Game Favorites '22 - GROUP 2

[Nessos]

Who's the bad guy? Is it @Nessos? Is he a little scummy scum?

I wish I were a Cult Leader, but no just Town with a nonstop playing ability....
@Lind you are not the only one

 

[SinRaven]

I would still prefer the Xadlin lynch

[Change Vote Lynch Didi]

What's your case against Xadlin?

 

[Ekkologix]

See my above post kinda. But it's mostly just shameless bandwagoning.

and ur okay with this being ur gameplay this game?

 

[Nessos]

Btw was someone besides @Ekkologix and me contacted and asked, If they think "positive" or "negative" about Lalisa?

 

[Soul]

Shizune's wording is clear that the superkills will happen during this next night, it's a delayed effect. That's why people can visit Nata and I to help mitigate individual damage. The mark does prevent me from just flashing though, I would have had to flash on n1 to completely dodge it.

But you/nat could be dead even when protected, right? It's not like Xad can come in and save you (assuming he is what he is claiming).

Also maybe it puts me in the crosshairs but why is there such a strong bandwagon/train for pushing on Didi as the lynch? Did he vote on Plat?

Not really I have been asking this for hours now.

I would still prefer the Xadlin lynch

[Change Vote Lynch Didi]

Then why would you vote Didi? lmao

 

[Ekkologix]

Btw was someone besides @Ekkologix and me contacted and asked, If they think "positive" or "negative" about Lalisa?

nat
and shud be 2 more who did not claim it yet

read lalisa's ability. 5 at random are targeted by it. oddly enough the 3 of us who were in the night chat got asked lol

 

[SinRaven]

and ur okay with this being ur gameplay this game?

Umm yes, are you not OK with it?

 

[Nessos]

What's your case against Xadlin?

The voting pattern.
Feels like he avoided to get eligible for this DP lynch. He jumped of the Didi Lynch right before He went offline and it was before the Plat train started.

 

[Nessos]

nat
and shud be 2 more who did not claim it yet

read lalisa's ability. 5 at random are targeted by it. oddly enough the 3 of us who were in the night chat got asked lol

Should have checked the dead roles

 

[Badalight]

Oh hey, that's not a terrible idea. If people who are being sussed want to prove their innocence, they can offer to protect WPK and Nat. Then, doctors will also know who to protect.

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

But you/nat could be dead even when protected, right? It's not like Xad can come in and save you (assuming he is what he is claiming).

Super kills ignore doctor protection. The only way I live through tonight is if enough people target me to spread the damage out to the point I can live.

 

[Soul]

Oh hey, that's not a terrible idea. If people who are being sussed want to prove their innocence, they can offer to protect WPK and Nat. Then, doctors will also know who to protect.

I did suggest this, but it can get very convoluted, we might not get enough info out of the write up to determine if Xad was saying the truth (someone else also protected them) and

Super kills ignore doctor protection.

this

 

[Ekkologix]

Umm yes, are you not OK with it?

I am not, and i hope your vote remains on the main wagon today.

 

[Nessos]

And there are really no candidates who really wants to party all night long

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

And there are really no candidates who really wants to party all night long

Since I might get offed by a super kill, give me night posting powers please and thank you

 

[SinRaven]

Hmm seems to me those last minute votes end of D1 could've just have been to save Worm Juice and not Didi

Like Worm Juice was the counterwagon to Didi and once that wagon gained traction a lot of votes on Platinum started to happen. If those votes were to save Didi I think the Plat wagon would've started earlier.

At least that's how I'm reading it at quick glance, maybe someone with more time can do a better analysis x)

I think according to this theory Xadlin and Lord Melkor look more suspicious since they were on both the Didi and Plat wagons

 

[Badalight]

And there are really no candidates who really wants to party all night long

I'd be down and also it might last longer on me dunno I'll ask Nitty how my ability works.

 

[SinRaven]

I am not, and i hope your vote remains on the main wagon today.

So you are okay with me shamelessly bandwagoning lmao

 

[Badalight]

Also does anyone think fang being like "omg this might make me sus but I'll say it anyway" is just cover for actually being legit sus?

 

[Nessos]

@WolfPrinceKiba how do you think about @Xadlin ?

 

[Ekkologix]

So you are okay with me shamelessly bandwagoning lmao

incorrect.
i am not okay with the thoughtless voting. the bandwagoning is needed to expand tomorow's lynch pool. the thoughtless voting in a wagon is not needed.

 

[Fang]

Also does anyone think fang being like "omg this might make me sus but I'll say it anyway" is just cover for actually being legit sus?

I literally said this all of two times that I admitted to doing a night action on Lalisa at the start of this day phase and then asking about the sudden shift on Didi the last few hours. Where are you getting "omg this might make me sus" when I'm already going out of my way to draw attention to myself fully knowing this?

 

[SinRaven]

I think according to this theory Xadlin and Lord Melkor look more suspicious since they were on both the Didi and Plat wagons

Actually nvm I believe they were already on the Plat wagon when Didi was still in the lead. Mainly Didi himself and Ratchet (dead town) were the determining votes there

 

[Nessos]

I think according to this theory Xadlin and Lord Melkor look more suspicious since they were on both the Didi and Plat wagons

I am up for the Xadlin Lord Melkor scumbuddy thought. Especially this post of Lord Melkor gives me huge scumvibes!

Vote Lynch Didi

Leaning scum on Xadlin, but we should not all vote one person when the day just began.

[Change Vote Lynch Xadlin]

 

[SoulKiller]

Alright now that I got the chance to read DP1/NP1 (At page 41). Time to throw my few cents.

DrProfessor, I can see he is having fun this time around, comfortable enough to do what he is doing right now, which by the way made me chuckle reading some of his posts. Refreshing and makes it interesting reading the way he carries himself. For that alone I am getting some townie vibes from him. I thought some of his posts and interaction with players were insightful for what it's worth.

Natalija, I liked some of her posts, felt very carefree and genuine, like she does not filter what she wants to say in her head and just says it. That being said, she tends to be a player that is bit difficult to read for me personally. Her personality makes me town read her even if she is scum. But as of now, town lean.

Juan, contributed here and there, I see that he is actively active this time around. While I didn't play much with him, he did tend to be coasting and contributing little from memory. Him being actually be this engaged in the game is something I noticed. Could swing either way tbh. Interested to see if he follows it up DP2. Noted that he voted plat because he didn't want didi yeeted.

BadLight and YoTan : Lumping these two together because I think best way to read them is by their back and forth which I personally thought YoTan looked better overall. BadLight picked some of yotan posts and started nitpicking on the guy, felt like easy way to make a player look bad, he then played it off as he was testing YoTan and town leaned him. Also, I found it funny that he mistaken me for a player called SoulTaker not sure how you can get things confused when my name was clearly stated. I am not familiar with this guy, so not sure if he is capable of faking such thing or not. Felt weird. As for YoTan, i liked the way he handled himself in that interaction. Plus, getting good vibes from the lad.


Lind, i think it's a waste focusing on him right now. He is probably indie/townie. I think his slot resolves itself. Either way he is making good posts overall, you can tell there is thought behind them. Town lean

Rej, didn't like him at the beginning trying to pocket me, but liked his posts as the game progressed. Null/Leaning more on the town side.

JW, his posts didn't ping me even tho he has more than alot of players, not good sign. Null/leaning more on the scum side.

Nesso, I noticed that alot of his posts or more so than anyone else he is paying close attention to the other game. Made couple of posts encouraging player to keep an eye out on it. Not sure I am fan of such thing when I remember a player. But he seems to allowed Ekko and Nat to talk during the NP, which I don't see as a scum ability but hey, who knows. Null.

Soul, besides him having an identity crisis because I am around. His posts didn't ping me much tbh, placed a vote on prof, made few posts stating his opinion and appeared again 10min after the DP ended. Not fan of it per say and wasn't a fan of that weird lie detector post he made, felt forced. But since I am his killer, I am welling to give him the benefit of the doubt. As of now I have him null/scum lean, and looking forward to how he move forward in DP2. Wasn't fa

Didi, I honestly thought the guy was fine? he felt to me like he is being himself. Not necessarily townie but not necessarily scummy either. Felt some of the pushes on him was very opportunistic, voting him because he used words 'maybe' and being unsure about a player was weird. Taking a look at his post as a stand alone, alot of them feels like he is fucking around? lol. Maybe that's just the vibe you get from reading his posts. Null can see him as scum. But also can see him as townie, guess DP2 should get better read since he should be eligible to be lynched.

Ekko, not surprised he is number 1 poster, I seen his posts and actually getting good vibes from him. He addressed different topics and people and even commented and reading the second game and offering help and opinion. I say cop him and save yourself the headach. But from where I am standing as of right now, he is town lean for me. Also, got to say that I liked his interaction with ratchet. Looked TvT.

Firestormer, while I don't remember her being engaging with other players, she made some lengthy posts addressing her reads and thoughts of the game. Looked okay. Would like to see more interactions from her.

Ratchet, what can I say ratchet chan, you will be by my side this entire game. Glad to have you abroad to the townie lock. It's good to see you being outed like this as a townie.

Xladin, didn't do much and voted plat because he was apparently on his ass. Looked like he was defending didi here as well. Wasn't much fan of his posts, nothing pinged me with townie mindset. Scummy.

Hero, I felt like some of his posts were genuine and some were fake, his post regarding my slot early in the game felt genuine for example but felt over reacting. Does not tell me much about his alignment though. However, when I came back to make use of my vote, he stated that he forgot about my slot and that my ass is grass this DP, now that felt fake to me. It's like he wanna scum read for the sake of it. I also found his response regarding ekko explanation about my vote weird, what part of it exactly is that you don't understand? idk felt fake and no thought behind it. But in some instances he did make good posts, he leaded the wagon on plat which is worth to note. Null/leaning more on the scum side.


Charlies, I remember getting good vibes while going through his posts. Usually you can read him well when you apply pressure his way. Null.

Fang, his early game was mostly one liner posts about how he is the omniverse and that he is town. Fluffed a bit, then tried to get some discussion going with ekko which was a good sign in my book. Then went after professor possibly because of prof RP which is weak reason imo. Then switched to LM because of vibe reasons apparently. Can see him either way.


Other players simply did not have any impression on me and are in my null/scum lean.


For the NP results, I am kinda glad ratchet died and can speak as a ghost, not having to worry about his slot is a relief. Unfortunate to see Lalisa gone since I thought she was doing well and liked her reads.

Looking at the lynch candidates at hand, ill need to catch up to the current events but for now I think Xadlin is the most scummy out of that bunch. As for execution, I don't really care they all the same to me.

Vote Lynch: Xaldin

 

[Badalight]

@SoulKiller

Hey now. I never said I town leaned on Yo Tan Wan. I did an iso on someone who hadn't been isoed and found very typical scum tells in there. After last night's actions I am more inclined to lean town on them.

Also fuck you soulkiller and soultaker are very similar names!

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

@WolfPrinceKiba how do you think about @Xadlin ?

Don't have much of a particular read on them atm, they're on the list to ISO

 

[Ekkologix]

Alright now that I got the chance to read DP1/NP1 (At page 41). Time to throw my few cents.

DrProfessor, I can see he is having fun this time around, comfortable enough to do what he is doing right now, which by the way made me chuckle reading some of his posts. Refreshing and makes it interesting reading the way he carries himself. For that alone I am getting some townie vibes from him. I thought some of his posts and interaction with players were insightful for what it's worth.

Natalija, I liked some of her posts, felt very carefree and genuine, like she does not filter what she wants to say in her head and just says it. That being said, she tends to be a player that is bit difficult to read for me personally. Her personality makes me town read her even if she is scum. But as of now, town lean.

Juan, contributed here and there, I see that he is actively active this time around. While I didn't play much with him, he did tend to be coasting and contributing little from memory. Him being actually be this engaged in the game is something I noticed. Could swing either way tbh. Interested to see if he follows it up DP2. Noted that he voted plat because he didn't want didi yeeted.

BadLight and YoTan : Lumping these two together because I think best way to read them is by their back and forth which I personally thought YoTan looked better overall. BadLight picked some of yotan posts and started nitpicking on the guy, felt like easy way to make a player look bad, he then played it off as he was testing YoTan and town leaned him. Also, I found it funny that he mistaken me for a player called SoulTaker not sure how you can get things confused when my name was clearly stated. I am not familiar with this guy, so not sure if he is capable of faking such thing or not. Felt weird. As for YoTan, i liked the way he handled himself in that interaction. Plus, getting good vibes from the lad.


Lind, i think it's a waste focusing on him right now. He is probably indie/townie. I think his slot resolves itself. Either way he is making good posts overall, you can tell there is thought behind them. Town lean

Rej, didn't like him at the beginning trying to pocket me, but liked his posts as the game progressed. Null/Leaning more on the town side.

JW, his posts didn't ping me even tho he has more than alot of players, not good sign. Null/leaning more on the scum side.

Nesso, I noticed that alot of his posts or more so than anyone else he is paying close attention to the other game. Made couple of posts encouraging player to keep an eye out on it. Not sure I am fan of such thing when I remember a player. But he seems to allowed Ekko and Nat to talk during the NP, which I don't see as a scum ability but hey, who knows. Null.

Soul, besides him having an identity crisis because I am around. His posts didn't ping me much tbh, placed a vote on prof, made few posts stating his opinion and appeared again 10min after the DP ended. Not fan of it per say and wasn't a fan of that weird lie detector post he made, felt forced. But since I am his killer, I am welling to give him the benefit of the doubt. As of now I have him null/scum lean, and looking forward to how he move forward in DP2. Wasn't fa

Didi, I honestly thought the guy was fine? he felt to me like he is being himself. Not necessarily townie but not necessarily scummy either. Felt some of the pushes on him was very opportunistic, voting him because he used words 'maybe' and being unsure about a player was weird. Taking a look at his post as a stand alone, alot of them feels like he is fucking around? lol. Maybe that's just the vibe you get from reading his posts. Null can see him as scum. But also can see him as townie, guess DP2 should get better read since he should be eligible to be lynched.

Ekko, not surprised he is number 1 poster, I seen his posts and actually getting good vibes from him. He addressed different topics and people and even commented and reading the second game and offering help and opinion. I say cop him and save yourself the headach. But from where I am standing as of right now, he is town lean for me. Also, got to say that I liked his interaction with ratchet. Looked TvT.

Firestormer, while I don't remember her being engaging with other players, she made some lengthy posts addressing her reads and thoughts of the game. Looked okay. Would like to see more interactions from her.

Ratchet, what can I say ratchet chan, you will be by my side this entire game. Glad to have you abroad to the townie lock. It's good to see you being outed like this as a townie.

Xladin, didn't do much and voted plat because he was apparently on his ass. Looked like he was defending didi here as well. Wasn't much fan of his posts, nothing pinged me with townie mindset. Scummy.

Hero, I felt like some of his posts were genuine and some were fake, his post regarding my slot early in the game felt genuine for example but felt over reacting. Does not tell me much about his alignment though. However, when I came back to make use of my vote, he stated that he forgot about my slot and that my ass is grass this DP, now that felt fake to me. It's like he wanna scum read for the sake of it. I also found his response regarding ekko explanation about my vote weird, what part of it exactly is that you don't understand? idk felt fake and no thought behind it. But in some instances he did make good posts, he leaded the wagon on plat which is worth to note. Null/leaning more on the scum side.


Charlies, I remember getting good vibes while going through his posts. Usually you can read him well when you apply pressure his way. Null.

Fang, his early game was mostly one liner posts about how he is the omniverse and that he is town. Fluffed a bit, then tried to get some discussion going with ekko which was a good sign in my book. Then went after professor possibly because of prof RP which is weak reason imo. Then switched to LM because of vibe reasons apparently. Can see him either way.


Other players simply did not have any impression on me and are in my null/scum lean.


For the NP results, I am kinda glad ratchet died and can speak as a ghost, not having to worry about his slot is a relief. Unfortunate to see Lalisa gone since I thought she was doing well and liked her reads.

Looking at the lynch candidates at hand, ill need to catch up to the current events but for now I think Xadlin is the most scummy out of that bunch. As for execution, I don't really care they all the same to me.

Vote Lynch: Xaldin

 

[Nessos]

Don't have much of a particular read on them atm, they're on the list to ISO

Do it, I think @Xadlin is a better lynch then @Didi!

 

[Ekkologix]

Sk finally using 1.2% of his full power

its settled

xadlin is the lynch

 

[Badalight]

Actually I take that back, SinRaven and Yo Tan Wan are booby trapped TONIGHT, not last night. That's weird. Why would that appear in the writeup? Did someone delay all actions because the superkills are delayed as well. If not, what purpose does a delayed booby trap that appears in the writeup even serve?

 

[SoulKiller]

@SoulKiller

Hey now. I never said I town leaned on Yo Tan Wan. I did an iso on someone who hadn't been isoed and found very typical scum tells in there. After last night's actions I am more inclined to lean town on them.

You said something along the lines that you were testing him and that you two should be friends, looked like you were putting him on your good side and try to win him over and backing down after seeing some resistance from his end. But if the latter part of this quote is true, It would of been better you kept the mechanical part to yourself as to why you town read him.

Also fuck you soulkiller and soultaker are very similar names!

Can you truly say this with a straight face?

 

[Badalight]

You said something along the lines that you were testing him and that you two should be friends, looked like you were putting him on your good side and try to win him over and backing down after seeing some resistance from his end. But if the latter part of this quote is true, It would of been better you kept the mechanical part to yourself as to why you town read him.

​

Can you truly say this with a straight face?

I mean yeah, isn't that the whole point of an ISO? To look more closely at a player that hasn't been looked at yet?

I already said I was embarrassed by my mistake okay. You're making me blush ;(

 

[Badalight]

As for the mechanical part, I updated my take because the fact that it was delayed or is a pre-announced booby trap has me very confused.

 

[SoulKiller]

I mean yeah, isn't that the whole point of an ISO? To look more closely at a player that hasn't been looked at yet?

There is multiple ways to take a closer look at a player, didn't think your method was the best per say.

I already said I was embarrassed by my mistake okay. You're making me blush ;(

It's okay I forgive you, nice to meet you by the way. I am SoulKiller, the best edition to the Souls in this forum.

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

Actually I take that back, SinRaven and Yo Tan Wan are booby trapped TONIGHT, not last night. That's weird. Why would that appear in the writeup? Did someone delay all actions because the superkills are delayed as well. If not, what purpose does a delayed booby trap that appears in the writeup even serve?

The super kills are undoubtedly delayed because they're super kills so are harder to pull off than normal ones, not because of some other ability delaying them. That the super kills damage can be spread out by players targeting us is the other dead give away. Nitty runs more moderately powered games than others, and while they've no doubt amped things up for Favorites, someone throwing out two instant super kills n1 is not something Nitty would put in the game.

 

[Badalight]

​

There is multiple ways to take a closer look at a player, didn't think your method was the best per say.

​

It's okay I forgive you, nice to meet you by the way. I am SoulKiller, the best edition to the Souls in this forum.

I've technically known Soul for like half my life so imo soul > you, but I am biased.

 

[Santí]

There is multiple ways to take a closer look at a player, didn't think your method was the best per say.

Tell me more

 

[Badalight]

The super kills are undoubtedly delayed because they're super kills so are harder to pull off than normal ones, not because of some other ability delaying them. That the super kills damage can be spread out by players targeting us is the other dead give away. Nitty runs more moderately powered games than others, and while they've no doubt amped things up for Favorites, someone throwing out two instant super kills n1 is not something Nitty would put in the game.

Right. I don't think I have played in past Nitty games so that's good to know. I only have my own role and the few revealed roles so far to go off of (and my scum mates roles).

Anyway, I had a similar thought as you but I thought it was weird that the booby traps were also delayed. Made me think it was like a mass delay. Then again, the mechanic of dispersing superkill damage seems very specific so I can believe that's just how superkills work in this game. If that's how the booby traps were supposed to work, it's much more likely to be a town ability. If that isn't how they were supposed to work, it's much more likely a mafia ability.

 

[Soul]

It's okay I forgive you, nice to meet you by the way. I am SoulKiller, the best edition to the Souls in this forum.

lmao Bada isn't a good target for those lies my friend.
Your writeup was pretty good and I guess it's not surprising we have a similar outlook. Started out weird in Day 1 but you read town to me after this.

 

[Soul]

I've technically known Soul for like half my life so imo soul > you, but I am biased.

 

[SoulKiller]

That's how it should be anyways, but Group 1 is kicking our ass

You see Nat the quality of players in Group 2 is clearly superior as of that of Group 1. We are the more dangerous group here. Let's see how they fair and how we fair by the time we merge and see who truly is the better.

 

[SoulKiller]

Tell me more

Are you willing to pay cash upfront?

 

[tinky winky]

-tinky winky trying to join the Didi wagon and also posting just enough to avoid the Execution makes him suspicious to me, and I hope he is able to provide a bit more this phase in terms of contributions since iirc his posts weren't really saying much either.

complete nonsense.
I was also like the first vote on didi last phase
how much reading did you do .
if anything they hopped on my wagon. #townleader


tbf to didi, he is still sort of a null read to me but he annoyed me so w/e.

 

[Badalight]

@Didi

hey come here

 

[SoulKiller]

>immediate claim

my thoughts exactly, didn't even try to defend his situation.

 

[Santí]

Are you willing to pay cash upfront?

Yeah yeah, fo' sho', I gotchu.

 

[tinky winky]

[vote execute Salah WG]

bet my left hand this bloke will be inactive

 

[tinky winky]

[vote execute Santi]

Did I do this right?

For executions, imo it's better to hit the people who posted rather than those who did not post at all.

how so
hmmmm
whats the logic behind that

 

[Badalight]

Yeah yeah, fo' sho', I gotchu.

are you going to post twice and then disappear again

 

[Badalight]

how so
hmmmm
whats the logic behind that

If we think there is mafia there, it is much more likely it would be one that posted a little in an attempt to fly under the radar but not be put up for execution, imo.

I guess I can see logic the other way too. If a mafia member is invested in the game enough to post, why would they not post enough to guarantee they aren't up for execution?

idfk man

 

[tinky winky]

If we think there is mafia there, it is much more likely it would be one that posted a little in an attempt to fly under the radar but not be put up for execution, imo.

I guess I can see logic the other way too. If a mafia member is invested in the game enough to post, why would they not post enough to guarantee they aren't up for execution?

idfk man

that fits my description so I def dont agree with you lol

but logically it makes sense. i guess thats why most are voting santi?

 

[Santí]

i guess thats why most are voting santi?

They vote me because they fear the havoc I could reap.

 

[SoulKiller]

I've technically known Soul for like half my life so imo soul > you, but I am biased.

Clearly lol.

 

[SoulKiller]

Yeah yeah, fo' sho', I gotchu.

The point of this interaction is? besides trying to be funny ofc.

 

[Badalight]

Also Nessos I confirmed with Nitty that if you use your ability on me it would work as normal, rip.

 

[tinky winky]

I've technically known Soul for like half my life so imo soul > you, but I am biased.

thats crazy
in 2007 I was playing with legos

you lot were already here?

 

[tinky winky]

I would still prefer the Xadlin lynch

[Change Vote Lynch Didi]

weird ....
arent you alllowed to vote xadlin then.....

 

[Xadlin]

Okay, well since you're claiming protect/shield, might I ask that you declare who you shielded last night?

Apologies for late response! My internet decided to die when i wrote the post last night.

I Actually tried to role crush Iwan, Worm juice and and melkor.my abilities was reflected back to me and am now role crushed.

>immediate claim

desperate I am. I got lynched last time i was more passive so i try to be more honest this time.

That sounds like a rather unimaginative role for this game.

hmmm...
well its kinda nice actually. it gets better as long as i survive.

And whom of the other ones should we choose?

Also, you are mainly a protective role, correct?

Im manily a protective role.
Either Iwan or Worm juice. unless you were the one that reflected my ability and bounced it back at me? did you do that?

@Xadlin who did you target last night and why?

Worm juice, iwan and melkor.
Worm since he was one of the people who was sus,

iwan since i need to check on him. either iwan is lazy or hes scum coasting.

Melkor since i needed to be extra sure, since when melkor was scum, he was participating and engaged the same way with town, until very late game when it was revelaled that melkor had bamboolxed everyone. just had to be sure, since meklor is good in both town and scum party.

Boo. Tomatoes. I’m throwing tomatoes.

1. That’s actually incredibly useful but if you’re shit at scum hunting, then your ability probably does more harm than good

2. So you have this idea of information you’d gain from a bandwagon on D1. Enlighten me. What did you find? You can’t be that terrible at scum hunting. I don’t understand how you have this concept of a bandwagon but in the same breath you admit you’re essentially dead weight and rather let others scum hunt. But wasn’t the point of you participating in the wagon to gain info per this post and a previous? I’m telling you now, you better step up

3. See above

4. Lol ok.

5. Then put in work.

ok, Ill do better coach.

The line of thought is that they would be vulnerable to a lynch in Day 2. Don't love it but it does make sense.


You do seem suspicious, but this write up seems believable.
Theoretically us townies could come together and select one to save. Then you could use your ability to that protect and help out the town.

Also, if you are indeed a townie the mafia would probably kill you, which means we would be wasting a lynch even if the majority wanted to get rid of you. Unfortunate that you got this role... Then again you might be lying and should be lynched.

Overall seems like too much of a hassle to do this, but if you are to be believed your abilities are valuable.
Does anyone knows if a protection has to be mentioned in the write ups?


Not if he does what the townies want/vote for. Because the townies are clear majority.
Then again it can get really messy, not sure if it's worth it.

 

[SoulKiller]

lmao Bada isn't a good target for those lies my friend.

Since when were you under the impression that it was a lie Soul?

I guess it's not surprising we have a similar outlook.

Guess we are Souls for a reason huh?

 

[WolfPrinceKiba]

12 threads alr3e4ady?
well surely we are in a fave mafia game alright
im gonna check on some people for during the day phase


I'm a good guy bytheway

Complaining about activity off the bat is nagl, and also rushing to say they're town without actually saying "I am town."

true
is usopp still scum?

Immediately shades ekko/usopp

im awake
[vote ly6nch didi]

@Platinum I love you to
Ill protect you this game, dont ya worry

Plat.

love you still bro

[change vote lynch platinum]


I had no real motivation for voting on Didi. seems good to jump on a lynch wagon on thé first day, so one can see which jumps on it, dissecting it and whom else gets a vote.

but plat has been on my ass, so im gonna vote for him. and im gonna stay on that.

i love you plat, but let old grudges be old

Tries too hard to justify their bandwagon vote on Didi, which itself might have been a distancing vote from a scummate. Turns onto Plat who they talked about protecting earlier

Im off to make dinner

play nice everyone

also Im town, so there be no confusion

If you say it enough, it might become true!

reads?
ill try:

1. @Badalight
-I dont know. havent played enough to know about them.
seems townie since they seem to repsond alot and be hunting
2. @Baroxio
-no idea
3. @charles101
-charles is active
4. @Didi
-i dont know
5. @DrProfessor83
-no idea
6. @Ekkologix
-usopp is always town and scum at the same time.
if usopp is not active scum hunting, they are more inclines to be scum, but he might as well be rp and fool everyone.
7. @Fang
-dont know. Fang usually manages to fool me, so they are neutral for now.
8. @Firestormer
-no idea
9. @Franky
-no ida
10. @hammer
- no idea, ill check after dinner
11. @Hero
dont knowe qwill chekc later
12. @Iwandesu
-non active iwan is usually scumdesu. untilo iwan says somwthing then scum
13. @John Wayne
have john said anything? ill check
14. @Juan
-dont like inactivefags so might lean towards town, unless rp
15. @Kira Yagami
dont knwo
16. @Lalisa
donkt know
17. @Lind
lind is good. dontm knowif town or scum but good.
18. @Lord Melkor
Ill check cause good scum and towqn playter
19. @Melodie
dont know
20. @Natalija
kndow know
21. @Nessos
neutral atm, dont know. active af
22. @Oddjutsu
dontm kow. odd is odd.
23. @Platinum
migth just be always aggresive but leanign towards scum
24. @Ratchet
know not
25. @Rej
dont know
26. @Salah WG
dont know, will check
27. @Santí
dontmknow
28. @SinRaven
dontk know
29. @Soul
dontk know
30. @SoulKiller
dont kmnoiw
31. @sworder
will chekc
32. @tinky winky
dont know
33. @WolfPrinceKiba
dotnm know
34. @Worm Juice
no idea. been active but dotnk know
36. @Yo Tan Wa
active, so thinkn good.

Way too tryhard.

I have nothing to offer except for protection. I can rolecrush or protect/shield a set amount of people i choose to.
Im not good at reading people, so thats that.

adn yeah, I think D1 bandwagons are just to splash the water, in order to find out more from others. D2 lynches are more important.
im trying to be more active and post more, yet im not always sure on whom are whom.

I usually go with my role and let people more better at scum hunting to their job. Im a righthand man. unless I have to step up to do a task, i rather wait for those more experenced in doing those task to do those.

Im not scum, and if you lynch me you will see that to, and then town will be towning even more.


I know im on the lynch list, but i ask that yo give me a chance, and choose one of the other ones

This is the only slightly good post they have, but it has some red flags as well. The bolded especially is just scummy guilt shading, and the whole of the post is largely explaining why they're useless in-thread giving them an out from contributing anything of value.


This can be nuked from orbit.

 

[Nessos]

Also Nessos I confirmed with Nitty that if you use your ability on me it would work as normal, rip.

Thanks for clarification!

 

[Badalight]

I actually kinda believe Xaldin ability wise because it sounds mechanically similar to how some of my stuff works and how some of the revealed roles work. That said, it doesn't necessarily mean he is town.

 

[Nessos]

@Didi who did you target tonight and why?

 

[Santí]

If we think there is mafia there, it is much more likely it would be one that posted a little in an attempt to fly under the radar but not be put up for execution, imo.

I guess I can see logic the other way too. If a mafia member is invested in the game enough to post, why would they not post enough to guarantee they aren't up for execution?

idfk man

I mean, personally I don't think we should be trying to weaponize the execute mechanic to such a degree unless the content of the individual is pretty sus and scummy enough to warrant being lynched in and of itself. You're effectively suggesting to retool an anti-inactivity system to punish the least inactive among the inactive (in this case me) for putting just a little more effort than the other 3 candidates.

If I were scum and any of my mates were up on the execute board, I just fucking might take advantage of the execute to target someone higher profile and effectively get a double mislynch for the town

 

[SoulKiller]

Finally caught up.

Liked Nat more than Juan in their interactions.

Soul looks better than last DP.

WPK looks townie.

Not fan of how fast votes are wracking up on Didi tbh. Some of them have little to no reason.

Xadlin looks same to me, didn't like his immediate claim, while his last post felt better, overall lean more scummy imo still. Not too fan of mechanics talk, player actions and how they behave in the thread matters more to me. Since this is a huge game with heavy role madness. Any role can be scum. Plus, the wagon building up fast on Didi is giving me sus vibes and feels like mafia are def on that train/wagon. Which is good if didi gets lynched, they will be examined closely.

 

[Badalight]

thats crazy
in 2007 I was playing with legos

you lot were already here?

I'm fucking OLD

I mean, personally I don't think we should be trying to weaponize the execute mechanic to such a degree unless the content of the individual is pretty sus and scummy enough to warrant being lynched in and of itself. You're effectively suggesting to retool an anti-inactivity system to punish the least inactive among the inactive (in this case me) for putting just a little more effort than the other 3 candidates.

If I were scum and any of my mates were up on the execute board, I just fucking might take advantage of the execute to target someone higher profile and effectively get a double mislynch for the town

Sounds like something a SCUM would say!!!!! ;o

 

[Santí]

Sounds like something a SCUM would say!!!!! ;o

You're not even trying to deny it then, Badaroach?

 

[Badalight]

Wagon is piling on Didi because one of the main people pushing his lynch was targeted with a super kill. Yes there are a few possibilities such as scum orchestrating this in order to make us a waste another lynch, or writeup manipulation, or WPK being scum, or dumb town/indie vig. That said, most of those possibilities are pretty unlikely imho.

 

[Nessos]

The good thing is even If we totally fuck up group 2 there is still group 1 doing well!
To be Town right now is quite comfy

 

[Badalight]

You're not even trying to deny it then, Badaroach?

I will live a long time in this game as well, but not because I'm scum ;(

 

[SoulKiller]

As for execute, I guess I will go with this. At least others showed sign of life.

Vote Execute: Salah WG

With that being said, it's getting late here. Night lads.

 

[Lind]

Is there anyone else among the people eligible for the lynch you scum read other than Xadlin?

I am wondering if Lalisa was a vig kill? I would expect Ratchet to be mafia kill.

Why would Lalisa be a vig kill? Her end of day was really good. No reason for her to be a vig kill at all. The opposite in fact would be my guess.

I am actually so suspicious of comments like this because its typically what I would do as scum to justify why I would be inactive ahead of time.

complete rubbish with all due respect but I also won't make excuses for not returning before the phase ended .


he was trying to pivot out of desperation .
he actually started playing the game . vote pressure works.

ditto
usually he would be a pest by now
grabbing the game by the nutsac , mass tagging everyone etc.

Gotta say I'm loving Tinky lol. His speech patterns are very different 'cause they're more aggressive, but I'm still loving him this phase haha.

Plus points for making me laugh btw.

What the reasoning behind this?

I thought Platinum was a viable lynch option, and I wanted Prof and Lalisa to be on the main wagons if we needed more votes to counter the Didi wagon.

Honestly, was a stupid move in hindsight because Plat was town. So apologies to Plat for that.

Sad that none of the public posters last night are lynch targets, whoever set up that action had to be mafia because they chose a group that did little to nothing to help scumhunt for this group during the night phase lol.

Isn't the fact that none of them being up for lynch, but were still chose to be put in the night talk a townie mindset? We got more of their thoughts out in the open, as opposed to getting their genuine thoughts in the day phase since the pressure of a vote wouldn't work on them.

Plus, I think putting players up for a night talk is a townie ability since it gets others talking.

I took away your vote power because I thought you were scum, I did the other passive ability to see who would target me. it makes more sense to reveal info after you have info rather than have scum know and not target me. makes perfect sense.

I just didn't understand this post.

You being booby trapped makes it much more likely that you are town imo. Dunno why a town would booby trap you because that would imply they believe mafia would target you... which doesn't seem to make much sense. Alternatively, mafia might have thought that I (a townie <3) or another townie would target you because you had mild suspicion on you.

Then again, it's weird that they wouldn't choose some of the bigger targets, but perhaps that's because a lot of the people with heat on the are up for lynch today.

The way the booby trapped is described tells me that it functions as a protective ability. So either town protecting them, or mafia protecting their mates.

Btw was someone besides @Ekkologix and me contacted and asked, If they think "positive" or "negative" about Lalisa?

Yes, me. I rated her positive.

Alright now that I got the chance to read DP1/NP1 (At page 41). Time to throw my few cents.

DrProfessor, I can see he is having fun this time around, comfortable enough to do what he is doing right now, which by the way made me chuckle reading some of his posts. Refreshing and makes it interesting reading the way he carries himself. For that alone I am getting some townie vibes from him. I thought some of his posts and interaction with players were insightful for what it's worth.

Natalija, I liked some of her posts, felt very carefree and genuine, like she does not filter what she wants to say in her head and just says it. That being said, she tends to be a player that is bit difficult to read for me personally. Her personality makes me town read her even if she is scum. But as of now, town lean.

Juan, contributed here and there, I see that he is actively active this time around. While I didn't play much with him, he did tend to be coasting and contributing little from memory. Him being actually be this engaged in the game is something I noticed. Could swing either way tbh. Interested to see if he follows it up DP2. Noted that he voted plat because he didn't want didi yeeted.

BadLight and YoTan : Lumping these two together because I think best way to read them is by their back and forth which I personally thought YoTan looked better overall. BadLight picked some of yotan posts and started nitpicking on the guy, felt like easy way to make a player look bad, he then played it off as he was testing YoTan and town leaned him. Also, I found it funny that he mistaken me for a player called SoulTaker not sure how you can get things confused when my name was clearly stated. I am not familiar with this guy, so not sure if he is capable of faking such thing or not. Felt weird. As for YoTan, i liked the way he handled himself in that interaction. Plus, getting good vibes from the lad.


Lind, i think it's a waste focusing on him right now. He is probably indie/townie. I think his slot resolves itself. Either way he is making good posts overall, you can tell there is thought behind them. Town lean

Rej, didn't like him at the beginning trying to pocket me, but liked his posts as the game progressed. Null/Leaning more on the town side.

JW, his posts didn't ping me even tho he has more than alot of players, not good sign. Null/leaning more on the scum side.

Nesso, I noticed that alot of his posts or more so than anyone else he is paying close attention to the other game. Made couple of posts encouraging player to keep an eye out on it. Not sure I am fan of such thing when I remember a player. But he seems to allowed Ekko and Nat to talk during the NP, which I don't see as a scum ability but hey, who knows. Null.

Soul, besides him having an identity crisis because I am around. His posts didn't ping me much tbh, placed a vote on prof, made few posts stating his opinion and appeared again 10min after the DP ended. Not fan of it per say and wasn't a fan of that weird lie detector post he made, felt forced. But since I am his killer, I am welling to give him the benefit of the doubt. As of now I have him null/scum lean, and looking forward to how he move forward in DP2. Wasn't fa

Didi, I honestly thought the guy was fine? he felt to me like he is being himself. Not necessarily townie but not necessarily scummy either. Felt some of the pushes on him was very opportunistic, voting him because he used words 'maybe' and being unsure about a player was weird. Taking a look at his post as a stand alone, alot of them feels like he is fucking around? lol. Maybe that's just the vibe you get from reading his posts. Null can see him as scum. But also can see him as townie, guess DP2 should get better read since he should be eligible to be lynched.

Ekko, not surprised he is number 1 poster, I seen his posts and actually getting good vibes from him. He addressed different topics and people and even commented and reading the second game and offering help and opinion. I say cop him and save yourself the headach. But from where I am standing as of right now, he is town lean for me. Also, got to say that I liked his interaction with ratchet. Looked TvT.

Firestormer, while I don't remember her being engaging with other players, she made some lengthy posts addressing her reads and thoughts of the game. Looked okay. Would like to see more interactions from her.

Ratchet, what can I say ratchet chan, you will be by my side this entire game. Glad to have you abroad to the townie lock. It's good to see you being outed like this as a townie.

Xladin, didn't do much and voted plat because he was apparently on his ass. Looked like he was defending didi here as well. Wasn't much fan of his posts, nothing pinged me with townie mindset. Scummy.

Hero, I felt like some of his posts were genuine and some were fake, his post regarding my slot early in the game felt genuine for example but felt over reacting. Does not tell me much about his alignment though. However, when I came back to make use of my vote, he stated that he forgot about my slot and that my ass is grass this DP, now that felt fake to me. It's like he wanna scum read for the sake of it. I also found his response regarding ekko explanation about my vote weird, what part of it exactly is that you don't understand? idk felt fake and no thought behind it. But in some instances he did make good posts, he leaded the wagon on plat which is worth to note. Null/leaning more on the scum side.


Charlies, I remember getting good vibes while going through his posts. Usually you can read him well when you apply pressure his way. Null.

Fang, his early game was mostly one liner posts about how he is the omniverse and that he is town. Fluffed a bit, then tried to get some discussion going with ekko which was a good sign in my book. Then went after professor possibly because of prof RP which is weak reason imo. Then switched to LM because of vibe reasons apparently. Can see him either way.


Other players simply did not have any impression on me and are in my null/scum lean.


For the NP results, I am kinda glad ratchet died and can speak as a ghost, not having to worry about his slot is a relief. Unfortunate to see Lalisa gone since I thought she was doing well and liked her reads.

Looking at the lynch candidates at hand, ill need to catch up to the current events but for now I think Xadlin is the most scummy out of that bunch. As for execution, I don't really care they all the same to me.

Vote Lynch: Xaldin

Too long lol.

Please break it into smaller chunks next time. Will read later.

 

[Badalight]

@Lind

Yes but what kind of protective ability is delayed and publicly announced?

 

[Lind]

I actually think almost everything in the night WU works against Didi:

- Ratchet and Lalisa were among the few that didn't want him lynched and they ended up dead.
- WPK who wanted Didi lynched get's targeted with a delayed super kill that shows up in the WU.

And now the votes pile on him pretty fast. Really think we're on the wrong track here.

In fact, I'd prefer a Xadlin or Melkor lynch at this point.

Vote lynch Xadlin.

 

[Lind]

@Lind

Yes but what kind of protective ability is delayed and publicly announced?

Not sure about the design of the ability, but I assume it's to counter a pretty strong protective ability by publicly announcing it.

I mean just targeting them gets you role crushed.

 

[Ratchet]

not really, we r playing favorites. the immunity does not have to be strictly against vote silence. could be against debuffs in general.

there r merits to claiming being vote silenced normally, but its not optimal here given the nature of the lynch mechanics this game, we are planning to have everyone we can get vote for the same wagon, majority style. wagons should not be close to the point where u being vote silenced risks being the lynch deciding factor.

aside from that, thoughts on the player vote silencing you?

I don't think this a strong point, nor is it one worth pressing.

 

[Badalight]

Yeah but flavor wise how is it a booby trap if everyone knows about it. Seems odd imo. That's not a trap at all, it's a warning.

 

[Nessos]

The question is why @Yo Tan Wa and @SinRaven were targeted by that ability?

Was there anyone thinking ScumRaven is Town?

 

[Badalight]

It's like me telling my brother that we're going to have a surprise birthday party for him. That's not a surprise!!!