Shizune
Broadcast message:
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
I thought we was lynching LGI townread RemChu so can't support his lynch. It's between you, LG and maybe LM for me.
You actually wanting to match your votes to your reads is so weird.
I'm reading you town now.
... Psychic, is that you?
Null on all
Ok so Hayumi is slight scummy tbh feels like hes mistly just memeing. I think hes the kind of player who does that normally?
Owner is saying some stuff I agree with but not THAT much. I'm also missing her unique reading methods such as analysing emoji choice and stuff like that, which she tends to do as town.
Kira is a blur. I think he barely played at all.
Wouldn't mind seeing any of the 3 lynched but not super into either of them.
Shizune
Broadcast message:
@DDL what are your current thoughts on each player? Feel like you're just kinda there. Just pointing that out because last game we played you had such a strong presence, but now...huh...
Shizune
Broadcast message:
Also, not going to push against Nessos or anything because 1) this never ends well with us and 2) he might really just be busy, but just meeting the post requirement and not being active much is weak. I hope he contributes more than that. He usually has good reads as Town and can be a strong asset if he puts his mind to that.
Don't tell him who I am and that I said that
Guess it wasn't saved in the forms on that one.
but last one is Town read on DDL for one reason only.
His reaction to me jokingly saying we can tango tonight was very raw and genuine. "Kill me and see what happens I'll humiliate you for it!"
I don't hate him btw. Just an inherent bias I have for targeting him in the past. No offense meant but I can see why he has those buried feelings and hostility towards me. I like him a lot though.
I almost rated you friendly for this and I can see where you are coming from, but you keep acting like you are superior which is so off-putting. I think I'll just keep distance from you from now on.
Flower it's unfair to call me out on not imitating my meta from last game cuz when I did that I played a big part in causing town to lose.
And then on the next day phase I changed to a more passive playstyle and started doing so much better.
I am better at this game when I'm not hyperconfident and just second guess myself.
Anyway I've been posting my reads left and right. I wanna lynch Cooler. Nobody seems to agree which sucks cuz there was a wagon for him early.
And then on the next day phase I changed to a more passive playstyle and started doing so much better.
I am better at this game when I'm not hyperconfident and just second guess myself.
Anyway I've been posting my reads left and right. I wanna lynch Cooler. Nobody seems to agree which sucks cuz there was a wagon for him early.
Shizune
Broadcast message:
He is very lowkey, most posts seem to be about game mechanics and he kind of vanished after the first half.
I have very little experience with his meta tho. Afaik he only ever plays Favorites.
Could lynch. In fact I might, looking at the tally.
I have very little experience with his meta tho. Afaik he only ever plays Favorites.
Could lynch. In fact I might, looking at the tally.
I also have to agree with the assessment Melodie feels forced. It's not the fact she is doing the iwandesu thing, but town Melo is annoying, she latches on scummy people and calls them out. Fuck, she calls me out on something every single game and hasn't done it here. While here she is mostly repeating other cases and going after every single angle at once.
Shizune
Broadcast message:
SinRaven
SPACED OUT
I'm still up for a Cooler lynch tbh. I was feeling a bit better about him, but there are still some things off about him. I just don't feel him being town most of the time.
Can't vote him tho :/
Shizune
Broadcast message:
@SinRaven.
Shizune
Broadcast message:
Nah, let me be honest, I hate holding grudges. It's just a game. But it's fun having a Nemesis.
Lord Genome
Spiral King
Kvothe
SinRaven
SPACED OUT
Random pick or have you actually been keeping up?
Lord Melkor
Well-Known Member
Not sure about Kvothe, she had some decent points, but she usually is able to fool me as scum.
Worm Juice
Braphog
Why cooler? Missed the whole him being suspicious
Laix
♡
That’s not what I’m doing. It’s just putting pressure on people. People are easier to read when they are responding under the pressure of votes on them.
I also don’t share how I truly feel about people because that would affect my gameplay.
Shizune
Broadcast message:
Laix
♡
I agree. I remember in MMV while she spent a lot of time dead, her scumdar was VERY accurate and she was scum’s worst nightmare, that’s why they spent so much effort killing her.
when she was scum in Faves, she was very low-key and just gave her two cents here and there. She’s probably scum this game tbh but I wouldn’t feel comfortable D1 lynching her as she’s valuable as town
Magic
XIII
Anything I said to you today was purely in jest. Didn't mean to make you upset.
If I don't apologize for past games, it's because for me it's a game. Okay, I made a mistakes but I learn from them and try not to repeat them. I play to win. I'm not going to per say apologize.
If I'm playing and come off arrogant, I don't know man it's a game I'm playing the role of someone seeking the truth and to be a anchor for the team. I only expressed I would find mafia and destroy them. I'm not going to hassle town players and it's all in good fun. Again I'm aware of my own limitations, strengths and weaknesses and it's a team game more or less. I'm not better or worse than anyone.
Like you don't have to avoid me in games. I'm not that cruel.
Laix
♡
This is gonna sound mean but a good Day 1 lynch for me is someone whom, unless they are very quite obviously scum, would be someone whom if they were town it wouldn’t be a huge loss. Mislynching someone who when town is a strong town player is the only kind of mislynch I want to avoid. I’m fine mislynching someone who doesn’t contribute much as town.
Magic
XIII
If I could divine all the scum players I would not need any of you. 
Shizune
Broadcast Message:
Laix
♡
@broadcaster
PM me what kind of gifs you need and I’ll provide
PM me what kind of gifs you need and I’ll provide
Dont think LM is scum tbh. That weird host defense newbie shit would put way too much attention on him. His posts also felt genuine.
Not sure about Melodie, tho. The Iwan role is something I'd expect to be mafia or indie.
Not sure about Melodie, tho. The Iwan role is something I'd expect to be mafia or indie.
Shizune
Broadcast message:
Lord Genome
Spiral King
Laix
♡
@broadcaster
Spoiler:
Laix
♡
@broadcaster
Spoiler:
Cooler is not a rolefag
Nowadays he can be kinda inactive regradless oif alingment
he making zero contributes posts might mean something tho
Laix
♡
@broadcaster
I've given you half my collection so there's no excuse for your announcements to be so... bland now
I've given you half my collection so there's no excuse for your announcements to be so... bland now
This post was not about Cooler tho.
These hoes keep taking up all my free time
Jokes aside, worm juice and Hero are obviously fits on this description
Cooler COULD be a fit but he CAN be good to town if he gets around it
i guess i should actually sleep once in a while
Laix be like Palpatine right now. Teaching Flower of the dark pink side.
Laix
♡
Data dump and analysis
0111000001010101
101001..
....
0101
Town Reads
Announcer strong town.
@Natalija @Owner Of A Lonely Heart I liked their back and forth synergy. Strong town read they also were talking a lot of with @Go D. Usopp Everyone very comfortable.
@Laix very active, town or could be a strong indie? Strong town
@Underworld Broker Her first posts are very comfortable and open, she said stuff I agree with. Same wavelength town read.
@SinRaven night and day difference from our last game where we mafia together. Confident SinRaven here imo.
@Kira Yagami as of late, whenever we play his posts are fire and I can town read him pretty easy now. Town read for now
@WolfPrinceKiba good analysis on DDL ~_~ I thought his rant on me was a bit much but if he had those feelings it's good for him to express it lol. I bully DDL in mafia.
@Worm Juice
is wormjuice ....
Oh on @Owner Of A Lonely Heart The Lie detect thing seems like a big red flag though. Though overall aside from that they read townie to me.
Players who seem uneasy, unsteady to post.
@Melodie
Her opening 2 posts seem very distant.
@Hero
Refuses to provide reasoning for suspicions on players and reasoning in vote. Low activity, bad vibes in general. Super Scummy.
@Juan compared to when he was town and image reaction posting and his godfather play of low activity. He is well in his scum meta right now. Just did easy posts reacting / talking to @Hayumi
no work so far. 60/40 he is town saw that 1 post from him felt kinda genuine. But eh again no activity. He reads apathetic townie eh.
@John Wayne ? IIrc someone said he brought something sus up. Iwan give a read on him too. Eh. I don't read him too well.
@Lord Melkor he is always scummy and he always sus me. Hmmmmm. We are yin and yang. Prob town though. Dummy
Neutral but high value players
Null read on @Scumdesu He is pissing me off. Probably town.
@Badalight My gut distrusts him. Can't tell if it's PTSD from the moon. His posts are very solid and town like though. ~_~ Scum hunting too.
@is a
My first vote on him was done without reading the thread. Metagaming he is a power role or something imo.
But, seeing how he is openly posting early on, it came off more relaxed. Eh.
Like when he's scum kinda a tinge of fakeness to his friendliness. Would like to see some meaty posts from him so he can stay in a null read from now.
@Santí
I suck at reading him. Probably town??
@Ratchet I don't recall him at all.
-------------------------------
The nitty commenting on LM thing, isn't that a role mechanic? Someone mentioned it?
hmmmm
[Vote Lynch Hero]
Hero plays the same as town and scum. He could very much be town, but a mislynch on him wouldn't be the worst thing that could happen to us...
Oh you talking about badalight
@broadcaster
I've given you half my collection so there's no excuse for your announcements to be so... bland now
That's half your collection? Seems like your collection is much smaller than I remember.
Kvothe Kingkiller
Well-Known Member
I was asked about you three for whatever reason from iwan. And at the time, there wasn't much to be said except for that. You barely even posted and if you read the rest of my post, I said I would wait and see. And after some of that, my order is still the same.
Except I am. What about you? I guess after people called you out, you started trying a little more in your iwanwpkdesu style of posting.
Laix
♡
I get a lot of gifs on the fly. My collection is things I have hotkeyed and can use easily from my phone
Laix
♡
Hero doesn't use his abilities much either. In MMV the Godfather was sending all his actions in, and I remember they actually begged him to post at one point so he wouldn't get modblocked
Kvothe Kingkiller
Well-Known Member
Badalight, among the rolefishing that juan iso seems forced and fake too.
There are a number of people who are barely playing.
Lg, Worm Juice, Hero. The usual suspects.
Lynching them is not a bad idea per se. Especially if we can get a lot of people to talk about them as opposing to a last minute lynch with 3 votes.
Vigging them is probably a better idea tho, while lynching someone who is actually interacting with others and being attacked/defended by some. But that depends on us having active, unlocked vigs.
Lg, Worm Juice, Hero. The usual suspects.
Lynching them is not a bad idea per se. Especially if we can get a lot of people to talk about them as opposing to a last minute lynch with 3 votes.
Vigging them is probably a better idea tho, while lynching someone who is actually interacting with others and being attacked/defended by some. But that depends on us having active, unlocked vigs.
Laix
♡
[VOTE LYNCH Badalight]
This will be my final lynch as we approach the end of the phase, unless someone can come up with a convincing alternative argument. While I would prefer an Iwan lynch, Iwan at leasts asks questions and generates discussion so I would feel bad about mislynching him.
This will be my final lynch as we approach the end of the phase, unless someone can come up with a convincing alternative argument. While I would prefer an Iwan lynch, Iwan at leasts asks questions and generates discussion so I would feel bad about mislynching him.
Yes...Hero doesn't use his abilities much either. In MMV the Godfather was sending all his actions in, and I remember they actually begged him to post at one point so he wouldn't get modblocked
Kira Yagami
God
Ratchets been quite lowkey so far, Feel like hes usually a bit more of a tryhard as town
Laix
♡
They are better vig targets. We will lose if we just lynch inactives
Bada Bada kun might get the short end
Magic
XIII
Hey Twitter world@broadcaster
Spoiler:
I mean you are actually right
at the same he is ratchet, day 1ing him is like day1ng melodie or WPK
He can be really useful
Laix
♡
This is my fourth game with Ratchet now and he's usually quite lowkey? In all games he was quiet until he got a breakthrough from an action / interaction and then would put out a good case. He did this in MMV when he scanned Nitty as scum, and in Nitty's WoW game where he sussed Law.
Kvothe Kingkiller
Well-Known Member
ah fuck you james >_> you wanted me to despair in the sandwich game too
Laix
♡
Basically, I don't think him being quiet is out of character and I think anyone picking up on that either doesn't have much experience of his playstyle or is just trying to get an easy scapegoat/seem like they are contributing
Cooler
Well-Known Member
He's not normally this low key no. The times I've seen him so laidback and he's flipped town he had a powerful role. I can't remember his scum meta at all though.
Badalight
JOJO
Lots of notifications, woof.
Are you asking us or the thread? Anyway, obv not gonna say myself and I will never lynch LG so... even in faves when he was enemy mafia GF I didn't want to kill him. I'll look into Kvothe in a bit,
How rude
For the record, I pushed back against the idea that we should be hunting down the player when it was brought up. I was simply trying to connect roles to mechanics in ways that pretty much half of this thread has done (people talked for like two pages of how my namesake role might work). I also don't see how doing that is much different than trying to figure out the role that is making Nitty malfunction over Melkor. The only difference is that some people had already started to catch on to who the announcer was (I hadn't yet) and when that was brought to my attention, I didn't bring it up anymore. I've personally called out multiple people for rolefishing (Go D. Ussopp).
I was reading the thread at the time, so yeah I responded? I'm not sure what "not willing to post" means as I'm around the top 10 most active players in this game. At the time that game had pretty much just started. I woke up, caught up with the thread, and posted.
This is a weird take. How is it reactionary if I offered the information without being prompted? It's also where how you say I'm only there to reply to people when you also quoted multiple instances of me doing exactly the opposite. I have pushed on a few people that others hadn't pressured and I have added input to popular topics of discussion.
Agreed!
Please look at the context of this post. It was a response to everyone else in the thread hunting low activity players. My post is actually a pushback against that idea. My point was that I often do hunt for low activity players when I'm town. However, I was also saying the pressure on WPK was weird since he had a post requirement for the phase. Additionally, the next post of mine you quote is me again talking about how it may not be a good idea to focus on low activity players, yet you label it as mechanical talk.
Also look at the context of this post in full. While I didn't quote anyone, this was in response to Hero's comments about people being quick to believe high activity players. It was also in response to people discussing possible mechanics of my namesake role.
I lost the message where announcer mentioned me, but my response to that: I still don't see the "buddying" that you are implying. I pushed back against Iwan's ideas and put pressures onto him. I was suspicious of Iwan because I had a town read on Rem (I said as much quite early on) and Iwan was putting pressure on Rem. Iwan then makes a post where he was suspicious of Hayumi. I responded by saying that I had a town lean of Hayu and listed my reasonings. After that, Iwan changed his tune and said he also had a town read on Hayu. If anyone was buddying, it was him, not me.
Here are the relevant posts.
Me believing Hayumi after announcer PMs me.
Me saying I think Rem is town.
Iwan with pressure on Hayu.
Me pushing back against Iwan's assertions (this is while I was concerned about his spat with Rem)
Iwan immediately backtracking after my post
So again, if someone was "buddying" it was Iwan.
Are you asking us or the thread? Anyway, obv not gonna say myself and I will never lynch LG so... even in faves when he was enemy mafia GF I didn't want to kill him. I'll look into Kvothe in a bit,
How rude
For the record, I pushed back against the idea that we should be hunting down the player when it was brought up. I was simply trying to connect roles to mechanics in ways that pretty much half of this thread has done (people talked for like two pages of how my namesake role might work). I also don't see how doing that is much different than trying to figure out the role that is making Nitty malfunction over Melkor. The only difference is that some people had already started to catch on to who the announcer was (I hadn't yet) and when that was brought to my attention, I didn't bring it up anymore. I've personally called out multiple people for rolefishing (Go D. Ussopp).
I was reading the thread at the time, so yeah I responded? I'm not sure what "not willing to post" means as I'm around the top 10 most active players in this game. At the time that game had pretty much just started. I woke up, caught up with the thread, and posted.
This is a weird take. How is it reactionary if I offered the information without being prompted? It's also where how you say I'm only there to reply to people when you also quoted multiple instances of me doing exactly the opposite. I have pushed on a few people that others hadn't pressured and I have added input to popular topics of discussion.
Agreed!
Yeah, makes sense, focusing on low activity players is easy points and wouldn't bring much attention or suspicion for a mafia to do, as dealing with inactivity is a good thing that only a townie would pay a lot of attention to.
Please look at the context of this post. It was a response to everyone else in the thread hunting low activity players. My post is actually a pushback against that idea. My point was that I often do hunt for low activity players when I'm town. However, I was also saying the pressure on WPK was weird since he had a post requirement for the phase. Additionally, the next post of mine you quote is me again talking about how it may not be a good idea to focus on low activity players, yet you label it as mechanical talk.
Also look at the context of this post in full. While I didn't quote anyone, this was in response to Hero's comments about people being quick to believe high activity players. It was also in response to people discussing possible mechanics of my namesake role.
I lost the message where announcer mentioned me, but my response to that: I still don't see the "buddying" that you are implying. I pushed back against Iwan's ideas and put pressures onto him. I was suspicious of Iwan because I had a town read on Rem (I said as much quite early on) and Iwan was putting pressure on Rem. Iwan then makes a post where he was suspicious of Hayumi. I responded by saying that I had a town lean of Hayu and listed my reasonings. After that, Iwan changed his tune and said he also had a town read on Hayu. If anyone was buddying, it was him, not me.
Here are the relevant posts.
Me believing Hayumi after announcer PMs me.
Me saying I think Rem is town.
Iwan with pressure on Hayu.
Me pushing back against Iwan's assertions (this is while I was concerned about his spat with Rem)
Iwan immediately backtracking after my post
So again, if someone was "buddying" it was Iwan.
SinRaven
SPACED OUT
Eh I disagree. Dont have a real read on Ratchet yet atm, but the way he's been lowkey posting resorting mostly to one-liners reminds me a LOT of his play in Get Good 3, where he was town.
Some of the stuff he said caught my attention tho, but nothing too incriminating.
Kira Yagami
God
I have played with him plenty, he mostly starts off strong when town imo, this being just your 4th game with him we have different experiences i suppose
Ok imma sheep this
[vote lynch Badalight]
[vote lynch Badalight]
Damn giant Bada post ninja'ing me
Kira Yagami
God
that post felt very unnecessarily accusatory laix, trying to get a reaction? 
Ratchet is always lowkey who is the one pursuing that obvious case
Oh yeah it's Cooler again
Oh yeah it's Cooler again
Cooler
Well-Known Member
You are really underselling my town play here wtf.
Yeah I'm not going to lie these posts mischaracterising both my play this game AND my general play as town has annoyed me.
SinRaven
SPACED OUT
Can we actually just lynch Melodie? Come on, make the dream happen! Make momma proud!
Kira Yagami
God
what even is the case on melodie?
Laix
♡
that post felt very unnecessarily accusatory laix, trying to get a reaction?
Perhaps
Laix
♡
Stop or she's gonna start dissecting Ravens at med school
Cooler
Well-Known Member
Keep tunneling me man. You're turning misrepresenting my posts into an art form. Kira asks if Ratchet is usually low key, I respond and apparently I'm pushing it. GTFO.
I remember many games with Ratchet where he wrote essay like posts and was quite forceful aggressive...
Bada makes a giant post but it's mostly quote-by-quote replies to Melodie's already underwhelming casing.
One of those is scum.
One of those is scum.
SinRaven
SPACED OUT
I have no solid case on her yet, actually, and have been flip flopping in my thoughts on her, but I'll look into her more tonight. I'll always want to see her lynched D1 tho.
Curious as to how you read her though?
Laix
♡
But on Day 1? I've seen that from him too, but not on Day 1.
Either way, he falls into my 'can't afford to mislynch' category so he's not worth pushing right now.
I'm not even voting for you ningen.
I'm merely throwing shit at you in small but constant amounts until the rest of town sees what I'm seeing eventually
Cooler
Well-Known Member
Not saying we should lynch him.
SinRaven
SPACED OUT
Don't worry DDL, I see it tooI'm not even voting for you ningen.
I'm merely throwing shit at you in small but constant amounts until the rest of town sees what I'm seeing eventually
Kira Yagami
God
Hows Santi got 48 posts and i dont recall a single one of substance