be an afk scum, so ur naturally high on the sus list xd
Click to expand...
Understandable. I’ve seen you bring me up multiple times due to the Legend situation, but I’m definitely not scum. If anything, if I was an outsider looking in, I’d have a town read on me right now, since Legend was inactive, and that’s usually a sign of being unbothered and not really caring about seeming suspicious. Also an easy target for a vig (if it was a vig that killed him) since he didn’t contribute anything and was most likely town.
 
Badalight said:
No because the circumstances are completely different.
Click to expand...
Not at all. Because that player needs a lot of Townies to vote for the same player today to not draw too much attention to themselves. And factually, that player even asked me to reveal that because they saw that many people don't bother voting. Stop playing the concerned Townie card, this is not working.
 
Badalight said:
Flower is talking about somebody else. My point was there was zero reason to reveal that to the thread because it does nothing to change how we approach this lynch. It only gives mafia info that they previously didn't have.
Click to expand...

not rly

its the same as ur reveal tbh

actually it works better for us cuz it will now make the lynch more threatening so the mafia would have to react and start getting more active to defend themselves.

flower didn't reveal the person so its fine
 
Hayumi said:
Understandable. I’ve seen you bring me up multiple times due to the Legend situation, but I’m definitely not scum. If anything, if I was an outsider looking in, I’d have a town read on me right now, since Legend was inactive, and that’s usually a sign of being unbothered and not really caring about seeming suspicious. Also an easy target for a vig (if it was a vig that killed him) since he didn’t contribute anything and was most likely town.
Click to expand...

he was 100% not killed by a town vig i can tell u that much

cuz the prio order in kills is mafia/indie > town
 
Nessos said:
Can you explain the Ratchet/DDL thing.
For now I would still prefer to lynch LG.

Btw how do you think about Aragorn?
I mean there are 2 lynches.

[Vote lynch LG]
Click to expand...
I feel like @Dragon D. Luffy can explain it better. Short: RemChu claimed to have blocked a lot of people, DDL states his ability would let him know if townies have blocked townies (after 3 blocks), so the people who RemChu blocked must most be scum. Those people are Santi, Ratchet, Juan, Karma and Owner.

I thought Aragorn was supicious before this phase but I was inclined to believe him after he revealed his abilities (tho I already forgot what he revealed x) )
 
Hayumi said:
Interesting. So you think that makes me more suspicious because? And what makes you feel like there was any indicator Legend was inactive scum. And, in my experience, being inactive usually indicates the opposite.
Click to expand...

thats what I used to think too, but on the super smash mafia, like half of scum were inactive at the start.

I'm not gna waste time speculating into it tho, but legend is killed by mafia or indie. reasons unknown.

But if you ask me, unless its part of an indie's wincon, its weird asfk for mafia/indie to kill inactive townies. Dont u agree?
 
Go D. Usopp said:
thats what I used to think too, but on the super smash mafia, like half of scum were inactive at the start.

I'm not gna waste time speculating into it tho, but legend is killed by mafia or indie. reasons unknown.

But if you ask me, unless its part of an indie's wincon, its weird asfk for mafia/indie to kill inactive townies. Dont u agree?
Click to expand...
Mafia maybe, indie no. Especially if we’re going off of your own logic. Maybe because Legend WAS inactive, they were hoping to get some type of scum. Same thing would have applied for any of the other inactives as well.

If you keep bringing it up tho, but won’t waste time speculating into it, then try to read me based off my actual posts if nothing else. Otherwise going off the small change legend was inactive scum, and thus I have a scum role by default even though you really have no idea, is a bad angle.
 
Go D. Usopp said:
thats what I used to think too, but on the super smash mafia, like half of scum were inactive at the start.

I'm not gna waste time speculating into it tho, but legend is killed by mafia or indie. reasons unknown.

But if you ask me, unless its part of an indie's wincon, its weird asfk for mafia/indie to kill inactive townies. Dont u agree?
Click to expand...
Hayumi's role would be the first person killed in the night. So Legend was the first to be killed and considering indie/mafia kills happen before other kills in this game, it seems more likely for Hayumi to be town than the other options.
 
SinRaven said:
I feel like @Dragon D. Luffy can explain it better. Short: RemChu claimed to have blocked a lot of people, DDL states his ability would let him know if townies have blocked townies (after 3 blocks), so the people who RemChu blocked must most be scum. Those people are Santi, Ratchet, Juan, Karma and Owner.

I thought Aragorn was supicious before this phase but I was inclined to believe him after he revealed his abilities (tho I already forgot what he revealed x) )
Click to expand...

Realistically it only takes one of them to flip to prove it

Ideally not Santi since he claimed indie
 
Hayumi said:
Mafia maybe, indie no. Especially if we’re going off of your own logic. Maybe because Legend WAS inactive, they were hoping to get some type of scum. Same thing would have applied for any of the other inactives as well.

If you keep bringing it up tho, but won’t waste time speculating into it, then try to read me based off my actual posts if nothing else. Otherwise going off the small change legend was inactive scum, and thus I have a scum role by default even though you really have no idea, is a bad angle.
Click to expand...

it could be an indie whose win con is to eliminate inactive players, or an SK, or w.e. I like to eliminate inactive players, so wouldn't doubt if that's my namesake role if its an indie.

But yea, I am not going to spend more time on it cuz I already said all I have. You're the one who brought it back up btw xd. Your other posts seem ok for now.

SinRaven said:
Hayumi's role would be the first person killed in the night. So Legend was the first to be killed and considering indie/mafia kills happen before other kills in this game, it seems more likely for Hayumi to be town than the other options.
Click to expand...

its not too far fetched for mafia to kill maifa for a replacement, specially after hayumi (melodie) was revealed to be able to take the role of the next death.

but like u said it could be mafia killing inactive townies for sm reason, or an indie killing in actives again for some unknown reason. I find it just weird that in actives get targetted by mafia/indies tbh. There has to be some stronger reason imo, that's all.
 
SinRaven said:
Tbh I dont like how @Go D. Usopp has been acting this phase. Seems like hes trying to exert more influence. He feels sly and manipulative in some posts. He's basically pitting everyone against everyone?
Click to expand...

well ive been away the entire d2 so ur only seeing me now or on d1 xd

my scum reads on d1 were on WAD, melkor, hero, and nessos

i came after 500 posts of day 2, did some skimming, and i think WAD, melkor and nessos are more town lean.

today its been mostly LG, hayumi, nat, nfc, and maybe hero still. I missed the stuff with ratchet
 
Go D. Usopp said:
it could be an indie whose win con is to eliminate inactive players, or an SK, or w.e. I like to eliminate inactive players, so wouldn't doubt if that's my namesake role if its an indie.

But yea, I am not going to spend more time on it cuz I already said all I have. You're the one who brought it back up btw xd. Your other posts seem ok for now.



its not too far fetched for mafia to kill maifa for a replacement, specially after hayumi (melodie) was revealed to be able to take the role of the next death.

but like u said it could be mafia killing inactive townies for sm reason, or an indie killing in actives again for some unknown reason. I find it just weird that in actives get targetted by mafia/indies tbh. There has to be some stronger reason imo, that's all.
Click to expand...
I agree it could be an indie with said wincon, but the reason I brought it back up was because I’ve seen you mention something similarly about me “probably” being scum, since Legend could have been inactive scum, multiple times, so I wanted to talk to you about it directly. In my honest opinion it seemed like you’re reaching for low hanging fruit when you bring it up. Because like I said, it could go both ways in regard to if it was an indie/mafia or town that killed Legend, and there’s less evidence he was scum then town based off being an inactive (to me).

And even if you see it the other way, which you seem to, that also gives reason for what you’re acting confused about, being the reason for why the killer would target Legend, because maybe they also thought he was inactive scum, and were hoping to get rid of another potential threat. If it was an indie/SK they wouldn’t even need something in their wincon for a valid reason to pick Legend as their target. See how it seems like you’re almost angle shooting based off one “what if”?
 
Hayumi said:
I agree it could be an indie with said wincon, but the reason I brought it back up was because I’ve seen you mention something similarly about me “probably” being scum, since Legend could have been inactive scum, multiple times, so I wanted to talk to you about it directly. In my honest opinion it seemed like you’re reaching for low hanging fruit when you bring it up. Because like I said, it could go both ways in regard to if it was an indie/mafia or town that killed Legend, and there’s less evidence he was scum then town based off being an inactive (to me).

And even if you see it the other way, which you seem to, that also gives reason for what you’re acting confused about, being the reason for why the killer would target Legend, because maybe they also thought he was inactive scum, and were hoping to get rid of another potential threat. If it was an indie/SK they wouldn’t even need something in their wincon for a valid reason to pick Legend as their target. See how it seems like you’re almost angle shooting based off one “what if”?
Click to expand...

thats y im not voting u and ur not on any prio list lol

because nothing is confirmed, its just a speculation. But you should agree with me that, regardless of the killer, killing someone with less than 10 post count is interesting isnt it?

if what im thinking is correct it likely wont happen again, unless for some indie reasons against inactives lol.

you dont have to act like ur targeted by anything, there is none rly voting or hard susing u rn so take it ez xd
 
Go D. Usopp said:
thats y im not voting u and ur not on any prio list lol

because nothing is confirmed, its just a speculation. But you should agree with me that, regardless of the killer, killing someone with less than 10 post count is interesting isnt it?

if what im thinking is correct it likely wont happen again, unless for some indie reasons against inactives lol.

you dont have to act like ur targeted by anything, there is none rly voting or hard susing u rn so take it ez xd
Click to expand...
I don’t feel targeted, but I wanted to talk to you about it and hear your full take on it. I disagree but at least I understand your thought process now.

:zaru
 
Cooler said:
Why lynch 1?
Click to expand...

because:
The game has been occupied and divided by an invading force. There will now be 2 lynches each day, but each player may only participate in 1 lynch. To vote in the first lynch, you will use the normal [vote lynch] command. To participate in the second lynch, you will use [vote lynch 2]. At the end of the day, your most recently cast vote will be considered your final vote, and that is the lynch you will be considered to be part of. If you have any questions, please ask the host for clarification.
Click to expand...
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
Back
Top