Game Favorites '22 - THE FINALS (purple mafia wins!)

[Nessos]

When I was studying for my exam, I did miss a night of sending in actions.

Which Night?

 

[Hero]

Which Night?

I’m not sure but I can double check. It’s right when my activity dropped. I think that was day/night 3

 

[Karma]

[vote lynch badalight]

 

[Nessos]

I’m not sure but I can double check. It’s right when my activity dropped. I think that was day/night 3

Which night you targeted 2?

 

[Hero]

Which night you targeted 2?

You’re asking who I targeted night 2?

Lind

 

[Mich]

if you'd read our game you'd know that I've been starting to trust them less and less



Lmao you should've seen Oddjutsu's role if you think that's outlandish

that's convenient to say tbh

I skimmed it, but it's too complicated for me

 

[Nessos]

You’re asking who I targeted night 2?

Lind

No at which night you targeted 2 player?

 

[Nessos]

[Change Vote Lynch Hero]

 

[Karma]

imo we should put baba in first place to test this unlynchable claim tbh

 

[Shizune]

>he put himself in his own game
>had more time to prepare a roast than anyone
>and he still only got second place

Lmao I just realized this, rough L Juan

DrProf was not playing about that roast. He came in like he had a personal vendetta against Juan AND me

 

[Badalight]

imo we should put baba in first place to test this unlynchable claim tbh

I never said I was unlynchable, for the record. Please re-read. I said a lynch won't get rid of me and that I'd stick around for a bit. Also why on earth would you want to waste a lynch on such a thing when there are tons of viable targets in group 2.

Also I'm a big reason we hit 2 scum in one day, thank you very much. If not for me I'm not sure the Iwan execute would have gone through (I've been actively targeting and sussing him more than anyone) and it's very possible FS (town) would have been lynched over SR (Scum). I pushed for SR due to my theory of iwan and FS bussing, which seems to be confirmed correct.

 

[Badalight]

To clarify, the lynch would not hit 2nd place in votes instead of me. It would hit me. It just wouldn't get rid of me fully.

 

[Lord Melkor]

In no particular order

Fang, Santí, Lind, Juan

For the avoidance of doubt, all were town?

 

[Badalight]

@Hero yes very interested especially on that Lind result. Why have you not shared this until now? You realize you are either #1 or #2 in terms of lynch votes right now, yes?

 

[DrProfessor83]

so you believe that either I am a naive cop or the mafia has been fucking my results and keeping me alive for a long time because of it?

Weird you left out a GF passive as an option.

I think one of juan or bada are scum here. Not both tho, very unlikely.

What do you think of Bada if Iwan flips purple?

Hayooo Michelle ^^ good to see you around!

Well, it mostly stems from Bada and Juan interactions, if you go back and ISO they basically were calling each other liar pretty much. Was weird interaction and they were at each other throat for a while. Don't think it was a TvT interaction.

Pretty sure what happened between these two could be explained if you just actually think about what the two were saying for a minute + look at Iwan.

And if not then you can just ask them to clarify now that Iwan is some type of exposed scum.

@Juan does Iwan possible being bus driven change your mind on Bada’s action hitting Iwan like he said?

Weird you aren’t thinking about these things beyond a very surface level or trying to look into them SK. If you’re town it’s very lazy.

iirc he said he was being careful with his checks and thus I'm his only scan

This makes absolutely no sense to me if he’s town. Like if he changes what he scans when he scans scum who gives a shit. Why would you ever be careful to not hit scum if you’re a cop whose consequence would be turning into a miller?

Pros - Find scum, Cons - become miller

Conclusion - I better not scan any scum this game lol.

No townie cop should ever think like that. Why would he give a shit if it could catch scum. Why is he more worried about what he’s gonna scan than catching scum lol.

Why he claimed invest and got us a guilty. He then got poisoned and I healed him. That is a waste of a lynch.

And Dr. Professor gets guilty result on someone in group 2 so he most likely is a cop.

I have not gotten any guilties lol.

That's why I don't totally trust hero, Dr. Proff, or Didi. Good chance one of the three is lying imo.

i don't even remember, who did prof check and get guilty on?

You don’t even remember it but you don’t trust me for it lol. Seems like a legit thought process

tinky winky
soulkiller
lord melkor

in that order

[Vote Lynch Tinky Winky]
[Vote Execute Revan]

Why are you scum reading Tinky and what do you think about the innocent on LM.

What should be caught here is why Hero would choose to role cop Santi when he was being vouched by 2 players.

This is a good question lol.

Ratchey also implied here. Meaning Professor got guilty result on mafia and it's suicide to frame his own scum buddy if Professor gor guilty result if Professor is indeed mafia.

I still don't understand by Ratchet post saying Professor did kamikaze if Professor is indeed mafia. Kamikaze means Professor threw the game or he exposed his own scum buddy.

No, Ratchet is talking about how I’d have permanently destroyed any good will in future games, and tarnished my reputation if I’m scum.

On second thought though, I am reading Hero's posts. His claim is actually somewhat believable. He knew Fang's role name, which would make sense if he is literally imitating people... which was his claim.

That said, he needs to get in here and spill the info he's been withholding.

His claim has a major hole in it (or his thought process behind his actions do)

Also I just realized during this catch up that he’s probably The Thing (my submission) which seems perfect for a giga scum role or a nasty indie role.

Then we have a possible science them starting in Purple Mafia with My Girlfriend and Worm’s guy.

 

[Karma]

im gonna have to read group 2 huh?

To clarify, the lynch would not hit 2nd place in votes instead of me. It would hit me. It just wouldn't get rid of me fully.

who would u lynch today?

 

[DrProfessor83]

DrProf was not playing about that roast. He came in like he had a personal vendetta against Juan AND me

It was my solemn duty lol.

 

[Hero]

For the avoidance of doubt, all were town?

From the summation of their abilities, I strongly believe so. I can give their role names too and a summary if you’d like.

@Hero yes very interested especially on that Lind result. Why have you not shared this until now? You realize you are either #1 or #2 in terms of lynch votes right now, yes?

I just woke up, that’s why. You can checked the game. When our votes started stacking, I was nowhere to be found.

 

[Hero]

*check the game

 

[Badalight]

im gonna have to read group 2 huh?



who would u lynch today?

My vote is on JW atm. I have no comments about group 1 people because I didn't read it and there prob aren't much scum left alive anyway. I think Hero is an okay choice for the fact that no one has cleared him, it's weird to have 6 cops, and he has been very quiet about his information until now.

 

[Badalight]

From the summation of their abilities, I strongly believe so. I can give their role names too and a summary if you’d like.

I just woke up, that’s why. You can checked the game. When our votes started stacking, I was nowhere to be found.

Yes but this is the first time we've heard about you checking Lind or Juan. Why wait until now to reveal that info?

Also, is this post confirmation that you're not actually alignment checking people? If so, then Santi isn't cleared either is he?

 

[Karma]

My vote is on JW atm. I have no comments about group 1 people because I didn't read it and there prob aren't much scum left alive anyway. I think Hero is an okay choice for the fact that no one has cleared him, it's weird to have 6 cops, and he has been very quiet about his information until now.

lol theres no way theres 6 cops

who r these claimed cops besides didi and hero?

 

[Lord Melkor]

From the summation of their abilities, I strongly believe so. I can give their role names too and a summary if you’d like.

I just woke up, that’s why. You can checked the game. When our votes started stacking, I was nowhere to be found.

I quess so. I am especially interested in Lind.

So is @Didi only traditional claimed cop in group 2? It makes him close to being confirmed as town then. Scum should have a role cop rather than alignment cop.

 

[DrProfessor83]

Lean town on Juan for the host roast ability.

Santi is almost for sure town with the Hero result.

Early Group 1 impressions just from reading this thread:
- Hidden - super town
- Draeke - town
-
- TS - lean scum, he is going after Draeke for scum but also calling him a dirty stalker and imo if he actually thinks about it for a few seconds going through that trouble to stalk someone actually seems like more of a townie thing to do so it’s weird to turn around and tunnel them as scum for it.
- Owner - scummy vibes. They made some useless commentary post that ping’d me as just posting to post. Did have some actually good posts between though, but if scum it’s easy to actually scum hunting into Group 2 if you’re Group 1 scum here. Didn’t like their posts about my Pariaton RP but maybe they just don’t know anything about Pariston.

-
Back to Hero, gonna go look at the specific timing of that Plat wagon and if it really did time badly with the WJ wagon.

 

[Badalight]

lol theres no way theres 6 cops

who r these claimed cops besides didi and hero?

Didi, Hero, YTW (dead town), Charles (dead town), Fang (dead town), and Dr. Prof??? Still confused about that last one

 

[Hero]

Yes but this is the first time we've heard about you checking Lind or Juan. Why wait until now to reveal that info?

Also, is this post confirmation that you're not actually alignment checking people? If so, then Santi isn't cleared either is he?

Thats correct. That’s why I also haven’t been the most forthcoming because what could I add to the discussion if all I’m getting are names & a summation of abilities. I technically can’t clear anyone. I can make guesses though based on the information/summation nitty gives me.

also I’ve been inactive so there’s that aspect

 

[Hero]

The only way we could verify my investigees is if I impersonate one of them again during the night and see what I scan as.

any player that I imitate becomes apart of a bank of roles i can imitate

 

[DrProfessor83]

Also I still don’t like Soul lol. Believe he needs to go.

Didn’t love SK today but I think the chances of 1 of Didi/Soul being scum are better than SK being scum rn and he doesn’t look aligned with them in his interactions.

 

[DrProfessor83]

Dr. Prof??? Still confused about that last one

Stop including me in the cop list lol.

 

[DrProfessor83]

Lean town on Juan for the host roast ability.

Santi is almost for sure town with the Hero result.

Early Group 1 impressions just from reading this thread:
- Hidden - super town
- Draeke - town
-
- TS - lean scum, he is going after Draeke for scum but also calling him a dirty stalker and imo if he actually thinks about it for a few seconds going through that trouble to stalk someone actually seems like more of a townie thing to do so it’s weird to turn around and tunnel them as scum for it.
- Owner - scummy vibes. They made some useless commentary post that ping’d me as just posting to post. Did have some actually good posts between though, but if scum it’s easy to actually scum hunting into Group 2 if you’re Group 1 scum here. Didn’t like their posts about my Pariaton RP but maybe they just don’t know anything about Pariston.

-
Back to Hero, gonna go look at the specific timing of that Plat wagon and if it really did time badly with the WJ wagon.

That blank 3rd - was supposed to be JoJo - town lean

 

[Juan]

@Juan does Iwan possible being bus driven change your mind on Bada’s action hitting Iwan like he said?

i have mechanical reason to think bada can't be redirected or anything

and he said he was a commuter

all my knowledge of a commuter says they can't take actions the night they commute because uh

wtf lol

iwan being the target of a bus drive is possible, but i do not believe badalight targeted him anyway

 

[DrProfessor83]

I don’t particularly scum read Kira. But I think we should execute him just to clear the Group 2 POE bc I feel like we have about 8 people that could have the scum in them if I include my nulls (and take LM out who has an innocent on him)

Kira was scary accurate with his reads this game for someone with such low engagement/activity. Maybe too accurate.

Was on WJ D1 and looks good for that. Then he scum read Sin and Iwan in subsequent days (but just made comments about them, didn’t do anything to endanger him).

So unless he’s just a deadly accurate inactive townie, I could see him as scum with TMI.

His only other scum read I noticed was JW (which he is actually pushing on)
-
- Bada
- Didi
- Hero
- hammer
- Kira
- JW
- Soul
- SK
- Lanji

That’s 9, some higher in POE than others, but could have as many as 4 scum in there if Mafia starts with 8. (maybe 5 if Iwan is an indie). Need to start clearing some of these out one way or another.

 

[DrProfessor83]

i have mechanical reason to think bada can't be redirected or anything

and he said he was a commuter

all my knowledge of a commuter says they can't take actions the night they commute because uh

wtf lol

iwan being the target of a bus drive is possible, but i do not believe badalight targeted him anyway

I figured you just didn’t think he could be redirected bc actions failed on him so a redirect would fail on him.

So what do you think of the Iwan situation? Bussing/lucky guess (if Bada is indie)?

 

[JoJo]

hammer
jw
soul

prolly all scum

 

[JoJo]

i still think that d1 the WJ voters were not all town. at least one of them was a bussing scum avoiding the next day’s lynch

 

[Ratchet]

Hero I think is a viable lynch here.

 

[Juan]

I figured you just didn’t think he could be redirected bc actions failed on him so a redirect would fail on him.

So what do you think of the Iwan situation? Bussing/lucky guess (if Bada is indie)?

it's probably bussing because iwan is super inactive yes, and the scum team gets to use his abilities anyway (iirc from what nitty said)

or maybe iwan is an indie and shit, idk

either way, bada smells bad and i want him out

@JoJo end him broski

 

[DrProfessor83]

[Vote Lynch Hero]

 

[JoJo]

if hero flips scum whar does that say

and if hero flips town what does that say

 

[JoJo]

it's probably bussing because iwan is super inactive yes, and the scum team gets to use his abilities anyway (iirc from what nitty said)

or maybe iwan is an indie and shit, idk

either way, bada smells bad and i want him out

@JoJo end him broski

did you guys get mafia abilities recycled in this game like how it was in g1?

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

So it's between Didi and Hero for cop role claim.

[Vote lynch Hero]

 

[Juan]

did you guys get mafia abilities recycled in this game like how it was in g1?

yes nitty said he would do that because there were inactives or something

 

[Juan]

@Shizune change your avatar, i keep typing "she" everytime i fucking talk about you lol

 

[Shizune]

@Shizune change your avatar, i keep typing "she" everytime i fucking talk about you lol

Just landed like fresh tilapia

 

[DrProfessor83]

if hero flips scum whar does that say

and if hero flips town what does that say

That’s a question to dig into later lol.

For now the question is “is he scum?” lol.

 

[JoJo]

That’s a question to dig into later lol.

For now the question is “is he scum?” lol.

i mean we r flipping him cuz we know we will get useful from him

but what info is that

 

[JoJo]

are u guys actually gonna make me read g1

 

[Juan]

are u guys actually gonna make me read g1

did

did you not read your game

 

[JoJo]

did

did you not read your game

typo i meant g2

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

If hero flips town doesn't that make Didi suspicious? Because there is no way for 5 cops in this game. If Hero flips town we have 4 cops from group 2.

 

[DrProfessor83]

i mean we r flipping him cuz we know we will get useful from him

but what info is that

I didn’t see who was calling him an info lynch.

Off the top of my head we probably get some info on Didi.

If we think one of Didi/Hero are scum cop then one of their flips could tip the scales on the other (since we already have several dead town cops)

 

[DrProfessor83]

Because there is no way for 5 cops in this game.

Never say never but it would seem unlikely.

 

[Hero]

I mean, that's basically what I am. An info lynch

 

[DrProfessor83]

I mean, that's basically what I am. An info lynch

Why were you worried about having your alignment scan changed?

 

[Juan]

if hero flips town he does assure everyone that didi santi and me are town i guess

 

[Hero]

Because if I imitated someone who was scum and I happened to be investigated, there was no way I could defend myself.

 

[DrProfessor83]

Because if I imitated someone who was scum and I happened to be investigated, there was no way I could defend myself.

Okay but then at worst you’d get lynched/killed and your dying words + flip would get scum lynched. Seems like a good trade.

 

[Traveling Swordsman]

Never say never but it would seem unlikely.

How does Didi look if Hero flips town and how does Didi look if he flips scum?

 

[DrProfessor83]

And that’s If you got scanned there. You could potentially catch scum and never get coped lol.

 

[DrProfessor83]

How does Didi look if Hero flips town and how does Didi look if he flips scum?

Obviously it makes the other look worse if one flips town. But saying we can’t possibly have 5 is probably not true.

We *probably* don’t have 5.

 

[Hero]

Okay but then at worst you’d get lynched/killed and your dying words + flip would get scum lynched. Seems like a good trade.

 

[DrProfessor83]

You disagree that’s a good trade?

 

[Rej]

I remember you being chatty with Ekko. You read him townie, right?

Yes

 

[DrProfessor83]

It sounds like you’re more worried about survival than catching scum lol.

 

[Hero]

Mf, I want to live . So yes, that's an awful trade

 

[Hero]

It sounds like you’re more worried about survival than catching scum lol.

Because I can still hunt scum while alive without dwindling our numbers???

That's not even an arguing point.

 

[Rej]

But I still don’t know where the 6 cop narrative is coming from. At most we had 4 - Charles, Yo Tan, Fang and Didi

I have no idea where Prof being an invest is coming From and Hero only came out as role cop last day phase in group 2 and scanned Santi and got poisoned. @Hero any other results?


He flipped town so don’t know what was going on there. Like Hidden suspected - either he was forced into making those posts, or … he just threw, which is very unlikely considering Ish.


@Rej Prof never claimed cop. I have no memory of it at least.


Ratchet is implying something else completely. Prof basically promised in the beginning of the game that he’s not mafia. Owner even quoted that post in this day phase in her read through of group 2.

Fuck I didnt read the thread then. I saw two cops and both were poisoned. Probably I fucked up.

 

[Badalight]

i have mechanical reason to think bada can't be redirected or anything

and he said he was a commuter

all my knowledge of a commuter says they can't take actions the night they commute because uh

wtf lol

iwan being the target of a bus drive is possible, but i do not believe badalight targeted him anyway

Me targeting is like almost mod confirmed lol. Nitty even posted about it kind. We know that FS got hit by a kill, and I copped to that (because I got redirected). That info helped us realize the bussing situation and lynch SR instead of FS. No reason for me to throw myself under the bus for no reason if I am scum.

 

[DrProfessor83]

Because I can still hunt scum while alive without dwindling our numbers???

That's not even an arguing point.

It is an arguing point. I believe you’ll find few townies who wouldn’t accept a superkill on themselves right now if it took a scum down with them lol.

 

[DrProfessor83]

Me targeting is like almost mod confirmed lol. Nitty even posted about it kind. We know that FS got hit by a kill, and I copped to that (because I got redirected). That info helped us realize the bussing situation and lynch SR instead of FS. No reason for me to throw myself under the bus for no reason if I am scum.

Forgot about Nitty coming into the thread lol.

 

[JoJo]

It is an arguing point. I believe you’ll find few townies who wouldn’t accept a superkill on themselves right now if it took a scum down with them lol.

mfer i sure as hell wouldn’t

i’m greedy as hell

 

[Ratchet]

Because if I imitated someone who was scum and I happened to be investigated, there was no way I could defend myself.

I'm not really convinced with this. Initially you said it was alignment, then it just changed to how you investigate as, and now your reasoning is because it might look bad if you also happened to be investigated. But I'm not sure why you would assume that there was another investigation role that checked for alignment off the bad, at least to the extent of being concerned about it.

 

[Ratchet]

Also Michelle as far as Didi's claim he keeps adding things to it, I can't even keep track of it any more.

 

[Badalight]

I think I still prefer JW over Hero but idk

 

[Ratchet]

I think I still prefer JW over Hero but idk

What does a JW lynch give us?

 

[Hero]

I'm not really convinced with this. Initially you said it was alignment, then it just changed to how you investigate as, and now your reasoning is because it might look bad if you also happened to be investigated. But I'm not sure why you would assume that there was another investigation role that checked for alignment off the bad, at least to the extent of being concerned about it.

Because I mixed alignment up with scan. I don't know mafia terminology all that well.

You can check last game. I've been using terms wrong the whole time. @Lord Melkor asked me previously what I meant by coasting when I called John Wayne town. I meant the actual definition and not mafia lingo. I just choose my words poorly. But I corrected myself in the last phase that I didn't mean alignment. I meant what I scanned.

 

[JoJo]

. @Badalight - Santi
2. @Baroxio - Lord Melkor > Worm Juice
3. @charles101
4. @Didi - John Wayne > Lord Melkor > Worm Juice > Platinum
5. @DrProfessor83 - Worm Juice
6. @Ekkologix - DrProfessor > Hammer > Worm Juice
7. @Fang - DrProfessor > Lord Melkor
8. @Firestormer - Nessos > Hammer
9. @Franky
10. @hammer - Didi
11. @Hero - Platinum
12. @Iwandesu
13. @John Wayne - Nessos
14. @Juan - DrProfessor83 > Platinum
15. @Kira Yagami - Worm Juice
16. @Lalisa - Lord Melkor > Xadlin
17. @Lind - Lalisa > Worm Juice > Platinum
18. @Lord Melkor - Didi > Platinum
19. @Melodie
20. @Natalija - Xadlin > Lord Melkor
21. @Nessos - Rej
22. @Oddjutsu
23. @Platinum - Didi
24. @Ratchet - Worm Juice > Platinum
25. @Rej - Worm Juice
26. @Salah WG
27. @Santí
28. @SinRaven - Melodie
29. @Soul - DrProfessor >
30. @SoulKiller - Platinum
31. @sworder
32. @tinky winky - Didi
33. @WolfPrinceKiba - Didi
34. @Worm Juice - Franky > Didi
35. @Xadlin - Didi > Platinum
36. @Yo Tan Wa - Worm Juice

d1 votes

who on the WJ is scum bussing her? you guys said YTW claimed cop one of the cops

 

[Ratchet]

SoulKiller can go too but I think he'll be an execution candidate soon.

 

[Hero]

Also Michelle as far as Didi's claim he keeps adding things to it, I can't even keep track of it any more.

So you'd prefer if I revealed more of my role then? Because I can easily do that

 

[Badalight]

What does a JW lynch give us?

dead scum

but also it'd be the first dead person on didi's list on invests