Game Favorites '22 - GROUP 2

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
Juan said:
????????

why you asking ME

nitty is the one that fucked up

go get yo host ma'am
Click to expand...
….. Come on, don’t play dumb. You voted Plat, correct? It’s correct.

So you should be eligible for lynch. But unlike the other Plat voters, Nitty says you aren’t. Then some kind of mechanic is in motion, OR it’s about your role.

Do you have any explanation for this?
 
Natalija said:
….. Come on, don’t play dumb. You voted Plat, correct? It’s correct.

So you should be eligible for lynch. But unlike the other Plat voters, Nitty says you aren’t. Then some kind of mechanic is in motion, OR it’s about your role.

Do you have any explanation for this?
Click to expand...
natalija i am BEGGING you to stfu
 
actually after I left, given the pile on on didi last phase
i also want to know why xadlin voted him initially.


I didnt really vote him cause I had much to go off him being scum
he was just bad energy all round at the start of the game.
funny asf some other voters tried to act like they had serious reasons to suspect him tho :hestonpls



Lind and soulkiller out of the question , think those two are town
hero put me in as possible scum so yeah fuck him
 
Baroxio said:
I don't understand your thinking in this instance. I also don't understand the idea that mafia can't change votes last minute, especially when they're likely to be far more organized and aware of potential wagons than regular townies.
Click to expand...
The line of thought is that they would be vulnerable to a lynch in Day 2. Don't love it but it does make sense.

Xadlin said:
I have nothing to offer except for protection. I can rolecrush or protect/shield a set amount of people i choose to.
Im not good at reading people, so thats that.

adn yeah, I think D1 bandwagons are just to splash the water, in order to find out more from others. D2 lynches are more important.
im trying to be more active and post more, yet im not always sure on whom are whom.

I usually go with my role and let people more better at scum hunting to their job. Im a righthand man. unless I have to step up to do a task, i rather wait for those more experenced in doing those task to do those.

Im not scum, and if you lynch me you will see that to, and then town will be towning even more.


I know im on the lynch list, but i ask that yo give me a chance, and choose one of the other ones
Click to expand...
You do seem suspicious, but this write up seems believable.
Theoretically us townies could come together and select one to save. Then you could use your ability to that protect and help out the town.

Also, if you are indeed a townie the mafia would probably kill you, which means we would be wasting a lynch even if the majority wanted to get rid of you. Unfortunate that you got this role... Then again you might be lying and should be lynched.

Overall seems like too much of a hassle to do this, but if you are to be believed your abilities are valuable.
Does anyone knows if a protection has to be mentioned in the write ups?

Hero said:
1. That’s actually incredibly useful but if you’re shit at scum hunting, then your ability probably does more harm than good
Click to expand...
Not if he does what the townies want/vote for. Because the townies are clear majority.
Then again it can get really messy, not sure if it's worth it.
 
Soul said:
The line of thought is that they would be vulnerable to a lynch in Day 2. Don't love it but it does make sense.


You do seem suspicious, but this write up seems believable.
Theoretically us townies could come together and select one to save. Then you could use your ability to that protect and help out the town.

Also, if you are indeed a townie the mafia would probably kill you, which means we would be wasting a lynch even if the majority wanted to get rid of you. Unfortunate that you got this role... Then again you might be lying and should be lynched.

Overall seems like too much of a hassle to do this, but if you are to be believed your abilities are valuable.
Does anyone knows if a protection has to be mentioned in the write ups?


Not if he does what the townies want/vote for. Because the townies are clear majority.
Then again it can get really messy, not sure if it's worth it.
Click to expand...
There's no point in believing Xadlin's claim if he can't even state who he attempted to protect/rolecrush and why. Simply having a protect and/or rolecrush isn't enough to make you town...something he notably never actually claimed to be in that post of his.

He simply alluded to it by saying "town will be towning" if he's lynched (which to me is not the kinda talk a townie should have this early into the game), but he never actually claims to be town in this post.
 
Baroxio said:
There's no point in believing Xadlin's claim if he can't even state who he attempted to protect/rolecrush and why. Simply having a protect and/or rolecrush isn't enough to make you town...something he notably never actually claimed to be in that post of his.

He simply alluded to it by saying "town will be towning" if he's lynched (which to me is not the kinda talk a townie should have this early into the game), but he never actually claims to be town in this post.
Click to expand...
Of course, but he doesn't seem to be here and we aren't even a third of the way through.
I believe that having options is a good thing for the townies, which is why I wrote all that.

If he doesn't do anything to defend himself then suspicion will grow and he will most likely be lynched today.
The risk of jumping the gun is to lynch him when we can lynch someone else that actually is scum. If enough people don't have anyone else that is suspicious then Xadlin should go, but if there's another one you suspect it might be better to get them instead.

Even if he is independent he is useful if he protects townies, and it forces the scum to target him, saving one of us in the process.
Don't have a lot figured out yet since the thread isn't really moving that much. Really thought we would have more by now.

Lynch candidates:

1. @Didi
2. @Hero
3. @Lind
4. @Lord Melkor
5. @SoulKiller
6. @Xadlin ​

Didi and Hero seem fine to me so far.
I don't think that FakeSoul is scum, but boy is he playing weird. That vote was completely unnecessary and he made himself a target. Smart move if he is scum and wants to be cleared of suspicion but it's very risky and it just doesn't seem the case.
Lind has made some good post and some not so good ones: him calling to vote for plat is unnecessary. Not a terrible look, but since we don't have that much info (and can only lynch 6 people) it could make him a viable target.

Lind said:
@DrProfessor83 @Lalisa vote plat.
Click to expand...
What the reasoning behind this?

Anyways, haven't read enough about Melkor but I'll be around on and off for the next 6 hours so I am ok with waiting before I decide anything. So far I am leaning Xadlin, but him being able to protect could change the game.
 
something common in the NF meta is if someone randomly votes for mafia too soon is that the other members rush to start a new wagon, so I feel didi may be scum and people who instantly start an anti wagon suggest some people there are mafia. Also scum typically use me because i'm generally underestimated.

also also despite 4 people voting for me, NOBODY targeted me last night kind of odd nobody so much as investigated me
 
Sad that none of the public posters last night are lynch targets, whoever set up that action had to be mafia because they chose a group that did little to nothing to help scumhunt for this group during the night phase lol.

Anyway, ignoring the execution because I feel like it'll probably just be townies that don't give a shit about their role? So eh, skipping over it and will probably just vote a non-poster eventually. Quick reads on the vulnerable votes before I read this phase:

1. Didi - No read on him, need to hear an updated case on him but I assume he'll be another popular topic today.
2. Hero - Townread, seems like one of the most helpful players so far.
3. Lind - Unlikely to be mafia just on role dynamics, ignoring as I don't care to potentially indy hunt at this stage.
4. Lord Melkor - Don't feel great on him so far, seemed to be really into voting Platinum but then also tried to frame it as him just following Hero's lead when he actually cast the vote? I got bad vibes from that.
5. SoulKiller - no idea, need more than the quit-unquit of day 1 though.
6. Xadlin - Was scummy day 1 based on their contributions or lack thereof, I did notice they were trying to be helpful this time now that their back is up against the wall. Unsure what to make of it.

ok time to read the new phase now hi
 
hammer said:
something common in the NF meta is if someone randomly votes for mafia too soon is that the other members rush to start a new wagon, so I feel didi may be scum and people who instantly start an anti wagon suggest some people there are mafia. Also scum typically use me because i'm generally underestimated.

also also despite 4 people voting for me, NOBODY targeted me last night kind of odd nobody so much as investigated me
Click to expand...
i did but i got roleblocked

so u r aware of people voting for u but u wud rather let them waste abilities on u instead of talk to them about it in the thread and make ur self easy to read? how does this help town?


WolfPrinceKiba said:
Not even tryharding and people still have it out for me, a superkill and vote silence already :lmao

Even if it's only in spirit :

[Vote Lynch Didi]

As last phase, will be catching up throughout the night on stuff when I have downtime.
Click to expand...
why r u revealing that u r vote silenced?
 
Ekkologix said:
i did but i got roleblocked

so u r aware of people voting for u but u wud rather let them waste abilities on u instead of talk to them about it in the thread and make ur self easy to read? how does this help town?



why r u revealing that u r vote silenced?
Click to expand...
umm what? I never said I vote silenced anyone I said I know who targets me. if I tell people I know who targets me, then mafia knows as well. so I didn't say anything. Kind of fucking obvious why I wouldn't tell anyone.
 
hammer said:
umm what? I never said I vote silenced anyone I said I know who targets me. if I tell people I know who targets me, then mafia knows as well. so I didn't say anything. Kind of fucking obvious why I wouldn't tell anyone.
Click to expand...
that doesnt make sense. if u dont want mafia to know about ur ability, then why reveal it like this when it provides no info anyway? u could of very well just revealed it day 1. moreso, u act surprised that the players who suspected u did not target u, but u roleblocked me, your biggest pusher day 1. that makes no foken sense.

my post about the vote silence was to WPK. im sure u know how quotes work. u've been here since 2008
 
Ekkologix said:
that doesnt make sense. if u dont want mafia to know about ur ability, then why reveal it like this when it provides no info anyway? u could of very well just revealed it day 1. moreso, u act surprised that the players who suspected u did not target u, but u roleblocked me, your biggest pusher day 1. that makes no foken sense.

my post about the vote silence was to WPK. im sure u know how quotes work. u've been here since 2008
Click to expand...
I took away your vote power because I thought you were scum, I did the other passive ability to see who would target me. it makes more sense to reveal info after you have info rather than have scum know and not target me. makes perfect sense.
 
Ekkologix said:
disagree, because as town u just tell mafia that u arent immune to vote silence = give them the confidence to rely on vote silencing ur slot if they want to safely down the line
Click to expand...
the mod will tell you it worked. and at the end of the day mafia can count the votes. it hurts town more by not telling anyone. like what you say makes less sense.


anyways the didi protectors are extra sus.
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
Back
Top