Game Members Mafia 4 (indies win!)

Campaign
Help with Donations ~ Better than Ads :)
Unwatch
Natalija said:
It’s a damn COOL ability. And I wanted to use it to make a partieh last night :peperave

The thing is I just copied the player list. Then shifted a few people who might be dangerous to make more balanced groups, just based on a hunch.

Which group was Sigi in?
Click to expand...

I dont like the ''balanced groups'' reasoning of here here. Wouldn't it be more beneficial to put all suspects in one group so the damage they can do to town is less high?

Judging by her overall aloof posts so far id not put her down as town right away.
 
Broadcast message:

*analyzes the wagons which nobody else bothered doing so far*
*tries getting reactions from players*
*actually tries narrowing down candidates for Laix' killer*
*is actually trying*

But sure, not a single proactive post in sight.

Sorry, but that line of reasoning looks like you just throw shades at me without even reading anything.
Click to expand...
 
nfcnorth said:
Especially the group that laix was in since that group has a kill in it so it would be good to see thoughts from that group
Click to expand...
Yes, I think we should look into this. But the first group with Sigi is maybe easier to pinpoint scum?
As for Laix, I wouldn’t put it past Scumdesu doing it
Underworld Broker said:
I dont like the ''balanced groups'' reasoning of here here. Wouldn't it be more beneficial to put all suspects in one group so the damage they can do to town is less high?

Judging by her overall aloof posts so far id not put her down as town right away.
Click to expand...
Take it or leave it, that was my reasoning.
 
Melodie said:
all gone
Click to expand...

sad

Underworld Broker said:
how come wad isnt the one talking to flower rn and instead a bunch of other ppl are doing it
Click to expand...

Dragon D. Luffy said:
That's a good point, actually. I think wad is letting us go after each other on purpose just to see who slips first.
Click to expand...

are you guys actually trolling?

i was literally tagging/talking to her for a while and not even an hour passed by between then and the posts you guys made here

i went to go do something
im not actively engaged in the thread at all times

Underworld Broker said:
so uuhh.. are we gonna see wad vs Melo round 2 today close to end of phase or what?
Click to expand...

is there any particular reason you want to see us go at each other again?
 
Hero said:
Too easy? I don’t think many suspect her. She was vocal day 1, almost helpful, then fell off the map.

I might be wrong but I never liked how she was trying to figure out Flower’s abilities and other people got flack for it
Click to expand...
To easy in the sense that a lot of people seem to be okay with it without thinking it through. And Hayumi ain’t here to defend himself.
 
Ratchet said:
Not sure I love the focus on groups. I would honestly assume scum is present in every group, but why focus down on a single group until it's established that the killer is actually in a certain group (as in multiple kills). I think the possibility of scum having certain modifiers on their kill based on who is doing the kill is fairly high, too.
Click to expand...
Main reason I bring it up is this: It gives a reason to force the people talk about people they might not otherwise. Maybe there are multiple scum in the group of laix and they are avoiding talking about each other.
 
is a said:
are you guys actually trolling?

i was literally tagging/talking to her for a while and not even an hour passed by between then and the posts you guys made here

i went to go do something
im not actively engaged in the thread at all times
Click to expand...

i'm still not really a fan of how that interaction went, reminded me of something

what your thoughts on the ppl who suddenly started jumping at flower, did it feel genuine to you?

is a said:
is there any particular reason you want to see us go at each other again?
Click to expand...

ppl like drama so it might get a bit more activity in here

is a said:
>last post was barely more than 2 hours ago
>8th in top posts overall
>almost double your posts

you have some fucking nerve asking me why im quiet LOL
Click to expand...

rude post tbh
 
Underworld Broker said:
i'm still not really a fan of how that interaction went, reminded me of something

what your thoughts on the ppl who suddenly started jumping at flower, did it feel genuine to you?
Click to expand...

truthfully i dont trust DDL or JoJo who were the 2 people who 'sided' with me against her, if you could call it that
i cant for sure say if their concerns were genuine or not but its definitely made me consider that the road i am taking, the road to "AWWWW SHIET FLOWER IS SCUM YO" is the wrong path after all



ppl like drama so it might get a bit more activity in here
Click to expand...

would you call our interaction with each other drama?
i thought she was scum last phase, i still think she's scum but ive been sidetracked by other people i wanna see get got first, and she has completely reverted to her early day 1 activity/mentality

could i try and bring her back into the light again? sure, but i dont actually have anything new on her so is there a point to reintroducing that case against her



rude post tbh
Click to expand...

poke the bear and see what happens etc. :ufdup
 
Owner Of A Lonely Heart said:
Also, does everyone instinctively say "hello mafia friends" it feels like an overused template or just filler nonsense, I mean yes a greeting is sometimes nice, but we are at the same time playing mafia here

[change vote lynch is a]

yes, I'm rereading, thanks for not noticing
Click to expand...

Owner Of A Lonely Heart said:
Hostile indie with difficult wincon maybe? This was one of their first posts. Why would it be difficult?

[change vote lynch Natalija]
Click to expand...

do you actually have any stake in your votes

like do you really think you can manifest any of these votes into becoming a lynch

we have what, 5 hours until day end?

what are you accomplishing by these throwaway useless votes

seems like ur avoiding vote tracking rn
 
Pool Party Nitty said:
The game has been divided into 3 groups. These groups are:

Iwandesu
John Wayne
Juan
Karma
Kira Yagami
Laix
Legend
Lord Genome
Lord Melkor
Melodie
Nessos

During the night phase, you will only be able to target players who are in your group, so plan your actions accordingly.
Click to expand...

Iwan, Melkor, Nessos, Melodie

Between Melkor & Nessos. Who is more likely to be mafia y’all?
 
is a said:
truthfully i dont trust DDL or JoJo who were the 2 people who 'sided' with me against her, if you could call it that
i cant for sure say if their concerns were genuine or not but its definitely made me consider that the road i am taking, the road to "AWWWW SHIET FLOWER IS SCUM YO" is the wrong path after all





would you call our interaction with each other drama?
i thought she was scum last phase, i still think she's scum but ive been sidetracked by other people i wanna see get got first, and she has completely reverted to her early day 1 activity/mentality

could i try and bring her back into the light again? sure, but i dont actually have anything new on her so is there a point to reintroducing that case against her





poke the bear and see what happens etc. :ufdup
Click to expand...

Jojo is on his town meta.
Trust me who trusts in you.
 
Hero said:
Iwan, Melkor, Nessos, Melodie

Between Melkor & Nessos. Who is more likely to be mafia y’all?
Click to expand...

before this phase i would have said nessos 10 out of 10 times but i actually liked some of his posts and i think too many people have aggro'd him over the last 2 days which to me makes it seem like he is a potential patsy being set up by mafia while lord melkor has literally eluded all discussion

so melkor
 
is a said:
do you actually have any stake in your votes
Click to expand...

yes

like do you really think you can manifest any of these votes into becoming a lynch
Click to expand...

It depends on what else I see.

we have what, 5 hours until day end?
Click to expand...

I know. I'm finally off of work. Generally, I don't often play 24 hour days as it is hard to stay active consistently throughout the whole day with work being in the way.

what are you accomplishing by these throwaway useless votes
Click to expand...

They aren't necessarily throwaways. I'm letting players know that I'm suspicious of them because of x thing they said or did.

seems like ur avoiding vote tracking rn
Click to expand...

what do you mean? generally someone tallies them, so I wouldn't say that that would be avoiding
 
is a said:
truthfully i dont trust DDL or JoJo who were the 2 people who 'sided' with me against her, if you could call it that
i cant for sure say if their concerns were genuine or not but its definitely made me consider that the road i am taking, the road to "AWWWW SHIET FLOWER IS SCUM YO" is the wrong path after all
Click to expand...

what was your guess on flower anyways? like do you expect her too be mafia and be rather active with the way she's been responding or you consider her to be more of an indie? has felt more townie to me so far, or lets say shes prolly not mafia and low chance of indie

is a said:
would you call our interaction with each other drama?
i thought she was scum last phase, i still think she's scum but ive been sidetracked by other people i wanna see get got first, and she has completely reverted to her early day 1 activity/mentality

could i try and bring her back into the light again? sure, but i dont actually have anything new on her so is there a point to reintroducing that case against her
Click to expand...

it was definitely nice seeing you two interact lol btw what happened to LG iirc he's been like ''i think she a jester or town hurp durp'', dont remember him posting today tbh
i also think melo is scum, weird posts, not much doing so far

is a said:
poke the bear and see what happens etc. :ufdup
Click to expand...

i was actually expecting that so was fun doing it :catpole
 
is a said:
before this phase i would have said nessos 10 out of 10 times but i actually liked some of his posts and i think too many people have aggro'd him over the last 2 days which to me makes it seem like he is a potential patsy being set up by mafia while lord melkor has literally eluded all discussion

so melkor
Click to expand...
WAD you fucking perfectly describe whatever I'm thinking every fucking time. Fuck it. Im calling you my strongest townread from here on out.

Yeah call it buddying all you want fuckers, I'm riding it! :catpole
 
@Flower

https://www.narutoforums.org/posts/62119501/

but how do you know that i don't know you're town
what if in fact i AM scum all along
i would certainly presume you're town but im not gonna be pedantic and presume ur creating this hypothetical in the scenario in which we're both town (the aforementioned what if)

anyways, did i not answer this question with broki?
i feel less confident about nurturing a potential scumread on you considering no one that i particularly read as town has 'jumped' you
 
RemChu said:
and this is a complete 360 for wad compared to his scum game in git gud.

Dude is in the dark like the rest of us. Hard to fake being lost.

he is town.

Git gud he was cool and collected with his posts not much figuring out of things when he gave his reads.

/my perspective
Click to expand...

Indies could be lost. The problem with this is that some players are capable of changing their playstyle from what they just played. I don't know what his threshold is.

As for faking in general, you can pull from different experiences; I guess imo faking feelings or tone is harder than just being lost or confused.
 
I think Juan and Melkor are good choices.

I don't think I can effectively iso on my phone so could someone look into Juan's posts and his interactions with Laix?

I'm going to [Vote Lynch Lord Melkor] for now. Nitty's announcement to save him was definitely the use of an ability and I can't imagine a town role using that to save him when they could have otherwise spoken up for example if they were masons.
 
Shizune

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 1, guests: 0)
Back
Top