Game Favorites '22 - THE FINALS (purple mafia wins!)

[Legend]

Has anyone from group 1 actually read the shit show that is group 2 btw?

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

Has anyone from group 1 actually read the shit show that is group 2 btw?

I'm reading it now. Not super excited that there are less posts than group 1s to go on.

 

[Hidden]

Has anyone from group 1 actually read the shit show that is group 2 btw?

why would i subject myself to that

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

why would i subject myself to that

because group 2 has purple cookies!!!

 

[Santí]

Some people like Santi are into that fetish

I don't have many opportunities to get into character these days, your old but unexpected face will ignite the flame of youth which once burned in my heart for one more Favorites. The bravado which has paved the way to many great victories in the past, rooted in the unbreakable foundation of absolute faith in myself

 

[Santí]

Now someone help me kill Hero

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

Now someone help me kill Hero

What did he do wrong this game?

 

[Santí]

What did he do wrong this game?

Be useless

 

[Santí]

tl;dr he investigated me, fucked around and got poisoned, claimed to be a role cop who changes alignment to mirror his target due to character flavor which makes him mimic/impersonate said target, and I had nothing else to do at night after he begged me to heal him so I did and now I'm having healer's remorse because idk if I trust him still

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

let's see SinRaven interacted with both Melodie and WormJuice from the start. let's keep reading and see if he may have given away other teammates

---
Soulkiller's posts seem non-threating...,maybe he's an indie, something feels different about his posts, but I'm not particularly sure what it is.

Soulkiller and Lind for indies

Badalight-old meta reasons (it could totally be wrong), Juan, Santi, DrProfessor83, Kira Yagami, and Soul for purple ones

 

[Hidden]

tl;dr he investigated me, fucked around and got poisoned, claimed to be a role cop who changes alignment to mirror his target due to character flavor which makes him mimic/impersonate said target, and I had nothing else to do at night after he begged me to heal him so I did and now I'm having healer's remorse because idk if I trust him still

um, did he actually claim that he changes alignment?

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

Be useless

That seems to be a lot of people. Why only him?

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

tl;dr he investigated me, fucked around and got poisoned, claimed to be a role cop who changes alignment to mirror his target due to character flavor which makes him mimic/impersonate said target, and I had nothing else to do at night after he begged me to heal him so I did and now I'm having healer's remorse because idk if I trust him still

hmm still processing that

 

[Santí]

um, did he actually claim that he changes alignment?

I’m town. My role just had a drawback (I guess it’s apart of the flavor).

I’m being vague without revealing my identity. But when I investigate a player, I imitate them. That’s why my alignment changes depending on who I use it on.

 

[Hidden]

what are hero's checks so far?

 

[Hidden]

what are hero's checks so far?

@Santí

 

[Hidden]

what are hero's checks so far?

Also @Hero tbh lol

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

I’ll read their posts and get back to you. I’ve just kind of been posting and not reading.

Apathy in a role madness game to me is odd in general. I found the post I quoted more odd because I’m not sure how a player’s apathy indicates alignment or how said player can claim SK isn’t mafia 60 or so posts in with maybe 5 or less posts

this does seem like a real thought

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

Which submitted character fits that ability? If that's character is main character then there's a high chance he is scum because most players who got main character role turned out to be scum in group 1.

 

[Hidden]

Which submitted character fits that ability? If that's character is main character then there's a high chance he is scum because most players who got main character role turned out to be scum in group 1.

that's a red mafia thing, no reason to think that applies to purple

 

[Santí]

what are hero's checks so far?

iirc he said he was being careful with his checks and thus I'm his only scan (which he got poisoned for), but he alleges he knows my name and all my abilities.

Idk, he could be town and maybe I'm just trippin

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

that's a red mafia thing, no reason to think that applies to purple

How do you know it's only red mafia with roles like that?

 

[hammer]

What kind of playground tier fight is this.

If you're displaying your online activity in a Mafia game, you are basically signing a waiver consenting to be watched. Either hide your activity in your settings or accept it like the rest of us do.

I legit would look at my sus list and see who was invis and see how many invis members where in the thread. like legit its a way to find scum

 

[Badalight]

Badalight-old meta reasons (it could totally be wrong), Juan, Santi, DrProfessor83, Kira Yagami, and Soul for purple ones

what does this even mean

you've never even seen my town play!

 

[Hidden]

iirc he said he was being careful with his checks and thus I'm his only scan (which he got poisoned for), but he alleges he knows my name and all my abilities.

Idk, he could be town and maybe I'm just trippin

I.... doubt that. Unless group 2 just doesn't know how to read or something, because according to the op if an alignment change happens it gets announced... why would hero claim that if he knew he could turn mafia lol

 

[Hidden]

How do you know it's only red mafia with roles like that?

I don't? How do you know that's a purple thing? What I'm saying is that seems like a random thing to automatically assume might be a purple mafia trait, and there hasn't been any indication that being the case so far as far as I'm aware

 

[Santí]

I legit would look at my sus list and see who was invis and see how many invis members where in the thread. like legit its a way to find scum

I mean, it's technically angling and unsportsmanlike etc, etc.

But I'm not naïve enough to believe a bunch a nibbas just like you aren't all doing it

 

[hammer]

I mean, it's technically angling and unsportsmanlike etc, etc.

But I'm not naïve enough to believe a bunch a nibbas just like you aren't all doing it

like if you where online all up before the mafia game but all of a sudden you're invis? that's more of someone's meta at that point.

 

[Legend]

I don't have many opportunities to get into character these days, your old but unexpected face will ignite the flame of youth which once burned in my heart for one more Favorites. The bravado which has paved the way to many great victories in the past, rooted in the unbreakable foundation of absolute faith in myself

Well thats a good thing, Id rather not play with someone who was a shell of themself. I want you at your best.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

what does this even mean

you've never even seen my town play!

Gottem, you just claimed that you are not town this game.

 

[Hidden]

I.... doubt that. Unless group 2 just doesn't know how to read or something, because according to the op if an alignment change happens it gets announced... why would hero claim that if he knew he could turn mafia lol

idk it's just like, the only time hero claims is when he got poisoned and might actually want/need someone to help him out with healing? That's the one time he happened to investigate? Seems real sketchy

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

I don't? How do you know that's a purple thing? What I'm saying is that seems like a random thing to automatically assume might be a purple mafia trait, and there hasn't been any indication that being the case so far as far as I'm aware

I'm just assuming the possibility since I saw 3 purple mafia flips. My Girlfriend, Teutonic Knight and Werner Heisenburg. These are real life concept. Real life concept could be mafia/town in group 1 mafia. So I assume it could be the same case in group 2 mafia too.

 

[Santí]

I.... doubt that. Unless group 2 just doesn't know how to read or something, because according to the op if an alignment change happens it gets announced... why would hero claim that if he knew he could turn mafia lol

I was thinking the same thing when I initially called him out because no such announcement was made in group 2, but the implication seems to be I'm the only scan he's chosen so far.

If he's town and had scanned me, another town, no announcement would have been made because there wouldn't have been a change in alignment.

 

[JoJo]

what are the reads for g1

@Didi @Santí @Badalight @John Wayne @Juan

unironically give me either the entire player list and what you think of their alignment or give me a top 5 for both town and scum with at least a few sentences

thanks

 

[Badalight]

I'm just assuming the possibility since I saw 3 purple mafia flips. My Girlfriend, Teutonic Knight and Werner Heisenburg. These are real life concept. Real life concept could be mafia/town in group 1 mafia. So I assume it could be the same case in group 2 mafia too.

Good catch. Especially because I was thinking Iwan might have my submitted role of Deus Ex Machina. Would make sense with none of our shit ever working on him.

 

[JoJo]

i will obvi do the same

 

[Legend]

I was thinking the same thing when I initially called him out because no such announcement was made in group 2, but the implication seems to be I'm the only scan he's chosen so far.

If he's town and had scanned me, another town, no announcement would have been made because there wouldn't have been a change in alignment.

The thing is, if he is telling the truth it could be a useful ability. But it could also just be a asspull excuse to buy time after he was caught. Did anyone else in your group check him?

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

Good catch. Especially because I was thinking Iwan might have my submitted role of Deus Ex Machina. Would make sense with none of our shit ever working on him.

I made a mistake. Teutonic Knight is from Age of Empire game. Heisen and Girlfriend are still from real life. Maybe Shizune distributed the roles randomly. But if there's a player who got main character role in group 2 it still ping me

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

My personal opinion on SK is that he’s a new player maybe even new to the forum that doesn’t know favorites history. I also haven’t been active on NF in a while so I don’t know what the scene is like but I doubt y’all have that many games active around FAVORITES if NF is how I remember it.

Based off this, what he is saying doesn’t make sense. Plus, if I’m going to be active, he doesn’t have an excuse because I’m notorious for inactivity whether I like my role or not. Nitty is an excellent host. I’m pretty mid, but it’s aggravating having people throw your hard work back in your face and not respect it. I would vote him up on that alone.

as for alignment, it could go either way. He is giving me a Juan vibe of apathy and I find that more common among people who are mafia and trying to slide under the radar. Unfortunately for SK he doesn’t have the clout to act the way he does so it’s backfiring.


Not at all. I’ve played mafia with my brother on this website who theoretically should be the most familiar with me and it never produced anything.

I’m also slow on the mafia lingo, but metas (Shark Skin is an exception) and white knighting (I think that’s what it is called) is all bullshit.

I guess what I mean to say is that familiarity with a player imo doesn’t give you an advantage over other players. I just go by how they’re playing currently/what’s tangible.

I'll actually counter that. If Soulkiller is a relatively new, that changes everything. The apathy would make sense here. That would mean that he isn't one of us that has been addicted to mafia. Within my first 10 games of playing mafia, I backed out of game for in real life reasons, but I was a serial killer that game. In hindsight as a veteran player, serial killer is an awesome role to get. As a new player, you don't totally get some of the nuances of mafia until you are truly in it or have spent countless games obsessing over it. Apathy towards mafia is something I have seen and experienced.

Now, I'm less sure about him being indie. I need to see who pushes on him.

 

[Legend]

I made a mistake. Teutonic Knight is from Age of Empire game. Heisen and Girlfriend are still from real life. Maybe Shizune distributed the roles randomly. But if there's a player who got main character role in group 2 it still ping me

It might not always be a theme or a obvious theme connecting the roles.

 

[Badalight]

what are the reads for g1

@Didi @Santí @Badalight @John Wayne @Juan

unironically give me either the entire player list and what you think of their alignment or give me a top 5 for both town and scum with at least a few sentences

thanks

Scum:
John Wayne - Has posted just enough to not be put up for execution. Has given basically zero reads all game. When asked for reads just gives broad statements. Has contributed nothing at all. Always comes in at the end to join bandwagons. Soft defended Iwan who is almost certainly scum.
Hero - Has been pretty useless townie and is a big reason why plat got lynched over WJ (confirmed scum). Also made a really weird claim about his abilities
Tinky Winky - Has contributed literally nothing all game


Town:
Ratchet - confirmed dead townie
Myself - I know I am town
Rej - Their ability claim was very believable to me, for reasons... I had the same feeling with Xaldin and I was right about that when everyone else thought he was scum

Tbh those are the only "strong" feelings I have atm. SK and Soul I'd also keep an eye out on. Soul has not been helpful all game and has done almost nothing to stand out which is a bit sus. Juan I'm not sure but he lied about me which was weird. I feel like it's just him being dumb and not understanding the mechanics though, but def could be scum.

Most of the players I felt good about died so, rip.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

But yeah, if Soulkiller is new, then his posts are going to feel funny as he may not have mafia lingo or rhythm or whatever down. Or he hasn't necessarily learned there's a certain way to talk within a mafia game. I guess I'm trying to say a lot of us have been through the ringer. We kind of know sometimes how we are perceived or craft posts based on different perceptions or understanding of how we should look in a sense to others to help garner reads.

I guess I'll say that I think in order to get a read of him I think I need to see how other flipped people have interacted with him.

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

>we're getting soulkiller vs ratchet this early in the game

tune out and vote them both folks

I think this could be tmi. scum notoriously will bring up 2 players arguing or conflicting with each other. Sometimes they will call them both town. Other times they kind of just ignore them.

FoS Juan if that wasn't clear

---
so light town for Soulkiller

 

[Badalight]

what is tmi!!!

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

what is tmi!!!

Too much indie

Spoiler:

Too much information

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

*sees Alwaysmind is here* Is it just me does it seem kind of empty here? Though I guess it could be late for people or something...hmm

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

what is tmi!!!

Too much information, or basically oversharing they have knowledge that this group of people is likely town or indie

 

[Badalight]

^ (use bro) why is this a bunch of “they did nothing” clearly in 4k posts someone did something. u just repeated urself p much here and said nothing of substance.

do a vote analysis. right now.

Because they did nothing. Do you wanna iso their posts and tell me what the fuck they did! Juan Wayne literally did nothing except would come in and bandwagon every single leading lynch. When asked about reads he was like "ionno, active players seem town" or something to that effect.

Hero voted plat which was the main reason WJ did not get lynched, which is pretty incriminating.

SK also did last minute vote on plat to change wagon away from WJ leading to play lynch.

 

[Hidden]

I was thinking the same thing when I initially called him out because no such announcement was made in group 2, but the implication seems to be I'm the only scan he's chosen so far.

If he's town and had scanned me, another town, no announcement would have been made because there wouldn't have been a change in alignment.

I mean yeah it technically checks out sure. It's just a nice big coincidence that's the only time he's investigated someone apparently, and it just so happens that he got poisoned from it it sounds like lol.

Also, on another note, this means santi is more likely town. I mean not guaranteed or anything but it does make it more likely. Just because if hero is town santi being mafia requires hero getting redirected or something. And if hero is mafia it requires him blatantly tie-ing himself to his partner.

 

[Hidden]

I made a mistake. Teutonic Knight is from Age of Empire game. Heisen and Girlfriend are still from real life. Maybe Shizune distributed the roles randomly. But if there's a player who got main character role in group 2 it still ping me

Didn't we just establish that like, there's no evidence for that yet for purple wtf

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

Didn't we just establish that like, there's no evidence for that yet for purple wtf

I open to any possibilities

 

[JoJo]

Because they did nothing. Do you wanna iso their posts and tell me what the fuck they did! Juan Wayne literally did nothing except would come in and bandwagon every single leading lynch. When asked about reads he was like "ionno, active players seem town" or something to that effect.

Hero voted plat which was the main reason WJ did not get lynched, which is pretty incriminating.

SK also did last minute vote on plat to change wagon away from WJ leading to play lynch.

idk

give me a vote analysis right now

with ur opinions and memories of the events

or else i’m just gonna redirect the lynch to you

 

[Hidden]

I open to any possibilities

aka needlessly opening options to throw scum at group 2 people for nothing but their claim got it

Like read the person based on how they're playing, don't have the claim "ping you" when there's actually no given connection there smh

 

[Owner Of A Lonely Heart]

Didi also claims to be town.

Tinky winky seems to react to a lot of posts, but I still haven't seen much activity from them...post wise

 

[Badalight]

idk

give me a vote analysis right now

with ur opinions and memories of the events

or else i’m just gonna redirect the lynch to you

wtf do you mean vote analysis. I told you the votes that I found sus. JW always coming in after the lynch was set in stone and bandwagoning, hero starting the train on plat which saved wj, SK cementing the lynch on plat at the last minuet which saved wj

those are all red flags

 

[Hidden]

Lowkey last day phase in group 1 I was just voting TS to cover a secondary wagon for lynch shenanigans. This time I kinda want to lynch him actually lmao I've kinda hated this day so far from him

Plus tbh it could've been the reason we didn't have lynch shenanigans happen that last day. Maybe TAC didn't get the lynch save from WAD's role, but ts was also mafia and so there was no reason to use it lmao

 

[JoJo]

Lowkey last day phase in group 1 I was just voting TS to cover a secondary wagon for lynch shenanigans. This time I kinda want to lynch him actually lmao I've kinda hated this day so far from him

Plus tbh it could've been the reason we didn't have lynch shenanigans happen that last day. Maybe TAC didn't get the lynch save from WAD's role, but ts was also mafia and so there was no reason to use it lmao

iirc wads redirect couldn’t be used successively

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

Lowkey last day phase in group 1 I was just voting TS to cover a secondary wagon for lynch shenanigans. This time I kinda want to lynch him actually lmao I've kinda hated this day so far from him

Plus tbh it could've been the reason we didn't have lynch shenanigans happen that last day. Maybe TAC didn't get the lynch save from WAD's role, but ts was also mafia and so there was no reason to use it lmao

This post doesn't make sense. I was on the The Ancient lynch since day 1.

 

[Hidden]

Lowkey last day phase in group 1 I was just voting TS to cover a secondary wagon for lynch shenanigans. This time I kinda want to lynch him actually lmao I've kinda hated this day so far from him

Plus tbh it could've been the reason we didn't have lynch shenanigans happen that last day. Maybe TAC didn't get the lynch save from WAD's role, but ts was also mafia and so there was no reason to use it lmao

I get that technically it's optimal to go for group 2 people, but honestly TS is giving me that gut mafia feeling I've been getting the whole game from mafia lol

 

[Hidden]

iirc wads redirect couldn’t be used successively

the first time it wasn't wad's redirect thing that saved tac. It was deus ex machina's

 

[JoJo]

the first time it wasn't wad's redirect thing that saved tac. It was deus ex machina's

oh shit i didn’t even notice that

 

[Hidden]

oh shit i didn’t even notice that

or wait. Actually I jsut checked and I don't think deus ex could do that? Either way it wasn't spidermans thing I don't think? Hold on maybe I'm wrong on that though let me investigate lol

 

[Hidden]

huh yeah I could've sworn deus ex could save from the lynch but I guess I'm wrong on that. So maybe it was spiderman's. Though was WAD even there that day to use it? Lmao. I guess it could've been someone piloting that.

I could've sworn there was another lynch save option at some point though whatever.

My point still mostly stands that I've hated ts today lmao

 

[Hidden]

This post doesn't make sense. I was on the The Ancient lynch since day 1.

....okay? That doesn't really relate to why I was pushing you lol. And I was talking about tac getting saved from scum abilities not you pushing him or not

 

[JoJo]

no i'm not fuckin doing ur homework for u fuck off
ask one of the other 4 slaves you tagged to do it

vote lynch bada

 

[JoJo]

let’s see what this bozo flips

 

[Hidden]

Also I get revan is probably town but can we just yeet this slot they've made ~15 posts the entire game

[Vote Execute Revan]

Tbh unless Kira or whoever the other g2 slot is mafia both cooler and revan are probably town, but at least cooler has enough posts to be read into

 

[Badalight]

vote lynch bada

even if you wanna lynch me i will delay my death until late game u bitch

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

....okay? That doesn't really relate to why I was pushing you lol. And I was talking about tac getting saved from scum abilities not you pushing him or not

If I was his scum buddy I won't pro his lynch from day 1 until day 5. Lynch immunity also cannot be used to save the same players 2 days in a row asask when I saw from scum abilities.

Why is it bad to consider all possibilities? Did you see any town flip main character?

 

[JoJo]

even if you wanna lynch me i will delay my death until late game u bitch

LMFAOOOOOOOOOO

u haven’t seen my role u clown

throw the damn towel

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

Did you see any town flip main character?

In group 2

 

[Badalight]

LMFAOOOOOOOOOO

u haven’t seen my role u clown

throw the damn towel

i mean that's what they said when they tried to kill me the last 2 times and it didn't work so

 

[Santí]

Also I get revan is probably town but can we just yeet this slot they've made ~15 posts the entire game

[Vote Execute Revan]

Tbh unless Kira or whoever the other g2 slot is mafia both cooler and revan are probably town, but at least cooler has enough posts to be read into

I've got a town read on the posts Kira has made thus far, and it was the same for sworder tbh and I was a bit annoyed by that day kill.

 

[Hidden]

If I was his scum buddy I won't pro his lynch from day 1 until day 5. Lynch immunity also cannot be used to save the same players 2 days in a row asask when I saw from scum abilities.

Why is it bad to consider all possibilities? Did you see any town flip main character?

And why are you so obsessed with leaving open scum pushes on people from g2 based on nothing but their character claim? And yes maybe? Serika Onoe is the female protagonist of that game according to google so. And Phosphophyllite from Land of the Lustrous from game 2

Plus i'd have to look at how hard you actually pushed for tac. But just cause you pushed one scum doesn't actually clear you lmao

 

[JoJo]

i mean that's what they said when they tried to kill me the last 2 times and it didn't work so

this aint a kill, it's a mfin lynch

it's over for you man, conclusion, the end of your story, finito, donezo, etc.

tell ur mafia buddies to hit me with everything they got tonight

 

[nfcnorth]

Personally I am Cooler > or = Revan >>>>>>>>>>>>> Kira for execute

 

[Badalight]

this aint a kill, it's a mfin lynch

it's over for you man, conclusion, the end of your story, finito, donezo, etc.

tell ur mafia buddies to hit me with everything they got tonight

I will survive a lynch too, lol

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

And why are you so obsessed with leaving open scum pushes on people from g2 based on nothing but their character claim? And yes maybe? Serika Onoe is the female protagonist of that game according to google so. And Phosphophyllite from Land of the Lustrous from game 2

Plus i'd have to look at how hard you actually pushed for tac. But just cause you pushed one scum doesn't actually clear you lmao

Serika is the second main character no primary main character like Inuyasha/Peter Parker/Ash.

I didn't notice Phosphophyllite I made a mistake. The roles could be distributed randomly.

I already asked Nessos the explanation for his scum reads. It's like you get main character role and you hate people who think main character role could be mafia

 

[Hidden]

Serika is the second main character no primary main character like Inuyasha/Peter Parker/Ash.

I didn't notice Phosphophyllite I made a mistake. The roles could be distributed randomly.

I already asked Nessos the explanation for his scum reads. It's like you get main character role and you hate people who think main character role could be mafia

rolefishing smh

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

rolefishing smh

I assume that's your reason to hate my read. I didn't say your ability btw.